scoresvideos
International Human Rights
Table of Contents

🧍🏼‍♂️international human rights review

8.2 Geneva Conventions and Additional Protocols

Citation:

The Geneva Conventions and Additional Protocols form the backbone of international humanitarian law. They set rules for armed conflicts, protecting civilians, prisoners of war, and the wounded. These agreements aim to limit the brutality of war and ensure basic human rights are respected even in the midst of violence.

The conventions cover a wide range of situations, from international wars to internal conflicts. They establish standards for treating prisoners, caring for the wounded, and protecting civilians. The protocols expand on these rules, addressing modern warfare challenges and strengthening protections for those caught in conflict zones.

Geneva Conventions: Key Provisions

Core Treaties and Their Focus

  • Four Geneva Conventions adopted in 1949 form the foundation of international humanitarian law for armed conflicts
  • First Geneva Convention protects wounded and sick soldiers on land during war
    • Establishes rules for treatment of battlefield casualties (field hospitals, medical evacuation)
    • Outlines protections for medical personnel (non-combatant status, right to perform duties)
  • Second Geneva Convention extends protections to shipwrecked military personnel at sea
    • Addresses unique challenges of maritime warfare (rescue operations, hospital ships)
    • Ensures similar protections as land-based conflicts for naval forces
  • Third Geneva Convention establishes standards for treatment of prisoners of war (POWs)
    • Outlines POW rights (humane treatment, protection from coercion)
    • Defines acceptable living conditions (adequate food, shelter, medical care)
    • Specifies rules for repatriation (return of POWs after hostilities cease)
  • Fourth Geneva Convention provides protection for civilians in war-torn areas and occupied territories
    • Addresses issues such as deportations, hostage-taking, and property destruction
    • Establishes rules for treatment of civilian populations under occupation

Common Article 3 and Applicability

  • Common Article 3 present in all four conventions sets minimum standards for non-international armed conflicts
    • Protects persons not taking part in hostilities (civilians, wounded combatants)
    • Prohibits violence, cruel treatment, and torture
    • Ensures fair trials for those facing criminal charges
  • Geneva Conventions apply to all cases of declared war or armed conflict between signatories
    • Applicable even if state of war is not recognized by one of the parties
    • Ensures protection regardless of formal declarations of war

Additional Protocols to the Geneva Conventions

1977 Protocols: Expanding Protection

  • Two Additional Protocols adopted in 1977 to supplement Geneva Conventions
  • Protocol I extends protection to victims of international armed conflicts
    • Includes wars of national liberation and conflicts against racist regimes
    • Introduces specific rules on conduct of hostilities
      • Principle of distinction between civilians and combatants
      • Prohibitions on indiscriminate attacks (carpet bombing, chemical weapons)
  • Protocol II develops and supplements Common Article 3
    • Applies to non-international armed conflicts
      • Conflicts between state's armed forces and organized armed groups
    • Provides more detailed protection for civilians in internal conflicts
      • Rules on treatment of children (prohibition of child soldiers)
      • Protection of objects indispensable to civilian survival (food sources, water supplies)

Modernizing Humanitarian Law

  • Additional Protocols aim to address gaps in original conventions
  • Adapt humanitarian law to realities of modern warfare
    • Asymmetric conflicts (state vs non-state actors)
    • Civil wars and internal armed conflicts
  • Third Additional Protocol adopted in 2005
    • Establishes Red Crystal as additional emblem
    • Complements existing Red Cross and Red Crescent symbols
    • Provides neutral emblem option for countries with religious concerns

Protection for Civilians, POWs, and the Wounded

Civilian Protection Measures

  • Civilians must be spared from effects of military operations to greatest extent possible
    • Prohibition on direct attacks against civilian populations
    • Requirement to take precautions in attack to minimize civilian casualties
  • Principle of distinction requires parties to differentiate between civilians and combatants
    • Combatants must wear distinctive emblems or uniforms
    • Civilian objects (homes, schools, hospitals) must be distinguished from military objectives
  • Specific protections for vulnerable groups
    • Women (protection against sexual violence, separate quarters for female POWs)
    • Children (evacuation from conflict zones, access to education)
    • Elderly (special consideration in evacuation and medical treatment)

Rights and Treatment of Prisoners of War

  • POWs must be treated humanely
    • Protected from violence, intimidation, insults, and public curiosity
    • Prohibition on torture or coercion for intelligence gathering
  • Entitled to adequate living conditions
    • Sufficient food and water
    • Appropriate housing and clothing
    • Access to medical care
    • Right to communicate with families (through letters, Red Cross messages)
  • POWs retain legal rights
    • Right to fair trial if accused of crimes
    • Protection against prosecution for lawful acts of war

Care for the Wounded and Sick

  • Wounded and sick must be collected, cared for, and protected
    • Applies regardless of nationality or allegiance
    • Obligation to search for and collect casualties after battle
  • Medical personnel, facilities, and transport granted special protection
    • Must not be attacked if exclusively engaged in medical duties
    • Allowed to cross front lines to treat wounded
  • Use of protective emblems regulated
    • Red Cross, Red Crescent, Red Crystal symbols
    • Misuse of emblems constitutes a war crime

Obligations of Parties to Conflict

Implementation and Enforcement

  • Parties obligated to respect and ensure respect for Geneva Conventions in all circumstances
    • Requirement to train military personnel in laws of war
    • Obligation to prosecute or extradite those who commit grave breaches
  • States must disseminate text of Conventions
    • Incorporation into domestic law and military regulations
    • Public education on principles of international humanitarian law
  • Measures to prevent and suppress grave breaches
    • Establishment of military justice systems to address violations
    • Cooperation with international tribunals (International Criminal Court)

Command Responsibility and Accountability

  • Principle of command responsibility holds military commanders accountable
    • Responsible for violations committed by subordinates if they knew or should have known
    • Obligation to prevent and punish war crimes within chain of command
  • States required to search for and prosecute persons alleged to have committed grave breaches
    • Universal jurisdiction for war crimes
    • Obligation to either prosecute or extradite suspects

Humanitarian Access and Information Sharing

  • Parties must allow and facilitate impartial humanitarian relief operations
    • Access for organizations like the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC)
    • Obligation to ensure safe passage for humanitarian aid
  • ICRC and other impartial organizations granted access to protected persons
    • Right to visit POWs and civilian internees
    • Ability to provide humanitarian assistance and monitor compliance
  • Establishment of National Information Bureau required
    • Collects and transmits information about protected persons
    • Coordinates with Central Tracing Agency of the ICRC
    • Facilitates communication between detainees and their families