1.2 Agile vs. traditional project management
5 min read•august 13, 2024
Agile project management shakes up traditional methods by focusing on flexibility and collaboration. It's all about delivering in short sprints, getting constant feedback, and adapting to change. This approach is perfect for projects with unclear requirements or frequent updates.
Traditional project management, on the other hand, follows a linear path with distinct phases. It's great for projects with well-defined scopes and fixed budgets. The key is choosing the right method based on your project's needs and your team's structure.
Agile vs Traditional Project Management
Iterative vs Linear Approaches
Top images from around the web for Iterative vs Linear Approaches
Iterative and incremental development - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Architecting the uncertain - Getting started with Agile Software Architecture | print("Hello ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Floreth's Blog 2016-10-28 19:13:00 – TC1019 Fall 2016 View original
Is this image relevant?
Iterative and incremental development - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Architecting the uncertain - Getting started with Agile Software Architecture | print("Hello ... View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Iterative vs Linear Approaches
Iterative and incremental development - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Architecting the uncertain - Getting started with Agile Software Architecture | print("Hello ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Floreth's Blog 2016-10-28 19:13:00 – TC1019 Fall 2016 View original
Is this image relevant?
Iterative and incremental development - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Architecting the uncertain - Getting started with Agile Software Architecture | print("Hello ... View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Agile project management is an iterative approach that focuses on delivering working software incrementally
- Software is developed in short cycles called sprints or iterations (1-4 weeks)
- Each iteration includes planning, design, development, testing, and review
- Goal is to deliver a potentially shippable product increment at the end of each iteration
- Traditional project management follows a linear, sequential approach with distinct phases
- Phases typically include initiation, planning, execution, monitoring and controlling, and closing
- Each phase is completed before moving on to the next, with limited opportunity for change or feedback
Flexibility and Collaboration vs Planning and Structure
- Agile methodologies prioritize flexibility, collaboration, and adapting to change
- Teams are self-organizing and cross-functional, with a focus on face-to-face communication
- Regular feedback and adjustments are made based on customer input and changing requirements
- Emphasis is on delivering value to the customer and responding quickly to change
- Traditional approaches emphasize detailed planning, documentation, and following a fixed plan
- Teams are often structured hierarchically with defined roles and responsibilities
- Detailed project plans, Gantt charts, and other documentation are created upfront
- Changes to the plan are often difficult and require formal change control processes
Customer Involvement and Feedback
- Agile projects involve the customer throughout the development process
- Regular demos, reviews, and feedback sessions are held with the customer
- Customer input is used to prioritize features and make adjustments to the product
- Goal is to ensure the product meets the customer's needs and expectations
- Traditional projects typically involve the customer at the beginning and end of the project
- Requirements are gathered upfront and documented in detail
- Customer feedback is often limited to formal reviews or acceptance testing at the end of the project
- Changes to requirements can be difficult and costly to implement
Choosing the Right Methodology
Factors to Consider
- Project complexity and scope
- Agile is well-suited for projects with unclear or rapidly changing requirements
- Traditional approaches are more appropriate for projects with well-defined requirements and a clear scope
- Team size and structure
- Agile works best with small, cross-functional teams (typically 5-9 people)
- Traditional approaches can accommodate larger teams with specialized roles and responsibilities
- Customer involvement and collaboration
- Agile requires regular customer feedback and involvement throughout the project
- Traditional approaches may have limited customer involvement, especially during the execution phase
- Organizational culture and processes
- Agile requires a culture of trust, transparency, and
- Traditional approaches may be more compatible with hierarchical organizations and established processes
Examples of Agile and Traditional Projects
- Agile is often used in software development projects
- Web and mobile app development
- SaaS (Software as a Service) products
- Projects with evolving requirements or frequent releases
- Traditional methods are common in construction or manufacturing projects
- Building construction (residential, commercial, or industrial)
- Product development with established specifications (automobiles, appliances)
- Projects with fixed budgets, timelines, and deliverables
Iterative Development in Agile
Benefits of Iterative Development
- Allows for regular feedback and continuous improvement
- Each iteration includes a review and retrospective to identify areas for improvement
- Changes can be made to the product, process, or priorities based on feedback
- Enables faster delivery of value to the customer
- Working software is delivered at the end of each iteration
- Customers can start using and benefiting from the product earlier in the project lifecycle
- Helps manage risk and uncertainty
- Issues and challenges are identified and addressed early in the project
- Scope can be adjusted based on feedback and changing priorities
- Reduces the risk of delivering a product that doesn't meet customer needs
Iteration Planning and Execution
- Each iteration starts with a planning session
- Team selects user stories or features to be developed during the iteration
- Tasks are identified, estimated, and assigned to team members
- Development, testing, and review activities are conducted during the iteration
- Team collaborates closely to complete the planned work
- meetings are held to share progress, identify issues, and plan next steps
- Iteration ends with a demo and retrospective
- Working software is demonstrated to stakeholders and feedback is gathered
- Team reflects on what went well, what could be improved, and makes adjustments for the next iteration
Prioritizing Software over Documentation
Agile Manifesto Principle
- The Agile Manifesto states that working software is more valuable than comprehensive documentation
- Principle 2: "Working software over comprehensive documentation"
- Emphasis is on delivering a product that meets the customer's needs, rather than creating detailed documentation
- Documentation is still important in Agile projects, but is created as needed
- Just enough documentation to support the development process and maintain a shared understanding
- Documentation may include user stories, acceptance criteria, wireframes, or technical specifications
- Agile teams focus on face-to-face communication and collaboration
- Regular meetings, demos, and feedback sessions help ensure everyone is aligned
- Documentation is used to supplement and reinforce communication, not replace it
Benefits of Prioritizing Working Software
- Faster feedback and adaptation
- Customers can provide feedback on working software earlier in the project lifecycle
- Changes and improvements can be made based on real-world usage and feedback
- Increased customer satisfaction
- Customers see progress and value being delivered regularly
- Product is more likely to meet the customer's needs and expectations
- Reduced waste and rework
- Less time and effort is spent on creating and maintaining detailed documentation
- Changes to requirements or design can be incorporated more easily without extensive rework of documentation
- Earlier return on investment
- Working software can be released to customers sooner, generating revenue or benefits earlier in the project lifecycle
- allows for a faster realization of project value
Key Terms to Review (18)
Burn-down chart: A burn-down chart is a visual tool used in Agile project management to track the amount of work remaining in a project over time, typically displayed in a graph format. It helps teams monitor their progress toward completing work within a sprint or project and provides insights into whether they are on track to meet deadlines.
Continuous Improvement: Continuous improvement is an ongoing effort to enhance products, services, or processes through incremental and breakthrough improvements. This concept is essential in various methodologies to foster a culture of learning and adaptability, enabling teams to respond to changes effectively and efficiently.
Customer collaboration: Customer collaboration is a key principle in Agile methodologies that emphasizes working closely with customers and stakeholders throughout the project to gather feedback, understand needs, and ensure that the delivered product meets their expectations. This ongoing partnership is essential for creating value and fostering adaptability in response to changing requirements.
Daily Stand-Up: A daily stand-up is a short, time-boxed meeting held by Agile teams, usually lasting around 15 minutes, where team members share updates on their progress, discuss challenges, and plan their work for the day. This practice fosters communication and accountability within the team, allowing for quick identification of obstacles and alignment on tasks.
Incremental delivery: Incremental delivery is a project management approach where the product is developed and delivered in small, manageable segments or increments, allowing teams to build on previous work while gathering feedback throughout the process. This method contrasts with traditional project management, where a complete product is delivered only at the end of the project. By implementing incremental delivery, teams can adapt to changes more easily and ensure that the final product aligns closely with user needs and expectations.
Individuals and Interactions: Individuals and interactions emphasize the importance of people and their collaboration in the Agile framework over strict processes and tools. This principle highlights that successful project outcomes are driven by effective communication, teamwork, and relationships among team members rather than rigid methodologies, allowing for greater adaptability and responsiveness to change.
Kanban: Kanban is a visual workflow management method that helps teams visualize their work, limit work in progress, and maximize efficiency. It encourages a continuous flow of work by using a Kanban board to display tasks, allowing teams to manage and optimize their processes effectively.
PRINCE2: PRINCE2, which stands for PRojects IN Controlled Environments, is a structured project management methodology that provides a clear framework for managing projects efficiently. It emphasizes organization, control, and accountability throughout the project lifecycle, allowing for better project planning and execution. PRINCE2 is highly regarded for its adaptability to various project types and its focus on delivering successful outcomes, making it an essential reference in the conversation of project management approaches.
Product Owner: The Product Owner is a key role in Agile project management, specifically within the Scrum framework, responsible for maximizing the value of the product resulting from the work of the development team. This role acts as a bridge between stakeholders and the development team, ensuring that the product backlog is prioritized and that user stories reflect the needs and expectations of users and stakeholders.
Responding to Change: Responding to change refers to the ability of a project team to adapt and adjust their plans, processes, and deliverables in reaction to evolving circumstances, requirements, or feedback. This flexibility is a core principle of Agile methodologies, allowing teams to embrace uncertainty and capitalize on new opportunities throughout the project lifecycle.
Rigidity: Rigidity refers to the inflexibility or strict adherence to predetermined plans and processes, often leading to an inability to adapt to changing circumstances. In project management, rigidity can hinder responsiveness to client needs and market dynamics, emphasizing the contrast between traditional methods and more adaptive approaches like Agile.
Scope creep: Scope creep refers to the gradual expansion of a project's objectives, requirements, or deliverables beyond the original plan, often without proper control or approval. This phenomenon can lead to project delays, budget overruns, and team frustration, as it challenges the balance between project goals and resources.
Scrum: Scrum is an Agile framework used for managing and completing complex projects, emphasizing iterative progress, teamwork, and accountability. This approach divides work into small, manageable increments called sprints, enabling teams to adapt quickly to changes and continuously improve their processes.
Scrum Master: A Scrum Master is a facilitator and servant leader for a Scrum team, responsible for ensuring that the team adheres to Agile practices and principles while helping to remove any obstacles that may impede progress. This role is crucial in fostering an environment of collaboration, accountability, and continuous improvement within the team.
Sprint Planning: Sprint Planning is a collaborative meeting in Agile methodologies, specifically within the Scrum framework, where the team defines the work to be accomplished during the upcoming sprint. This meeting sets the stage for the sprint by prioritizing tasks and ensuring that the entire team understands the sprint goal, connecting to principles of iterative development and flexibility.
Velocity: Velocity is a key metric in Agile project management that measures the amount of work a team completes in a given iteration, typically expressed in story points. This measurement allows teams to gauge their productivity and predict future performance, making it an essential tool for planning and improving efficiency in Agile practices.
Waterfall: Waterfall is a traditional project management methodology characterized by a linear and sequential approach, where each phase must be completed before moving on to the next. This method is structured and systematic, often relying on extensive documentation and planning upfront, which contrasts sharply with more flexible approaches like Agile. Waterfall is best suited for projects with clearly defined requirements and minimal expected changes throughout the development process.
Working Software: Working software refers to software that is fully developed, functional, and ready for use by end-users. It is a core principle of Agile methodologies, emphasizing that the primary measure of progress is the delivery of functional software rather than comprehensive documentation or extensive planning. The focus on working software facilitates iterative development and frequent feedback, allowing teams to adapt quickly to changing requirements.