10.3 BB84 Protocol and Security Analysis
3 min read•july 24, 2024
The is a groundbreaking quantum key distribution method. It uses quantum states to securely share cryptographic keys between two parties, Alice and Bob. The protocol leverages quantum principles like superposition and the uncertainty principle to detect eavesdropping attempts.
BB84's security relies on the laws of quantum mechanics. It uses polarized photons to encode bits, with random basis choices ensuring that any intercepted information is useless to eavesdroppers. The protocol's robustness is further enhanced by error estimation and privacy amplification techniques.
BB84 Protocol Overview
Procedure of BB84 protocol
Top images from around the web for Procedure of BB84 protocol
Optimizing the decoy-state BB84 QKD protocol parameters | Quantum Information Processing View original
Is this image relevant?
Modified BB84 Protocol Using CCD Technology View original
Is this image relevant?
Optimizing the decoy-state BB84 QKD protocol parameters | Quantum Information Processing View original
Is this image relevant?
Modified BB84 Protocol Using CCD Technology View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 2
Top images from around the web for Procedure of BB84 protocol
Optimizing the decoy-state BB84 QKD protocol parameters | Quantum Information Processing View original
Is this image relevant?
Modified BB84 Protocol Using CCD Technology View original
Is this image relevant?
Optimizing the decoy-state BB84 QKD protocol parameters | Quantum Information Processing View original
Is this image relevant?
Modified BB84 Protocol Using CCD Technology View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 2
- Preparation phase
- Alice generates random bits for the key using quantum random number generator
- Alice randomly chooses between two bases (rectilinear or diagonal) for each bit
- Transmission phase
- Alice encodes each bit into a quantum state using polarized photons
- Alice sends the quantum states to Bob through quantum channel (optical fiber)
- Measurement phase
- Bob randomly chooses a measurement basis for each received qubit (rectilinear or diagonal)
- Bob measures each qubit and records the results using single-photon detectors
- Sifting phase
- Alice and Bob publicly announce their basis choices over classical channel
- They discard measurements where bases didn't match, keeping ~50% of bits
- Key extraction
- Remaining bits form the sifted key, raw shared secret between Alice and Bob
- Error estimation
- Alice and Bob compare a subset of their sifted keys (typically 10%)
- They calculate the quantum bit error rate (QBER) to detect eavesdropping
- Privacy amplification
- If QBER is below threshold (~11%), they perform privacy amplification
- This reduces potential information leakage to an eavesdropper using hash functions
Quantum elements in BB84
- Quantum states represent encoded bits using superposition principle
- Typically use polarization states of photons for encoding
- Horizontal/vertical polarization for 0/1 in rectilinear basis
- Diagonal polarization (45°/135°) for 0/1 in diagonal basis
- Bases provide security through quantum uncertainty principle
- Two non-orthogonal bases used: rectilinear and diagonal
- Random basis choice ensures eavesdropper can't deterministically extract information
- Measurements project qubits onto chosen basis following collapse postulate
- Correct basis choice yields deterministic result
- Incorrect basis yields random result with 50% probability
- Measurement process destroys the original quantum state due to
Security Analysis
Security analysis of BB84
- Intercept-resend attack introduces 25% error rate
- Eavesdropper (Eve) intercepts qubits, measures, and resends
- Detectable by Alice and Bob through increased QBER
- prevented by authentication of classical channel
- Eve poses as Bob to Alice and as Alice to Bob
- Digital signatures or pre-shared keys used for authentication
- Photon-number splitting attack mitigated by decoy state protocol
- Exploits imperfect single-photon sources (weak coherent pulses)
- Eve splits multi-photon pulses, storing one for later measurement
- Decoy states with varying intensities detect this attack
- Trojan horse attack prevented by optical isolators and filters
- Eve sends light pulses into Alice's or Bob's apparatus
- Analyzes reflected light to gain information on settings
- Optical components block or detect unauthorized light
- Information leakage in privacy amplification reduced using universal hash functions
- Eve may gain partial information during key exchange
- Privacy amplification reduces Eve's knowledge to negligible levels
- Final key length shortened based on estimated leakage
QBER in BB84 security
- QBER defined as ratio of incorrect bits to total bits in sifted key
- Expressed as percentage, calculated from comparison subset
- QBER = (number of mismatched bits) / (total bits compared)
- Significance as indicator of eavesdropping or channel noise
- Used to estimate information leakage to potential eavesdropper
- Determines whether to proceed with key generation
- Security thresholds guide protocol decisions
- QBER < 11%: secure key can be extracted
- QBER > 11%: protocol aborted, potential eavesdropper presence
- Factors affecting QBER include eavesdropping, channel noise, detector imperfections
- Channel loss (attenuation in fiber)
- Detector dark counts and efficiency
- Environmental perturbations (temperature fluctuations)
- Relationship to key rate shows inverse correlation
- Higher QBER reduces final secure key rate
- Affects amount of privacy amplification required
- Key rate , where is binary entropy function
Key Terms to Review (15)
BB84 Protocol: The BB84 Protocol is a quantum key distribution scheme introduced by Charles Bennett and Gilles Brassard in 1984. It allows two parties to securely share a secret key by exploiting the principles of quantum mechanics, ensuring that any attempt at eavesdropping can be detected. This protocol is a cornerstone in quantum cryptography, emphasizing security through the laws of physics rather than mathematical assumptions.
Bell test: A Bell test is an experimental procedure used to demonstrate the presence of quantum entanglement by testing the predictions of quantum mechanics against those of classical physics. The test involves measuring correlations between entangled particles and checking whether these correlations exceed what can be explained by classical local hidden variable theories. This concept is crucial in understanding the security and effectiveness of quantum communication protocols, particularly in assessing the robustness of systems like the BB84 protocol.
Charles Bennett: Charles Bennett is a prominent physicist and computer scientist known for his groundbreaking contributions to the field of quantum information science, particularly in quantum cryptography. He co-developed the BB84 protocol, which laid the foundation for secure communication using quantum mechanics, and has been instrumental in advancing the theoretical understanding of quantum key distribution protocols. His work connects various aspects of classical and quantum cryptography, helping to establish frameworks for secure communications in future quantum networks.
Decoherence: Decoherence is the process by which a quantum system loses its coherent superposition of states due to interactions with its environment, leading to the emergence of classical behavior. This phenomenon is crucial in understanding how quantum systems transition to classical states, impacting various applications and theoretical concepts in quantum mechanics.
Eavesdropping detection: Eavesdropping detection refers to methods and protocols that identify unauthorized access or interception of communication in a secure environment. This concept is essential in ensuring the integrity and confidentiality of data exchanges, particularly in quantum key distribution systems where any eavesdropping can compromise the security of the keys being exchanged. Detecting eavesdropping not only involves monitoring for intrusions but also analyzing changes in communication patterns that indicate potential security breaches.
Gisin et al.: Gisin et al. refers to a significant work by Nicolas Gisin and his collaborators that critically examined the security of the BB84 quantum key distribution protocol. This foundational research highlights how real-world applications of quantum cryptography can be impacted by various types of attacks and vulnerabilities, ultimately shaping the understanding of quantum security in communication systems.
Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle: The Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle states that it is impossible to simultaneously know both the exact position and exact momentum of a particle. This principle reflects a fundamental limit on measurement and highlights the inherent probabilistic nature of quantum systems, connecting deeply with various aspects of quantum theory and its implications in different fields.
Man-in-the-middle attack: A man-in-the-middle attack is a cybersecurity breach where an attacker secretly intercepts and relays messages between two parties who believe they are directly communicating with each other. This type of attack can compromise the confidentiality and integrity of communication, making it a significant concern in secure information exchange protocols like BB84. By exploiting vulnerabilities, attackers can gain access to sensitive data or manipulate the communication without either party being aware.
No-Cloning Theorem: The no-cloning theorem states that it is impossible to create an identical copy of an arbitrary unknown quantum state. This principle is crucial in quantum mechanics as it ensures the security of quantum information and plays a pivotal role in many quantum technologies, making it impossible to simply duplicate quantum information like one can with classical bits.
Photon number splitting attack: A photon number splitting attack is a type of security breach that targets quantum key distribution protocols, specifically by exploiting the quantum nature of light. This attack occurs when a malicious eavesdropper intercepts photons sent from a sender to a receiver, particularly in scenarios where the sender uses weak coherent states. By measuring and splitting these photons, the attacker can gain information about the key without being detected, undermining the security of the communication.
Quantum Channels: Quantum channels are the mathematical models that describe how quantum information is transmitted from one location to another, taking into account the effects of noise and loss. They play a crucial role in quantum communication, determining how qubits are sent and received while preserving their integrity as much as possible. Understanding quantum channels is essential for analyzing protocols like BB84, as they directly impact the security and efficiency of quantum key distribution systems.
Quantum Cryptography: Quantum cryptography is a method of secure communication that uses the principles of quantum mechanics to ensure the confidentiality and integrity of information. It leverages the unique behaviors of quantum bits, or qubits, to create cryptographic keys that are theoretically impossible to intercept without detection. This security comes from the fundamental properties of quantum mechanics, such as superposition and entanglement, which provide a strong foundation for secure communication protocols.
Quantum Error Correction: Quantum error correction is a method used in quantum computing to protect quantum information from errors due to decoherence and other quantum noise. This technique is essential for maintaining the integrity of qubits during computation, ensuring reliable results even in the presence of errors. By employing specific codes and logical qubits, quantum error correction allows for the detection and correction of errors without directly measuring the quantum states.
Quantum Repeaters: Quantum repeaters are essential components in quantum communication networks that enable the transfer of quantum information over long distances by overcoming the limitations of direct transmission. They utilize entanglement swapping and purification techniques to extend the range of quantum communication while maintaining the fidelity of the quantum states being transmitted. This technology is pivotal in establishing secure and reliable quantum communication links across large distances.
Quantum state tomography: Quantum state tomography is a method used to determine the complete quantum state of a system by performing a series of measurements and reconstructing the state from the measurement outcomes. This process is crucial for verifying quantum states in various applications, such as quantum communication and error correction. It allows for a detailed understanding of the quantum system, providing insights into its properties and behaviors.