Fiveable
Fiveable
Fiveable
Fiveable

10.4 Accountability and review of use of force incidents

3 min readLast Updated on August 9, 2024

Police use of force incidents require thorough review and accountability. Departments employ internal affairs investigations and after-action reviews to assess officer conduct and identify areas for improvement. External oversight, like civilian review boards, provides independent evaluation of police actions.

Technology plays a crucial role in monitoring police behavior. Body cameras and early intervention systems help deter misconduct and flag concerning patterns. Transparency initiatives, like publishing use of force data, aim to build public trust. Training programs and policy reforms address systemic issues and promote continuous improvement.

Oversight and Investigations

Internal Review Processes

Top images from around the web for Internal Review Processes
Top images from around the web for Internal Review Processes
  • Internal affairs investigations conducted by specialized units within police departments
    • Investigate allegations of misconduct or excessive force
    • Interview officers, witnesses, and complainants
    • Gather and analyze evidence (surveillance footage, physical evidence)
    • Prepare detailed reports with findings and recommendations
  • After-action reviews assess incidents to identify areas for improvement
    • Conducted by supervisors or specialized teams
    • Examine tactics, decision-making, and adherence to policies
    • Identify lessons learned and best practices
    • Recommend changes to training, equipment, or procedures

External Oversight Mechanisms

  • Civilian review boards provide independent oversight of police conduct
    • Comprised of community members not affiliated with law enforcement
    • Review complaints against officers and use of force incidents
    • Hold public hearings and issue reports on findings
    • Make recommendations for disciplinary action or policy changes
  • Disciplinary procedures address misconduct and policy violations
    • Range from verbal warnings to termination of employment
    • May include additional training, suspension, or demotion
    • Follow due process requirements and union agreements
    • Aim to correct behavior and deter future misconduct

Monitoring and Reporting

Technology-Enabled Accountability

  • Body-worn cameras record officer interactions and use of force incidents
    • Provide objective evidence of encounters
    • Deter misconduct and improve officer behavior
    • Assist in investigations and training
    • Raise privacy concerns and data management challenges
  • Early intervention systems identify officers at risk of misconduct
    • Track performance indicators (complaints, use of force incidents)
    • Flag patterns of concerning behavior
    • Trigger interventions (counseling, training, reassignment)
    • Help prevent future incidents and improve officer wellness

Transparency and Documentation

  • Use of force reporting requirements ensure thorough documentation
    • Officers must complete detailed reports for all use of force incidents
    • Include justification, witness statements, and injuries sustained
    • Supervisors review and assess compliance with policies
    • Data used for analysis, training, and policy development
  • Transparency initiatives increase public access to information
    • Publication of use of force statistics and policies
    • Release of body camera footage in high-profile incidents
    • Community engagement forums and public reporting
    • Aim to build trust and legitimacy with the community

Consequences and Reform

Accountability Measures

  • Legal liability for excessive force or misconduct
    • Civil lawsuits against individual officers or departments
    • Criminal prosecution for egregious violations
    • Financial settlements paid by municipalities
    • Can lead to increased scrutiny and pressure for reform
  • Policy reform addresses systemic issues and evolving standards
    • Regular review and update of use of force policies
    • Incorporation of de-escalation techniques and crisis intervention
    • Implementation of duty to intervene policies
    • Alignment with national best practices and legal standards

Continuous Improvement Strategies

  • Training programs focus on decision-making and de-escalation
    • Scenario-based exercises simulate high-stress situations
    • Emphasis on communication skills and cultural competency
    • Regular refresher courses on use of force policies and tactics
  • Data-driven approaches inform policy and practice
    • Analysis of use of force trends and patterns
    • Identification of factors contributing to excessive force
    • Development of targeted interventions and reforms
    • Evaluation of the effectiveness of implemented changes


© 2025 Fiveable Inc. All rights reserved.
AP® and SAT® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse this website.

© 2025 Fiveable Inc. All rights reserved.
AP® and SAT® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse this website.
Glossary
Glossary