8.1 Understanding and mapping value chains in developing economies
7 min read•july 30, 2024
Value chains in developing economies are complex systems linking , , , and . They play a crucial role in economic growth, , and poverty reduction by enhancing competitiveness and integrating small-scale producers into markets.
Mapping value chains helps identify opportunities and challenges. It involves visualizing actors, activities, and relationships, using both quantitative and qualitative data. Participatory approaches ensure stakeholder engagement, leading to better understanding of upgrading possibilities and systemic issues needing attention.
Value chains and economic development
Definition and components of value chains
Top images from around the web for Definition and components of value chains
Interaction of Actors and Factors in Entrepreneurial Ecosystem: Indonesian Creatives Industries View original
Is this image relevant?
Interaction of Actors and Factors in Entrepreneurial Ecosystem: Indonesian Creatives Industries View original
Is this image relevant?
Capital Structure Determinants and Performance of Startup Firms in Developing Economies: A ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Interaction of Actors and Factors in Entrepreneurial Ecosystem: Indonesian Creatives Industries View original
Is this image relevant?
Interaction of Actors and Factors in Entrepreneurial Ecosystem: Indonesian Creatives Industries View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Definition and components of value chains
Interaction of Actors and Factors in Entrepreneurial Ecosystem: Indonesian Creatives Industries View original
Is this image relevant?
Interaction of Actors and Factors in Entrepreneurial Ecosystem: Indonesian Creatives Industries View original
Is this image relevant?
Capital Structure Determinants and Performance of Startup Firms in Developing Economies: A ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Interaction of Actors and Factors in Entrepreneurial Ecosystem: Indonesian Creatives Industries View original
Is this image relevant?
Interaction of Actors and Factors in Entrepreneurial Ecosystem: Indonesian Creatives Industries View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
A value chain encompasses all activities a firm in a specific industry performs to deliver a valuable product or service to the market
Includes steps from concept to distribution to the end user (raw material sourcing, production, processing, marketing, sales)
Each step in the chain adds incremental value to the product or service
Value chains involve a series of actors, including producers, processors, traders, retailers, and service providers, who perform specific functions and are linked through various types of business relationships
Role of value chains in economic development
Value chains enhance competitiveness by promoting specialization, efficiency, and innovation among actors
Leads to increased productivity, lower costs, and improved product quality
Enables firms to focus on their core competencies and outsource non-core activities
Strengthening value chains contributes to job creation, income generation, and poverty reduction
Creates employment opportunities along the chain, particularly in labor-intensive sectors (agriculture, manufacturing)
Increases incomes for value chain actors through higher prices, improved bargaining power, and access to new markets
Value chain development fosters economic growth and structural transformation
Facilitates the transition from low-productivity, subsistence-oriented activities to higher-value, market-oriented production
Promotes diversification of the economy and reduces dependence on primary commodities
In developing economies, integrating small-scale producers and marginalized groups into value chains provides them with access to markets, resources, and knowledge
Helps overcome barriers to entry and scale, such as limited access to finance, technology, and information
Enables participation in the formal economy and improves livelihoods
Actors in value chains
Primary actors and their functions
Producers are the starting point, responsible for growing, harvesting, or extracting raw materials
In developing economies, often small-scale farmers (crops), artisanal miners (minerals), or micro-entrepreneurs (handicrafts)
Key functions include input sourcing, production, and post-harvest handling
Processors transform raw materials into intermediate or finished products, adding value through activities like cleaning, sorting, packaging, or manufacturing
Can be small-scale enterprises (local food processing) or larger industrial firms (textile mills)
Key functions include processing, quality control, and product development
Traders and wholesalers aggregate and distribute products from producers to retailers or other intermediaries
Play a crucial role in linking supply and demand and ensuring smooth flow of goods
Key functions include transportation, storage, grading, and price negotiation
Retailers sell products directly to , serving as the final link between the value chain and end users
In developing economies, often small shops, market stalls, or informal vendors
Key functions include product display, pricing, and customer service
Supporting actors and services
Input suppliers provide raw materials, equipment, and other production inputs to value chain actors
Include seed companies, fertilizer dealers, and equipment manufacturers
Ensure timely availability and quality of inputs critical for value chain performance
Financial service providers offer credit, savings, and insurance products tailored to the needs of value chain actors
Include banks, institutions, and informal savings groups
Enable investments in production, processing, and trade, and help manage risks
Extension and advisory services provide technical assistance, training, and information to value chain actors
Include government agencies, NGOs, and private sector providers
Build capacity of actors to improve production practices, adopt new technologies, and meet market requirements
Logistics and transport services facilitate the movement of goods along the value chain
Include trucking companies, warehouses, and cold storage facilities
Ensure efficient and cost-effective flow of products from producers to consumers
Value chain dynamics in developing economies
Informality and fragmentation
Value chains in developing economies often have a high degree of informality, with many small-scale actors operating outside the formal legal and regulatory framework
Leads to challenges like limited access to finance, markets, and support services
Informal actors may face barriers to upgrading and scaling up their operations
Value chains may be fragmented, with limited coordination and collaboration among actors
Results in inefficiencies, duplication of efforts, and missed opportunities for synergies and economies of scale
Lack of vertical and horizontal linkages hinders information flow and joint problem-solving
Power imbalances and unequal distribution of benefits
Larger firms or intermediaries often have greater bargaining power and can capture a larger share of the value created
Leads to unequal distribution of benefits and limited upgrading opportunities for small-scale actors
Power imbalances may be exacerbated by lack of market information, limited alternative buyers, or high switching costs
Small-scale producers may face unfavorable terms of trade, such as low prices, delayed payments, or strict quality requirements
Limits their ability to invest in production improvements or access higher-value markets
May perpetuate poverty and inequality within the value chain
Export orientation and vulnerability to global markets
Many value chains in developing economies are export-oriented, making them vulnerable to fluctuations in global market prices and demand
Dependence on a narrow range of export products or markets increases exposure to external shocks (price volatility, trade barriers)
Limited bargaining power in global markets may result in a "race to the bottom" in terms of prices and labor standards
Diversification and development of domestic markets can help reduce vulnerability and increase resilience
Requires investments in local processing, branding, and marketing to add value and meet domestic consumer preferences
Domestic market development can also create opportunities for import substitution and regional trade
Upgrading challenges and opportunities
Upgrading involves moving to higher value-added activities within the value chain, such as improving product quality, increasing efficiency, or adding new functions
Requires access to knowledge, skills, technology, and finance, which may be limited in developing economies
Upgrading can be hindered by lack of market information, limited bargaining power, or inadequate supporting services
Opportunities for upgrading exist in various forms, such as process upgrading (improving production efficiency), product upgrading (introducing new or higher-quality products), functional upgrading (taking on new functions, like processing or marketing), or chain upgrading (moving to a new value chain)
Successful upgrading can lead to increased incomes, job creation, and improved competitiveness
Requires a conducive enabling environment, including supportive policies, infrastructure, and institutions
Mapping value chains for opportunities vs challenges
Value chain mapping process and components
Value chain mapping visually represents the actors, activities, and relationships within a value chain
Helps understand the flow of products, information, and money and identify bottlenecks and opportunities
Involves mapping the core processes (production, processing, distribution), supporting services (inputs, finance, logistics), and enabling environment (policies, regulations, infrastructure)
Mapping should include all relevant actors, from input suppliers to end consumers, and capture their functions and linkages
Horizontal linkages show relationships among actors at the same stage of the chain (producer associations, cooperatives)
Vertical linkages show relationships between actors at different stages of the chain (contracts, standards, information flows)
Quantitative and qualitative data in value chain mapping
Quantitative data, such as production volumes, prices, costs, and market shares, can be overlaid on the map to provide a comprehensive picture
Helps identify areas where value is being created or lost and where interventions may be needed
Quantitative data can be collected through surveys, focus group discussions, or secondary sources
Qualitative data, such as actor perceptions, power dynamics, and institutional arrangements, provide insights into the underlying factors influencing value chain performance
Helps understand the incentives, constraints, and decision-making processes of different actors
Qualitative data can be gathered through interviews, observations, or participatory workshops
Participatory mapping and stakeholder engagement
Participatory mapping involves value chain actors in the process of creating and validating the map
Helps build a shared understanding of the system and fosters collaboration and trust among stakeholders
Ensures that the perspectives of marginalized groups, such as women or small-scale producers, are included
Stakeholder engagement throughout the mapping process is crucial for generating buy-in and ownership of the findings and recommendations
Involves regular communication, consultation, and validation with value chain actors and supporting institutions
Helps identify champions and change agents who can drive the implementation of upgrading strategies
Identifying upgrading opportunities and addressing challenges
Mapping can reveal opportunities for upgrading, such as improving product quality, increasing efficiency, or adding new functions
Opportunities may arise from unmet market demand, underutilized resources, or untapped synergies between actors
Upgrading strategies should be based on a realistic assessment of the feasibility, costs, and benefits of different options
Mapping can also help identify challenges that need to be addressed, such as limited access to markets, finance, or services, or unsupportive policies and regulations
Challenges may be specific to certain actors or stages of the chain, or may cut across the entire system
Addressing challenges requires a systemic approach that involves multiple stakeholders and levels of intervention (firm, market, policy)
Prioritizing and sequencing interventions based on their potential impact, feasibility, and resources required is key to effective value chain upgrading
Interventions may include capacity building, technology transfer, market linkage facilitation, or policy advocacy
Monitoring and evaluation of interventions is essential to track progress, learn from experience, and adapt strategies as needed
Key Terms to Review (21)
Business Model Canvas: The Business Model Canvas is a strategic management tool that visually outlines a company's value proposition, infrastructure, customers, and finances on a single page. It helps entrepreneurs and organizations map out their business models, focusing on how they create, deliver, and capture value. This framework is particularly useful for understanding and optimizing value chains, especially in developing economies where resources and market dynamics may differ significantly from more established markets.
Circular economy: A circular economy is an economic model aimed at minimizing waste and making the most of resources by creating closed-loop systems where products, materials, and resources are reused, refurbished, and recycled. This approach contrasts with the traditional linear economy that follows a 'take, make, dispose' model. The circular economy focuses on sustainability, resource efficiency, and reducing environmental impact while fostering innovation and new business opportunities.
Consumers: Consumers are individuals or groups that purchase goods and services for personal use, playing a crucial role in driving demand within an economy. Their preferences and behaviors influence production, pricing, and market trends, making them integral to the functioning of value chains. Understanding consumer needs is vital for businesses, especially in developing economies, as it helps tailor offerings to meet specific local demands.
Cost efficiency: Cost efficiency refers to the ability to deliver goods or services at the lowest possible cost while maintaining quality standards. It is crucial in maximizing profits and improving the sustainability of businesses, especially in developing economies where resources are often limited and competition is intense.
Economic Empowerment: Economic empowerment refers to the process of enabling individuals and communities, particularly those marginalized or in poverty, to gain control over their economic resources and improve their livelihoods. This concept emphasizes the importance of providing access to economic opportunities, skills development, and the ability to make financial decisions that positively impact one's quality of life and community development.
Frugal Innovation: Frugal innovation refers to the process of creating high-quality, affordable solutions tailored to the needs of resource-constrained consumers, particularly in developing markets. This approach emphasizes simplicity, cost-effectiveness, and sustainability while maximizing value from limited resources. Frugal innovation plays a crucial role in addressing global poverty by enabling access to essential goods and services for low-income communities.
Inclusive business models: Inclusive business models are strategies that integrate low-income individuals into the value chain as consumers, producers, or employees, enabling them to participate in and benefit from economic growth. These models aim to create shared value, addressing social challenges while ensuring financial sustainability for businesses.
Job Creation: Job creation refers to the process of generating new employment opportunities within an economy, often driven by entrepreneurship and business development. This is crucial for economic growth, as it not only provides individuals with income and livelihoods but also stimulates local economies and reduces poverty levels. By fostering a dynamic labor market, job creation plays a vital role in addressing social issues and promoting inclusive growth across various sectors.
Microfinance: Microfinance is a financial service that provides small loans and financial assistance to low-income individuals or groups who typically lack access to traditional banking services. This approach aims to empower marginalized communities, stimulate entrepreneurship, and promote sustainable economic development by enabling individuals to start or grow small businesses.
Porter's Value Chain: Porter's Value Chain is a model that identifies the key activities and processes within a company that add value to its products or services, ultimately leading to a competitive advantage. This model breaks down the organization's activities into primary and support categories, allowing businesses to analyze how each step contributes to value creation and where improvements can be made. In developing economies, understanding these value chains can help entrepreneurs identify opportunities for enhancing productivity and efficiency, which are crucial for driving growth and addressing poverty.
Primary Activities: Primary activities refer to the essential actions and processes involved in creating and delivering a product or service, primarily focused on the extraction and production of raw materials. These activities form the backbone of a value chain in developing economies, where local resources and labor are often utilized to meet basic needs and drive economic development. Understanding these activities is crucial for identifying opportunities to enhance productivity and improve living standards.
Processors: Processors refer to entities or individuals that transform raw materials into finished goods or services within a value chain. They play a critical role in the production process, adding value through various methods such as manufacturing, assembly, or processing. In developing economies, processors can be vital for creating local jobs, improving product quality, and enhancing supply chain efficiency.
Producers: Producers are individuals or organizations that create goods or services for consumption in an economy. In the context of value chains in developing economies, producers play a critical role as they are responsible for transforming raw materials into finished products, which can ultimately lead to economic growth and poverty alleviation.
Retailers: Retailers are businesses or individuals that sell goods or services directly to consumers. They play a crucial role in the value chain by connecting producers and consumers, often providing essential services such as distribution, marketing, and customer support. Retailers can range from small local shops to large multinational chains and are key players in the economic landscape, especially in developing economies where they help facilitate access to products and services for local communities.
Social entrepreneurship: Social entrepreneurship is the practice of using entrepreneurial principles to create and manage organizations that aim to address social, cultural, or environmental issues while achieving financial sustainability. It combines the innovation and risk-taking typical of traditional entrepreneurship with a strong commitment to social impact, making it a powerful tool in fighting global poverty and inequality.
Supply Chain Management: Supply chain management is the process of overseeing and coordinating the various stages of production and distribution of goods and services, from raw materials to final delivery to the consumer. It involves managing relationships with suppliers, manufacturers, and distributors to enhance efficiency and optimize the flow of products in a way that adds value at each step. Effective supply chain management is critical for businesses in developing economies, as it can significantly impact economic growth and poverty alleviation.
Support Activities: Support activities refer to the various functions that assist and enhance primary activities within a value chain, enabling organizations to operate efficiently and effectively. These activities include areas such as procurement, technology development, human resource management, and firm infrastructure, all of which play a crucial role in improving the overall value delivered by the business, especially in developing economies where resource optimization is critical.
Sustainable sourcing: Sustainable sourcing refers to the procurement of goods and services in a way that considers the long-term social, economic, and environmental impacts. This approach aims to ensure that resources are obtained responsibly while promoting fair labor practices and minimizing harm to ecosystems. By integrating sustainability into supply chains, businesses can contribute positively to local economies and communities, particularly in developing areas.
Traders: Traders are individuals or entities involved in the buying and selling of goods or services, often acting as intermediaries in various markets. They play a crucial role in the economic landscape, especially in developing economies, by facilitating the flow of products and information along value chains, thereby connecting producers to consumers and enhancing market efficiency.
Value addition: Value addition refers to the process of enhancing the worth of a product or service by improving its quality, features, or benefits through various stages of production and distribution. This concept is crucial for businesses, especially in developing economies, as it helps in increasing profitability and fostering sustainable growth by transforming raw materials into finished products that meet consumer needs and preferences.
Value Chain Analysis: Value chain analysis is a strategic tool used to identify the activities within an organization that create value and contribute to competitive advantage. It helps to understand how different processes work together to produce goods or services and where improvements can be made to enhance efficiency, reduce costs, or increase customer satisfaction. In the context of emerging markets, particularly at the Base of Pyramid (BOP), it can reveal challenges and opportunities for businesses looking to serve low-income consumers by optimizing their operations and understanding local needs.