scoresvideos
Intro to Contemporary Literature
Table of Contents
Unit 3 Overview: Identity and Diversity in Literature
3.1 Gender and sexuality
3.2 Race and ethnicity
3.3 Intersectionality
3.4 Marginalized voices and perspectives
3.5 Identity politics and social justice

Intersectionality examines how multiple social identities intersect to shape experiences of privilege and oppression. Rooted in Black feminism, this framework challenges single-axis approaches that focus on one aspect of identity, recognizing the complex interplay of race, gender, class, and other factors.

In literature, intersectionality provides a lens to analyze diverse characters, critique dominant narratives, and examine power dynamics. It has influenced feminist, postcolonial, and queer literary theories, reshaping canon formation debates and approaches to various genres.

Intersectionality definition and origins

  • Intersectionality is a critical framework for understanding how multiple social identities intersect and shape individual experiences of privilege and oppression
  • The concept emerged from the work of Black feminist scholars and activists who sought to highlight the unique challenges faced by Black women at the intersection of race and gender
  • Intersectionality moves beyond single-axis frameworks that focus on one aspect of identity (race or gender) to consider how multiple identities interact and create distinct lived experiences

Kimberlé Crenshaw's coining of term

  • Kimberlé Crenshaw, a legal scholar and critical race theorist, coined the term "intersectionality" in 1989 to describe how race and gender intersect to shape Black women's employment experiences
  • Crenshaw argued that single-axis frameworks in antidiscrimination law, feminist theory, and antiracist politics failed to capture the multidimensional experiences of Black women
  • She used the analogy of a traffic intersection to illustrate how multiple forms of discrimination (racism and sexism) can collide and compound each other

Roots in Black feminism

  • Intersectionality has its roots in the long tradition of Black feminist thought and activism dating back to the 19th century
  • Black feminists like Sojourner Truth, Anna Julia Cooper, and the Combahee River Collective articulated the need for an intersectional analysis that recognized the interlocking nature of race, gender, and class oppression
  • They challenged the exclusion of Black women's experiences from both the mainstream (white) feminist movement and the male-dominated civil rights movement

Intersectionality vs single-axis frameworks

  • Single-axis frameworks focus on one aspect of identity (race or gender) and assume a universal experience within that category
  • Intersectionality recognizes that individuals have multiple, intersecting identities that shape their unique experiences of privilege and oppression
  • An intersectional approach examines how power structures and systems of oppression interact to create distinct challenges and opportunities for individuals based on their specific social location

Key concepts of intersectionality

Interlocking systems of oppression

  • Intersectionality posits that systems of oppression (racism, sexism, classism, heterosexism, ableism) are interlocking and mutually reinforcing
  • These systems create a complex matrix of domination that shapes the lived experiences of individuals and groups
  • For example, a low-income, disabled, queer woman of color may face multiple, compounding forms of marginalization and discrimination

Privilege and marginalization

  • Intersectionality highlights how individuals can simultaneously experience privilege and marginalization based on their multiple identities
  • Privilege refers to unearned advantages and benefits conferred by membership in dominant social groups (white, male, cisgender, able-bodied)
  • Marginalization refers to the systematic exclusion and oppression of individuals and groups based on their social identities
  • An intersectional lens examines how privilege and marginalization intersect and shape access to power, resources, and opportunities

Social identities and power dynamics

  • Intersectionality focuses on the role of social identities (race, gender, class, sexuality, ability) in shaping power dynamics and inequalities
  • These identities are socially constructed categories that are assigned meaning and value within specific historical and cultural contexts
  • Power is understood as relational and contextual, with dominant groups exercising power over marginalized groups through individual, institutional, and structural means
  • An intersectional analysis examines how power operates across multiple axes of identity to create complex hierarchies and inequalities

Applying intersectional lens to literature

Representation of diverse identities

  • An intersectional approach to literature examines the representation of diverse identities and experiences in literary texts
  • This includes considering how characters' multiple identities (race, gender, class, sexuality) shape their experiences, relationships, and outcomes in the narrative
  • An intersectional lens also examines the representation of marginalized and underrepresented groups in literature and the ways in which their stories are told (or not told)

Critiquing dominant narratives

  • Intersectionality provides a framework for critiquing dominant narratives and perspectives in literature that privilege certain identities and experiences over others
  • This includes challenging the universality of white, male, cisgender, heterosexual perspectives and experiences as the default or norm
  • An intersectional approach examines how dominant narratives perpetuate and reinforce systems of oppression and marginalization
  • It also highlights the ways in which marginalized voices and perspectives resist and subvert dominant narratives

Intersectional analysis of characters

  • An intersectional analysis of literary characters examines how their multiple identities and social locations shape their experiences, relationships, and outcomes in the narrative
  • This includes considering how characters' experiences of privilege and oppression intersect and influence their actions, choices, and development over the course of the story
  • An intersectional lens also examines how characters navigate and resist the interlocking systems of oppression that shape their lives
  • It highlights the complexity and diversity of characters' identities and experiences beyond single-axis categories or stereotypes

Intersectionality in contemporary literary criticism

Influence on feminist literary theory

  • Intersectionality has had a significant influence on feminist literary theory and criticism since the 1990s
  • It has challenged earlier feminist approaches that focused primarily on gender oppression and assumed a universal women's experience
  • Intersectional feminist criticism examines how gender intersects with other identities (race, class, sexuality) to shape women's experiences in literature
  • It also highlights the diversity of women's voices and perspectives in literature and the need for more inclusive and representative feminist literary canons

Postcolonial and queer theory intersections

  • Intersectionality has important intersections with postcolonial and queer literary theories
  • Postcolonial theory examines the legacies of colonialism and imperialism on literature and culture, including the intersection of race, nation, and language
  • Queer theory challenges heteronormative assumptions and binary categories of gender and sexuality in literature
  • An intersectional approach brings together insights from these fields to examine how multiple systems of oppression (colonialism, racism, heterosexism) intersect in literary texts and contexts

Intersectionality in canon formation debates

  • Intersectionality has played a key role in debates over the formation and revision of literary canons
  • It has challenged the dominance of white, male, European authors and texts in traditional literary canons and called for greater inclusion and diversity
  • An intersectional approach examines how canon formation is shaped by power dynamics and systems of oppression that privilege certain voices and marginalize others
  • It advocates for the inclusion of more diverse voices and perspectives in literary canons, including works by women, people of color, LGBTQ+ authors, and postcolonial writers

Intersectional approaches to literary genres

Intersectionality in fiction

  • Intersectionality provides a framework for analyzing the representation of diverse identities and experiences in fiction
  • This includes examining how characters' multiple identities (race, gender, class) shape their experiences and outcomes in the narrative
  • An intersectional approach also considers how fiction can challenge or reinforce dominant narratives and power structures through its representation of marginalized voices and perspectives
  • Examples of intersectional fiction include works by authors such as Toni Morrison, Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie, and Junot Díaz that explore the intersections of race, gender, class, and culture

Intersectional poetry and spoken word

  • Intersectionality is a powerful lens for analyzing poetry and spoken word, particularly works that explore themes of identity, oppression, and resistance
  • Intersectional poetry often gives voice to marginalized experiences and perspectives and challenges dominant narratives and power structures
  • It highlights the intersections of multiple identities (race, gender, sexuality, class) and how they shape the speaker's experiences and voice
  • Examples of intersectional poetry include works by Audre Lorde, Maya Angelou, and Staceyann Chin that explore the intersections of race, gender, and sexuality

Memoir and autobiography through intersectional lens

  • Intersectionality provides a valuable framework for analyzing memoir and autobiography, particularly works that explore the author's multiple identities and experiences
  • An intersectional approach examines how the author's race, gender, class, sexuality, and other identities shape their lived experiences and the stories they tell
  • It also considers how memoir and autobiography can challenge dominant narratives and give voice to marginalized perspectives and experiences
  • Examples of intersectional memoir and autobiography include works by authors such as Roxane Gay, Janet Mock, and Ta-Nehisi Coates that explore the intersections of identity, oppression, and resistance

Challenges and limitations of intersectionality

Critiques of intersectionality framework

  • While intersectionality has been widely influential, it has also faced critiques and challenges as a theoretical framework
  • Some critics argue that intersectionality can lead to an infinite regress of identity categories and a fragmentation of social justice movements
  • Others critique the emphasis on individual identity and experience over structural and systemic analysis
  • There are also debates over the operationalization of intersectionality in research and practice, including how to measure and analyze intersectional experiences

Intersectionality and identity politics debates

  • Intersectionality has been a key concept in debates over identity politics and the role of identity in social justice movements
  • Critics of identity politics argue that it can lead to a narrow focus on individual identity and a fragmentation of solidarity and collective action
  • Proponents of intersectionality argue that it provides a necessary framework for understanding the complex ways in which identity shapes experiences of oppression and privilege
  • There are ongoing debates over how to balance the recognition of diverse identities with the need for collective action and solidarity in social justice movements

Operationalizing intersectionality in literary studies

  • There are challenges and limitations to operationalizing intersectionality in literary studies, including how to analyze and measure intersectional experiences in texts
  • Some scholars argue for the need for more empirical and quantitative approaches to studying intersectionality in literature, while others emphasize the importance of qualitative and interpretive methods
  • There are also debates over how to balance the focus on individual identity and experience with broader structural and systemic analysis in literary studies
  • Scholars continue to grapple with how to effectively apply intersectional frameworks to the study of literature in ways that are rigorous, nuanced, and transformative

Key Terms to Review (28)

Memoir and Autobiography through Intersectional Lens: Memoir and autobiography are literary forms that focus on an individual's personal experiences and life story. When viewed through an intersectional lens, these narratives reveal how various social identities—such as race, gender, sexuality, and class—interact and shape one's experiences. This perspective helps to highlight the complexity of identity formation and the influence of systemic structures on individual lives, providing a richer understanding of personal history within broader societal contexts.
Postcolonial and Queer Theory Intersections: Postcolonial and queer theory intersections examine how colonial histories shape and inform contemporary understandings of gender and sexuality. This perspective highlights the ways in which both colonialism and heteronormativity have imposed rigid identities, creating a complex landscape where issues of race, class, and sexual orientation intersect. By analyzing these intersections, scholars can better understand the multifaceted nature of identity and the power dynamics that influence marginalized groups.
Intersectionality in Canon Formation Debates: Intersectionality in canon formation debates refers to the analytical framework that examines how various social identities—such as race, gender, sexuality, and class—interact and contribute to unique experiences of oppression and privilege. This concept challenges traditional literary canons by advocating for the inclusion of diverse voices that reflect the complexity of human experience, rather than a monolithic narrative dominated by a singular perspective.
Intersectional Poetry and Spoken Word: Intersectional poetry and spoken word refer to a style of poetic expression that emphasizes the interconnectedness of various social identities, such as race, gender, sexuality, and class. This form of poetry seeks to highlight the unique experiences and struggles faced by individuals at the intersections of these identities, often drawing on personal narratives and societal critiques. By doing so, it fosters a deeper understanding of the complexities of identity and promotes social justice through the power of spoken word performance.
Intersectional Analysis of Characters: Intersectional analysis of characters examines how various social identities, such as race, gender, class, sexuality, and disability, intersect and influence a character's experiences and perspectives. This approach allows for a deeper understanding of how these overlapping identities shape characters' motivations, challenges, and relationships within a narrative.
Intersectionality in Fiction: Intersectionality in fiction refers to the way multiple social identities—such as race, gender, class, sexuality, and ability—interact and shape an individual's experiences and perspectives within literary narratives. This concept emphasizes that people's lives are not defined by a single identity but are influenced by overlapping social factors, leading to unique challenges and insights in storytelling.
Critiquing dominant narratives: Critiquing dominant narratives involves analyzing and challenging widely accepted stories or beliefs that shape societal understanding, often highlighting biases, omissions, and power dynamics. This process is crucial for uncovering marginalized voices and perspectives that are often overlooked in mainstream discourse. By questioning these dominant narratives, one can better understand the complexities of identity, experience, and the interplay of various social factors.
Influence on Feminist Literary Theory: The influence on feminist literary theory refers to the ways in which feminist perspectives and critiques have shaped the understanding and interpretation of literature, particularly in addressing gender, power dynamics, and representation. This influence emphasizes the importance of intersectionality, recognizing that experiences of gender cannot be separated from other social categories such as race, class, sexuality, and ability, which inform how individuals experience oppression and privilege in literature.
Representation of diverse identities: Representation of diverse identities refers to the inclusion and portrayal of individuals from various social, cultural, racial, gender, and sexual backgrounds in literature, media, and other forms of expression. This concept emphasizes the importance of showcasing a variety of perspectives and experiences, which can challenge stereotypes and promote understanding among different groups. It plays a crucial role in creating a more equitable society by acknowledging and validating the identities of marginalized communities.
Interlocking systems of oppression: Interlocking systems of oppression refer to the various and interconnected ways in which social categories like race, gender, sexuality, and class create overlapping forms of discrimination and disadvantage. These systems are not isolated; instead, they work together to reinforce inequality and limit opportunities for marginalized groups, highlighting the complexity of social identities and the unique challenges faced by individuals who experience multiple forms of oppression simultaneously.
Intersectional feminism: Intersectional feminism is a framework that examines how various social identities, such as race, gender, class, sexuality, and ability, intersect to create unique experiences of discrimination and privilege. This approach emphasizes that the struggles against oppression cannot be separated from each other and advocates for a more inclusive feminist movement that recognizes diverse experiences and challenges faced by different groups of women and marginalized individuals.
Disadvantage: Disadvantage refers to a condition or situation that puts an individual or group at a comparative disadvantage relative to others, often resulting in reduced opportunities or access to resources. This term often highlights the structural inequalities that exist within society, influenced by factors such as race, gender, class, and sexuality, and is crucial in understanding how intersectional identities shape experiences of marginalization and privilege.
Social Location: Social location refers to the specific social and cultural context in which an individual or group exists, shaped by various intersecting factors such as race, gender, class, sexuality, and geographic location. Understanding social location helps in recognizing how these factors influence one's identity, experiences, and access to resources and opportunities in society.
Oppression: Oppression refers to the systematic and pervasive mistreatment or exploitation of a group of people, often based on characteristics such as race, gender, class, or sexuality. This term is central to understanding the dynamics of power and inequality in society, highlighting how certain groups are marginalized and subjected to unequal treatment. Oppression can manifest in various forms, including institutional policies, cultural norms, and individual behaviors that reinforce existing hierarchies.
Privilege: Privilege refers to the unearned advantages or benefits that certain individuals or groups receive in society based on their identity characteristics, such as race, gender, socioeconomic status, and sexual orientation. This concept highlights how systemic inequalities can grant some people easier access to opportunities and resources while marginalizing others. Understanding privilege is essential in discussions about social dynamics and disparities as it sheds light on the structures that maintain inequity.
Me Too: Me Too is a social movement that aims to raise awareness about the prevalence of sexual harassment and assault, primarily in the workplace, and to empower survivors to share their experiences. The movement highlights the systemic issues surrounding gender-based violence and emphasizes the need for accountability and change in societal norms. It connects deeply with broader themes of intersectionality and identity politics as it acknowledges how different identities experience harassment differently and seeks to elevate marginalized voices in the conversation about social justice.
Black Lives Matter: Black Lives Matter is a social and political movement advocating for the rights and dignity of Black individuals, emphasizing the importance of addressing systemic racism, police violence, and social injustice. The movement seeks to highlight the unique experiences of Black people and challenges existing structures that perpetuate inequality. It promotes activism aimed at achieving justice and equality while fostering an understanding of how various identities intersect within the context of race and systemic oppression.
The Color Purple: The Color Purple is a novel by Alice Walker that tells the story of African American women in the early 20th century South, addressing themes of racism, sexism, and empowerment. It highlights the interconnectedness of various identities and experiences, emphasizing how race, gender, and class shape the lives of its characters while also shedding light on the importance of marginalized voices and family dynamics.
Beloved: The term 'beloved' refers to a deep emotional attachment and affection towards someone or something, often evoking feelings of love, nostalgia, and longing. It is particularly significant in literature as it captures the complexity of relationships, memories, and the struggles against the legacies of the past. The notion of being 'beloved' intertwines with themes of identity, trauma, and the intersection of various social categories, illustrating how love can be both a source of strength and vulnerability.
Patricia Hill Collins: Patricia Hill Collins is a prominent American sociologist known for her work on intersectionality and Black feminist thought. She emphasizes how various social identities—such as race, gender, class, and sexuality—intersect to shape individuals' experiences and societal structures. Collins' work highlights the importance of understanding these overlapping identities to address issues of oppression and privilege in society.
Kimberlé Crenshaw: Kimberlé Crenshaw is a legal scholar and critical race theorist best known for her work on intersectionality, which examines how different aspects of a person's identity, such as race, gender, and class, intersect to create unique experiences of oppression or privilege. Her scholarship emphasizes that traditional frameworks often fail to capture the complexities of marginalized identities, highlighting the need for an inclusive approach to understanding social justice issues.
Critical Race Theory: Critical Race Theory (CRT) is an intellectual movement and framework that examines the relationship between race, racism, and power, emphasizing that racism is not just an individual act but a systemic issue embedded in legal and social structures. It highlights how laws and policies can perpetuate racial inequalities and seeks to understand the lived experiences of marginalized communities, connecting deeply with concepts of intersectionality, identity politics, and social justice.
Multiple identities: Multiple identities refer to the various social, cultural, and personal identities that an individual possesses, often shaped by factors such as race, gender, sexuality, class, and religion. This concept highlights the complexity of identity formation and emphasizes that individuals can embody different identities that intersect and influence their experiences and perspectives in diverse contexts.
Class and sexuality: Class and sexuality refer to the interconnectedness of social class structures and sexual identities, emphasizing how these two aspects influence each other in society. The way individuals experience their sexuality can be deeply shaped by their economic status, while societal norms regarding class can also dictate the expressions of sexuality. This relationship often highlights issues of power, privilege, and marginalization, where individuals navigate their identities within a framework defined by both class status and sexual orientation or expression.
Race and Gender: Race and gender are social constructs that categorize individuals based on physical characteristics and gender identity, respectively. These constructs shape experiences, identities, and societal dynamics, influencing how individuals interact with systems of power, privilege, and oppression. Understanding race and gender together is crucial for examining the layered ways in which discrimination operates in society.
Feminist theory: Feminist theory is an analytical framework that examines the ways in which gender, particularly women's experiences and perspectives, influences and shapes social structures, cultural norms, and power dynamics. It seeks to address and challenge inequalities faced by women and emphasizes the importance of understanding the intersections of gender with other identity factors such as race, class, and sexuality.
Intersectionality: Intersectionality is a framework for understanding how various social identities, such as race, gender, sexuality, and class, intersect and interact to create unique experiences of privilege or oppression. This concept highlights that individuals do not experience discrimination or advantage based solely on one aspect of their identity but rather through the complex interplay of multiple identities.
Postcolonialism: Postcolonialism is an academic and critical framework that examines the cultural, political, and social impacts of colonialism and imperialism on colonized nations and peoples. It focuses on the ways in which these societies have resisted, adapted to, and been shaped by colonial forces, exploring themes of identity, power dynamics, and the ongoing effects of colonial legacies in a global context.