9.7 International tax and VAT compliance

International tax and VAT compliance are crucial for e-commerce businesses expanding globally. Understanding income tax, permanent establishment, and transfer pricing rules in different countries helps companies make informed decisions and optimize their tax positions.

VAT, a consumption tax on value added at each production stage, is essential for e-commerce businesses selling internationally. Companies must navigate varying VAT rates, goods vs. services classifications, and B2B vs. B2C transactions to properly charge, collect, and remit VAT across multiple jurisdictions.

International tax obligations

• Understanding international tax obligations is crucial for e-commerce businesses expanding globally to ensure compliance and avoid penalties
• Income tax, permanent establishment, and transfer pricing rules vary by country and impact how much tax is owed on foreign sales
• Proactively addressing international tax considerations helps e-commerce businesses make informed decisions about their global operations and optimize their tax positions

Income tax on foreign sales

Top images from around the web for Income tax on foreign sales

• 

  The Effects of Compliance and Growth Opinions on SMEs Compliance Decisions: An Empirical ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Handling An International Tax Assessment Form 3520 on Vimeo View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  International Trade and Welfare Costs of Tariffs | Marginal Revolution University View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Effects of Compliance and Growth Opinions on SMEs Compliance Decisions: An Empirical ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Handling An International Tax Assessment Form 3520 on Vimeo View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Income tax on foreign sales

• 

  The Effects of Compliance and Growth Opinions on SMEs Compliance Decisions: An Empirical ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Handling An International Tax Assessment Form 3520 on Vimeo View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  International Trade and Welfare Costs of Tariffs | Marginal Revolution University View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Effects of Compliance and Growth Opinions on SMEs Compliance Decisions: An Empirical ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Handling An International Tax Assessment Form 3520 on Vimeo View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• E-commerce businesses may owe income tax in countries where they have customers, even without a physical presence, based on local tax laws
• Tax treaties between countries impact where income is taxed and can provide exemptions or reduced rates for certain types of income (royalties, interest)
• Factors such as sales volume, type of products/services sold, and level of business activity in the country determine income tax obligations
• Examples of activities triggering income tax: selling through a local website, using local payment processors, storing inventory in local warehouses

Permanent establishment risks

• Having a fixed place of business or dependent agent in a foreign country creates a permanent establishment (PE) and income tax obligations
• E-commerce activities like using local servers, providing installation/training services, or having sales reps in the country increase PE risk
• Structuring e-commerce operations (drop shipping, third-party logistics) to avoid creating a PE in each country
• Tax planning strategies to minimize PE exposure: fragmenting activities across countries, using independent contractors vs employees

Transfer pricing considerations

• Transfer pricing rules govern pricing of goods, services, and intellectual property between related entities in different countries
• E-commerce businesses must use arm's length pricing for intercompany transactions to avoid shifting profits to low-tax jurisdictions
• Documenting transfer pricing policies, performing comparability analyses, and preparing support for pricing used
• Common e-commerce transfer pricing issues: valuing intangibles (website, algorithms), cost sharing arrangements, marketing/promotion services

Value-added tax (VAT) basics

• VAT is a consumption tax assessed on the value added at each stage of production and ultimately paid by the end consumer
• Understanding VAT principles is essential for e-commerce businesses selling internationally to properly charge, collect, and remit VAT
• VAT typically applies to each sale within a country but special rules (reverse charge) may shift VAT liability to the customer

VAT rates by country

• Standard VAT rates vary across countries, typically ranging from 5-27% (Hungary 27%, Australia 10%, UK 20%)
• Reduced VAT rates or exemptions apply to certain products (food, medicine, books) to lower the tax burden on essentials
• E-commerce businesses must identify the correct VAT rate for each product in each country and configure systems accordingly
• Staying current on VAT rate changes in each country and updating pricing/invoicing to reflect new rates

Goods vs services VAT

• Physical goods are subject to VAT in the country where the customer receives the product, based on customs value plus duties/transport costs
• Digital services (streaming, e-books, software) are subject to VAT based on the customer's location, requiring sellers to verify location
• Goods below a certain value threshold (£135 in UK) may qualify for import VAT exemption to simplify compliance for small e-commerce sellers
• Determining whether products are classified as goods or services for VAT and managing inventory in each country to optimize VAT obligations

B2B vs B2C transactions

• B2B sales are between VAT-registered businesses who can recover VAT paid, while B2C sales to consumers have non-recoverable VAT
• B2B buyers provide their VAT registration number to be exempted from VAT, shifting the payment obligation to the buyer (reverse charge mechanism)
• B2C sales require the seller to charge VAT and remit to the tax authority, with VAT a cost to the end consumer
• E-commerce platforms facilitating B2B and B2C sales must verify customer VAT status and apply correct VAT treatment for each transaction

VAT registration requirements

• E-commerce sellers must register for VAT in countries where they have a business presence or sell to consumers, to properly assess and remit VAT
• VAT registration rules vary by country in terms of threshold, process, and ongoing compliance obligations for foreign businesses
• Failing to register for VAT when required can lead to penalties, interest, and reputational damage for e-commerce sellers

Thresholds for VAT registration

• Most countries have sales thresholds above which foreign businesses must register for VAT (£85,000 annually in UK)
• Thresholds may apply at the country level or for the EU as a whole (€10,000 annually), requiring tracking of sales by jurisdiction
• E-commerce businesses should monitor sales by country against registration thresholds to proactively register when required
• Voluntary VAT registration below thresholds can enable recovering VAT on local costs or add legitimacy with customers and suppliers

Fiscal representation needs

• Some countries require foreign e-commerce businesses to appoint a fiscal representative (local agent) for VAT compliance
• Fiscal representatives act on behalf of the foreign business to submit VAT returns, communicate with tax authorities, and even be liable for VAT debts
• Countries requiring fiscal representation for non-EU businesses: Poland, Portugal, Sweden, Spain, Norway
• Choosing a fiscal representative, negotiating fees (often a % of VAT), and managing the ongoing relationship and information sharing

VAT registration process

• Registering for VAT involves submitting an application, providing business details, and obtaining a local VAT number to print on invoices
• E-commerce sellers may need to appoint a local agent (fiscal rep), open a bank account, or establish a local place of business
• Gathering required documents: articles of incorporation, proof of address, ID of directors, description of e-commerce activities
• Estimating registration timelines to ensure compliance (typically 2-6 weeks but can take longer) and planning for ongoing VAT filings post-registration

VAT compliance processes

• E-commerce businesses registered for VAT must follow local rules for invoicing, returns, payments, and recordkeeping to stay compliant
• Automating VAT processes through software and integrations is crucial to efficiently manage compliance across multiple jurisdictions
• Regularly reviewing VAT processes to identify errors, overpayments, or improvements to streamline compliance and reduce costs

VAT invoicing rules

• VAT-registered businesses must issue invoices meeting local requirements (VAT amount, VAT number, address) to support the buyer's VAT recovery
• E-commerce businesses should collect customer VAT numbers and issue B2B invoices without VAT, shifting the VAT accounting to the buyer
• Invoicing in the local language and currency, following sequential numbering, and including required references (PO number, shipping details)
• Retaining VAT invoices for the statutory period (typically 5-10 years) in case of an audit and to enable the buyer's VAT deduction

VAT returns and filings

• VAT returns are periodic filings (monthly, quarterly) summarizing VAT collected on sales and paid on purchases, with the net VAT payable to the tax authority
• E-commerce sellers must compile sales and purchase data in the required format, often by VAT rate or by country for cross-border sales
• Monitoring VAT return deadlines across countries, filing electronically where required, and making timely payments to avoid penalties and interest
• Performing reconciliations between VAT returns and internal sales/accounting systems to validate accuracy and completeness of filings

Record keeping for VAT

• Maintaining accurate and detailed records is essential to support VAT compliance, returns, and audits
• Records to retain: sales and purchase invoices, shipping documents, payment records, VAT calculations, and VAT returns
• Implementing systems to efficiently capture and store VAT-relevant data, with backups and access controls to ensure integrity
• Extracting VAT data in formats required by tax authorities (XML, SAF-T) and submitting as part of VAT audits or information requests

Managing international tax

• As e-commerce businesses expand globally, proactively managing international tax obligations becomes increasingly complex and resource-intensive
• Leveraging external advisors, technology, and internal processes can help e-commerce businesses optimize their global tax positions while minimizing risk
• Embedding international tax considerations into strategic decisions (product mix, pricing, supply chain) to align tax planning with business objectives

Tax advisors and accountants

• Engaging local tax advisors and accountants in key markets to provide guidance on tax obligations, registration, and compliance processes
• Advisors can help interpret local tax laws, identify tax planning opportunities, and represent the business in tax audits or disputes
• Considerations for choosing advisors: e-commerce experience, language capabilities, references from similar clients, fee structures
• Establishing communication protocols and information sharing with advisors to keep them current on business changes impacting tax positions

Tax compliance software

• Implementing tax compliance software to automate VAT calculations, invoicing, returns, and reporting across multiple countries
• Integrating tax software with e-commerce platforms, ERP, and accounting systems to streamline data flow and minimize manual intervention
• Evaluating software vendors on functionality, ease of use, data security, and support for local tax requirements in key markets
• Building internal capabilities to effectively use tax software, monitor updates, and validate outputs for accuracy and audit-readiness

Budgeting for international taxes

• Developing budgets and forecasts that incorporate international tax costs (VAT, income tax, customs duties) based on projected sales mix and volumes
• Modeling tax impacts of different supply chain and entity structures to optimize global effective tax rate and cash flows
• Allocating internal resources (personnel, systems) to manage international tax compliance and planning as the business scales
• Monitoring actual international tax costs against budget, investigating variances, and adjusting pricing or operations to stay within targets