3.2 Trade Barriers and Protectionism
3 min read•august 16, 2024
Trade barriers and protectionism play a crucial role in international trade. Countries use various methods like , , and to shield domestic industries from foreign competition and achieve economic or political goals.
These measures can have both positive and negative impacts. While they may protect jobs and infant industries in the short term, they often lead to higher prices for consumers and reduced in the long run. Understanding these trade-offs is key to grasping international trade dynamics.
Types of Trade Barriers
Tariffs and Quotas
Top images from around the web for Tariffs and Quotas
Gains from Trade | Boundless Economics View original
Is this image relevant?
Tariffs vs. Quotas | Marginal Revolution University View original
Is this image relevant?
Tariff - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Gains from Trade | Boundless Economics View original
Is this image relevant?
Tariffs vs. Quotas | Marginal Revolution University View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Tariffs and Quotas
Gains from Trade | Boundless Economics View original
Is this image relevant?
Tariffs vs. Quotas | Marginal Revolution University View original
Is this image relevant?
Tariff - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Gains from Trade | Boundless Economics View original
Is this image relevant?
Tariffs vs. Quotas | Marginal Revolution University View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Tariffs increase prices of imported goods in domestic markets through taxation
- Ad valorem tariffs calculate as a percentage of good's value
- Specific tariffs apply fixed amounts per unit
- Quotas restrict quantity or value of specific imported goods during set periods
- (VERs) limit exports to importing countries through agreements
- Example: 1980s Japanese auto exports to U.S. limited by VER
Non-Tariff Barriers
- Non-tariff barriers (NTBs) restrict trade without using tariffs
- Include , , ,
- require government permission before importing certain goods
- Example: Agricultural product import licenses in India
- Technical barriers encompass product standards, safety regulations, certification requirements
- Example: EU restrictions on genetically modified organisms (GMOs)
Motivations for Trade Barriers
Economic Rationales
- shields new domestic industries from foreign competition
- Allows time to develop competitiveness (South Korea's automotive industry)
- considerations aim to reduce imports and improve trade balance
- Example: Brazil's import substitution policies in 1960s-70s
- provides government income, especially in developing countries
- Example: Import duties contribute significantly to government revenue in many African nations
Political and Security Motivations
- concerns protect strategic industries or prevent foreign dependence
- Example: U.S. restrictions on Chinese technology companies (Huawei)
- preserves domestic employment in industries facing foreign competition
- Example: U.S. steel tariffs to protect American steel workers
- against unfair trade practices serves as economic diplomacy
- Example: EU tariffs on U.S. goods in response to steel and aluminum tariffs
- protects domestic cultural industries from foreign influence
- Example: Canadian content requirements for broadcasting
Impact of Protectionist Measures
Effects on Domestic Economy
- Increased prices for consumers result from reduced competition and higher import costs
- Example: Higher smartphone prices due to tariffs on imported components
- Domestic industries may become less efficient and innovative due to reduced competition
- Example: U.S. automotive industry in 1970s-80s
- Resource allocation distortions lead to economic inefficiencies and reduced welfare
- Example: Subsidies for inefficient industries divert resources from more productive sectors
- Short-term benefits for protected industries include increased profitability and job security
- Example: Temporary boost to U.S. steel industry following tariff implementation
International Consequences
- Retaliatory measures by other countries potentially lead to
- Example: U.S.-China trade war escalation in 2018-2019
- Damaged international relations strain diplomatic and economic ties
- Example: Deterioration of U.S.-EU relations over agricultural subsidies
- affect businesses relying on international sourcing
- Example: Automotive industry supply chain issues due to trade restrictions
- Reduced and quality for consumers due to limited access to foreign goods
- Example: Decreased availability of European cheeses in U.S. due to tariffs
Effectiveness of Trade Barriers
Short-Term Outcomes
- Immediate job protection in targeted industries provides temporary relief
- Example: Increased employment in U.S. washing machine industry following tariffs
- Quick revenue generation through tariffs boosts government income
- Example: Increased customs revenue in developing countries implementing tariffs
- Rapid response to unfair trade practices demonstrates economic strength
- Example: EU's swift implementation of retaliatory tariffs against U.S. in 2018
Long-Term Consequences
- Infant industry protection success depends on developing competitive advantages
- Example: South Korea's successful electronics industry vs Venezuela's failed automotive sector
- Job protection often offset by losses in other sectors due to increased costs
- Example: Job losses in U.S. steel-using industries outweighing gains in steel production
- Reduced overall economic growth from lower trade volumes and inefficiencies
- Example: Estimated GDP losses from U.S.-China trade war
- Limited effectiveness due to global economic integration and technological advancements
- Example: Digital services trade bypassing traditional trade barriers
- Potential violations of international trade agreements leading to disputes
- Example: rulings against countries for maintaining illegal trade barriers
Key Terms to Review (24)
Balance of Payments: The balance of payments is a financial statement that summarizes all economic transactions between residents of a country and the rest of the world over a specific period. It includes trade in goods and services, investment income, and transfer payments, providing insights into a country’s economic stability and financial health. The balance of payments is crucial for understanding international financial markets, identifying trade deficits or surpluses, and assessing the impact of trade barriers and protectionism on a nation's economy.
Consumer prices: Consumer prices refer to the average price level of a basket of goods and services purchased by households, reflecting the cost of living and the purchasing power of consumers. These prices are influenced by various factors, including supply and demand dynamics, inflation, and government policies. Understanding consumer prices is crucial in analyzing how trade barriers and protectionism can impact domestic economies and global trade flows.
Cultural Preservation: Cultural preservation refers to the efforts made to protect, maintain, and revitalize the cultural heritage of a community, including its traditions, customs, languages, and historical artifacts. This concept is closely linked to the idea of safeguarding cultural identity in a globalized world, where local cultures may be threatened by dominant foreign influences and homogenization.
Economic efficiency: Economic efficiency refers to the optimal allocation of resources in a way that maximizes output and minimizes waste. This concept is crucial in evaluating how well a nation or economy utilizes its resources, particularly in the context of trade barriers and protectionism, where inefficient practices can arise. When trade barriers are imposed, it can lead to a misallocation of resources, reducing overall economic efficiency by preventing goods from flowing to their most valued uses and increasing costs for consumers.
Embargoes: Embargoes are government-imposed restrictions that prohibit the trade of specific goods or services with particular countries. These measures are often used as a tool of foreign policy to influence or punish nations for various reasons, including human rights violations or military aggression, and they can significantly impact international trade dynamics.
Global supply chain disruptions: Global supply chain disruptions refer to significant interruptions in the flow of goods and services across international borders, affecting production and distribution processes. These disruptions can stem from various factors including natural disasters, political instability, trade barriers, and pandemics, leading to delays, shortages, and increased costs in the global marketplace.
Import licenses: Import licenses are official permissions granted by a government that authorize individuals or businesses to bring specific goods into a country. These licenses are often used to control the volume and type of products entering a nation, serving as a tool to protect domestic industries from foreign competition while also ensuring compliance with regulations. By regulating imports, governments can mitigate trade imbalances and safeguard local economies.
Infant Industry Protection: Infant industry protection refers to the economic policy of shielding newly established or emerging industries from foreign competition through tariffs, subsidies, and other forms of government intervention. This approach aims to foster domestic industries until they become mature and competitive enough to stand on their own in the global market. By protecting these industries, governments hope to promote economic growth, job creation, and technological advancement within their countries.
Job protection: Job protection refers to government policies and regulations designed to safeguard employees from being unfairly dismissed or laid off, ensuring job security. This concept is often linked to trade barriers and protectionism, as it aims to shield domestic workers from international competition and the potential negative effects of globalization on employment.
Long-term consequences: Long-term consequences refer to the enduring effects or outcomes that arise from specific actions, decisions, or policies over an extended period. In the context of trade barriers and protectionism, these consequences can significantly shape economic relationships, market dynamics, and the overall health of a nation's economy, influencing both domestic industries and international trade relations for years to come.
National security: National security refers to the protection of a nation's borders and territories against external threats, as well as the safety and well-being of its citizens. It encompasses a range of strategies, policies, and actions aimed at safeguarding a country's sovereignty, political stability, and economic interests from both military and non-military risks. In the context of trade barriers and protectionism, national security can influence governmental decisions to impose restrictions on imports and exports to protect domestic industries and maintain economic independence.
Non-tariff barriers: Non-tariff barriers are trade restrictions that countries use to control the amount of trade across their borders without involving tariffs. These barriers can take many forms, such as quotas, import licensing requirements, and standards for products. They play a significant role in shaping international trade dynamics by influencing how products can enter a country and can be used strategically to protect domestic industries from foreign competition.
Product Variety: Product variety refers to the range of different products or versions of a product that a company offers to consumers. This can include variations in size, color, features, and models, and is often used as a strategy to meet diverse consumer preferences and needs in various markets. A rich product variety can help businesses differentiate themselves from competitors and appeal to broader audiences.
Quotas: Quotas are government-imposed trade restrictions that limit the quantity or value of specific goods that can be imported or exported during a given timeframe. By controlling the amount of a particular product that can enter a market, quotas serve to protect domestic industries from foreign competition, maintain favorable trade balances, and ensure the availability of certain goods. They play a crucial role in shaping the dynamics of international trade and are a form of protectionism often employed by nations.
Retaliation: Retaliation refers to the act of responding to an adverse action, typically by imposing countermeasures or sanctions against another entity. In the context of trade, this often manifests when one country imposes tariffs or trade barriers in response to similar actions taken by another country. Retaliation is a crucial concept in international trade relations, as it can lead to escalating trade wars that affect global economic stability.
Revenue Generation: Revenue generation refers to the process of increasing the income produced by a business or organization through various means, such as sales, investments, and services. It is a crucial aspect for businesses to sustain operations, reinvest in growth, and create value for stakeholders. In the context of trade barriers and protectionism, revenue generation can be significantly impacted by tariffs, quotas, and subsidies that influence market access and pricing strategies.
Sanctions: Sanctions are punitive measures imposed by countries or international organizations to influence the behavior of a target nation, typically in response to violations of international laws or norms. These measures can take various forms, including economic restrictions, trade barriers, or diplomatic isolation, aimed at compelling a change in the actions of the targeted state. They serve as a tool for promoting compliance and can significantly affect global trade dynamics and international relations.
Short-term outcomes: Short-term outcomes refer to the immediate effects or results that occur as a direct consequence of specific actions or policies. In the context of trade barriers and protectionism, these outcomes can manifest quickly, impacting both domestic and international markets, consumer behavior, and economic stability. Understanding these outcomes is crucial for assessing the effectiveness and implications of such economic strategies.
Subsidies: Subsidies are financial assistance provided by the government to support businesses, industries, or consumers to encourage certain economic activities or lower the cost of goods and services. They can be used to promote exports, protect domestic industries, or reduce prices for consumers. Subsidies can impact trade dynamics, often leading to tensions in international markets.
Tariffs: Tariffs are taxes imposed by a government on imported goods and services, designed to raise revenue and protect domestic industries from foreign competition. They influence global pricing, distribution strategies, and can act as trade barriers that affect international trade dynamics.
Technical barriers: Technical barriers refer to regulatory measures that countries use to control the import and export of goods, often involving standards and regulations related to product safety, quality, and environmental impact. These barriers can include mandatory certifications, testing requirements, and compliance with specific industry standards that foreign products must meet to enter a market. While these regulations aim to protect consumers and the environment, they can also serve as protectionist tools that hinder international trade.
Trade wars: Trade wars refer to a situation in which countries impose tariffs or other trade barriers on each other in response to trade practices they deem unfair. This tit-for-tat escalation often stems from disputes over trade imbalances, intellectual property theft, or government subsidies, leading to increased tensions between the nations involved. Trade wars can significantly impact global markets and economic relationships, as they disrupt trade flows and raise costs for consumers and businesses alike.
Voluntary Export Restraints: Voluntary export restraints (VERs) are trade agreements between exporting and importing countries where the exporter agrees to limit the quantity of goods exported to a specific market. This type of trade barrier is often used to avoid more severe restrictions or tariffs that could be imposed by the importing country. VERs can help protect domestic industries while still allowing for some level of international trade.
WTO: The World Trade Organization (WTO) is an international body that regulates and facilitates trade between nations by providing a framework for negotiating trade agreements and resolving disputes. It aims to promote free trade and reduce trade barriers, which is crucial for fostering global economic growth and stability.