6.3 Managed Care Organizations and Models
3 min read•july 22, 2024
Managed care models aim to control healthcare costs while maintaining quality. Health Maintenance Organizations, Preferred Provider Organizations, and Point of Service plans offer different levels of provider choice and cost-sharing. Each model has its own approach to balancing affordability, access, and patient flexibility.
Primary care physicians play a crucial role in managed care as gatekeepers and care coordinators. These models impact healthcare delivery by emphasizing , implementing cost control measures, and influencing quality, access, and overall healthcare spending. Understanding these models is key to navigating the modern healthcare landscape.
Managed Care Models
Models of managed care
Top images from around the web for Models of managed care
LVCHEN 的美國生活指南: HMO, PPO？ 美國的健保真難懂！（上） View original
Is this image relevant?
Führungsmodell für Gesundheitsorganisationen (Center for Creative Leadership) - scil View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Role of Wireless Communication in Healthcare System to Cater Disaster Situations ... View original
Is this image relevant?
LVCHEN 的美國生活指南: HMO, PPO？ 美國的健保真難懂！（上） View original
Is this image relevant?
Führungsmodell für Gesundheitsorganisationen (Center for Creative Leadership) - scil View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Models of managed care
LVCHEN 的美國生活指南: HMO, PPO？ 美國的健保真難懂！（上） View original
Is this image relevant?
Führungsmodell für Gesundheitsorganisationen (Center for Creative Leadership) - scil View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Role of Wireless Communication in Healthcare System to Cater Disaster Situations ... View original
Is this image relevant?
LVCHEN 的美國生活指南: HMO, PPO？ 美國的健保真難懂！（上） View original
Is this image relevant?
Führungsmodell für Gesundheitsorganisationen (Center for Creative Leadership) - scil View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) deliver comprehensive healthcare services to members for a fixed prepaid fee (), requiring patients to select a who coordinates care and provides referrals to specialists within a limited provider network (), resulting in lower premiums and out-of-pocket costs but restricted patient choice
- Preferred Provider Organizations (PPOs) contract with a network of providers to offer discounted rates, allowing patients to see any in-network provider without a referral () or out-of-network providers at a higher cost, providing more flexibility than HMOs but with generally higher premiums and out-of-pocket expenses
- plans blend elements of HMOs and PPOs, requiring patients to choose a PCP for and referrals () while permitting out-of-network visits at a higher cost, offering a middle ground between the restrictiveness of HMOs and the flexibility of PPOs
Role of primary care physicians
- Primary care physicians (PCPs) function as gatekeepers in managed care, overseeing patient care and managing overall health by
- Delivering preventive services (annual physicals, immunizations)
- Diagnosing and treating common illnesses (flu, strep throat)
- Managing chronic conditions (diabetes, hypertension)
- PCPs assess the necessity for specialty care and issue referrals when needed in plans like HMOs, helping to control costs and ensure appropriate utilization of services (MRI for persistent back pain)
Pros and cons of managed care
- Advantages for patients include lower out-of-pocket expenses compared to traditional fee-for-service plans () and a focus on preventive care and care coordination ()
- Disadvantages for patients involve constrained provider choice, particularly in HMOs (), and potential limitations on access to certain treatments or services (experimental therapies)
- Advantages for providers encompass a guaranteed patient base through contracts with managed care organizations () and potential financial incentives for delivering cost-effective care ()
- Disadvantages for providers comprise reduced clinical decision-making autonomy () and increased administrative workload related to referrals and prior authorizations ()
- Advantages for payers consist of cost control through negotiated provider rates () and () as well as predictable healthcare spending via capitation and other payment models ()
- Disadvantages for payers include the potential for , attracting sicker enrollees (individuals with pre-existing conditions), and administrative expenses associated with managing provider networks and utilization ()
Impact on healthcare delivery
- Quality
- Emphasis on preventive services and care coordination can improve health outcomes (lower rates of preventable hospitalizations)
- Potential for underutilization of necessary services due to cost-control measures ()
- Quality measures and performance incentives can promote evidence-based care ()
- Access
- Lower out-of-pocket costs can enhance access to care for some patients ()
- Limited provider networks may restrict access to certain providers or specialists ()
- Referral requirements and prior authorizations can postpone access to needed services ()
- Costs
- Managed care has contributed to slowing the growth of healthcare spending through various cost-control mechanisms
- Negotiated provider rates ()
- Capitation (fixed payments per patient)
- Utilization management ()
- Shift towards value-based payment models that reward quality and efficiency ()
- Potential for cost-shifting to patients via higher premiums, deductibles, and copayments ()
- Managed care has contributed to slowing the growth of healthcare spending through various cost-control mechanisms
Key Terms to Review (35)
Accountable Care Organizations: Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs) are groups of healthcare providers that come together to provide coordinated care to patients, with the goal of improving quality while reducing costs. ACOs focus on collaboration among various healthcare professionals, emphasizing preventive care and efficient management of resources, which connects them to managed care models, cost drivers in healthcare, cost containment strategies, comparative healthcare systems, and economic concepts applied to healthcare.
Adherence to clinical guidelines: Adherence to clinical guidelines refers to the extent to which healthcare providers follow established protocols and recommendations for patient care. This practice is essential for ensuring that patients receive evidence-based treatments, which can lead to improved health outcomes, reduced variability in care, and enhanced overall efficiency within healthcare systems.
Adverse selection: Adverse selection refers to a situation in which individuals with higher risks are more likely to seek out insurance coverage, leading to an imbalance in the insurance pool. This phenomenon can cause insurers to face greater losses due to a disproportionate number of high-risk individuals, ultimately driving up costs for everyone involved and potentially leading to market failures.
Blue Cross Blue Shield: Blue Cross Blue Shield (BCBS) is a federation of 36 independent health insurance companies in the United States, providing healthcare coverage to millions of members. BCBS operates under two main entities: Blue Cross, which primarily focuses on hospital care, and Blue Shield, which emphasizes physician services. Together, they play a significant role in the managed care landscape by offering a variety of insurance plans that cater to different healthcare needs and financial situations.
Bonuses for meeting quality metrics: Bonuses for meeting quality metrics are financial incentives provided to healthcare providers and organizations for achieving specific performance standards related to patient care quality. These bonuses aim to improve healthcare outcomes by encouraging providers to focus on delivering high-quality services, thus enhancing patient satisfaction and overall care efficiency.
Capitation: Capitation is a payment arrangement in healthcare where a provider is paid a fixed amount per patient for a specified period, regardless of the number of services provided. This model encourages providers to focus on preventive care and efficient management of resources, while also directly linking compensation to the overall health of the patient population.
Care coordination: Care coordination refers to the organization of patient care activities and sharing of information among all participants concerned with a patient's care to facilitate appropriate delivery of healthcare services. This process aims to improve patient outcomes and satisfaction by ensuring that patients receive the right care at the right time, particularly within complex healthcare systems. Effective care coordination is essential in managed care settings and also plays a critical role in understanding competition and regulatory issues within healthcare markets.
Claims processing: Claims processing refers to the systematic handling and evaluation of insurance claims submitted by healthcare providers or patients for reimbursement. This process is essential in managed care organizations, as it ensures that claims are assessed accurately and efficiently, allowing for timely payments and maintaining the financial integrity of the healthcare system.
Discounts: Discounts are reductions in the price of healthcare services or products, often offered by managed care organizations as part of their pricing strategy. These reductions can help increase access to care for patients, encourage the use of specific providers, and promote overall cost containment within the healthcare system. Discounts are typically negotiated between healthcare providers and managed care organizations to create a more competitive pricing structure.
Disease management programs: Disease management programs are coordinated healthcare interventions aimed at improving the health outcomes of individuals with chronic diseases by providing education, support, and monitoring. These programs focus on empowering patients to take control of their health while also reducing healthcare costs and hospitalizations. They often involve a multidisciplinary approach, integrating services from various healthcare providers to ensure comprehensive care.
Fee schedules: Fee schedules are predetermined lists of fees that healthcare providers charge for specific services or procedures. These schedules are crucial for managed care organizations as they dictate the amount of reimbursement a provider receives for each service rendered to patients under a managed care plan. They help standardize costs, streamline billing, and ensure that payments are consistent across various providers and services within the organization.
Fixed per-member-per-month fees: Fixed per-member-per-month fees are predictable, set payments made by managed care organizations for each enrolled member, regardless of the number of healthcare services utilized. This model allows organizations to control costs and encourages providers to focus on preventive care and efficient service delivery, as they receive a consistent payment regardless of the services rendered.
Health maintenance organization (HMO): A health maintenance organization (HMO) is a type of managed care organization that provides health insurance coverage through a network of doctors and hospitals. HMO plans focus on preventive care and require members to choose a primary care physician who coordinates all healthcare services, emphasizing cost control and efficient delivery of medical care.
Health outcomes measurement: Health outcomes measurement refers to the systematic assessment of the results of healthcare interventions and services, evaluating their impact on patients' health status, quality of life, and overall well-being. This process involves using various metrics to gather data on patient outcomes, which helps healthcare organizations improve the quality and effectiveness of care delivered to patients. By understanding health outcomes, managed care organizations can tailor their services to meet the needs of their populations better.
In-network only: In-network only refers to a type of health insurance plan that requires members to use a specified network of healthcare providers to receive benefits. This means that services provided by out-of-network providers are not covered, or are covered at a significantly lower level, which can lead to higher out-of-pocket costs for patients. This model encourages members to utilize specific providers who have agreed to provide services at negotiated rates, promoting cost containment and quality of care.
Increased cost-sharing: Increased cost-sharing refers to the practice where patients are required to pay a larger portion of their healthcare expenses, such as copayments, deductibles, or coinsurance. This approach is often implemented by managed care organizations to control healthcare costs and encourage more responsible utilization of services among patients. By shifting more financial responsibility onto consumers, increased cost-sharing aims to reduce unnecessary healthcare use while also promoting cost-conscious decision-making regarding treatment options.
Kaiser Permanente: Kaiser Permanente is a managed care organization that provides health insurance and medical care services through an integrated delivery system. Founded in 1945, it combines health insurance coverage with healthcare services, which allows for coordinated and preventive care. This model emphasizes member health and well-being, while controlling costs through a focus on preventive measures and comprehensive care.
Lower copays: Lower copays refer to the reduced out-of-pocket expenses that patients must pay for healthcare services at the time of receiving care. This concept is significant in managing healthcare costs as it can lead to increased access to necessary medical services, encourage preventive care, and promote adherence to treatment plans. Lower copays are often a feature of managed care organizations, which seek to balance cost containment with quality patient care.
Medical necessity reviews: Medical necessity reviews are assessments conducted by managed care organizations to determine whether a healthcare service or treatment is necessary based on established clinical guidelines and criteria. These reviews help ensure that the services provided to patients are appropriate for their specific health conditions, aiming to control costs while maintaining quality of care.
Narrow networks: Narrow networks refer to health insurance plans that provide a limited selection of healthcare providers, typically aimed at controlling costs while still delivering quality care. These networks are designed to encourage patients to use a specific set of doctors and hospitals, often resulting in lower premiums compared to broader network plans. By limiting choices, narrow networks can reduce overall healthcare spending for both insurers and consumers.
Paperwork: Paperwork refers to the documentation and forms that are required for various administrative processes, particularly in healthcare settings. It encompasses patient records, insurance claims, authorizations, and compliance documents that ensure proper management and accountability within managed care organizations. Efficient handling of paperwork is crucial as it impacts patient care, billing accuracy, and regulatory compliance.
Patient satisfaction: Patient satisfaction refers to the extent to which patients feel their healthcare needs are being met, including their experiences with care, communication, and outcomes. This concept is vital for improving healthcare quality, as satisfied patients are more likely to engage with their healthcare providers, adhere to treatment plans, and experience better health outcomes. High levels of patient satisfaction can influence various reimbursement models, impact care delivery structures, and inform staffing strategies in healthcare settings.
Pay-for-performance programs: Pay-for-performance programs are initiatives in healthcare that financially reward providers for meeting specific quality and efficiency benchmarks in patient care. These programs aim to improve health outcomes, enhance patient satisfaction, and reduce costs by linking reimbursement to performance metrics rather than the volume of services provided. By focusing on value rather than volume, these programs encourage healthcare providers to deliver higher-quality care and engage in cost-effective practices.
Point of Service (POS): A Point of Service (POS) plan is a type of managed care health insurance that combines features of both Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) and Preferred Provider Organizations (PPOs). This system allows members to choose between in-network providers, who offer lower costs, and out-of-network providers, who are more expensive. It emphasizes flexibility in choosing healthcare providers while still promoting cost-effective care.
Preferred provider organization (PPO): A preferred provider organization (PPO) is a type of managed care health insurance plan that offers a network of healthcare providers to its members. Members can choose to use providers within this network for reduced costs or opt for out-of-network services at a higher out-of-pocket expense. PPOs provide flexibility in choosing healthcare providers while also managing costs through negotiated rates with their preferred providers.
Preventive care: Preventive care refers to health services designed to prevent illnesses or detect health issues early, thereby improving health outcomes and reducing the need for more extensive treatments later. It encompasses a range of services including vaccinations, screenings, and regular check-ups that aim to catch potential health problems before they escalate, ultimately leading to lower costs and better quality of life.
Primary Care Physician (PCP): A primary care physician (PCP) is a healthcare professional who serves as the first point of contact for patients seeking medical care. PCPs provide comprehensive, ongoing care, focusing on preventive services, diagnosis, and management of various health conditions. They play a crucial role in managed care organizations by coordinating patient care, ensuring efficient use of healthcare resources, and building long-term relationships with patients.
Prior Authorization: Prior authorization is a process used by managed care organizations to determine if a healthcare service, procedure, or medication is medically necessary before it is provided. This process requires healthcare providers to obtain approval from the insurer before the service can be rendered, which helps control costs and ensure that treatments align with established medical guidelines.
Quality of Care: Quality of care refers to the degree to which health services for individuals and populations increase the likelihood of desired health outcomes and are consistent with current professional knowledge. It encompasses several dimensions including effectiveness, safety, patient-centeredness, timeliness, efficiency, and equity. Understanding quality of care is crucial for evaluating different healthcare delivery models and for making comparisons between healthcare systems globally.
Rationing: Rationing refers to the allocation of limited healthcare resources among individuals or groups in order to ensure that everyone has access to necessary services. This concept is particularly relevant in contexts where demand for healthcare exceeds supply, making it crucial for managing costs, maintaining quality of care, and prioritizing services effectively.
Reduced financial barriers: Reduced financial barriers refer to the elimination or minimization of costs that individuals face when accessing healthcare services. This concept plays a crucial role in improving healthcare access, as it allows more people to seek necessary medical attention without the fear of excessive out-of-pocket expenses, ultimately promoting better health outcomes and equity in healthcare delivery.
Steady revenue stream: A steady revenue stream refers to a consistent and reliable source of income that an organization can expect to receive over time. In the context of managed care organizations and models, having a steady revenue stream is crucial as it ensures the sustainability and financial health of these entities while enabling them to plan for future healthcare services and investments.
UnitedHealthcare: UnitedHealthcare is one of the largest health insurance companies in the United States, providing a wide range of healthcare plans and services to individuals, employers, and government programs. As a key player in the healthcare market, UnitedHealthcare focuses on delivering health benefits through various managed care models and is heavily involved in the economics of medical devices and technology, ensuring patients have access to necessary innovations while managing costs effectively.
Utilization Management: Utilization management is a systematic approach used in healthcare to evaluate the appropriateness and necessity of services provided to patients. It involves assessing whether the care being delivered is suitable for a patient's condition and if it aligns with established guidelines, ensuring that resources are used efficiently. This concept is crucial for balancing quality care with cost containment, making it relevant to various payment models, organizational structures, cost factors, and strategies aimed at controlling expenses in healthcare delivery.
Waiting Periods: Waiting periods are specific durations of time that individuals must wait before they can access certain benefits or services in managed care organizations. These periods are commonly used to prevent adverse selection and ensure that members do not enroll in a plan only when they need immediate care. By implementing waiting periods, organizations can manage costs and maintain the sustainability of their healthcare delivery models.