11.1 Gender dynamics in competition-based reality shows
3 min read•august 7, 2024
Reality TV competitions often reinforce gender stereotypes through casting and challenges. Women are frequently sexualized and portrayed as catty, while men are shown as aggressive alpha males. These shows perpetuate harmful gender norms and cater to the .
Editing and storylines further entrench gender biases. Women get less airtime to explain themselves, and their competence is downplayed in favor of interpersonal drama. Intersectional issues compound these problems for contestants with multiple marginalized identities.
Gender Representation and Stereotyping
Reinforcing Gender Stereotypes through Casting and Characterization
Top images from around the web for Reinforcing Gender Stereotypes through Casting and Characterization
Endless forms of sexual selection [PeerJ] View original
Is this image relevant?
Meeting Point: 2016 View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | The Multiple Dimensions of Gender Stereotypes: A Current Look at Men’s and Women’s ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Endless forms of sexual selection [PeerJ] View original
Is this image relevant?
Meeting Point: 2016 View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Reinforcing Gender Stereotypes through Casting and Characterization
Endless forms of sexual selection [PeerJ] View original
Is this image relevant?
Meeting Point: 2016 View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | The Multiple Dimensions of Gender Stereotypes: A Current Look at Men’s and Women’s ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Endless forms of sexual selection [PeerJ] View original
Is this image relevant?
Meeting Point: 2016 View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Reality competition shows often cast contestants that conform to traditional gender stereotypes (alpha males, catty females)
- Contestants are frequently portrayed in ways that reinforce gender stereotypes
- Women shown as emotional, catty, focused on appearance
- Men depicted as aggressive, competitive, less expressive
- Challenges and storylines play into gendered tropes and expectations
- Stereotypical gender roles are used for comedic effect or to create drama
Problematic Representation Practices
- involves including a small number of marginalized individuals to give the appearance of diversity without meaningful inclusion
- LGBTQ+ contestants often tokenized or portrayed stereotypically
- Contestants of color underrepresented and subject to stereotypical storylines
- of female contestants is common, with focus on their bodies and sexual appeal
- Revealing clothing, gratuitous bikini shots, sexual storylines
- Reinforces of women and prizing of conventional attractiveness
- Male gaze refers to the assumption of a heterosexual male viewer and portrayal of women as sexual objects
- Camerawork, editing, and storylines cater to the male gaze
Gendered Dynamics in Challenges and Editing
Performative Gender Roles in Challenges
- Challenges often designed to highlight stereotypical gender strengths and weaknesses
- Physical challenges favor male contestants' assumed superior strength and athleticism
- Styling, cooking, and design challenges play into assumption of women's domestic skills
- Contestants feel pressure to perform gender roles in challenges to avoid negative portrayal
- Women downplaying abilities in physical challenges to avoid being seen as butch or aggressive
- Men hesitant to show aptitude in feminine-coded challenges for fear of emasculation
- Success and failure in gendered challenges used to reinforce gender essentialist narratives
Biased Editing and Manufactured Storylines
- Editors have immense power to craft narratives through selective footage use and juxtaposition
- Frankenbiting splices audio to create artificial dialogue and misleading impressions
- Villainous or heroic storylines created through editing rather than organic dynamics
- Women given significantly less confessional airtime than men to explain their perspectives
- Gendered stereotypes inform editing decisions and storylines
- Women's relationships and conflicts central to storylines
- Competence of female contestants downplayed in favor of interpersonal drama
- Uneven editing creates skewed, often sexist depictions of contestants' characters and dynamics
Intersectional Issues and Microaggressions
Intersectionality of Gender, Race, and Sexuality
- highlights the overlapping, interdependent systems of discrimination and disadvantage
- Contestants with multiple marginalized identities face compounded and bias
- Black women portrayed as sassy, aggressive, and hypersexual in contrast with demure white femininity
- Asian men desexualized and emasculated through nerdy stereotypes and lack of romantic storylines
- LGBTQ+ contestants' storylines center heavily on their identities, often in stereotypical ways
- Gay men portrayed as sassy, fashion-obsessed sidekicks to straight women
- Lesbian and bisexual women fetishized and depicted as sexually aggressive
- Normative whiteness, heterosexuality, and binary gender identity centered as default
Microaggressions and Double Standards
- are subtle slights or insults that communicate bias against marginalized groups
- Tokenizing comments that other BIPOC contestants and center whiteness as the norm
- Deadnaming or misgendering of transgender contestants by hosts, judges, or other contestants
- Expecting LGBTQ+ contestants to be spokespeople for their entire community's experiences
- Marginalized contestants held to different standards than privileged counterparts
- Women criticized more harshly for assertiveness or competitiveness praised in men
- BIPOC contestants' emotions and reactions policed more than white contestants'
- Transgender contestants' gender identity treated as a novelty rather than accepted
Key Terms to Review (21)
Audience agency: Audience agency refers to the capacity of viewers to interpret, respond to, and engage with media content in ways that can challenge or reinforce the messages being presented. This concept highlights how audiences are not just passive consumers but active participants who have the power to influence the reception and meaning of media narratives.
Bell hooks: bell hooks is a prominent cultural critic, feminist theorist, and author whose work focuses on the intersections of race, gender, and class. She emphasizes the importance of understanding how these identities shape experiences and representations in media, particularly television, which plays a crucial role in shaping cultural narratives and societal norms.
Body Image: Body image refers to an individual's perception, thoughts, and feelings about their physical appearance, which can be influenced by societal standards and media representations. It encompasses how people feel in their bodies and how they think others perceive them, often shaped by cultural narratives and images portrayed in media. This concept is crucial for understanding self-esteem and identity, especially in relation to how television contributes to shaping and reinforcing specific ideals of beauty and desirability.
Double standards: Double standards refer to the application of different sets of principles for similar situations, often based on gender, which leads to unequal treatment and expectations. In the context of gender dynamics, this concept highlights how men and women are judged differently for similar behaviors, particularly in competitive environments such as reality shows, where societal norms and biases come into play.
Feminine ideals: Feminine ideals refer to societal standards and expectations that define what is considered 'feminine' behavior, appearance, and roles. These ideals often emphasize traits like beauty, nurturing, submissiveness, and domesticity, which can shape how women are perceived and treated in various contexts. In competition-based reality shows, these ideals can significantly influence the portrayal of female contestants, impacting their interactions and the competitive dynamics they experience.
Girl-on-girl crime: Girl-on-girl crime refers to the interpersonal conflicts and competition between women, often manifested through jealousy, rivalry, and bullying. This term highlights the way women can undermine each other in various social settings, particularly in environments that foster competition, like reality television. It points to the dynamics of societal expectations and the pressures women face to compete against one another, which can perpetuate stereotypes and reinforce negative behaviors.
Hegemonic Masculinity: Hegemonic masculinity refers to the cultural ideal of male behavior that promotes the dominance of men over women and other gender identities. It encompasses traits like aggression, emotional restraint, and authority, shaping societal expectations around what it means to be a 'real man' and often marginalizing those who do not conform to these ideals.
Interpretive Communities: Interpretive communities refer to groups of people who share similar cultural backgrounds, experiences, and values that influence their interpretation of media texts. These communities shape how individuals perceive and engage with narratives, often resulting in diverse meanings based on factors such as gender, race, class, and personal identity. Understanding these communities is crucial for analyzing media representation, especially in the context of intersectionality, competition dynamics, fandoms, and media literacy.
Intersectionality: Intersectionality is a framework that examines how various social identities, such as race, gender, class, and sexuality, overlap and interact to create unique experiences of oppression or privilege. This concept helps us understand that individuals do not experience social categories in isolation but rather in complex interconnections that shape their realities.
Laura Mulvey: Laura Mulvey is a British feminist film theorist best known for her essay 'Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema,' which introduced the concept of the male gaze in cinema. Her work critiques how visual arts and media reinforce patriarchal structures and objectify women, influencing feminist media theory and criticism across various platforms, including television.
Male gaze: The male gaze is a concept in feminist theory that describes the way visual arts and literature depict the world from a masculine, heterosexual perspective. It often objectifies women, presenting them as passive subjects to be looked at by male viewers, which reinforces gender power dynamics and reflects societal norms about gender roles and sexuality.
Microaggressions: Microaggressions are subtle, often unintentional comments or actions that convey derogatory or negative messages toward marginalized groups. These can manifest in everyday interactions and reflect underlying biases related to race, gender, class, or other identities. Understanding microaggressions is crucial as they contribute to the larger narratives around social inequalities and can significantly affect individuals' self-esteem and mental health.
Objectification: Objectification is the act of treating a person as an object or a commodity rather than as a human being with feelings and agency. This concept often highlights how media representations can reduce individuals, especially women, to mere objects for visual pleasure or consumption, stripping them of their humanity and individuality.
Patriarchy: Patriarchy is a social system in which men hold primary power and dominate in roles of political leadership, moral authority, social privilege, and control of property. This structure often leads to systemic inequalities between genders, where women's roles are often relegated to the domestic sphere, impacting cultural narratives and representations in various media forms.
Performative gender roles: Performative gender roles refer to the behaviors, actions, and expectations that society imposes on individuals based on their perceived gender identity. These roles are not inherent or natural but are instead constructed through repeated performances that align with societal norms. In competition-based reality shows, these performative roles can often be exaggerated and showcased, impacting how contestants interact and compete.
Postfeminism: Postfeminism is a term that refers to an ideology that emerges in the wake of feminist movements, often emphasizing individualism, empowerment, and the idea that gender equality has been achieved. It critiques traditional feminist narratives and suggests that women can now achieve success through personal choice rather than collective political action, which can impact how women's stories are portrayed in media.
Sexualization: Sexualization refers to the process by which individuals, particularly women, are portrayed in ways that emphasize their sexual attributes and diminish their other qualities. This can manifest in media representations that focus on physical appearance, suggestive behavior, or sexual roles, often reinforcing societal norms about gender and sexuality. In competition-based reality shows, sexualization becomes a key factor in how participants are viewed and evaluated, influencing dynamics of power, competition, and audience engagement.
Sisterhood: Sisterhood refers to the bond and solidarity among women, fostering support, empowerment, and collective action. This concept emphasizes the importance of women coming together to share experiences, advocate for each other's rights, and challenge societal norms that perpetuate inequality. It plays a crucial role in creating a sense of community and identity among women, often seen as a vital force in feminist movements.
Stereotyping: Stereotyping refers to the oversimplified and generalized beliefs about a group of people that often lead to misconceptions and prejudices. This concept plays a crucial role in how media, including television, constructs cultural narratives and shapes societal perceptions, especially regarding gender, race, and class.
Third-wave feminism: Third-wave feminism emerged in the 1990s as a response to the limitations of previous feminist movements, emphasizing diversity, individuality, and the complexities of gender. It seeks to address issues such as intersectionality, sexual autonomy, and the representation of women in popular culture, reflecting a more inclusive approach to feminism that recognizes the varied experiences of different women.
Tokenism: Tokenism is the practice of making a symbolic effort to include a small number of underrepresented individuals in a group or setting, often to give the appearance of inclusivity without any real commitment to diversity or equity. This practice can result in superficial representation that fails to address systemic issues of inequality and often reinforces stereotypes rather than challenging them.