2.1 Clayton Christensen's theory of disruptive innovation
3 min read•august 16, 2024
Clayton Christensen's theory of explains how new products or services can upend established markets. It describes how simple, affordable offerings can evolve to meet mainstream needs, eventually displacing industry leaders.
Disruptive innovations often start in overlooked market segments, offering different benefits than traditional products. They follow a predictable pattern of improvement, creating new markets and value networks. Examples include , , and .
Disruptive Innovation
Concept and Key Characteristics
Top images from around the web for Concept and Key Characteristics
Cracks In The Foundation Of Disruptive Innovation -e-Literate View original
Is this image relevant?
Innovación Disruptiva (Christensen) – juandon. Innovación y conocimiento View original
Is this image relevant?
Bits or pieces?: What is right and wrong with Christensen's Disruptive Innovation? View original
Is this image relevant?
Cracks In The Foundation Of Disruptive Innovation -e-Literate View original
Is this image relevant?
Innovación Disruptiva (Christensen) – juandon. Innovación y conocimiento View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Concept and Key Characteristics
Cracks In The Foundation Of Disruptive Innovation -e-Literate View original
Is this image relevant?
Innovación Disruptiva (Christensen) – juandon. Innovación y conocimiento View original
Is this image relevant?
Bits or pieces?: What is right and wrong with Christensen's Disruptive Innovation? View original
Is this image relevant?
Cracks In The Foundation Of Disruptive Innovation -e-Literate View original
Is this image relevant?
Innovación Disruptiva (Christensen) – juandon. Innovación y conocimiento View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Disruptive innovation theory developed by Clayton Christensen explains how products or services initially take root in simple applications at market bottom and move upmarket, eventually displacing established competitors
- Lower gross margins, smaller target markets, and simpler products characterize disruptive innovations compared to traditional performance metrics
- Start in low-end or new-market footholds (areas unattractive or overlooked by industry incumbents)
- Offer different features and benefits prioritizing affordability, simplicity, convenience, or accessibility
- Driven by enabling technologies or innovative business models serving underserved or unserved customer segments
- Follow predictable pattern improving over time to meet more demanding customer needs, often surpassing established products in mainstream markets
- Create new markets and value networks unlike sustaining innovations
Examples and Applications
- Personal computers disrupted mainframe and minicomputer markets
- Smartphones disrupted traditional mobile phone industry
- () disrupted video rental and cable TV markets
- (Southwest) disrupted traditional airline industry
- disrupted film photography market
- E-commerce platforms () disrupted traditional retail industry
- disrupting internal combustion engine automobile market
Disruption vs Sustaining Innovation
Process of Disruption
- New entrants target overlooked segments, gaining foothold by delivering suitable functionality at lower price
- Disruptive innovations improve and attract mainstream customers, moving upmarket and gaining market share
- Process typically slower than , allowing incumbents time to respond
- Often difficult for incumbents to recognize or address effectively due to and focus on existing high-value customers
- Leads to creation of new markets and value networks
- Sacrifices performance in "traditional" attributes but offers new features valued by subset of customers
Sustaining Innovation Characteristics
- Improve performance of established products along dimensions valued by mainstream customers
- Can be incremental or radical but do not create new markets or value networks
- Focus on improving products for incumbent's existing customers
- Reinforce existing markets and value networks
- Typically easier for incumbents to recognize and respond to effectively
- Often driven by customer demand and competitive pressures within existing market
Impact of Disruptive Innovation
Market and Industry Effects
- Reconfigures industry structures and redefines market boundaries
- Creates new customer segments and shifts power dynamics within industry value chains
- Alters basis of competition in established markets
- Impacts extend beyond individual firms, affecting entire ecosystems and complementary industries
- Can lead to devaluation of incumbents' core competencies
- Emergence of new capabilities and resources as sources of
Impact on Incumbent Firms
- Incumbents struggle to respond effectively due to organizational rigidities and resource allocation processes
- Loss of market share, decreased profitability, and potential business failure or obsolescence for established firms
- Market leaders generally good at responding to sustaining innovations but often fail to address disruptive innovations
- Core competencies of incumbents may become obsolete or less valuable
- Challenges existing business models and value propositions
Challenges and Opportunities for Disruption
Challenges for Incumbents
- choosing between sustaining innovations for existing customers or pursuing potentially disruptive innovations
- Overcoming organizational inertia and reallocating resources from sustaining to potentially disruptive projects
- Managing expectations of existing customers and shareholders while pursuing disruptive opportunities
- Developing new capabilities and competencies required for disruptive innovations
- Balancing short-term performance with long-term survival and growth
Strategies and Opportunities
- Create autonomous units to explore disruptive opportunities (IBM's PC division)
- Pursue strategic partnerships or acquisitions to access disruptive technologies (Facebook acquiring WhatsApp)
- Engage in corporate venturing to invest in potentially disruptive startups (Intel Capital)
- Develop ambidextrous organizational structures to pursue both sustaining and disruptive innovations simultaneously
- Build dynamic capabilities to sense, seize, and reconfigure resources in response to disruptive changes
- Adopt different metrics, processes, and cultural norms for disruptive innovation initiatives
- Explore adjacent markets or redefine existing business models to capture value from disruptive trends
Key Terms to Review (27)
Amazon: Amazon is a multinational technology and e-commerce company known for its vast online marketplace and innovative services. Founded by Jeff Bezos in 1994, Amazon transformed the retail landscape by leveraging technology and data analytics, ultimately becoming a prime example of disruptive innovation that reshapes industries.
Business model innovation: Business model innovation refers to the process of creating, redefining, or transforming a company's existing business model to improve its competitive position and enhance value creation. This type of innovation often involves altering the way a company delivers products or services, engages with customers, and generates revenue, making it essential for adapting to market changes and emerging opportunities.
Chasm: In the context of disruptive innovation, the chasm refers to the critical gap between early adopters and the early majority in the adoption lifecycle of a new technology. This concept highlights the challenges that innovative products face when transitioning from niche markets, where they initially find support, to mainstream markets, where broader acceptance is essential for success. Overcoming this chasm is crucial for disruptive technologies to achieve widespread adoption and reach their full market potential.
Competitive Advantage: Competitive advantage refers to the unique attributes or resources that allow a company to outperform its competitors, leading to greater sales, margins, or customer loyalty. It can stem from various factors such as superior technology, brand reputation, cost efficiency, or specialized expertise. Understanding how to leverage competitive advantage is crucial for assessing industry value chains and business models, as well as recognizing the potential for disruptive innovation and fostering an entrepreneurial culture within organizations.
Digital photography: Digital photography is the process of capturing and storing images using electronic sensors instead of traditional film, allowing for immediate viewing and manipulation of photos. This technology revolutionized the way people take, share, and edit images, leading to significant changes in various fields including journalism, art, and social media.
Disruption theory framework: The disruption theory framework is a model developed by Clayton Christensen that explains how smaller companies with fewer resources can successfully challenge established businesses. This framework highlights how disruptive innovations typically start in low-end or new market footholds, where mainstream customers do not initially demand the new technologies or services, allowing the disruptors to gain traction before moving upmarket.
Disruptive innovation: Disruptive innovation refers to a process where a smaller company with fewer resources successfully challenges established businesses by focusing on underserved markets and offering simpler, more affordable solutions. This often leads to significant shifts in industry dynamics, as established companies may struggle to adapt to the new market conditions created by these innovations.
E-commerce platforms: E-commerce platforms are online systems that facilitate the buying and selling of goods and services over the internet. These platforms provide the necessary infrastructure for businesses to set up online stores, manage inventory, process payments, and connect with customers, thereby transforming traditional retail practices through digital means. They play a crucial role in enabling companies to reach larger audiences and adapt to changing consumer behaviors in a digital economy.
Electric vehicles: Electric vehicles (EVs) are automobiles that are powered by electric motors instead of internal combustion engines, using energy stored in batteries. They represent a shift in the automotive industry as they provide a cleaner, more sustainable alternative to traditional gasoline-powered cars, linking them closely to innovations that disrupt established markets.
Incumbent Firms: Incumbent firms are established companies that hold a significant position in their respective industries, often enjoying competitive advantages such as brand loyalty, market share, and resources. These firms are typically resistant to change and may struggle to adapt when faced with disruptive innovations that challenge their existing business models and market dominance.
Innovator's Dilemma: The innovator's dilemma refers to the challenge faced by established companies when they must choose between investing in new, disruptive innovations or continuing to invest in their existing successful products. This dilemma arises because the company's existing customers and revenue streams often lead to a focus on sustaining innovations that improve current offerings, while disruptive innovations may initially serve a smaller or different market.
Jobs-to-be-done theory: Jobs-to-be-done theory is a framework that helps understand customer needs by focusing on the jobs they want to accomplish rather than the products they buy. This theory emphasizes that customers 'hire' products or services to get a job done, which can lead to insights for innovation and market opportunities. By identifying these jobs, businesses can develop solutions that better meet the specific needs of their customers.
Kodak: Kodak is a multinational corporation known for its role in the photography industry, particularly for its invention of the film camera and photographic film. The company was a pioneer in the field of imaging but struggled to adapt to the digital revolution, ultimately leading to its decline. Kodak's story is often cited as a classic example of a company that failed to recognize and respond to disruptive innovation.
Low-cost airlines: Low-cost airlines are carriers that offer significantly lower fares than traditional airlines by eliminating many of the frills and services typically associated with air travel. These airlines focus on reducing operational costs, which allows them to pass savings onto customers, thereby making air travel more accessible to a broader audience. They often operate on a point-to-point model, avoiding hubs and offering direct routes to maximize efficiency.
Low-End Disruption: Low-end disruption refers to a process where a smaller company with fewer resources successfully challenges established businesses by targeting overlooked segments of the market, often offering simpler, more affordable products or services. This concept highlights how incumbent companies can be vulnerable to competitors that start at the lower end of the market and gradually improve their offerings, capturing more market share over time.
Market segmentation: Market segmentation is the process of dividing a broad consumer or business market into smaller, more defined categories based on shared characteristics. This allows companies to tailor their products, services, and marketing strategies to meet the specific needs of different groups, ultimately enhancing their competitive advantage. In the context of disruptive innovation, understanding market segmentation helps identify underserved or overlooked market segments that can be targeted with new, innovative solutions.
Market transformation: Market transformation refers to the process through which significant changes occur in a market, often driven by disruptive innovations that reshape consumer preferences, industry dynamics, and competitive landscapes. This transformation can lead to the emergence of new business models, changes in the way products are delivered, and shifts in market leadership as traditional players adapt or are replaced by innovative entrants.
Netflix: Netflix is a streaming service that revolutionized the way audiences consume entertainment by offering a vast library of movies, TV shows, and original content on-demand. This shift from traditional cable television to streaming exemplifies disruptive innovation by leveraging technology to provide greater convenience and personalized viewing experiences.
New Market Disruption: New market disruption refers to a type of disruptive innovation that creates new markets by targeting non-consumers or underserved segments of the existing market, often using simpler, more affordable solutions. This form of disruption allows innovative companies to attract customers who previously could not afford or access the product or service, thereby reshaping industries. By focusing on these overlooked segments, businesses can create entirely new categories that challenge established companies and alter competitive dynamics.
Online streaming services: Online streaming services are digital platforms that deliver audio, video, and other multimedia content to users over the internet in real-time. These services have revolutionized how people consume media, providing instant access to a wide variety of entertainment options, such as movies, TV shows, and music, often on-demand and without the need for traditional broadcasting methods. This shift has significant implications for media industries and consumer behavior.
Organizational Inertia: Organizational inertia refers to the tendency of a company to continue on its existing path and resist change, even in the face of significant external shifts or disruptive innovations. This resistance can stem from established structures, processes, and cultural norms that prioritize stability over adaptation. When organizations face disruptive innovation, their inertia can hinder their ability to pivot and scale effectively, ultimately impacting their long-term success.
Personal computers: Personal computers (PCs) are versatile computing devices designed for individual use, typically featuring a microprocessor, memory, and storage. They revolutionized how people interacted with technology by making computing accessible and affordable, thus enabling widespread personal and professional applications.
Pivoting: Pivoting refers to the strategic change in direction that a company or startup takes to adapt its business model or product in response to market feedback, technological advancements, or competitive pressures. This concept is crucial for recognizing when an existing strategy isn't yielding desired results and highlights the importance of flexibility in entrepreneurship and innovation.
Smartphones: Smartphones are handheld mobile devices that combine the functionality of a computer with that of a traditional mobile phone, allowing users to perform a variety of tasks such as calling, texting, browsing the internet, and running applications. Their rapid evolution has made them a prime example of technological disruption, reshaping how we communicate and access information while also affecting industries like telecommunications, computing, and media.
Sustaining Innovation: Sustaining innovation refers to the process of improving existing products or services in a way that meets the needs of current customers and enhances a company's performance. This type of innovation typically focuses on maintaining market position and improving efficiency rather than creating entirely new markets. It is essential for organizations to balance sustaining innovations with disruptive innovations to adapt to changing environments and consumer expectations.
Technology adoption lifecycle: The technology adoption lifecycle is a model that describes the stages of adoption of new technologies among different groups of users, typically classified into five categories: innovators, early adopters, early majority, late majority, and laggards. This model helps to understand how disruptive innovations spread through society and how they can impact various stakeholders by influencing technology acceptance and integration.
Value network: A value network is a structured system of relationships and interactions among various stakeholders that create and deliver value through their collaborative efforts. This concept emphasizes how different players, such as customers, suppliers, and partners, contribute to the overall value proposition, enabling organizations to innovate and adapt within their environment.