7.3 Cutting plane methods
4 min read•july 30, 2024
Cutting plane methods are a powerful tool in integer programming, slicing through the solution space to find optimal answers. They work by adding constraints to the linear programming relaxation, gradually tightening the until an integer solution emerges.
These methods can stand alone or team up with branch and bound techniques for a one-two punch. By generating cuts based on problem structure, they help solve tricky issues in areas like vehicle routing and production planning.
Cutting Plane Methods in Integer Programming
Concept and Purpose
Top images from around the web for Concept and Purpose
Convex hull - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
File:Jarvis march convex hull algorithm diagram.svg - Wikimedia Commons View original
Is this image relevant?
Cutting-plane method - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Convex hull - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
File:Jarvis march convex hull algorithm diagram.svg - Wikimedia Commons View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Concept and Purpose
Convex hull - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
File:Jarvis march convex hull algorithm diagram.svg - Wikimedia Commons View original
Is this image relevant?
Cutting-plane method - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Convex hull - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
File:Jarvis march convex hull algorithm diagram.svg - Wikimedia Commons View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Cutting plane methods solve integer programming problems by adding constraints (cuts) to the linear programming relaxation
- Tighten the feasible region of the linear programming relaxation bringing it closer to the of integer solutions
- Identify and eliminate fractional solutions not feasible for the integer program
- Gomory generates cuts based on the simplex tableau of the linear programming relaxation
- Used as standalone algorithms or combined with techniques like branch and bound for efficient problem-solving
- Effectiveness depends on strength and relevance of generated cuts as well as problem structure
- Iterative process refines the solution space until an optimal integer solution emerges
Applications and Variations
- Applied to various integer programming problems (vehicle routing, facility location, production planning)
- Fractional cutting planes derived from optimal simplex tableau basic variables
- Gomory mixed-integer cuts handle problems with both integer and continuous variables
- Lift-and-project cuts strengthen by exploiting problem structure
- Disjunctive cuts leverage logical relationships between variables
- Cutting plane methods adapt to specific problem classes (network flow, set covering, knapsack problems)
- Implementation in commercial solvers (CPLEX, Gurobi) enhances performance for large-scale problems
Valid Inequalities and Cutting Planes
Types of Cuts
- Valid inequalities satisfied by all feasible integer solutions cut off some fractional solutions of linear programming relaxation
- Gomory fractional cuts derived from fractional parts of basic variables in optimal simplex tableau
- Lift-and-project cuts generated by lifting valid inequalities from lower-dimensional to higher-dimensional spaces
- obtained by taking non-negative linear combinations of constraints and rounding down right-hand side
- Knapsack cuts derived from knapsack constraints in many integer programming problems
- Clique cuts and odd-hole cuts based on constraint matrix structure useful for set packing and partitioning problems
- Mixed-integer rounding cuts combine continuous and integer variables to generate strong inequalities
Cut Strength and Generation
- Cut strength measured by ability to separate fractional solutions from convex hull of integer solutions
- Strong cuts significantly reduce the feasible region of linear programming relaxation
- Weak cuts may have minimal impact on solution quality or convergence speed
- Cut generation algorithms identify violated inequalities efficiently
- Separation problem solves optimization problem to find most violated inequality
- Heuristic methods quickly generate cuts sacrificing guaranteed optimality
- Cut strengthening techniques improve effectiveness of generated inequalities
- Dynamic cut generation adapts to evolving problem structure during solution process
Cutting Planes and Branch and Bound
Branch-and-Cut Algorithm
- Integration of cutting plane methods with branch and bound algorithms creates branch-and-cut hybrid approach
- Cutting planes generated at each node of branch and bound tree tighten linear programming relaxation before branching
- Decision to generate cuts or branch based on criteria (objective function improvement, node depth, computational time)
- Local cuts generated and applied to specific nodes in branch and bound tree
- Global cuts valid for entire problem applied to all nodes
- Cut management strategies balance benefits of adding cuts with increased computational complexity
- Effectiveness depends on interplay between branching decisions and cut generation as well as problem-specific characteristics
Implementation Strategies
- Dynamic cut generation determines when and where to apply cuts in branch and bound tree
- Cut pool management stores and reuses effective cuts across multiple nodes
- Primal heuristics incorporated to find feasible integer solutions quickly
- Branching strategies (strong branching, pseudocost branching) complement cutting plane generation
- Parallel implementations exploit multi-core processors for simultaneous cut generation and branching
- Warm starting techniques leverage information from previous solutions to accelerate convergence
- Hybrid approaches combine branch-and-cut with other metaheuristics (genetic algorithms, tabu search)
Cutting Plane Strategy Effectiveness
Performance Metrics
- Effectiveness measured by ability to reduce integrality gap and accelerate convergence to optimal integer solution
- Metrics include number of cuts generated improvement in objective function value reduction in branch and bound nodes explored
- Computational overhead of generating and managing cuts balanced against benefits of tightening linear programming relaxation
- Problem-specific cut generation strategies often outperform generic methods for certain integer programming classes
- Order of different cut types generation and addition significantly impacts overall cutting plane method performance
- Strategies focusing on generating small number of strong cuts often more effective than those generating many weak cuts
- Effectiveness varies depending on problem structure size and characteristics necessitating careful selection and tuning
Advanced Considerations
- Cut separation time versus linear programming solve time trade-off analysis
- Impact of cut density on linear programming solver performance
- Interaction between cutting planes and preprocessing techniques
- Effectiveness of cutting planes in presence of symmetry in problem formulation
- Robustness of cutting plane strategies across different problem instances
- Learning algorithms to predict most effective cutting plane strategy for given problem
- Theoretical guarantees on convergence and solution quality for specific cutting plane methods
Key Terms to Review (16)
Alexander Chvátal: Alexander Chvátal is a prominent mathematician known for his significant contributions to combinatorial optimization and graph theory, particularly in the development of cutting plane methods. His work in this area has influenced the way optimization problems are approached, especially in relation to integer programming and polyhedral theory.
Branch-and-cut algorithm: The branch-and-cut algorithm is a powerful method for solving integer programming problems, which combines two techniques: branching and cutting planes. By systematically exploring feasible solutions through branching and refining the solution space using cutting planes, this algorithm efficiently narrows down to the optimal integer solution. This approach is particularly useful for complex optimization problems where traditional methods may struggle.
Chvátal-Gomory Cuts: Chvátal-Gomory cuts are a type of cutting plane used in integer programming to help improve the solution of linear relaxation problems. These cuts are derived from the idea of adding constraints that eliminate fractional solutions while preserving all integer feasible solutions. By integrating these cuts into algorithms, they enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of methods aimed at finding optimal solutions in combinatorial optimization problems.
Convex Hull: A convex hull is the smallest convex set that contains a given set of points in a Euclidean space. It can be visualized as the shape formed by stretching a rubber band around the outermost points. Understanding the convex hull is crucial for various optimization problems, as it helps identify feasible regions and optimal solutions within convex sets.
Cutting Plane Algorithm: The cutting plane algorithm is a mathematical optimization technique used to solve integer programming problems by iteratively refining a feasible region. It works by adding linear inequalities, called cutting planes, to eliminate portions of the feasible region that do not contain optimal integer solutions, thereby moving closer to the solution. This method enhances efficiency by focusing on specific areas of the search space, leading to quicker convergence towards an optimal solution.
Extreme Points: Extreme points are the vertices of a feasible region in optimization problems, where the maximum or minimum values of an objective function can be achieved. These points are crucial because they represent the best potential solutions within the constraints set by the problem. Identifying extreme points allows for a systematic approach to optimize the objective function while adhering to the specified constraints.
Facet-defining inequalities: Facet-defining inequalities are crucial constraints in optimization problems that define the boundaries of the feasible region for a polytope. These inequalities play a significant role in characterizing the shape of the feasible set, ensuring that it is bounded and well-defined. Essentially, they help in tightening the formulation of optimization problems, leading to more efficient solutions.
Feasible Region: The feasible region is the set of all possible solutions that satisfy a given set of constraints in an optimization problem. This region is crucial because it defines the limits within which the objective function must be optimized, reflecting the trade-offs and limitations imposed by the constraints.
Gomory cuts: Gomory cuts are a type of cutting plane used in integer programming to eliminate fractional solutions from the feasible region of a linear programming relaxation. They help refine the feasible set and push the solution towards integer values, thereby aiding in the optimization process. By adding these constraints, the search space is reduced, making it possible to find integer solutions more efficiently.
Integer Feasibility: Integer feasibility refers to the condition where a solution to an optimization problem, particularly in integer programming, consists entirely of integer values. This is crucial because many real-world problems, such as scheduling or resource allocation, require decisions that cannot be fractional, making integer solutions essential for practical applicability.
Lp relaxation: LP relaxation refers to the process of transforming a combinatorial optimization problem, which typically has integer constraints, into a linear programming problem by relaxing these integer constraints. This means that the variables that were previously restricted to take on only integer values can now take on any real value within a specified range. The purpose of LP relaxation is to simplify the problem, making it easier to solve while still providing valuable insights about the original problem's feasible region and optimal solutions.
Network design problems: Network design problems involve optimizing the layout and connections of a network to meet specific objectives, such as minimizing costs or maximizing efficiency. These problems are crucial in various fields, including telecommunications, transportation, and logistics, where effective network structures can significantly impact performance and service delivery.
Polytopes: Polytopes are geometric figures that exist in a finite-dimensional space, defined as the convex hull of a finite set of points. They can be thought of as the generalization of polygons and polyhedra to any number of dimensions, characterized by their vertices, edges, and faces. Polytopes play a crucial role in various optimization methods, particularly in the formulation and solution of linear programming problems.
Ralph Gomory: Ralph Gomory is a prominent mathematician and computer scientist known for his significant contributions to optimization, particularly in the area of cutting plane methods. His work laid the foundation for advancements in integer programming, introducing techniques that helped refine solutions by iteratively adding constraints. Gomory's approaches have been instrumental in making optimization problems more tractable and efficient, particularly in industrial applications.
Scheduling problems: Scheduling problems involve allocating resources over time to perform a collection of tasks, with the goal of optimizing specific criteria such as minimizing completion time or maximizing resource utilization. These problems are often characterized by constraints like deadlines, resource availability, and task dependencies, making them a significant focus within optimization strategies. They can be formulated as various types of optimization problems, especially integer programming, where decisions must be made on discrete variables.
Valid inequalities: Valid inequalities are constraints added to a mathematical optimization problem that do not exclude any feasible solutions of the original problem, thus maintaining its feasible region while potentially improving the efficiency of the solution process. They play a crucial role in enhancing linear programming formulations and are particularly significant in cutting plane methods, where they help to tighten the linear relaxation of integer programming problems by cutting off non-integer solutions.