2.3 Early Liberal and Nationalist Movements
4 min read•july 30, 2024
The Restoration era saw the rise of liberal and nationalist movements challenging the conservative order established by the . These groups, inspired by Enlightenment ideals, sought constitutional monarchies, , and nation-states based on shared culture and language.
Secret societies and fueled these movements, which faced fierce opposition from the and . Despite setbacks, they laid the groundwork for future political changes, inspiring events like the and the .
Early Liberal and Nationalist Movements
Ideological Foundations and Goals
Top images from around the web for Ideological Foundations and Goals
Frédéric Sorrieu - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
File:Thomas P. Rossiter, Signing of the Constitution.jpg - Wikimedia Commons View original
Is this image relevant?
Revolutions of 1848 - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Frédéric Sorrieu - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
File:Thomas P. Rossiter, Signing of the Constitution.jpg - Wikimedia Commons View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Ideological Foundations and Goals
Frédéric Sorrieu - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
File:Thomas P. Rossiter, Signing of the Constitution.jpg - Wikimedia Commons View original
Is this image relevant?
Revolutions of 1848 - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Frédéric Sorrieu - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
File:Thomas P. Rossiter, Signing of the Constitution.jpg - Wikimedia Commons View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Early liberal movements advocated for constitutional monarchies, individual rights, and limited government power drew inspiration from Enlightenment ideals and the American and French Revolutions
- Emphasized personal freedoms (freedom of speech, press, religion)
- Promoted separation of powers and checks and balances
- Nationalist movements sought to unite people based on shared language, culture, and history challenged the multinational empires established by the Congress of Vienna
- Aimed to create nation-states aligned with ethnic and linguistic boundaries
- Promoted cultural revival and preservation of national traditions
- Both movements emphasized and rejected the divine right of kings and the legitimacy of absolute monarchies
- Supported the idea that political authority derives from the will of the people
- Advocated for representative government and expanded suffrage
Organizational Structures and Influences
- Secret societies played a crucial role in organizing and spreading liberal and nationalist ideas
- Carbonari in Italy focused on and constitutional government
- Philiki Etaireia in Greece worked towards Greek independence from Ottoman rule
- Romanticism heavily influenced these movements emphasized emotion, individualism, and national identity in literature, art, and politics
- Promoted the idea of the "national spirit" ()
- Glorified historical and cultural traditions unique to each nation
- Early liberal and nationalist movements varied in their specific goals and methods across different European regions reflected local conditions and historical contexts
- German states focused on unification and overcoming political fragmentation
- Polish nationalists sought to restore independence after partitions
Challenges to the Conservative Order
Political and Institutional Obstacles
- Congress of Vienna (1814-1815) established a conservative order in Europe aimed to suppress revolutionary ideas and maintain the balance of power among great powers
- Restored pre-Napoleonic monarchies and boundaries
- Created the German Confederation to prevent German unification
- Holy Alliance formed by Russia, Prussia, and Austria sought to defend monarchical rule and suppress liberal and nationalist movements across Europe
- Intervened militarily to crush revolts (Spain 1823, Italian states 1820-1821)
- Coordinated intelligence sharing and surveillance of revolutionary activities
- Metternich's system of political repression in the Austrian Empire served as a model for other conservative regimes employed censorship, surveillance, and political persecution
- Established elaborate network of spies and informants
- Banned political meetings and associations
Social and Practical Challenges
- Legal restrictions on freedom of speech, press, and assembly limited the ability to organize and spread ideas
- Strict censorship of publications and correspondence
- Prohibition of public gatherings and political clubs
- Lack of a unified middle class in many European countries weakened the social base for liberal movements particularly in less industrialized regions
- Limited economic power and political influence of potential supporters
- Fragmented and localized nature of early industrialization
- Nationalist movements struggled with competing definitions of national identity and conflicting territorial claims especially in multi-ethnic regions like the Balkans
- Overlapping ethnic populations and disputed borders
- Conflicting historical claims to territories
Impact of Early Movements on Europe
Political and Constitutional Changes
- Greek War of Independence (1821-1832) marked a significant success for nationalist movements inspired similar uprisings across Europe and challenged the conservative order
- Resulted in the establishment of an independent Greek state
- Demonstrated the power of to mobilize popular support
- in France led to the establishment of a constitutional monarchy provided a model for liberal reforms in other European countries
- Replaced the Bourbon monarchy with the more liberal
- Inspired the Belgian Revolution and Polish November Uprising
- Revolutions of 1848, known as the "Springtime of Peoples," were largely inspired by the ideas and organizational structures developed by early liberal and nationalist movements
- Spread across multiple European countries (France, German states, Austrian Empire, Italy)
- Resulted in short-lived democratic governments and constitutional reforms
Long-term Ideological and Social Impacts
- Early movements contributed to the gradual erosion of absolute monarchies and the spread of constitutional systems across Europe throughout the 19th century
- Increased adoption of written constitutions and parliamentary systems
- Expanded suffrage and political participation
- Concept of national self-determination became a central principle in European politics influenced the formation of new nation-states
- Played a role in the unification of Italy (1861) and Germany (1871)
- Fueled independence movements in multinational empires (Ottoman, Austro-Hungarian)
- Early liberal and nationalist ideas laid the groundwork for the development of modern political parties and mass politics in the latter half of the 19th century
- Emergence of organized political movements (socialism, conservatism)
- Growth of labor unions and workers' rights movements
- Failures and setbacks of these movements led to a reassessment of revolutionary tactics contributed to the rise of more organized and pragmatic political movements in subsequent decades
- Shift towards gradual reform and parliamentary strategies
- Development of more sophisticated political theories and ideologies
Key Terms to Review (28)
Civic nationalism: Civic nationalism is a form of nationalism that emphasizes the rights and responsibilities of citizenship and promotes the idea that national identity is rooted in shared political principles, such as democracy, liberty, and equality, rather than ethnic or cultural characteristics. This type of nationalism allows for the inclusion of individuals from diverse backgrounds, as long as they adhere to the civic values of the nation, creating a sense of unity through shared governance and civic engagement.
Congress of Vienna: The Congress of Vienna was a diplomatic conference held from 1814 to 1815, aimed at reshaping Europe after the defeat of Napoleon and restoring stability to the continent. It established a framework for international relations and sought to balance power among the major European nations, while addressing the rise of nationalism and liberalism that emerged during and after the Napoleonic Wars.
Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen: The Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen is a fundamental document of the French Revolution that outlines the individual and collective rights of all citizens, emphasizing liberty, equality, and fraternity. It played a crucial role in the development of democratic principles in Europe, influencing liberal and nationalist movements and contributing to various revolutionary uprisings.
Ethnic nationalism: Ethnic nationalism is a form of nationalism where the nation is defined in terms of shared ethnicity, culture, language, and history. It emphasizes the importance of a common heritage and often advocates for the rights of ethnic groups to self-determination. This type of nationalism played a crucial role in shaping political movements and tensions throughout Europe, particularly during the 19th century and beyond.
Freedom of Expression: Freedom of expression refers to the fundamental right of individuals to hold and express opinions without censorship or restraint. This concept became increasingly significant during early liberal and nationalist movements in 19th-century Europe, as it played a crucial role in advocating for individual rights and promoting democratic ideals. Freedom of expression was central to the push for political reforms and national self-determination, empowering citizens to challenge oppressive regimes and call for social change.
Giuseppe Garibaldi: Giuseppe Garibaldi was a prominent Italian military leader and nationalist who played a key role in the unification of Italy during the 19th century. Known as the 'Hero of Two Worlds,' he is celebrated for his leadership of volunteer forces and his campaigns that contributed significantly to the establishment of a unified Italian state.
Greek War of Independence: The Greek War of Independence was a successful revolution by Greek revolutionaries against the Ottoman Empire, lasting from 1821 to 1829. This struggle for national self-determination emerged during a time when nationalist sentiments were growing across Europe, significantly influenced by the political upheavals following the fall of Napoleon and the Congress of Vienna, as well as early liberal movements seeking democratic reforms and independence in various regions.
Holy Alliance: The Holy Alliance was a coalition formed in 1815 among Russia, Austria, and Prussia, aimed at promoting Christian values and conservative policies in Europe following the Napoleonic Wars. This agreement sought to maintain the status quo by suppressing revolutionary movements and promoting monarchical rule, reflecting the broader trends of conservatism and reaction against liberal and nationalist aspirations emerging during this period.
Individual Rights: Individual rights refer to the liberties and entitlements that belong to each person, which are meant to protect their freedom and autonomy against infringement by others, particularly the state. These rights are foundational to liberal thought, emphasizing personal freedom, equality, and the protection of private property, and played a significant role in the development of early liberal and nationalist movements across Europe during the 19th century.
Italian Unification: Italian unification, or Risorgimento, was the political and social process that consolidated the various states of the Italian Peninsula into a single nation-state during the 19th century. This movement was fueled by a combination of nationalist sentiments and liberal ideals, leading to significant political changes and the establishment of the Kingdom of Italy in 1861.
John Stuart Mill: John Stuart Mill was a British philosopher and political economist, known for his contributions to liberal thought and utilitarianism during the 19th century. He championed individual liberty, social justice, and gender equality, influencing early liberal and nationalist movements, ideologies of liberalism, and social transformations in his time. Mill's writings emphasized the importance of personal freedom, representative government, and the role of society in promoting happiness.
July Revolution of 1830: The July Revolution of 1830 was a successful uprising in France that led to the overthrow of King Charles X and the establishment of the July Monarchy under Louis-Philippe. This revolution was a pivotal moment for early liberal and nationalist movements in Europe, highlighting the struggles for political freedom and national identity during a time of widespread discontent against autocratic rule.
Liberal backlash: Liberal backlash refers to the reaction against the liberal movements and ideologies that emerged during the 19th century, primarily in response to the demands for political freedom, civil rights, and national self-determination. This backlash often manifested itself through conservative and authoritarian measures aimed at suppressing liberal reforms, resulting in increased tension between liberal aspirations and established powers.
Metternich's System: Metternich's System refers to the diplomatic and political framework established by Austrian Foreign Minister Klemens von Metternich during the early 19th century, which aimed to maintain conservative order in Europe following the Napoleonic Wars. This system prioritized the balance of power, the suppression of nationalist and liberal movements, and the restoration of monarchies, seeking to prevent revolutions and maintain stability across European states.
National sovereignty: National sovereignty is the principle that a state has the ultimate authority and independence over its territory, free from external interference. This concept connects deeply with ideas of self-determination, governance, and the rights of nations to control their own affairs without outside influence. In the 19th century, national sovereignty became a rallying point for various movements seeking independence or reform, as different groups sought to assert their right to self-govern and define their national identity.
Nationalism: Nationalism is a political ideology that emphasizes the interests, culture, and identity of a particular nation or group of people. It often promotes the idea that individuals should be loyal to their nation and work towards its independence and self-determination, which can lead to significant social and political changes within a country or across regions.
Nationalist sentiment: Nationalist sentiment refers to the strong feelings of pride, loyalty, and devotion that individuals have towards their nation or ethnic group, often accompanied by the desire for self-determination and independence. This feeling played a crucial role in shaping early liberal and nationalist movements, as people sought to assert their identity and establish nation-states based on shared culture, language, and history.
Orleans Dynasty: The Orleans Dynasty was a French royal family that ruled France from 1830 to 1848, following the July Revolution. It represented a constitutional monarchy that emerged as a result of the early liberal and nationalist movements, emphasizing a more liberal governance compared to previous regimes. This dynasty played a significant role in the shifting political landscape of France during the 19th century, promoting ideas of constitutionalism and nationalism while also facing opposition from more radical factions.
Pan-Slavism: Pan-Slavism is a political and cultural movement aimed at uniting all Slavic peoples under one political entity, often driven by a shared language, culture, and history. This movement emerged in the 19th century as a response to nationalism and imperialism, promoting Slavic solidarity against outside domination and advocating for the independence of Slavic nations.
Parliamentary Reform: Parliamentary reform refers to the series of changes and modifications aimed at improving the structure, functions, and representation within a country's parliamentary system. These reforms were essential during the 19th century as they addressed issues of underrepresentation, corruption, and inefficiency, reflecting the growing demand for democratic principles and civil rights among citizens, particularly in the context of early liberal and nationalist movements seeking greater political participation and national identity.
Popular Sovereignty: Popular sovereignty is the principle that the authority of a state and its government is created and sustained by the consent of its people, through their elected representatives. This concept emerged prominently during significant political upheavals and movements in Europe, advocating for the idea that political power rests with the populace rather than a monarch or elite ruling class. It became a driving force behind revolutions and movements seeking democracy and self-determination.
Revolutions of 1848: The Revolutions of 1848 were a series of interconnected uprisings across Europe that sought to challenge the existing conservative order and promote liberal, nationalist, and democratic ideals. These revolutions emerged in response to social, economic, and political grievances, reflecting the widespread desire for reform and change, including demands for constitutional governance and national self-determination.
Romanticism: Romanticism was an artistic, literary, and intellectual movement that originated in the late 18th century and emphasized emotion, individualism, and the glorification of nature. This movement emerged as a response to the Industrial Revolution and the rationalism of the Enlightenment, fostering a deep connection to personal experience, the past, and national identity.
Self-determination: Self-determination is the principle that allows a group of people to decide their own political status and pursue their economic, social, and cultural development. This idea became particularly prominent in the 19th century as various ethnic and national groups sought autonomy and independence from larger empires or states. The rise of self-determination fueled early liberal and nationalist movements, shaped liberal ideologies, and led to significant international tensions as different groups struggled for recognition and independence.
Social contract theory: Social contract theory is a political philosophy that suggests that individuals come together to form a society and agree on certain rules and governance in exchange for protection of their rights and well-being. This theory emphasizes the idea that legitimate authority is derived from the consent of the governed, which resonates strongly with early liberal and nationalist movements seeking to redefine state power and individual rights during the 19th century.
Suffrage Expansion: Suffrage expansion refers to the process of extending the right to vote to a broader segment of the population, particularly during the 19th century in Europe. This movement was fueled by early liberal and nationalist ideologies that sought to promote individual rights and democratic governance. As various social groups, including the working class and women, mobilized for political representation, suffrage expansion became a crucial aspect of national identity and citizen participation in governance.
The Communist Manifesto: The Communist Manifesto is a political pamphlet published in 1848 by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, which outlines the principles of communism and calls for the working class to rise against the bourgeoisie. This influential text connects with various movements by critiquing capitalism, inspiring revolutionary sentiments, and promoting class struggle as a means to achieve social and economic equality.
Volksgeist: Volksgeist is a German term that translates to 'the spirit of the people,' representing the unique cultural and national identity of a particular community or nation. This concept emphasizes the importance of folklore, language, customs, and traditions in shaping a society's character and was central to the development of nationalist movements and liberal ideologies in 19th-century Europe, as people sought to assert their identity and promote their interests based on shared cultural heritage.