scoresvideos
History of Canada – Before 1867
Table of Contents
Unit 5 Overview: The Road to Confederation
5.1 The Charlottetown and Quebec Conferences
5.2 The British North America Act and the Creation of the Dominion of Canada
5.3 The Fathers of Confederation and their Vision for Canada
5.4 Early Challenges and Successes of the New Nation

🍁history of canada – before 1867 review

5.3 The Fathers of Confederation and their Vision for Canada

Citation:

The Fathers of Confederation were key figures who shaped Canada's future. They came from diverse backgrounds, bringing varied expertise to the table. Their vision balanced regional interests with a unified national identity.

These leaders faced challenges like American expansion and colonial dependence. They aimed to create a federal system with a strong central government, protect minority rights, and build a transcontinental railway. Their work laid the foundation for modern Canada.

Fathers of Confederation

Key Figures and Roles

  • Sir John A. Macdonald led Confederation negotiations as Conservative from Canada West
    • Became Canada's first Prime Minister
    • Skillfully balanced competing interests during negotiations
    • Advocated for a strong central government
  • George-Étienne Cartier gained French-Canadian support for Confederation
    • Represented Conservative interests from Canada East
    • Negotiated protections for French language and culture
    • Helped bridge divide between English and French Canada
  • George Brown set aside political differences to work with Macdonald
    • Led Reform Party from Canada West
    • Advocated for representation by population
    • Formed Great Coalition with Macdonald to pursue Confederation
  • Sir Charles Tupper championed Confederation in Nova Scotia
    • Later became Prime Minister of Canada in 1896
    • Overcame significant opposition in his home province
    • Negotiated favorable terms for Nova Scotia's entry
  • Sir Samuel Leonard Tilley secured New Brunswick's entry into Confederation
    • Coined term "Dominion of Canada"
    • Served as Minister of Finance in Macdonald's cabinet
    • Advocated for prohibition and temperance
  • Thomas D'Arcy McGee promoted vision of bilingual, multicultural Canada
    • Irish-Canadian politician and journalist
    • Passionate orator for Canadian nationalism
    • Assassinated in 1868, possibly by Fenian sympathizers
  • Sir Alexander Tilloch Galt contributed to Confederation's financial arrangements
    • Prominent businessman from Canada East
    • Served as first Minister of Finance of the Dominion
    • Advocated for protection of English-speaking minority rights in Quebec

Motivations of the Fathers

Diverse Backgrounds and Expertise

  • Delegates represented mix of English and French-speaking backgrounds
    • Reflected linguistic duality of future nation
    • Brought varied cultural perspectives to negotiations
  • Professional backgrounds spanned multiple fields
    • Lawyers (Macdonald, Cartier)
    • Journalists (Brown, McGee)
    • Businessmen (Galt)
    • Career politicians (Tupper)
  • Diverse expertise enriched Confederation discussions
    • Legal knowledge informed constitutional framework
    • Business acumen guided economic considerations
    • Political experience facilitated compromise

Political and Regional Interests

  • Political ideologies ranged from conservative to reform
    • Conservatives (Macdonald, Cartier) favored strong central government
    • Reformers (Brown) advocated for greater representation by population
    • Required significant compromise and coalition-building
  • Regional interests shaped delegates' priorities
    • Maritime delegates focused on economic benefits and railway connections
    • Canada West representatives sought representation by population
    • Canada East delegates prioritized protection of French-Canadian rights
  • Economic considerations motivated business-oriented delegates
    • Galt emphasized need for larger internal market
    • Improved trade relations with Britain and United States
    • Development of national infrastructure and transportation networks

Shared Motivations and Concerns

  • Fear of American expansion united delegates across ideological lines
    • Recent U.S. Civil War heightened concerns
    • Desire to maintain distinct British North American identity
  • Pursuit of greater autonomy from Britain
    • Sought to reduce colonial dependence while maintaining ties
    • Aimed to establish more self-governing federation
  • Vision of new nationality transcending ethnic and religious divisions
    • D'Arcy McGee championed inclusive Canadian identity
    • Sought to unite diverse populations under common cause

Vision for Canada

Political and Constitutional Framework

  • Federal system balancing provincial autonomy with strong central government
    • Division of powers between federal and provincial levels
    • Addressed regional concerns while fostering national unity
    • Allowed for flexibility in governance of diverse regions
  • Bicameral parliamentary system for balanced representation
    • Lower house (House of Commons) based on representation by population
    • Upper house (Senate) provided regional representation
    • Modeled on British parliamentary system with Canadian adaptations
  • Protection of minority rights enshrined in constitution
    • Safeguards for French language and culture in Quebec
    • Separate school systems for religious minorities
    • Recognition of existing treaty rights with Indigenous peoples

Economic and Infrastructure Development

  • Interprovincial trade and economic integration
    • Removal of internal trade barriers
    • Creation of unified Canadian market
    • Standardization of currency and banking systems
  • National railway system to connect provinces
    • Intercolonial Railway linking Maritimes to central Canada
    • Proposed transcontinental railway to future western territories
    • Railway as symbol of national unity and economic progress
  • Development of national industries and resources
    • Protective tariffs to encourage domestic manufacturing
    • Exploitation of natural resources across vast territory
    • Diversification of economy beyond traditional agricultural base

National Identity and Expansion

  • Creation of new Canadian nationality
    • Uniting diverse populations under common identity
    • Balancing British heritage with distinct Canadian character
    • Fostering bilingualism and cultural pluralism
  • Establishment of Canada as significant North American power
    • Capable of resisting American influence
    • Maintaining strong ties with Britain while asserting autonomy
    • Developing independent foreign policy and trade relationships
  • Westward expansion and nation-building
    • Vision of Canada stretching from "sea to sea"
    • Incorporation of Rupert's Land and North-Western Territory
    • Settlement and development of western prairies
    • Eventual addition of British Columbia to complete transcontinental nation

Key Terms to Review (23)

Representation by population: Representation by population is a principle in political representation where the number of representatives for a particular region or group is determined based on its population size. This concept ensures that larger populations have a greater influence in government, which was a key concern during the formation of Canada as various regions sought fair representation in the legislative process.
Compromise: Compromise refers to a settlement of differences in which each side makes concessions. In the context of nation-building, particularly during the formation of Canada, compromise was essential for addressing the diverse interests and needs of various regions and groups. It involved negotiation and collaboration among the Fathers of Confederation, who sought to create a united country while respecting the distinct identities and priorities of provinces and territories.
Sir John A. Macdonald: Sir John A. Macdonald was a Canadian statesman and one of the founding Fathers of Confederation, serving as the first Prime Minister of Canada from 1867 to 1873 and again from 1878 to 1891. His leadership was pivotal in shaping Canada's national identity and promoting the expansion of the Canadian West, as well as establishing key policies that impacted Indigenous peoples and the economy.
Negotiation: Negotiation is a process where two or more parties discuss and come to an agreement on specific issues or terms. In the context of forming Canada, it involved balancing the diverse interests of various provinces and groups to establish a unified nation. This process required compromise, communication, and strategic planning to ensure that all parties felt their concerns were addressed in the final outcome.
Quebec's Distinct Society: Quebec's distinct society refers to the unique cultural, linguistic, and social identity of Quebec within Canada, particularly its French-speaking population and their historical experiences. This concept emerged during discussions about Canadian Confederation and the need to recognize Quebec's special status, ensuring that its language and culture would be protected and promoted within a predominantly English-speaking country.
Railway construction: Railway construction refers to the process of building railroads, which are vital for transportation and trade. It played a crucial role in the development of Canada by connecting distant regions, facilitating economic growth, and promoting national unity among provinces. The Fathers of Confederation viewed railway construction as essential for creating a strong and unified country, enhancing both movement and communication across vast distances.
Thomas D'Arcy McGee: Thomas D'Arcy McGee was an Irish-Canadian politician, journalist, and poet who played a significant role in the movement for Canadian Confederation. He was one of the most prominent Fathers of Confederation, advocating for a united Canada as a means to foster stability, security, and economic growth in the region. His contributions were particularly influential during the Charlottetown and Quebec Conferences, where he emphasized the importance of cooperation among provinces and the need for a federal structure.
Nationalism: Nationalism is a political ideology that emphasizes the interests, culture, and identity of a particular nation or group of people. It often promotes the idea of self-governance and unity among individuals who share a common language, culture, or history, advocating for the sovereignty of the nation-state. This sentiment played a crucial role in shaping the political landscape during the formative years of Canada.
Sir Samuel Leonard Tilley: Sir Samuel Leonard Tilley was a prominent Canadian politician and one of the key Fathers of Confederation who played a vital role in the creation of Canada in 1867. Tilley was instrumental in advocating for the union of the British North American colonies, envisioning a strong and united Canada that would enhance economic development and security.
George Brown: George Brown was a prominent Canadian politician, journalist, and one of the key Fathers of Confederation, who played a significant role in the creation of Canada as a nation. He was an advocate for responsible government and worked tirelessly to unite the provinces of British North America. His influence was crucial during the Charlottetown and Quebec Conferences, where he promoted the idea of federalism as a solution to political deadlock and regional rivalries.
Intercolonial trade: Intercolonial trade refers to the exchange of goods and services between different colonies within a larger political entity, such as British North America prior to Confederation in 1867. This trade was vital for economic growth, allowing colonies to become more self-sufficient while fostering relationships among them. It was also a key factor influencing the Fathers of Confederation as they envisioned a more unified and economically integrated Canada.
Sir Charles Tupper: Sir Charles Tupper was a Canadian politician and one of the Fathers of Confederation, serving as the sixth Prime Minister of Canada for a brief period in 1896. He played a vital role in the formation of Canada by promoting the idea of a unified nation and was instrumental in negotiating the terms of Confederation among the provinces. His vision for Canada included strong federal governance and economic development, reflecting the priorities and challenges of the time.
Liberalism: Liberalism is a political and economic philosophy that emphasizes individual freedom, equality, and the protection of civil rights. It advocates for limited government intervention in personal affairs and promotes free markets as a means to encourage personal initiative and economic growth. This ideology played a significant role in shaping the vision of the Fathers of Confederation as they aimed to create a united Canada based on democratic principles and individual liberties.
London Conference: The London Conference, held in 1866, was a crucial meeting that brought together representatives from the provinces of Canada, New Brunswick, and Nova Scotia to discuss the terms of Canadian Confederation. This conference was pivotal in shaping the future political landscape of Canada, as it laid the groundwork for the creation of the Dominion of Canada in 1867, emphasizing the desire for unity and cooperation among the provinces.
Sir Alexander Tilloch Galt: Sir Alexander Tilloch Galt was a prominent Canadian politician and businessman, known for his key role as one of the Fathers of Confederation. He advocated for the unification of the British North American colonies and played a crucial part in the negotiations that led to the formation of Canada in 1867. Galt's vision included economic development and the establishment of a strong central government to manage the diverse needs of the new nation.
Responsible Government: Responsible government is a political system where the executive branch derives its legitimacy from the elected legislature and is accountable to it. This concept was crucial in shaping the political landscape in Canada, as it marked a shift towards democratic governance and greater autonomy from colonial powers, ultimately influencing key historical events and the formation of the nation.
British North America Act: The British North America Act, enacted in 1867, was a crucial piece of legislation that created the Dominion of Canada by uniting the provinces of Ontario, Quebec, New Brunswick, and Nova Scotia. This act established a federal structure of government, outlining the division of powers between the national and provincial governments and laying the foundation for Canada's political landscape.
Quebec Conference: The Quebec Conference was a pivotal meeting held in October 1864, where representatives from the British North American colonies gathered to discuss the terms of Confederation. It built upon the earlier Charlottetown Conference, where the idea of uniting the colonies was first proposed. The Quebec Conference resulted in the drafting of a framework for a federal union, setting the stage for the eventual creation of Canada as a Dominion.
Federalism: Federalism is a political system where power is divided between a central authority and smaller political units, like provinces or states. This structure allows different levels of government to coexist and share responsibilities, ensuring local governance while maintaining national unity. It played a crucial role in shaping the governance and political landscape of Canada, particularly during key moments leading up to its formation as a nation.
George-Étienne Cartier: George-Étienne Cartier was a prominent Canadian politician and lawyer who played a crucial role in the Confederation movement, particularly in the creation of Canada as a nation in 1867. He was a leading advocate for the interests of French Canadians and sought to ensure their inclusion and representation in the new Dominion of Canada. His efforts were vital during the Charlottetown and Quebec Conferences, as well as in the passage of the British North America Act.
Charlottetown Conference: The Charlottetown Conference was a pivotal meeting held in September 1864 where representatives from the Province of Canada, New Brunswick, and Nova Scotia discussed the possibility of creating a federal union. This conference marked the beginning of the process leading to the Confederation of Canada, highlighting key issues such as political representation, economic cooperation, and defense against external threats.
Maritime union: Maritime union refers to the idea of uniting the British North American colonies located along the Atlantic coast, particularly Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, and Prince Edward Island, to form a more cohesive political and economic partnership. This concept was driven by the need for economic stability, defense against external threats, and increased trade among the colonies, which ultimately influenced the formation of the Dominion of Canada in 1867.
Language rights: Language rights refer to the legal and social entitlements of individuals or groups to use their native language in various contexts, including education, government, and public life. This concept is crucial for preserving cultural identity and ensuring equitable access to services for speakers of minority languages. Language rights were a significant consideration during the formation of Canada, shaping policies and governance structures that recognized the linguistic diversity within the country.