7.6 Poststructuralism
7 min read•august 21, 2024
emerged in the late 1960s as a critical response to structuralism's rigid systems of meaning. It challenged fixed truths in art and culture, emphasizing the instability and multiplicity of meanings in artistic interpretation.
Key thinkers like Derrida, Foucault, and Barthes influenced poststructuralist thought. Their ideas shaped artistic practices by encouraging experimentation, shifting focus to viewer interpretation, and blurring boundaries between art forms and cultural hierarchies.
Origins of poststructuralism
- Emerged in the late 1960s as a critical response to structuralism's rigid systems of meaning
- Challenged the notion of fixed, universal truths in art and culture during the postwar period
- Emphasized the instability and multiplicity of meanings in artistic interpretation
Reaction to structuralism
Top images from around the web for Reaction to structuralism
Gustavs Klucis’s ‘Constructions’ and Other Works – SOCKS View original
Is this image relevant?
Pragmatism, Critical Theory and Post-structuralism | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
GCD :: Cover :: For Beginners #[nn] - Structuralism and Poststructuralism for Beginners View original
Is this image relevant?
Gustavs Klucis’s ‘Constructions’ and Other Works – SOCKS View original
Is this image relevant?
Pragmatism, Critical Theory and Post-structuralism | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Reaction to structuralism
Gustavs Klucis’s ‘Constructions’ and Other Works – SOCKS View original
Is this image relevant?
Pragmatism, Critical Theory and Post-structuralism | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
GCD :: Cover :: For Beginners #[nn] - Structuralism and Poststructuralism for Beginners View original
Is this image relevant?
Gustavs Klucis’s ‘Constructions’ and Other Works – SOCKS View original
Is this image relevant?
Pragmatism, Critical Theory and Post-structuralism | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Rejected structuralism's belief in stable, underlying structures that govern all human activities
- Questioned the idea of universal laws or systems in language, culture, and art
- Emphasized the role of context, history, and power relations in shaping meaning
- Argued against the possibility of objective knowledge or interpretation
Key poststructuralist thinkers
- developed as a method of textual analysis
- explored and discourse in society and institutions
- examined the role of the author and reader in creating meaning
- contributed to feminist theory and the concept of
Influence of postmodernism
- Shared 's skepticism towards grand narratives and universal truths
- Embraced plurality, , and indeterminacy in artistic expression
- Challenged the modernist belief in progress and the avant-garde
- Blurred boundaries between high and low culture, influencing artistic practices
Fundamental concepts
- Emphasized the instability and in language and art
- Rejected the idea of fixed, universal truths or interpretations
- Explored how power structures and social contexts shape knowledge and artistic expression
Deconstruction of meaning
- Analyzed texts and artworks to reveal hidden assumptions and contradictions
- Emphasized the slippage between signifier and signified in language and visual representation
- Challenged the idea of a single, authoritative interpretation of an artwork
- Encouraged multiple, often conflicting readings of artistic works
Critique of grand narratives
- Rejected overarching explanations or theories that claim to explain all aspects of society or history
- Questioned the legitimacy of dominant ideologies and cultural norms
- Challenged the notion of linear progress in art history
- Emphasized local, contextual, and subjective experiences in artistic creation and interpretation
Rejection of binary oppositions
- Critiqued the tendency to organize thought in terms of opposing pairs (good/bad, male/female)
- Explored the spaces between and beyond traditional categories in art and culture
- Emphasized the fluidity and interconnectedness of concepts and identities
- Challenged hierarchical thinking in artistic evaluation and criticism
Poststructuralism in art
- Influenced artistic practices by encouraging experimentation and challenging conventions
- Shifted focus from the artist's intention to the viewer's interpretation
- Blurred boundaries between different art forms, media, and cultural hierarchies
Challenging artistic conventions
- Questioned traditional notions of authorship, originality, and artistic genius
- Experimented with non-linear narratives and fragmented compositions
- Incorporated everyday objects and popular culture references into fine art
- Explored the role of chance and indeterminacy in artistic creation (John Cage's music)
Emphasis on interpretation
- Shifted focus from the artist's intention to the viewer's role in creating meaning
- Encouraged multiple, often conflicting interpretations of artworks
- Explored the role of context and cultural background in shaping artistic reception
- Emphasized the ongoing process of meaning-making rather than fixed interpretations
Blurring of high vs low art
- Challenged the distinction between fine art and popular culture
- Incorporated mass media imagery and techniques into artistic practices
- Explored the role of kitsch and camp aesthetics in contemporary art
- Questioned the authority of art institutions and traditional canons
Theoretical frameworks
- Provided critical tools for analyzing art, culture, and society
- Influenced artistic practices and critical discourse in the postwar period
- Challenged traditional approaches to art history and criticism
Derrida's deconstruction theory
- Analyzed texts and artworks to reveal hidden assumptions and contradictions
- Emphasized the instability and multiplicity of meaning in language and visual representation
- Introduced concepts like "différance" to explore the deferral and difference of meaning
- Influenced practices and
Foucault's discourse analysis
- Examined how power structures shape knowledge and artistic expression
- Explored the relationship between art institutions and societal power dynamics
- Influenced institutional critique in contemporary art practices
- Emphasized the role of historical context in shaping artistic production and reception
Barthes and death of the author
- Challenged the idea of the artist as the sole creator of meaning in an artwork
- Emphasized the role of the viewer/reader in interpreting and creating meaning
- Influenced art and remix culture
- Explored the concept of intertextuality in artistic creation and interpretation
Impact on artistic practices
- Encouraged experimentation with new forms, media, and techniques
- Shifted focus from traditional notions of skill and craftsmanship to conceptual approaches
- Influenced the development of new art movements and styles in the postwar period
Appropriation and pastiche
- Incorporated existing images and texts into new artworks (Sherrie Levine's re-photographs)
- Challenged notions of originality and authorship in artistic creation
- Explored the role of context and recontextualization in creating meaning
- Influenced the development of remix culture and digital art practices
Text-based artworks
- Incorporated language and text as primary elements in visual art
- Explored the relationship between words and images (Joseph Kosuth's "One and Three Chairs")
- Challenged traditional boundaries between literature and visual art
- Emphasized the role of language in shaping perception and interpretation
Performance and conceptual art
- Prioritized ideas and concepts over traditional notions of artistic skill
- Explored the role of the body and lived experience in artistic creation
- Challenged the commodification of art through ephemeral and immaterial works
- Influenced the development of and
Key poststructuralist artists
- Incorporated poststructuralist ideas into their artistic practices
- Challenged traditional notions of representation, identity, and artistic authorship
- Influenced subsequent generations of artists and critical discourse
Barbara Kruger
- Combined text and found images to critique consumer culture and gender stereotypes
- Explored the relationship between power, identity, and representation
- Influenced feminist art practices and institutional critique
- Challenged the male gaze and traditional notions of femininity in advertising imagery
Jenny Holzer
- Created text-based installations and public artworks that explore power dynamics
- Used LED displays and projections to present provocative statements in public spaces
- Examined the role of language in shaping social and political realities
- Influenced conceptual art practices and public interventions
Cindy Sherman
- Created photographic self-portraits that explore identity construction and representation
- Challenged traditional notions of femininity and the male gaze in visual culture
- Influenced discussions of gender performativity and identity politics in art
- Explored the role of stereotypes and cultural archetypes in shaping perception
Criticism and debates
- Generated ongoing discussions and controversies in art theory and practice
- Challenged traditional approaches to art history and criticism
- Influenced broader cultural and philosophical debates in the postwar period
Accusations of relativism
- Critics argued that poststructuralism leads to extreme and nihilism
- Debated the possibility of meaningful critique without stable reference points
- Explored the tension between plurality of interpretations and the need for ethical stances
- Influenced discussions on the role of truth and objectivity in artistic evaluation
Poststructuralism vs modernism
- Challenged modernist notions of progress, originality, and artistic genius
- Questioned the avant-garde's role in pushing art forward
- Explored the relationship between tradition and innovation in contemporary art
- Influenced debates on the nature of artistic value and cultural hierarchies
Ethical implications
- Debated the potential for political engagement in poststructuralist art practices
- Explored the tension between critique and social responsibility in artistic creation
- Questioned the role of the artist in addressing social and political issues
- Influenced discussions on the relationship between aesthetics and ethics in contemporary art
Legacy in contemporary art
- Continues to influence artistic practices and critical discourse
- Shaped approaches to identity, representation, and interpretation in contemporary art
- Influenced the development of new media and digital art practices
Influence on identity politics
- Shaped discussions of gender, race, and sexuality in contemporary art
- Influenced intersectional approaches to identity and representation
- Explored the fluidity and performativity of identity in artistic practices
- Challenged essentialist notions of identity and cultural authenticity
Poststructuralism and digital art
- Influenced approaches to authorship and originality in digital and internet art
- Explored concepts of virtuality, simulation, and hyperreality in new media practices
- Shaped discussions of interactivity and user-generated content in digital art
- Influenced the development of glitch art and other forms of digital experimentation
Ongoing relevance in criticism
- Continues to shape approaches to art interpretation and evaluation
- Influenced the development of new critical methodologies (affect theory, new materialism)
- Shaped discussions of globalization and cultural in contemporary art
- Explored the role of institutions and markets in shaping artistic production and reception
Key Terms to Review (28)
Anti-essentialism: Anti-essentialism is a philosophical stance that rejects the idea that objects, people, or concepts have an inherent essence or set of characteristics that define them universally. This approach emphasizes that identities and meanings are fluid, shaped by context, culture, and experience rather than fixed traits. It plays a crucial role in poststructuralism by challenging the notion of stable meanings and encouraging a view of knowledge as constructed rather than discovered.
Appropriation: Appropriation is the act of taking or borrowing elements from one context and reusing them in another, often in art or cultural production. This practice raises questions about originality, authorship, and cultural ownership, as artists often blend various influences and sources to create new meanings. Appropriation can highlight issues of power dynamics in society by addressing the ways in which culture is shared and commodified.
Blurring of high vs low art: The blurring of high vs low art refers to the diminishing distinction between traditional 'high art', often associated with fine arts and elite cultural institutions, and 'low art', which includes popular and commercial forms of expression. This concept highlights how postwar artists began to incorporate elements from both categories, challenging the hierarchies that once separated them and reflecting broader social changes in art and culture.
Collage: Collage is an artistic technique that involves assembling different materials such as photographs, paper, fabric, and other objects onto a single surface to create a new composition. This method reflects the complexity of modern life and often comments on mass media, consumer culture, and the blending of various artistic styles, making it a crucial element in many postwar art movements.
Conceptual Art: Conceptual art is an artistic movement where the idea or concept behind the work is prioritized over the aesthetic or material aspects of the artwork. This approach emphasizes intellectual engagement and often challenges traditional definitions of art, inviting viewers to reconsider the relationship between art, meaning, and experience.
Contextual knowledge: Contextual knowledge refers to the understanding of the circumstances, environment, and historical background surrounding a subject or event. This type of knowledge is crucial for interpreting and analyzing art, as it provides insight into the social, political, and cultural factors that influence artistic creation and reception.
Death of the author: The death of the author is a concept that argues the creator's intentions and biographical context should not influence the interpretation of their work. This idea emphasizes that meaning arises from the interaction between the text and its readers rather than being anchored solely in the author's original intentions. This notion aligns with the broader principles of poststructuralism, which challenge fixed meanings and advocate for multiple interpretations.
Deconstruction: Deconstruction is a critical approach that seeks to unravel and challenge the assumptions, meanings, and structures within texts, philosophies, and cultural practices. It examines how language shapes our understanding of meaning and reveals the instability of concepts by exposing contradictions and ambiguities. This approach is particularly relevant in analyzing grand narratives and poststructuralist theories that question absolute truths and fixed interpretations.
Discourse analysis: Discourse analysis is a research method that focuses on understanding the ways language is used in communication, particularly how it shapes and is shaped by social contexts. It explores the relationship between language, power, and ideology, examining how meaning is constructed and conveyed through different forms of discourse, such as spoken, written, or visual texts. This approach highlights the influence of cultural and historical contexts on language use and encourages an analysis of how social structures impact communication.
Fragmentation: Fragmentation refers to the process of breaking or separating something into smaller, often disconnected parts. In art and theory, it highlights the idea that meaning is not fixed but is instead constructed from diverse and sometimes conflicting elements, reflecting the complexities of contemporary life. This notion is essential in understanding various artistic movements and critical theories that challenge unified perspectives, emphasizing multiplicity and chaos over coherence.
Hybridity: Hybridity refers to the blending and mixing of different cultural elements, identities, and practices to create something new. It captures the dynamic interaction between various influences and highlights how cultures are not static but constantly evolving, especially in a globalized world.
Installation Art: Installation art is a three-dimensional artistic genre that transforms a space into an immersive environment, often inviting viewer interaction and engagement. This form of art can be site-specific, responding directly to the characteristics of its surroundings, and it often incorporates a variety of materials and media, making it a dynamic and evolving practice in contemporary art.
Intertextuality: Intertextuality refers to the relationship between texts and how they influence, reference, or echo one another. It highlights the idea that no text exists in isolation but rather is shaped by and contributes to a web of meanings created by other texts. This concept is crucial in understanding various forms of art and literature, as it emphasizes how cultural contexts, past works, and collective memory inform new creations.
Jacques Derrida: Jacques Derrida was a French philosopher best known for developing deconstruction, a critical approach that seeks to uncover the assumptions and contradictions within texts. His work challenged established notions of meaning, authorship, and the stability of language, connecting deeply to ideas about grand narratives and poststructuralist thought. Derrida's insights have had a profound influence on various fields, including literary theory, philosophy, and cultural studies.
Julia Kristeva: Julia Kristeva is a Bulgarian-French philosopher, psychoanalyst, and literary critic, known for her work in semiotics and feminist theory. Her ideas about the relationship between language, identity, and culture have significantly influenced poststructuralist thought. Kristeva's concepts of intertextuality and the abject challenge traditional notions of meaning, emphasizing the fluidity and complexity of interpretation in literature and art.
Michel Foucault: Michel Foucault was a French philosopher and social theorist known for his work on the relationships between power, knowledge, and social institutions. His ideas about how institutions shape individuals' behavior and identity have influenced various fields, including art, literature, sociology, and cultural studies. Foucault's critiques of societal structures, particularly his focus on how knowledge is constructed and wielded to exert power, resonate deeply in discussions about institutional critique and grand narratives.
Multiplicity of meaning: Multiplicity of meaning refers to the idea that a single text, artwork, or concept can be interpreted in various ways, each providing different insights or understanding. This concept emphasizes that meanings are not fixed but can shift based on context, viewer perspective, and cultural background.
Pastiche: Pastiche refers to a work of art, literature, or music that imitates the style or character of another artist or period, often as a way to pay homage or celebrate the original. This blending and borrowing of elements can create a sense of nostalgia and commentary on the original work, while also raising questions about authenticity and originality in creative expression.
Performance Art: Performance art is a form of artistic expression that combines visual art with live action, often involving the artist's body as the primary medium. It challenges traditional notions of art by emphasizing the experience and presence of the artist and audience, transforming both participants into active collaborators in the artistic process.
Postmodernism: Postmodernism is an artistic, cultural, and philosophical movement that emerged in the mid-to-late 20th century, characterized by a skeptical, self-aware approach to art and culture. It often embraces fragmentation, irony, and the mixing of styles and mediums, challenging traditional narratives and conventions. This movement reflects the complexities of contemporary life and often questions the notion of absolute truths and fixed meanings.
Poststructuralism: Poststructuralism is an intellectual movement that emerged in the mid-20th century, challenging the structuralist approach to understanding language, culture, and meaning. It posits that meanings are not fixed but are instead fluid, influenced by context and interpretation. This perspective emphasizes the instability of language and the multiplicity of meanings, suggesting that no single interpretation can dominate, which leads to a deeper understanding of texts, artworks, and cultural phenomena.
Power dynamics: Power dynamics refers to the ways in which power is distributed and exercised within social, political, and cultural contexts. It involves the interactions between individuals or groups that influence their relative authority and influence, shaping relationships and societal structures. Understanding power dynamics is crucial for analyzing how different groups negotiate their roles, identities, and privileges in a poststructuralist framework, which challenges established hierarchies and norms.
Reader-response theory: Reader-response theory is a literary criticism approach that emphasizes the reader's role in interpreting texts, asserting that meaning is not solely derived from the author’s intention or the text itself but is co-created by the reader's experiences and emotions. This perspective challenges traditional notions of a fixed meaning and promotes a more pluralistic understanding of art and literature, where diverse interpretations coexist, which connects to the principles of pluralism and poststructuralism.
Relativism: Relativism is the philosophical viewpoint that asserts that beliefs, values, and truths are not absolute but are relative to the cultural, historical, or personal context in which they arise. This perspective challenges the idea of universal truths, suggesting instead that what is considered true or right can vary from one society or individual to another.
Roland Barthes: Roland Barthes was a French literary theorist and philosopher known for his influential ideas in semiotics, structuralism, and poststructuralism. His work challenged traditional interpretations of texts and emphasized the reader's role in creating meaning, particularly through concepts such as 'the death of the author' and 'textuality'. Barthes' thoughts significantly impacted various fields, including literature, art criticism, and cultural studies.
Sampling: Sampling refers to the practice of taking a portion of a larger whole and reusing it in a new context, often in art and music. This technique highlights the relationships between original works and their reinterpretations, allowing artists to create new meanings and commentary through appropriation. It plays a significant role in the creation of pastiche, where diverse elements from various sources are combined, as well as in poststructuralism, which challenges the idea of original authorship and meaning.
Site-specific practices: Site-specific practices refer to art or installations created with a particular location in mind, where the work's meaning and context are deeply intertwined with the environment it occupies. This approach challenges traditional art display methods by emphasizing the relationship between the artwork and its physical surroundings, encouraging viewers to engage with the space in a more personal way.
Text-based artworks: Text-based artworks are artistic creations that primarily utilize language or written text as their main medium of expression. These artworks often challenge traditional notions of visual art by emphasizing the conceptual aspects of language, blurring the boundaries between literature and visual arts, and engaging viewers in critical dialogues about meaning and interpretation. Text-based artworks can manifest in various forms such as installations, prints, and performances, often inviting audiences to interact with or reflect upon the text's significance.