9.2 Overexploitation of species
10 min read•august 21, 2024
of species is a critical issue in World Biogeography, impacting ecosystems globally. It involves unsustainable extraction of natural resources, altering species distributions and ecosystem functions. This topic explores various forms of exploitation, from direct harvesting to habitat destruction.
Understanding overexploitation is crucial for predicting future biogeographic patterns. The notes cover causes, impacts on terrestrial and marine ecosystems, vulnerable species groups, and global exploitation patterns. Conservation strategies and case studies provide insights into addressing this complex issue.
Definition of overexploitation
- Overexploitation refers to the unsustainable extraction or harvesting of natural resources at rates exceeding their ability to replenish
- In World Biogeography, overexploitation significantly alters species distributions, population dynamics, and ecosystem functions across global landscapes
- This concept intersects with various biogeographic principles, influencing species ranges, migration patterns, and community structures
Types of overexploitation
Top images from around the web for Types of overexploitation
Frontiers | Linking Terrestrial and Aquatic Biodiversity to Ecosystem Function Across Scales ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Figure 11.11 Baseline2010 eps View original
Is this image relevant?
Threats to Biodiversity | Boundless Biology View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Linking Terrestrial and Aquatic Biodiversity to Ecosystem Function Across Scales ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Figure 11.11 Baseline2010 eps View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Types of overexploitation
Frontiers | Linking Terrestrial and Aquatic Biodiversity to Ecosystem Function Across Scales ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Figure 11.11 Baseline2010 eps View original
Is this image relevant?
Threats to Biodiversity | Boundless Biology View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Linking Terrestrial and Aquatic Biodiversity to Ecosystem Function Across Scales ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Figure 11.11 Baseline2010 eps View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Direct exploitation involves targeted removal of specific species (whaling, logging)
- Indirect exploitation occurs through habitat destruction or modification (bottom trawling, coral reef destruction)
- Incidental exploitation results from unintended capture or harm to non-target species (bycatch in fisheries)
- Systematic exploitation targets entire ecosystems for resource extraction (clear-cutting forests, strip mining)
Historical context
- Ancient civilizations practiced sustainable resource management (Indigenous Australian fire management)
- Industrial Revolution marked a turning point in resource exploitation intensity
- Colonialism led to widespread resource extraction in newly discovered lands (rubber plantations in South America)
- 20th century saw exponential increase in global resource consumption due to technological advancements and population growth
- Recent decades have witnessed growing awareness and efforts to address overexploitation issues
Causes of overexploitation
- Overexploitation stems from complex interactions between human activities and natural systems
- World Biogeography examines how these causes manifest differently across global regions and ecosystems
- Understanding these drivers helps predict future patterns of species distributions and ecosystem changes
Economic drivers
- Market demand for high-value products drives intense exploitation (shark fins, rare earth metals)
- Profit-driven industries prioritize short-term gains over long-term sustainability
- Globalization increases access to previously isolated resources
- Lack of economic alternatives in developing regions leads to overreliance on natural resource extraction
- Subsidies for extractive industries can artificially inflate profitability and encourage overexploitation
Population growth
- Increasing global population creates higher demand for food, water, and energy resources
- Urbanization leads to concentrated resource consumption and waste production
- Expansion of human settlements encroaches on natural habitats, reducing available resources for other species
- Growing middle class in developing countries increases per capita resource consumption
- Demographic shifts alter patterns of resource use and exploitation across regions
Technological advancements
- Improved extraction technologies enable access to previously unreachable resources (deep-sea drilling)
- More efficient harvesting methods increase capture rates (industrial fishing trawlers)
- Remote sensing and GPS technologies facilitate resource location and tracking
- Transportation innovations allow for global distribution of extracted resources
- Social media and online marketplaces expand demand for exotic or rare products
Impacts on ecosystems
- Overexploitation profoundly affects ecosystem structure and function across biogeographic regions
- These impacts ripple through food webs and biogeochemical cycles, altering global patterns of biodiversity
- Understanding these effects is crucial for predicting future biogeographic distributions and ecosystem services
Biodiversity loss
- Direct removal of species reduces genetic diversity within populations
- Habitat destruction associated with exploitation eliminates entire communities
- Keystone species loss can lead to ecosystem collapse (sea otters in kelp forests)
- Reduction in species richness alters ecosystem resilience and stability
- Loss of endemic species in isolated biogeographic regions (island extinctions)
Trophic cascades
- Removal of top predators alters prey population dynamics (wolf reintroduction in Yellowstone)
- Changes in herbivore populations affect plant community composition and structure
- Disruption of pollinator-plant relationships impacts ecosystem productivity
- Alterations in detritivore communities affect nutrient cycling and decomposition rates
- Shifts in plankton communities due to can impact entire marine food webs
Habitat degradation
- Physical destruction of habitats during resource extraction (coral reef damage from dynamite fishing)
- Soil erosion and compaction from intensive agriculture or logging
- Water pollution from mining and industrial activities affects aquatic ecosystems
- Fragmentation of habitats reduces connectivity and gene flow between populations
- Alteration of fire regimes in fire-dependent ecosystems due to resource management practices
Overexploitation in terrestrial ecosystems
- Terrestrial overexploitation significantly shapes land-based biogeographic patterns
- These impacts vary across biomes and are influenced by local and global socio-economic factors
- Understanding terrestrial overexploitation is crucial for predicting future species distributions and ecosystem functions
Deforestation
- Clearing of forests for agriculture, timber, and urban development
- Tropical rainforests experience highest rates of deforestation (Amazon, Congo Basin)
- Loss of carbon sinks contributes to global climate change
- Fragmentation of forest habitats impacts species migration and gene flow
- Deforestation alters local and regional hydrological cycles
Bushmeat trade
- Hunting of wild animals for food, particularly in tropical regions
- Targets a wide range of species, from small rodents to large primates
- Often driven by poverty and lack of alternative protein sources
- Can lead to empty forest syndrome where ecosystems lose key fauna
- Poses risks of zoonotic disease transmission to human populations
Poaching for wildlife products
- Illegal hunting of animals for valuable body parts (rhino horns, tiger bones)
- Driven by high demand in traditional medicine and luxury goods markets
- Often involves organized crime networks and cross-border smuggling
- Severely impacts populations of charismatic
- Can lead to genetic bottlenecks in small, fragmented populations
Overexploitation in marine ecosystems
- Marine overexploitation alters oceanic biogeography on local and global scales
- These impacts affect species distributions, migration patterns, and ecosystem functions across marine realms
- Understanding marine overexploitation is essential for predicting future ocean biodiversity patterns
Overfishing
- Extraction of fish at rates exceeding natural replenishment
- Industrial fishing fleets deplete stocks globally (Atlantic cod, bluefin tuna)
- Impacts both target species and entire food webs
- Alters age and size structure of fish populations
- Can lead to fishing down the food web, targeting smaller, less valuable species
Bycatch issues
- Unintentional capture of non-target species in fishing gear
- Affects a wide range of marine life (sea turtles, dolphins, seabirds)
- Can lead to population declines in species not directly targeted by fisheries
- Varies by fishing method, with some practices (bottom trawling) causing more bycatch
- Efforts to reduce bycatch include gear modifications and fishing practice changes
Deep-sea resource extraction
- Mining of seafloor resources for minerals and rare earth elements
- Impacts unique and poorly understood deep-sea ecosystems
- Destruction of slow-growing, long-lived deep-sea corals and sponges
- Potential for large-scale habitat alteration and species extinctions
- Challenges in regulating activities in international waters
Vulnerable species groups
- Certain species groups are particularly susceptible to overexploitation due to their life history traits or economic value
- Understanding these vulnerabilities helps predict biogeographic changes and prioritize conservation efforts
- The loss of these species can have disproportionate impacts on ecosystem function and stability
Megafauna
- Large-bodied animals often targeted for meat, trophies, or body parts
- Includes terrestrial (elephants, rhinos) and marine (whales, sharks) species
- Often have slow reproductive rates, making population recovery difficult
- Loss of megafauna can lead to significant ecosystem changes (megaherbivore impacts on vegetation structure)
- Cultural and economic value can drive both exploitation and conservation efforts
Slow-reproducing species
- Species with long generation times and low fecundity
- Includes many large mammals, sharks, and some tree species
- Particularly vulnerable to overexploitation due to slow population recovery
- Often K-selected species with high parental investment in offspring
- Loss of these species can create long-lasting gaps in ecosystem function
Commercially valuable species
- Species with high economic value in global markets
- Includes both terrestrial (hardwood trees, medicinal plants) and marine (tuna, lobsters) species
- Often subject to intense exploitation pressure due to profit incentives
- Can lead to boom-and-bust cycles of exploitation and population collapse
- Management challenges due to conflicting economic and conservation interests
Global patterns of overexploitation
- Overexploitation patterns vary across biogeographic regions and are influenced by socio-economic factors
- Understanding these patterns is crucial for predicting future changes in species distributions and ecosystem functions
- Global patterns of overexploitation often reflect historical and current power dynamics between nations
Hotspots of exploitation
- Areas of intense resource extraction often coincide with biodiversity hotspots
- Tropical regions experience high levels of deforestation and wildlife exploitation
- Coastal areas face intense fishing pressure and habitat destruction
- Arctic and Antarctic regions increasingly targeted for resource extraction as ice cover decreases
- Exploitation hotspots often shift as resources are depleted and new areas become accessible
North-south disparities
- Developed countries often outsource resource extraction to developing nations
- Historical patterns of colonialism continue to influence resource exploitation dynamics
- Differences in environmental regulations and enforcement between Global North and South
- Unequal distribution of benefits from resource extraction between source countries and consumers
- Capacity disparities in implementing sustainable management practices
International trade dynamics
- Global demand drives overexploitation in resource-rich regions
- Complex supply chains often obscure the origins of exploited resources
- Trade agreements can influence patterns of resource extraction and consumption
- Illegal wildlife trade networks operate across international borders
- Efforts to regulate international trade in endangered species () face implementation challenges
Conservation strategies
- Conservation approaches aim to mitigate overexploitation and promote sustainable resource use
- These strategies often require consideration of biogeographic principles to be effective
- Successful conservation efforts can lead to shifts in species distributions and ecosystem recovery
Sustainable harvesting practices
- Implementing quotas based on scientific assessments of population dynamics
- Rotating harvest areas to allow for ecosystem recovery (sustainable forestry practices)
- Promoting selective harvesting techniques to minimize ecosystem impacts
- Developing alternative livelihoods to reduce pressure on overexploited resources
- Incorporating traditional ecological knowledge into management practices
Protected areas
- Establishing networks of protected areas to safeguard biodiversity
- Designing reserves to account for species' range shifts due to climate change
- Implementing marine protected areas to allow fish stock recovery
- Creating corridors to maintain connectivity between protected habitats
- Balancing conservation goals with local community needs and rights
International agreements
- Developing and enforcing treaties to regulate global resource exploitation (Montreal Protocol)
- Implementing trade restrictions on endangered species products (CITES)
- Establishing transboundary protected areas for migratory species conservation
- Creating mechanisms for benefit-sharing from genetic resources (Nagoya Protocol)
- Developing global targets for biodiversity conservation and sustainable use (Aichi Targets)
Case studies
- Examining specific instances of overexploitation provides insights into causes, impacts, and potential solutions
- These case studies illustrate how overexploitation can dramatically alter biogeographic patterns
- Learning from past examples is crucial for preventing future overexploitation scenarios
Passenger pigeon extinction
- Once the most abundant bird in North America, extinct by early 20th century
- Massive flocks numbering in billions reduced to zero in just decades
- for meat and sport primary cause of extinction
- Habitat loss from deforestation contributed to
- Illustrates how even abundant species can be vulnerable to rapid overexploitation
Atlantic cod collapse
- Dramatic decline of cod stocks in Northwest Atlantic in early 1990s
- Centuries of fishing culminated in industrial-scale overfishing
- Led to moratorium on cod fishing, causing significant economic impacts
- Ecosystem shifts as other species filled ecological niche left by cod
- Slow recovery highlights challenges in restoring overexploited marine ecosystems
Elephant ivory trade
- Long history of elephant hunting for ivory in Africa and Asia
- 20th century saw dramatic declines in elephant populations due to poaching
- International ivory trade ban implemented in 1989 to curb poaching
- Continued illegal trade and habitat loss threaten remaining populations
- Illustrates complexities of addressing global demand for wildlife products
Future challenges
- Anticipating future overexploitation trends is crucial for proactive conservation efforts
- These challenges will shape biogeographic patterns and ecosystem functions in coming decades
- Addressing these issues requires interdisciplinary approaches and global cooperation
Climate change interactions
- Shifting species ranges may expose new populations to exploitation pressure
- Climate-driven resource scarcity could intensify exploitation of remaining resources
- Melting Arctic ice opening new areas for resource extraction
- Ocean acidification and warming compounding impacts of overfishing
- Increased frequency of extreme weather events affecting resource availability and exploitation patterns
Emerging markets
- Growing demand for novel products driving new forms of exploitation (e.g., deep-sea organisms for biotechnology)
- Increasing affluence in developing countries creating new markets for luxury wildlife products
- Social media facilitating rapid spread of trends in wildlife product consumption
- Development of synthetic alternatives to some wildlife products (e.g., rhino horn)
- Potential for sustainable use of underutilized species to relieve pressure on overexploited resources
Technological solutions
- Advanced monitoring technologies improving detection of illegal exploitation (satellite tracking, eDNA)
- Blockchain and other traceability systems enhancing supply chain transparency
- Artificial intelligence aiding in predictive modeling of exploitation patterns
- Gene editing technologies offering potential for de-extinction or enhancing species resilience
- Development of lab-grown alternatives to reduce demand for animal products
Biogeographical implications
- Overexploitation significantly alters biogeographic patterns across global ecosystems
- These changes can have long-lasting impacts on species distributions and ecosystem functions
- Understanding these implications is crucial for predicting future biodiversity patterns and informing conservation strategies
Range contractions
- Overexploited species often experience significant reductions in their geographic range
- Local extinctions lead to fragmented distributions and isolated populations
- Loss of genetic diversity within contracted ranges reduces adaptive potential
- Range contractions can lead to cascading effects on dependent species
- Some species may persist in refugia, providing opportunities for future range expansion
Extinction debts
- Time lag between habitat loss or overexploitation and eventual species extinctions
- Current biodiversity patterns may not reflect full impacts of past overexploitation
- Particularly relevant for long-lived species or those with complex life histories
- Challenges in predicting and mitigating future extinctions resulting from past actions
- Importance of considering extinction debts in conservation planning and protected area design
Shifts in species distributions
- Overexploitation can drive changes in species' realized niches
- Removal of competing species may allow for range expansions of less exploited species
- Changes in predator-prey dynamics can alter species distributions across landscapes
- Human-mediated introductions of exploited species to new areas (e.g., game animals)
- Potential for rapid evolutionary responses to exploitation pressure, affecting species' distributional patterns
Key Terms to Review (22)
Anthropogenic pressures: Anthropogenic pressures refer to the environmental changes and stresses that result from human activities, significantly impacting ecosystems and biodiversity. These pressures include habitat destruction, pollution, climate change, and overexploitation of natural resources, all of which can lead to significant declines in species populations and disrupt ecological balance.
Atlantic Cod Collapse: The Atlantic Cod Collapse refers to the dramatic decline of cod populations in the North Atlantic, particularly along the coasts of Canada and New England, due to overfishing and unsustainable fishing practices. This event serves as a significant example of how excessive exploitation can lead to the near-extinction of a species, highlighting the urgent need for sustainable management of marine resources.
Biodiversity loss: Biodiversity loss refers to the decline in the variety and variability of life forms within a given ecosystem or the entire planet. This loss can occur through various mechanisms, including habitat destruction, climate change, and species extinction, which can significantly impact ecological balance and resilience. The interconnectedness of species means that biodiversity loss can lead to shifts in ecosystem functions, disruptions in food webs, and an overall reduction in ecosystem services that are vital for human well-being.
Biomass depletion: Biomass depletion refers to the significant reduction in the total mass of living organisms in a given area, often due to human activities such as overharvesting, habitat destruction, and pollution. This decline impacts ecosystem stability, biodiversity, and the availability of resources, ultimately disrupting the balance necessary for the health of both the environment and human populations.
Catch per unit effort: Catch per unit effort (CPUE) is a measure used in fisheries and wildlife management that quantifies the amount of fish or wildlife caught per unit of effort expended, such as hours fished or traps set. This metric is critical for assessing the health and sustainability of populations, helping to determine if a species is being overexploited. By evaluating CPUE, scientists and managers can gauge population trends and inform conservation strategies.
CITES: CITES, or the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora, is an international agreement aimed at ensuring that the trade of wild animals and plants does not threaten their survival. The agreement focuses on regulating and monitoring the international trade of species that are threatened or at risk, helping to combat overexploitation and promoting conservation efforts through cooperation among countries.
Commercially valuable species: Commercially valuable species are those organisms that have significant economic importance due to their use in industries such as fishing, agriculture, and forestry. These species are often targeted for extraction and trade because they can provide food, raw materials, or other products that contribute to local and global economies. However, the demand for these species can lead to overexploitation, threatening their populations and ecosystems.
Conservation management: Conservation management refers to the systematic approach to preserving natural resources, habitats, and species to prevent biodiversity loss. It involves strategies to balance ecological health with human needs, often addressing threats such as habitat destruction, pollution, and overexploitation of species. Effective conservation management aims to maintain ecosystem functions and services while promoting sustainable practices that benefit both the environment and local communities.
Daniel Pauly: Daniel Pauly is a prominent marine biologist known for his research on global fisheries and the impacts of overfishing on marine ecosystems. His work highlights the unsustainable practices in fishing and emphasizes the need for better management of fish stocks to ensure the health of ocean environments. Through his studies, he has become a leading voice in advocating for sustainable practices and policies in fisheries management.
E. O. Wilson: E. O. Wilson is an American biologist, researcher, and author known for his work in myrmecology, the study of ants, and his contributions to biodiversity and conservation. His advocacy for the importance of preserving ecosystems and species has made him a key figure in discussions about overexploitation and its impact on biodiversity.
Endangered Species Act: The Endangered Species Act (ESA) is a key piece of legislation in the United States aimed at protecting species at risk of extinction and their habitats. By designating species as endangered or threatened, the ESA provides a framework for conservation efforts that are vital in addressing habitat destruction, overexploitation, and other factors contributing to species decline. It promotes both in-situ and ex-situ conservation strategies to safeguard biodiversity and allows for actions like assisted migration when necessary to adapt to changing environments.
Extinction risk: Extinction risk refers to the likelihood that a species will become extinct in the near future, usually assessed through factors such as population size, habitat loss, and threats from human activities. It is a critical concept in conservation biology, highlighting how overexploitation, habitat destruction, and climate change contribute to the decline of species. Understanding extinction risk is essential for implementing effective conservation strategies to protect vulnerable species and maintain biodiversity.
Habitat degradation: Habitat degradation refers to the process through which a natural habitat becomes less able to support the species that inhabit it, often due to human activities or environmental changes. This can lead to a decline in biodiversity, as species struggle to adapt to altered conditions, resulting in population declines and even extinctions. The impacts of habitat degradation are closely tied to issues like resource overexploitation and pollution, which further exacerbate the challenges facing ecosystems and their inhabitants.
Megafauna: Megafauna refers to the large animals, typically over 44 kg (about 100 lbs), that roamed various ecosystems during the Pleistocene epoch and earlier. These creatures played crucial roles in their environments, influencing vegetation patterns and ecosystem dynamics, and many were subject to extinction due to a combination of climate change and human activity. Their disappearance has significant implications for biodiversity and ecosystem health, as well as ongoing discussions about species conservation and restoration.
Overexploitation: Overexploitation refers to the unsustainable use of natural resources, leading to the depletion of species and ecosystems. It occurs when the rate of resource extraction exceeds the natural replenishment rate, often driven by human demand for food, medicine, or materials. This phenomenon significantly impacts biodiversity, contributing to species decline and habitat degradation, making it a critical concern in environmental conservation.
Overfishing: Overfishing occurs when fish are caught at a rate faster than they can reproduce, leading to a depletion of fish stocks and disruption of aquatic ecosystems. This issue is particularly significant in aquatic environments where the balance of species is crucial for maintaining biodiversity and the overall health of marine life. The impact of overfishing extends beyond individual species, affecting food webs and the livelihoods of communities that depend on fishing.
Overhunting: Overhunting refers to the excessive and unsustainable hunting of wildlife, leading to a decline in animal populations and potentially causing species extinction. This practice disrupts ecosystems and can result in significant biodiversity loss, as many species are unable to recover from such pressure. Overhunting is a major aspect of the overexploitation of species, reflecting how human activities can adversely impact wildlife and their habitats.
Passenger pigeon extinction: Passenger pigeon extinction refers to the disappearance of the once-abundant passenger pigeon species, which was driven to extinction in the early 20th century due to extreme overhunting and habitat loss. The rapid decline of this species is a prime example of how human activities can lead to the dramatic reduction of wildlife populations and underscores the consequences of unsustainable exploitation of natural resources.
Population Decline: Population decline refers to a decrease in the number of individuals within a species or a specific population over time. This decline can occur due to various factors, including overexploitation, habitat loss, disease, and environmental changes, which often lead to reduced reproductive rates and increased mortality. Understanding population decline is crucial in conservation efforts, as it highlights the urgency of protecting species that are at risk of extinction due to unsustainable practices.
Slow-reproducing species: Slow-reproducing species are organisms that have long gestation periods, low birth rates, and take significant time to reach reproductive maturity. These traits make them particularly vulnerable to overexploitation, as their populations recover slowly from declines caused by factors such as hunting, habitat loss, or environmental changes.
Sustainable harvesting: Sustainable harvesting refers to the practice of extracting natural resources in a way that meets current needs without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. This approach balances the demand for resources with the health of ecosystems, ensuring that species populations can recover and thrive over time. By implementing sustainable harvesting techniques, we can mitigate the risks associated with overexploitation, maintaining biodiversity and ecosystem integrity.
Trophic cascade: A trophic cascade is an ecological phenomenon that occurs when changes in the population of one species, particularly a top predator, have significant impacts on multiple levels of the food web. This ripple effect can alter the abundance and distribution of various species within an ecosystem, influencing both plant and animal communities. Trophic cascades illustrate the interconnectedness of species and highlight how disruptions, whether natural or anthropogenic, can lead to dramatic shifts in ecosystem health and stability.