Glossary

9.2 Constrained Variation and Lagrange Multipliers

3 min read•july 22, 2024

Constrained variation tackles problems where we need to find the best solution while following specific rules. It's like trying to find the fastest route to school but only using certain roads.

are special tools that help us solve these problems. They're like magic numbers that let us turn a tricky problem with rules into a simpler one we can solve more easily.

Constrained Variation and Lagrange Multipliers

Formulation of constrained variational problems

Top images from around the web for Formulation of constrained variational problems

  • Lagrange-multiplicator - Wikipedia View original

    Is this image relevant?

  • Lagrange multiplier - Wikipedia View original

    Is this image relevant?

  • Lagrange-multiplicator - Wikipedia View original

    Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Formulation of constrained variational problems

  • Lagrange-multiplicator - Wikipedia View original

    Is this image relevant?

  • Lagrange multiplier - Wikipedia View original

    Is this image relevant?

  • Lagrange-multiplicator - Wikipedia View original

    Is this image relevant?

1 of 3
  • Variational problems seek to find extrema (maxima or minima) of functionals which map functions to real numbers
  • Constraints restrict the space of admissible functions in variational problems
    • Equality constraints expressed as g(x,y(x))=0g(x, y(x)) = 0 (geodesic curves on surfaces)
    • Inequality constraints expressed as h(x,y(x))≥0h(x, y(x)) \geq 0 (non-negative functions)
  • Lagrange multipliers (λ\lambda) incorporate constraints into the functional
    • Modified functional: J[y]=F[y]+∫λ(x)g(x,y(x))dxJ[y] = F[y] + \int \lambda(x) g(x, y(x)) dx where λ(x)\lambda(x) is a Lagrange multiplier function
    • Lagrange multiplier term acts as a penalty for violating the constraint (energy conservation)

Solution of constrained variational problems

  • for unconstrained problems: ∂F∂y−ddx(∂F∂y′)=0\frac{\partial F}{\partial y} - \frac{d}{dx}\left(\frac{\partial F}{\partial y'}\right) = 0
  • Modified Euler-Lagrange equation for constrained problems includes the constraint term
    • ∂F∂y+λ(x)∂g∂y−ddx(∂F∂y′)−ddx(λ(x)∂g∂y′)=0\frac{\partial F}{\partial y} + \lambda(x) \frac{\partial g}{\partial y} - \frac{d}{dx}\left(\frac{\partial F}{\partial y'}\right) - \frac{d}{dx}\left(\lambda(x) \frac{\partial g}{\partial y'}\right) = 0
  • Constraint equation g(x,y(x))=0g(x, y(x)) = 0 must also be satisfied simultaneously
  • Solve the system of equations to find the extremal function y(x)y(x) and Lagrange multiplier λ(x)\lambda(x)
    1. Derive the modified Euler-Lagrange equation and constraint equation
    2. Apply boundary conditions and initial conditions
    3. Solve the resulting system of differential equations (analytically or numerically)

Physical meaning of Lagrange multipliers

  • Lagrange multipliers represent the sensitivity of the optimal functional value to changes in the constraint
    • λ=∂J∂ε\lambda = \frac{\partial J}{\partial \varepsilon} where ε\varepsilon is a small change in the constraint
  • In physical systems, Lagrange multipliers often interpret as generalized forces or potentials
    • In a system with a total energy constraint, the Lagrange multiplier represents the reciprocal temperature (β=1/kT\beta = 1/kT)
    • In a system with a constant volume constraint, the Lagrange multiplier represents the pressure
  • Lagrange multipliers provide insight into the trade-offs between optimizing the objective and satisfying the constraints

Stability of constrained variation solutions

  • Second variation test assesses the stability of solutions
    • Calculate the second variation δ2J[y,η]\delta^2 J[y, \eta] for admissible variations η(x)\eta(x)
    • If δ2J[y,η]>0\delta^2 J[y, \eta] > 0 for all non-zero η(x)\eta(x), the solution is a strict local minimum (stable equilibrium)
    • If δ2J[y,η]<0\delta^2 J[y, \eta] < 0 for some η(x)\eta(x), the solution is not a minimum (unstable equilibrium)
    • If δ2J[y,η]≥0\delta^2 J[y, \eta] \geq 0 for all η(x)\eta(x), further analysis is needed (neutral stability)
  • Uniqueness of solutions depends on the properties of the functional and constraints
    • Strict convexity of the functional and linearity of the constraints are for uniqueness
    • Multiple solutions may exist in some cases, requiring additional criteria to select the physically relevant solution (ground state energy)

Key Terms to Review (16)

Boundary Value Problems: Boundary value problems involve finding solutions to differential equations subject to specific conditions at the boundaries of the domain. These problems are crucial in many areas of physics and engineering, as they help model real-world situations where values are fixed at certain points, such as temperature or potential in a physical system. Understanding how to solve these problems is essential for analyzing systems governed by Laplace's and Poisson's equations or applying techniques like Lagrange multipliers in constrained optimization.
Constraint equations: Constraint equations are mathematical expressions that limit the possible values of variables in a system. They play a crucial role in optimization problems, particularly when finding extrema of functions subject to certain conditions. These equations ensure that the solution adheres to specific constraints, allowing for the use of methods like Lagrange multipliers to handle situations where variables cannot be freely varied.
Euler-Lagrange Equation: The Euler-Lagrange equation is a fundamental equation in the calculus of variations that provides a necessary condition for a functional to have an extremum. This equation relates the derivatives of a function and arises when determining the path or function that minimizes or maximizes a certain quantity, often expressed as an integral. It plays a crucial role in formulating physical theories and understanding the dynamics of systems through variational principles.
Gradient: The gradient is a vector operator that represents the rate and direction of change of a scalar field. It points in the direction of the greatest increase of the scalar function, with its magnitude indicating how steep that increase is. Understanding the gradient is essential when dealing with multivariable functions, as it helps analyze how a function changes in various directions and is crucial in optimization problems involving constraints.
Hessian Matrix: The Hessian matrix is a square matrix of second-order partial derivatives of a scalar-valued function, used to determine the local curvature of the function. It provides crucial information about the behavior of functions in optimization problems, particularly in the context of constrained variations and Lagrange multipliers, by helping to assess whether a critical point is a minimum, maximum, or saddle point.
Holonomic Constraints: Holonomic constraints are restrictions on a system that can be expressed as equations involving the generalized coordinates and time, allowing for the description of the system's configuration. These constraints can typically be integrated into a form that only depends on the generalized coordinates and time, making them easier to handle in variational principles. They play a significant role in understanding constrained systems, especially when applying methods like Lagrange multipliers to optimize functions under specific conditions.
Isoperimetric Problems: Isoperimetric problems involve finding the shape of a given area that minimizes or maximizes a particular quantity, typically related to perimeter or surface area, while adhering to specific constraints. These problems are deeply rooted in calculus of variations and often utilize techniques like Lagrange multipliers to handle constraints effectively, showcasing the interplay between geometry and optimization.
Joseph-Louis Lagrange: Joseph-Louis Lagrange was an influential mathematician and physicist known for his significant contributions to various areas of mathematics and mechanics, particularly in formulating the principles of Lagrangian mechanics. His work laid the foundation for analyzing systems in terms of their energy and constraints, connecting to concepts like variational principles and optimization in mathematical physics.
Lagrange Multipliers: Lagrange multipliers are a mathematical technique used to find the local maxima and minima of a function subject to equality constraints. This method transforms a constrained optimization problem into an unconstrained one by introducing additional variables (the multipliers) that incorporate the constraints into the objective function. Understanding this concept connects deeply with multivariable functions and partial derivatives, as it involves taking partial derivatives and setting them to zero to find critical points while considering constraints.
Leonhard Euler: Leonhard Euler was an 18th-century Swiss mathematician and physicist who made significant contributions across various fields, including calculus, graph theory, and mechanics. His work laid the groundwork for many modern mathematical techniques, especially in the context of constrained variation and optimization problems.
Mechanical Systems: Mechanical systems are collections of interconnected components that interact through mechanical forces, often described mathematically by differential equations. These systems are essential in analyzing physical phenomena, enabling the prediction of behavior under various conditions and constraints. They can include anything from simple pendulums to complex machinery, and their study often involves understanding stability, equilibrium, and dynamics.
Necessary Conditions: Necessary conditions refer to the specific requirements that must be satisfied for a certain outcome or situation to occur. In the context of constrained variation and Lagrange multipliers, these conditions help identify the points at which a function achieves an extremum while adhering to constraints, guiding the optimization process.
Non-holonomic constraints: Non-holonomic constraints are restrictions on a system that depend on the velocities of the system's coordinates and cannot be expressed solely in terms of the coordinates themselves. These constraints are often associated with systems where the motion is subject to limits that do not integrate to a simple relationship between position variables, making them essential in the analysis of dynamic systems where path dependencies exist.
Optical Paths: Optical paths refer to the trajectories that light rays follow as they travel through different media. This concept is crucial in understanding how light behaves when it encounters varying refractive indices, and it directly relates to the principle of least time, which is often explored through constrained variation and optimization techniques.
Principle of least action: The principle of least action states that the path taken by a system between two states is the one for which the action is minimized. This fundamental concept links the dynamics of physical systems to their underlying mathematical descriptions, highlighting how systems evolve over time through a minimization process, which can be constrained by additional conditions.
Sufficient Conditions: Sufficient conditions are specific criteria or requirements that, if met, guarantee a certain outcome or conclusion. In the context of optimization and constrained variation, understanding sufficient conditions helps to identify when a solution can be confirmed as optimal, particularly when using techniques like Lagrange multipliers, which incorporate constraints into the optimization process.
© 2024 Fiveable Inc. All rights reserved.
AP® and SAT® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse this website.
Back
Practice QuizGlossary
Practice QuizGlossary
Next guide