8.3 Distance-Based and Character-Based Phylogenetic Algorithms
5 min read•july 30, 2024
Phylogenetic algorithms are essential tools for understanding evolutionary relationships. Distance-based methods like and use pairwise distances to construct trees quickly, while character-based approaches like and analyze sequence data directly.
Each method has its strengths and limitations. Distance-based algorithms are computationally efficient but may lose information, while character-based methods are more detailed but can be slower. Choosing the right approach depends on your data and research goals.
Distance-based algorithms for phylogenetics
UPGMA and Neighbor-Joining Methods
Top images from around the web for UPGMA and Neighbor-Joining Methods
pone.0012599.g005.png | Neighbor-joining phylogenetic tree i… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Figure 5 | Rooted neighbor-joining phylogenetic tree of Gamm… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Figure 4 | The neighbor-joining phylogenetic tree of the 136… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
pone.0012599.g005.png | Neighbor-joining phylogenetic tree i… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Figure 5 | Rooted neighbor-joining phylogenetic tree of Gamm… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for UPGMA and Neighbor-Joining Methods
pone.0012599.g005.png | Neighbor-joining phylogenetic tree i… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Figure 5 | Rooted neighbor-joining phylogenetic tree of Gamm… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Figure 4 | The neighbor-joining phylogenetic tree of the 136… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
pone.0012599.g005.png | Neighbor-joining phylogenetic tree i… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Figure 5 | Rooted neighbor-joining phylogenetic tree of Gamm… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Distance-based algorithms construct phylogenetic trees using pairwise distances between sequences to represent evolutionary relationships among organisms
- UPGMA (Unweighted Pair Group Method with Arithmetic Mean) assumes a constant evolution rate and produces ultrametric trees with equal branch lengths from any tip to the root
- Neighbor-joining allows for variable evolutionary rates and produces additive trees where branch lengths represent evolutionary distances
- Both methods use distance matrices as input calculated using various evolutionary models (Jukes-Cantor, Kimura two-parameter)
- Tree construction involves iterative clustering of taxa based on their pairwise distances
- Computationally efficient algorithms handle large datasets, making them suitable for initial tree estimation in phylogenetic analyses
- Accuracy depends on the quality of distance estimates and appropriateness of the evolutionary model used
Distance Matrix Calculation and Tree Construction
- Calculate pairwise distances between sequences using evolutionary models
- Jukes-Cantor model assumes equal substitution rates between all nucleotides
- Kimura two-parameter model distinguishes between transitions and transversions
- Create a distance matrix from the calculated pairwise distances
- Iteratively cluster taxa based on smallest distances in the matrix
- Update distances to newly formed clusters using average (UPGMA) or weighted (neighbor-joining) methods
- Continue clustering until all taxa are connected in a single tree
- Example: For 5 species A, B, C, D, E with pairwise distances:
A B C D E A 0 5 9 7 8 B 0 10 8 9 C 0 6 7 D 0 3 E 0 - UPGMA would first cluster D and E (smallest distance), then A and B, etc.
Advantages and Limitations
- Computationally efficient for large datasets (hundreds or thousands of sequences)
- Provide quick initial estimates of evolutionary relationships
- Can incorporate various evolutionary models for distance calculation
- May lose information by converting character data to distances
- UPGMA assumes a constant evolutionary rate, potentially leading to inaccurate trees for lineages with variable rates
- Neighbor-joining more flexible than UPGMA but may not always find the optimal tree
- Accuracy heavily dependent on the quality of distance estimates
Minimum evolution in phylogenetic inference
Principles and Methods
- Minimum evolution assumes the true evolutionary tree has the smallest total branch length
- Based on the parsimony principle favoring simpler explanations for observed data
- Aims to find the tree topology minimizing the sum of all branch lengths when fitted to a given distance matrix
- Neighbor-joining algorithm approximates the minimum evolution method, providing a computationally efficient way to estimate minimum evolution trees
- Used as an optimality criterion for selecting among alternative tree topologies
- Closely related to the least-squares method for fitting branch lengths to a given tree topology
- Sensitive to long-branch attraction, potentially leading to incorrect tree inference when evolutionary rates vary significantly among lineages
Implementation and Applications
- Calculate pairwise distances between sequences using an appropriate evolutionary model
- Generate initial tree topology (neighbor-joining or other method)
- Optimize branch lengths using least-squares method
- Calculate total tree length by summing all branch lengths
- Iterate through alternative tree topologies, recalculating branch lengths and total tree length
- Select the topology with the smallest total tree length as the minimum evolution tree
- Example: For three species A, B, C with distances:
A-B: 0.1 A-C: 0.2 B-C: 0.15 - Three possible unrooted tree topologies:
- (A,B),C
- (A,C),B
- (B,C),A
- Calculate total tree length for each topology and choose the smallest
Character-based methods for phylogeny
Maximum Parsimony
- Uses discrete character states (nucleotides, amino acids) directly to infer phylogenetic relationships
- Seeks the tree topology requiring the fewest evolutionary changes to explain observed character states across taxa
- Calculates minimum number of changes required for each possible tree, selecting tree(s) with lowest overall score
- Employs various algorithms to find most parsimonious tree(s):
- Branch-and-bound algorithm (exhaustive search for small datasets)
- Heuristic searches (stepwise addition, tree bisection and reconnection for larger datasets)
- Can incorporate different weights for character changes and account for multiple substitutions at the same site
- Example: For 4 species with the following DNA sequences:
Species A: ATCG Species B: ATTG Species C: ATCG Species D: ACCG - Most parsimonious tree would group A and C together, requiring only 2 changes (T->C in B, T->C in D)
Maximum Likelihood
- Estimates tree topology and branch lengths maximizing the probability of observing given sequence data under a specified evolutionary model
- Requires explicit models of sequence evolution (GTR - General Time Reversible for nucleotide sequences)
- Utilizes tree search algorithms to find maximum likelihood tree:
- Hill-climbing
- Simulated annealing
- Can incorporate different weights for character changes and account for multiple substitutions at the same site
- Provides more detailed information about evolutionary processes compared to distance-based methods
- Computationally intensive, especially for large datasets
- Example: Calculate likelihood of observing data given a tree topology and evolutionary model:
- Choose tree topology and branch lengths maximizing this likelihood
Phylogenetic algorithms: strengths vs limitations
Computational Efficiency and Information Usage
- Distance-based methods (UPGMA, neighbor-joining) computationally efficient and handle large datasets
- Character-based methods (maximum parsimony, maximum likelihood) utilize all available character information
- Distance methods may lose information by converting character data to distances
- Character-based methods can be computationally intensive for large datasets
Model Assumptions and Flexibility
- UPGMA assumes constant evolution rate, potentially leading to inaccurate trees when rates vary among lineages
- Neighbor-joining more flexible than UPGMA, accommodating variable evolutionary rates
- Maximum parsimony intuitive and doesn't require explicit evolutionary model
- Maximum likelihood provides statistical framework for hypothesis testing and model selection, but requires specifying evolutionary model
Accuracy and Limitations
- Neighbor-joining may not always find optimal tree
- Maximum parsimony sensitive to long-branch attraction, potentially underestimating change along branches
- Maximum likelihood can be computationally demanding
- Choice of algorithm depends on research question, dataset size, computational resources, and evolutionary process assumptions
Combining Methods and Statistical Support
- Using multiple methods provides more robust assessment of phylogenetic relationships
- or other statistical techniques evaluate tree reliability
- Example: Generate 100 bootstrap replicates of original dataset, construct trees for each replicate
- Calculate percentage of replicates supporting each branch in the final tree
- Branches with high bootstrap support (>70%) considered more reliable
Key Terms to Review (20)
AIC: AIC, or Akaike Information Criterion, is a measure used to compare different statistical models based on their goodness of fit while penalizing for model complexity. It helps in selecting the best model by balancing the trade-off between accuracy and overfitting. A lower AIC value indicates a better model, making it a crucial tool in model selection for phylogenetic analysis.
Analogy: An analogy is a cognitive process in which one situation or concept is compared to another in order to highlight similarities, often to explain complex ideas. In the context of distance-based and character-based phylogenetic algorithms, analogies can be used to illustrate evolutionary relationships by drawing parallels between different species or genetic traits. Understanding these analogies aids in visualizing the underlying biological concepts and enhances comprehension of phylogenetic analyses.
Bayesian Inference: Bayesian inference is a statistical method that applies Bayes' theorem to update the probability of a hypothesis as more evidence or information becomes available. This approach allows researchers to incorporate prior knowledge alongside new data, making it particularly useful in fields like bioinformatics and molecular biology for interpreting complex biological data.
BIC: BIC, or Bayesian Information Criterion, is a statistical criterion used for model selection among a finite set of models. It estimates the quality of each model based on its likelihood and the number of parameters used, with a penalty for complexity to avoid overfitting. The lower the BIC value, the better the model fits the data while maintaining simplicity, making it particularly useful in the context of phylogenetic algorithms where selecting an appropriate model can significantly influence tree reconstruction accuracy.
Bootstrap analysis: Bootstrap analysis is a statistical method used to estimate the accuracy of a sample statistic by resampling with replacement from the original data set. This technique is particularly valuable in molecular biology, as it helps in assessing the confidence levels of phylogenetic trees and aligning sequences, providing insight into the reliability of the inferred relationships and structures.
Character matrix: A character matrix is a tabular representation of the characteristics (or traits) of different species or entities, typically used in the analysis of phylogenetics. Each row represents a different species or taxon, while each column represents a specific character or trait, indicating the presence or absence of these traits across the species. This structured format helps researchers compare evolutionary relationships and construct phylogenetic trees.
Consensus tree: A consensus tree is a phylogenetic tree that summarizes the relationships inferred from multiple individual trees, aiming to represent common branching patterns and relationships among taxa. This method is particularly useful when there are different phylogenetic hypotheses, as it provides a unified view of the data while accommodating uncertainty in the evolutionary history.
Euclidean Distance: Euclidean distance is a measure of the straight-line distance between two points in Euclidean space. This concept is crucial for analyzing data points in various applications, such as clustering and phylogenetic analysis, where it helps quantify how similar or different entities are based on their attributes. By calculating the Euclidean distance, researchers can group similar data points together or determine the evolutionary relationships among organisms based on genetic data.
Hamming Distance: Hamming distance is a metric used to measure the difference between two strings of equal length by counting the number of positions at which the corresponding symbols differ. This concept is particularly useful in computational biology for comparing sequences, as it provides a quantitative way to evaluate genetic variations and similarities between DNA, RNA, or protein sequences. In various algorithms, this distance helps in constructing phylogenetic trees and clustering sequences based on their genetic similarity.
Homology: Homology refers to the similarity in sequence or structure between biological molecules, such as proteins or nucleic acids, due to shared ancestry. This concept is essential in comparing sequences and constructing phylogenetic relationships, as it allows researchers to identify conserved regions that may have important functional roles.
Maximum likelihood: Maximum likelihood is a statistical method used for estimating the parameters of a statistical model by maximizing a likelihood function, so the observed data is most probable under the model. This approach is foundational in various fields, including phylogenetics, as it allows researchers to infer the most likely tree structure that reflects the evolutionary relationships among species based on observed genetic data. By applying maximum likelihood estimation, researchers can assess different tree hypotheses and determine which one best explains the observed sequence data.
Maximum parsimony: Maximum parsimony is a method used in phylogenetics to construct a tree that represents the evolutionary relationships among a set of species by minimizing the total number of character changes or evolutionary events. This approach assumes that the simplest explanation, or the one with the least complexity, is usually the correct one, making it a popular choice for inferring phylogenetic trees based on genetic data.
Mega: In biological contexts, 'mega' typically refers to a factor of one million, often used in measurements or classifications of biological entities. It can indicate large scale or significant quantities, especially when discussing genetic variations or evolutionary processes that involve vast numbers of organisms or extensive timeframes.
Molecular clock: A molecular clock is a technique used to estimate the time of evolutionary events based on the rate of molecular change in DNA or protein sequences. This method assumes that mutations accumulate at a relatively constant rate over time, allowing scientists to infer the timing of divergences among species. The molecular clock is essential in understanding evolutionary relationships and in constructing phylogenetic trees.
Neighbor-joining: Neighbor-joining is a distance-based method for constructing phylogenetic trees that seeks to minimize the total branch length. This method uses pairwise distance data to create a tree that reflects the evolutionary relationships among a set of species or sequences, making it a key technique in molecular biology and bioinformatics. It's particularly valued for its efficiency and ability to handle large datasets, providing a good approximation of the true evolutionary history.
Phylogenetic tree: A phylogenetic tree is a graphical representation that illustrates the evolutionary relationships among various biological species or entities based on similarities and differences in their physical or genetic characteristics. It showcases how species have diverged from common ancestors over time, and helps in understanding the history of evolution. These trees are crucial in studying molecular evolution, as they can be constructed using multiple sequence alignment data, and serve as a foundation for both distance-based and character-based phylogenetic methods.
Raxml: RAxML (Randomized Axelerated Maximum Likelihood) is a software program used for constructing phylogenetic trees based on maximum likelihood estimation. It is particularly useful for analyzing large datasets and has become a standard tool in computational biology for inferring evolutionary relationships among species or genes, leveraging different models of sequence evolution.
Sequence Alignment: Sequence alignment is a computational method used to arrange sequences of DNA, RNA, or proteins to identify regions of similarity that may indicate functional, structural, or evolutionary relationships. This process is crucial for comparing biological sequences to detect conserved sequences, infer phylogenetic relationships, and predict secondary structures.
Tree robustness: Tree robustness refers to the stability and reliability of a phylogenetic tree in accurately representing evolutionary relationships among species. This concept is crucial for assessing how sensitive a tree is to changes in the underlying data, such as the addition or removal of taxa or variations in sequence alignment. A robust tree will maintain its structure and relationships even when faced with such perturbations, making it a valuable tool for understanding evolutionary biology.
UPGMA: UPGMA, or Unweighted Pair Group Method with Arithmetic Mean, is a simple agglomerative clustering method used to construct phylogenetic trees based on distance matrices. It operates by grouping sequences or taxa into clusters based on their average pairwise distances, creating a hierarchical tree structure that reflects the genetic relationships among the sequences.