12.3 Influence on law and government

The ancient Mediterranean world laid the groundwork for modern Western legal and political systems. Greek and Roman traditions established key principles like democracy, rule of law, and separation of powers that continue to shape governance today.

These early experiments in democracy and republicanism introduced concepts like citizen participation, representation, and checks on power. While adapted over time, core ideas from ancient Greece and Rome remain central to how many Western governments function.

Foundations of Western legal systems

• The legal systems of many Western countries have their roots in the legal traditions of ancient Mediterranean civilizations, particularly those of ancient Greece and Rome
• These ancient legal systems established fundamental principles and practices that continue to shape modern legal frameworks and understanding of law and justice

Influence of Roman law

• Roman law served as a foundation for many European legal systems, especially in continental Europe
• Developed a comprehensive legal code that covered a wide range of areas including property rights, contracts, family law, and criminal law
• Emphasized the importance of written laws and legal precedents in establishing a stable and predictable legal system
• Introduced concepts such as the presumption of innocence and the right to a fair trial

Corpus Juris Civilis

• Comprehensive collection of Roman laws compiled under the Byzantine Emperor Justinian I in the 6th century CE
• Consisted of four parts: the Code (imperial laws), the Digest (opinions of jurists), the Institutes (legal textbook), and the Novels (new laws)
• Served as a basis for many European civil law systems and influenced the development of international law
• Rediscovered and studied in medieval Europe, contributing to the development of modern legal scholarship and education

Common law vs civil law systems

• Two main legal traditions that emerged from the ancient Mediterranean world: common law and civil law
• Common law, associated with England and its former colonies, relies heavily on legal precedents set by courts and judges
• Civil law, associated with continental Europe, is based on comprehensive legal codes and statutes
• The distinctions between these two systems can be traced back to the different legal traditions of ancient Greece (common law) and Rome (civil law)

Democratic principles and practices

• Ancient Mediterranean civilizations, particularly ancient Athens, are often credited with developing the foundations of democratic governance
• These early experiments in democracy established principles such as citizen participation, representation, and accountability that continue to shape modern democratic systems

Athenian democracy

• Developed in ancient Athens during the 5th century BCE, considered one of the earliest forms of direct democracy
• Male citizens participated directly in the decision-making process through the Athenian Assembly (Ekklesia)
• Citizens had the right to vote on laws, elect officials, and serve on juries
• Athenian democracy had limitations, as citizenship was restricted to adult male citizens, excluding women, slaves, and foreigners

Roman Republic

• Established a system of government that combined elements of democracy, aristocracy, and monarchy
• Citizens elected representatives to the Roman Assemblies, which had the power to pass laws and elect magistrates
• The Senate, composed of wealthy and influential citizens, served as an advisory body and played a significant role in shaping public policy
• The Roman Republic introduced concepts such as the separation of powers and checks and balances between different branches of government

Representation and citizenship

• Ancient Mediterranean democracies emphasized the importance of citizen participation and representation in governance
• Citizenship was often tied to certain rights and responsibilities, such as the right to vote and the duty to serve in the military
• The concept of representation, where elected officials act on behalf of the citizens, has its roots in these early democratic systems
• Modern democracies continue to grapple with questions of representation, citizenship, and the scope of democratic participation

Separation of powers

• The idea that political power should be divided among different branches of government to prevent tyranny and abuse of power
• Ancient Mediterranean civilizations, particularly ancient Rome, developed early forms of the separation of powers that influenced later Western political systems

Executive, legislative, and judicial branches

• In the Roman Republic, power was divided among the executive (consuls), legislative (assemblies), and judicial (praetors) branches
• Consuls served as the chief executives and commanders of the military, elected annually by the Comitia Centuriata (Assembly of the Centuries)
• The Roman Assemblies, such as the Comitia Tributa (Tribal Assembly), had the power to pass laws and elect magistrates
• Praetors served as judges and oversaw the administration of justice, interpreting and applying the law

Checks and balances

• The Roman system of government included mechanisms to prevent any one branch from becoming too powerful
• The consuls, while holding significant executive power, were subject to the decisions of the Senate and the Assemblies
• The tribunes of the plebs, elected by the Concilium Plebis (Plebeian Council), had the power to veto actions taken by the consuls or the Senate
• The separation of powers and checks and balances in the Roman Republic influenced later Western political thinkers, such as Montesquieu, in developing modern systems of government

Rule of law

• The principle that all members of a society, including those in positions of power, are subject to the same laws and legal processes
• Ancient Mediterranean civilizations, particularly ancient Greece and Rome, developed early concepts of the rule of law that continue to shape modern legal systems

Equality before the law

• The idea that all citizens, regardless of social status or wealth, should be treated equally under the law
• In ancient Athens, reforms introduced by Solon in the 6th century BCE established the principle of equality before the law (isonomia)
• The Twelve Tables, a set of laws codified in the Roman Republic around 450 BCE, established a written legal code that applied to all citizens

Due process rights

• The concept that individuals have certain legal rights and protections when accused of a crime or facing legal action
• In ancient Athens, the right to a trial by jury was established, with citizens serving as jurors in legal proceedings
• The Roman legal system developed procedures to ensure fair trials, such as the right to present evidence and call witnesses

Protection of individual liberties

• Ancient Mediterranean legal systems recognized the importance of protecting individual rights and freedoms
• The Athenian constitution, as described by Aristotle, included provisions for the protection of individual liberties, such as freedom of speech in the Assembly
• The Roman legal concept of habeas corpus, which protected citizens against arbitrary imprisonment, has its roots in the Twelve Tables and later Roman legal developments

Republicanism and constitutionalism

• The idea that government should be based on the consent of the governed and limited by a set of fundamental laws or principles
• Ancient Mediterranean civilizations, particularly ancient Rome, developed early forms of republicanism and constitutionalism that influenced later Western political thought

Mixed government

• The concept that the best form of government combines elements of monarchy, aristocracy, and democracy
• The Roman Republic was seen as an example of a mixed government, with the consuls representing the monarchical element, the Senate representing the aristocratic element, and the Assemblies representing the democratic element
• The Greek historian Polybius, in his analysis of the Roman constitution, praised the balance and stability of the mixed government system

Limits on government power

• The idea that the power of government should be limited by law and subject to the consent of the governed
• The Roman Republic developed a system of checks and balances, such as the veto power of the tribunes, to limit the power of any one branch of government
• The Twelve Tables established a written legal code that placed limits on the power of magistrates and the aristocracy

Social contract theory

• The idea that the legitimacy of government is based on an implicit agreement between the rulers and the ruled
• Ancient Greek philosophers, such as Plato and Aristotle, explored the concept of the social contract in their political writings
• The Roman historian Livy, in his account of the founding of the Roman Republic, described a social contract between the Roman people and their rulers, with the people granting power to the rulers in exchange for protection and justice

Civic virtue and participation

• The idea that citizens have a responsibility to actively participate in public life and promote the common good
• Ancient Mediterranean civilizations, particularly ancient Athens and Rome, placed a strong emphasis on civic virtue and participation as essential to the functioning of a democratic society

Res publica and common good

• The Roman concept of res publica, meaning "public thing" or "commonwealth," emphasized the importance of placing the common good above individual interests
• In ancient Athens, the idea of the common good was central to the functioning of the democratic system, with citizens expected to prioritize the well-being of the polis (city-state) over personal gain

Citizenship duties and responsibilities

• In ancient Athens, citizens were expected to actively participate in the Assembly, serve on juries, and defend the city-state in times of war
• The Roman Republic had a strong tradition of public service, with citizens expected to hold public office and serve in the military as a duty to the state
• The Greek philosopher Aristotle, in his work "Politics," argued that the best form of government was one in which citizens actively participated in ruling and being ruled in turn

Legacy in modern governments

• The political and legal principles developed in ancient Mediterranean civilizations have had a profound and enduring impact on modern Western governments and political thought

Influence on Western democracies

• Many of the fundamental principles of modern Western democracies, such as citizen participation, representation, and the rule of law, can be traced back to the political systems of ancient Greece and Rome
• The Founding Fathers of the United States, in particular, were heavily influenced by the political ideas of the ancient Mediterranean world, drawing inspiration from the Roman Republic and Greek democracy in the creation of the American system of government

Adaptation and evolution of principles

• While modern Western governments have adapted and modified the political and legal principles of the ancient Mediterranean world to suit contemporary needs and values, the core ideas of democracy, republicanism, and the rule of law remain central to these systems
• The development of liberal democracy in the West has built upon the foundations laid by ancient Mediterranean civilizations, incorporating new ideas such as universal suffrage, human rights, and the welfare state

Enduring impact on political thought

• The political writings of ancient Greek and Roman thinkers, such as Plato, Aristotle, Cicero, and Polybius, continue to be studied and debated by modern political theorists and philosophers
• The ideas and principles developed in the ancient Mediterranean world have shaped the development of Western political thought, influencing thinkers such as Machiavelli, Locke, Montesquieu, and the Founding Fathers of the United States
• The legacy of ancient Mediterranean civilizations in the realm of law and government serves as a reminder of the enduring importance of these fundamental principles in the functioning of modern democratic societies