emerged in the 6th century BCE, marking a shift from mythological explanations to rational inquiry. This new approach sought to understand the world and human existence through logical reasoning, laying the foundation for Western philosophical thought.

Key figures like , , and shaped core ideas that continue to influence modern philosophy. Their work on ethics, metaphysics, and logic established enduring concepts and methods of inquiry that remain central to philosophical debates today.

Origins of Greek philosophy

  • Greek philosophy emerged in the 6th century BCE as a systematic approach to understanding the world and human existence
  • Marked a shift from mythological explanations to rational inquiry and logical reasoning about nature and reality
  • Laid the foundation for Western philosophical thought and scientific methodology

Pre-Socratic thinkers

Top images from around the web for Pre-Socratic thinkers
Top images from around the web for Pre-Socratic thinkers
  • proposed water as the fundamental substance of all matter
  • introduced the concept of the apeiron, an infinite and boundless substance
  • emphasized constant change and flux in the universe, famously stating "No man ever steps in the same river twice"
  • argued for the unchanging nature of reality, influencing later metaphysical thought
  • developed the atomic theory, positing that all matter consists of indivisible particles

Influence of mythology

  • Greek myths provided a framework for early philosophical questions about the nature of the world
  • Philosophers reinterpreted mythological concepts to explain natural phenomena
  • Allegorical interpretations of myths became a tool for philosophical discourse
  • Mythological figures like Prometheus inspired philosophical reflections on human knowledge and progress
  • The transition from mythos to logos marked the birth of rational inquiry in Greek thought

Major Greek philosophers

  • These thinkers shaped the core of Greek philosophy and influenced Western thought for centuries
  • Their ideas continue to be studied and debated in modern philosophy and other academic disciplines

Socrates and Socratic method

  • Socrates focused on ethical questions and the pursuit of wisdom through dialogue
  • Developed the , a form of cooperative argumentative dialogue between individuals
  • Emphasized the importance of self-knowledge, famously stating "Know thyself"
  • Challenged conventional wisdom and encouraged critical thinking
  • Socratic irony involved Socrates pretending ignorance to expose the weaknesses in others' arguments
  • His teachings were primarily recorded by his students, notably Plato, as Socrates himself wrote nothing

Plato's theory of forms

  • Proposed the existence of abstract, perfect forms separate from the physical world
  • Argued that the material world is an imperfect reflection of these ideal forms
  • Used the to illustrate the difference between appearance and reality
  • Divided reality into the visible world (perceived by senses) and the intelligible world (grasped by reason)
  • Influenced later philosophical and religious thought, including Christian theology

Aristotle's ethics and logic

  • Developed , focusing on the cultivation of moral character
  • Introduced the concept of the , the desirable middle between two extremes
  • Formulated the system of formal logic, including syllogisms and the law of non-contradiction
  • Categorized knowledge into theoretical, practical, and productive sciences
  • Emphasized and classification in natural sciences
  • His works covered a wide range of subjects, from metaphysics to politics and biology

Schools of Greek thought

  • Various philosophical schools emerged in ancient Greece, each with distinct approaches to understanding reality and ethics
  • These schools influenced later philosophical traditions and continue to shape modern thought

Stoicism vs Epicureanism

  • emphasized living in accordance with reason and virtue
    • Promoted emotional self-control and acceptance of fate
    • Key figures included Zeno of Citium, Seneca, and Marcus Aurelius
  • focused on achieving happiness through simple pleasures and freedom from fear
    • Advocated for atomic materialism and rejected divine intervention
    • Founded by Epicurus, who taught in his garden school in Athens
  • Both schools addressed the nature of happiness and the good life, but with different approaches
  • Stoicism influenced Roman thought and later Christian philosophy
  • Epicureanism contributed to the development of scientific materialism

Cynicism and Skepticism

  • rejected societal conventions and material possessions
    • Diogenes of Sinope lived in a barrel to demonstrate his rejection of luxury
    • Emphasized living in accordance with nature and virtue
  • questioned the possibility of certain knowledge
    • Pyrrhonism, founded by Pyrrho, advocated for suspending judgment on all beliefs
    • Academic Skepticism, associated with Plato's Academy, challenged dogmatic assertions
  • Both schools influenced later philosophical movements and critical thinking
  • Cynicism inspired ascetic practices in various religious traditions
  • Skepticism contributed to the development of epistemology and scientific inquiry

Key philosophical concepts

  • These fundamental ideas formed the core of Greek philosophical inquiry
  • They continue to be central to philosophical debates in the modern era

Virtue and morality

  • (excellence or virtue) was a central concept in Greek ethics
  • (flourishing or well-being) was considered the highest good
  • The four cardinal virtues (wisdom, justice, courage, and temperance) were widely discussed
  • Philosophers debated whether virtue could be taught or was innate
  • Ethical theories ranged from Aristotle's virtue ethics to the Cynic rejection of social norms

Nature of reality

  • explored the fundamental nature of being and existence
  • Debates centered on (reality as a single substance) vs (multiple fundamental substances)
  • Philosophers questioned the relationship between appearance and reality
  • The problem of change and permanence was a central issue (Heraclitus vs Parmenides)
  • Concepts of time, space, and causality were explored in relation to the nature of reality

Knowledge and epistemology

  • Philosophers debated the sources and limits of human knowledge
  • Plato's theory of recollection suggested that all learning is remembering innate ideas
  • Aristotle emphasized empirical observation and logical reasoning
  • Skeptics questioned the possibility of certain knowledge
  • The distinction between (opinion) and (knowledge) was a key focus
  • Methods of inquiry included , observation, and logical analysis

Greek philosophy in literature

  • Philosophical ideas were often expressed and explored through various literary forms
  • Literature served as a vehicle for disseminating and debating philosophical concepts

Philosophical dialogues

  • (, ) dramatized philosophical discussions
  • Dialogues allowed for the exploration of multiple viewpoints on complex issues
  • Characters in dialogues often represented historical figures or philosophical positions
  • The dialogue form influenced later philosophical writing and literary traditions
  • Xenophon's Memorabilia presented Socratic conversations in a more straightforward style

Tragedy and philosophy

  • Greek tragedies explored philosophical themes of fate, free will, and moral responsibility
  • raised questions about knowledge, self-awareness, and destiny
  • Euripides' plays often challenged traditional religious and moral assumptions
  • analyzed tragedy as a form of catharsis and moral education
  • The chorus in Greek tragedies often voiced philosophical reflections on the action

Legacy of Greek philosophy

  • Greek philosophical ideas have had a profound and lasting impact on Western thought
  • Many modern philosophical debates can be traced back to questions raised by ancient Greek thinkers

Influence on Western thought

  • Greek logic and rational inquiry formed the basis of Western scientific method
  • Platonic and Aristotelian concepts shaped medieval Christian and Islamic philosophy
  • The Renaissance saw a revival of interest in Greek philosophical texts
  • Enlightenment thinkers drew inspiration from ancient Greek ideas of reason and democracy
  • Modern fields such as psychology and political science have roots in Greek philosophical inquiries

Neo-Platonism

  • Developed by Plotinus in the 3rd century CE as a synthesis of Platonic thought
  • Emphasized the concept of "" as the source of all existence
  • Introduced a hierarchical view of reality, from the material world to the divine
  • Influenced early Christian theology and medieval mysticism
  • Played a significant role in the development of Renaissance philosophy and art
  • Key figures included Porphyry, Iamblichus, and Proclus

Philosophical debates

  • Greek philosophers engaged in ongoing debates about fundamental questions of existence and knowledge
  • These debates laid the groundwork for many enduring philosophical problems

Free will vs determinism

  • Questioned whether human actions are freely chosen or predetermined
  • Epicureans proposed the concept of atomic swerve to allow for free will in a materialist universe
  • Stoics reconciled determinism with moral responsibility through the concept of assent
  • The debate influenced later discussions on moral responsibility and human nature
  • Aristotle's concept of voluntary action contributed to the discourse on free will

Materialism vs idealism

  • Materialists (Democritus) argued that reality consists only of physical matter
  • Idealists (Plato) proposed the existence of non-physical, abstract forms or ideas
  • The debate centered on the nature of reality and the relationship between mind and matter
  • Aristotle's hylomorphism attempted to bridge the gap between materialism and idealism
  • This philosophical divide continues to influence modern debates in metaphysics and philosophy of mind

Methods of Greek philosophy

  • Greek philosophers developed various approaches to inquiry and argumentation
  • These methods laid the foundation for later philosophical and scientific methodologies

Dialectic reasoning

  • Involved the exchange of logical arguments to arrive at truth
  • Plato's dialogues exemplified the dialectic method in action
  • Aimed to expose contradictions in arguments and refine ideas
  • Hegel later developed dialectic into a comprehensive philosophical system
  • The method influenced the development of critical thinking and debate techniques

Logical argumentation

  • Aristotle formalized logic with his system of syllogisms
  • Developed rules for valid inference and identification of fallacies
  • Introduced the concept of categorical propositions and logical quantifiers
  • Laid the groundwork for formal logic and mathematical reasoning
  • Influenced the development of scientific method and rational inquiry

Greek philosophy and society

  • Philosophy played a significant role in ancient Greek culture and education
  • Philosophers often engaged with political and social issues of their time

Role of the philosopher

  • Philosophers were seen as seekers of wisdom and truth
  • Some, like Socrates, challenged societal norms and faced persecution
  • Plato's concept of the philosopher-king in the Republic proposed ideal political leadership
  • Cynics like Diogenes deliberately flouted social conventions to make philosophical points
  • Aristotle tutored Alexander the Great, influencing political thought and practice

Philosophy in education

  • Plato's Academy and Aristotle's Lyceum were influential educational institutions
  • The trivium (grammar, logic, and rhetoric) formed the basis of classical education
  • Philosophical training was considered essential for developing critical thinking skills
  • The Socratic method became a model for educational dialogue and inquiry
  • Philosophical schools competed to attract students and patrons in ancient Athens

Critiques of Greek philosophy

  • Greek philosophy faced challenges and criticisms both in ancient times and in later periods
  • These critiques helped refine philosophical arguments and led to new developments in thought

Sophists and relativism

  • Sophists challenged absolute truth claims and emphasized the role of rhetoric
  • Protagoras famously stated "Man is the measure of all things," suggesting moral relativism
  • Gorgias argued for the impossibility of certain knowledge
  • Sophists were criticized by Plato and others for prioritizing persuasion over truth
  • Their ideas influenced later developments in rhetoric, linguistics, and skepticism

Limitations of ancient thought

  • Greek philosophy was often limited by the scientific knowledge of the time
  • Some ideas, like Aristotle's physics, were later disproven by scientific discoveries
  • The focus on abstract reasoning sometimes neglected empirical observation
  • Greek philosophy was largely centered on Mediterranean culture, lacking global perspective
  • Later thinkers critiqued the exclusion of women and slaves from philosophical discourse

Key Terms to Review (40)

Allegory of the Cave: The Allegory of the Cave is a philosophical metaphor found in Plato's work 'The Republic', illustrating the difference between the world of appearances and the world of reality. In this allegory, prisoners are chained inside a dark cave, only able to see shadows cast on the wall by objects behind them, representing how most people live in ignorance, mistaking illusion for reality. This concept highlights essential ideas about knowledge, enlightenment, and the philosopher's role in society.
Anaximander: Anaximander was a pre-Socratic philosopher from Miletus who lived in the 6th century BCE. He is often recognized for his contributions to cosmology, geography, and biology, but is particularly known for introducing the concept of the 'apeiron' or 'infinite' as the source of all things, laying the groundwork for later philosophical thought and science.
Arete: Arete is a Greek term that translates to 'excellence' or 'virtue,' embodying the idea of reaching one's highest potential or the best version of oneself. This concept is central to Greek philosophy, particularly in discussions about ethics, personal development, and the pursuit of a good life. Arete represents not just skill or talent but also moral integrity and the fulfillment of one's purpose in society.
Aristotle: Aristotle was a Greek philosopher and polymath who lived from 384 to 322 BCE, and is often considered one of the greatest thinkers in Western philosophy. His works cover a vast range of subjects, including metaphysics, ethics, politics, logic, and natural sciences, establishing foundational concepts that have influenced countless areas of knowledge throughout history.
Aristotle's Poetics: Aristotle's Poetics is a seminal work that lays the foundations for literary theory and criticism, focusing particularly on tragedy and epic poetry. This text examines the elements of drama, such as plot, character, and emotion, and discusses the purpose of art in evoking catharsis among audiences. Aristotle's insights have profoundly influenced Western literature and aesthetics, linking philosophy with the analysis of artistic expression.
Athenian Golden Age: The Athenian Golden Age refers to a period of exceptional cultural and political achievement in Athens, spanning roughly from 480 to 404 BCE. This era is characterized by remarkable advancements in arts, philosophy, and democracy, as well as the construction of significant architectural masterpieces, such as the Parthenon. The period was marked by the leadership of figures like Pericles and the flourishing of thinkers who laid the groundwork for Western philosophy.
Cynicism: Cynicism is a philosophical doctrine that emerged in ancient Greece, characterized by a deep skepticism toward societal norms, institutions, and the motivations of others. It promotes a way of life that values virtue and self-sufficiency over material wealth and social status, often expressed through provocative or dismissive attitudes toward conventional values. This critical stance not only influenced Greek philosophy but also shaped the landscape of Roman satire, where cynicism served as a tool for critique and social commentary.
Democritus: Democritus was an ancient Greek philosopher known for formulating an early theory of atomism, which proposed that everything in the universe is composed of small, indivisible particles called atoms. His ideas laid the groundwork for later scientific thought, influencing not only philosophy but also the development of modern atomic theory.
Dialectic: Dialectic is a method of argument or discussion that seeks to understand the truth through the exchange of opposing ideas and their reconciliation. It is often used to explore the relationship between thesis and antithesis, leading to a synthesis, which represents a higher level of understanding. This concept is foundational in philosophical discourse and underpins many debates throughout history.
Dialectic reasoning: Dialectic reasoning is a method of argument or discussion that involves the exchange of opposing ideas to arrive at the truth or a deeper understanding of a subject. This approach, often associated with Socratic dialogue, emphasizes the importance of questioning and critically examining different viewpoints to foster intellectual development and uncover underlying assumptions.
Doxa: Doxa refers to the common belief or popular opinion that is widely accepted within a society. In the context of philosophical discussions, especially in ancient Greece, doxa represents a type of knowledge that contrasts with true knowledge or episteme, emphasizing the difference between mere opinion and informed understanding. This distinction is significant as it underscores the value of critical thinking and philosophical inquiry in seeking deeper truths beyond surface-level beliefs.
Empirical Observation: Empirical observation refers to the practice of gathering knowledge through direct experience or sensory evidence rather than through intuition or theoretical speculation. This method is crucial for developing a grounded understanding of the world, allowing individuals to draw conclusions based on observable data. In the context of philosophical thought, particularly in Greek philosophy, empirical observation emerged as a critical tool for inquiry, promoting the idea that knowledge should be based on what can be seen, heard, or measured.
Epicureanism: Epicureanism is a system of philosophy founded by the ancient Greek philosopher Epicurus, which emphasizes the pursuit of happiness through the acquisition of pleasure and the avoidance of pain. Central to this philosophy is the belief that true pleasure is achieved through modest living, the cultivation of friendships, and the pursuit of intellectual contemplation, rather than through indulgence in physical desires. This philosophical framework laid the groundwork for later discussions on ethics and hedonism in both Greek and Roman thought.
Episteme: Episteme is a Greek term that refers to knowledge or understanding, particularly in the context of justified true belief. In Greek philosophy, it contrasts with 'doxa,' which means opinion or belief. This distinction highlights the importance of a solid foundation for knowledge, emphasizing the need for certainty and rational justification in what is considered true knowledge.
Eudaimonia: Eudaimonia is a Greek term often translated as 'flourishing' or 'the good life,' representing a state of human well-being and fulfillment achieved through living virtuously and in accordance with one's true nature. It emphasizes the importance of personal growth, moral virtue, and meaningful engagement with life, connecting closely to concepts of happiness and purpose. This term holds particular significance in both ethical philosophy and the quest for identity and self-discovery.
Free Will vs Determinism: Free will is the philosophical idea that individuals have the capacity to make choices independent of external influences, while determinism posits that every event, including human actions, is determined by preceding events and natural laws. This debate raises questions about moral responsibility, as free will suggests accountability for one’s choices, whereas determinism implies that actions are preordained and beyond personal control. Understanding this concept is essential in analyzing various philosophical arguments about human behavior and ethics.
Golden Mean: The golden mean is a philosophical concept that advocates for moderation and balance in all aspects of life, emphasizing that virtue lies in finding the middle ground between extremes. It is rooted in the belief that excessive behavior, whether in pleasure or avoidance, leads to negative outcomes, while a balanced approach fosters personal well-being and moral character.
Greek Philosophy: Greek philosophy refers to the intellectual tradition originating in ancient Greece, characterized by critical thinking, rational inquiry, and the pursuit of knowledge through reason. This tradition laid the groundwork for Western thought, influencing various fields such as science, ethics, and politics. Key figures, such as Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle, emerged during this period, each contributing unique perspectives and methodologies that shaped philosophical discourse and inquiry.
Hellenistic Period: The Hellenistic Period was a historical phase that followed the conquests of Alexander the Great, spanning from approximately 323 BCE to 30 BCE. This era is characterized by the spread of Greek culture across a vast territory that included parts of Europe, Asia, and Africa, blending it with local traditions and leading to significant developments in mythology and philosophy.
Heraclitus: Heraclitus was a pre-Socratic Greek philosopher known for his doctrine of change being central to the universe, famously asserting that 'you cannot step into the same river twice.' He emphasized the idea that everything is in constant flux and that opposites are necessary for harmony. His thought represents a foundational shift in early Greek philosophy, moving away from static views of existence.
Logical argumentation: Logical argumentation is the process of using reasoning and structured evidence to persuade or support a claim or viewpoint. It involves constructing a coherent argument with premises that lead to a conclusion, often analyzed through formal logic and critical thinking. This method emphasizes clarity, consistency, and the use of valid reasoning to evaluate claims and their validity.
Materialism vs Idealism: Materialism is the philosophical viewpoint that emphasizes the physical and tangible aspects of reality, asserting that matter is the primary substance of nature. In contrast, idealism posits that ideas, consciousness, and mental phenomena are fundamental, suggesting that reality is shaped by the mind rather than the material world. These two perspectives are crucial in understanding ancient Greek philosophy as they reflect different approaches to knowledge, existence, and the nature of reality itself.
Monism: Monism is the philosophical concept that posits a single, unified reality or substance that underlies and connects all existence. This idea suggests that everything in the universe is interconnected and part of a singular essence, contrasting with dualistic views that separate mind and body or spirit and matter. Monism often explores the relationship between consciousness and the physical world, emphasizing that they are not distinct entities but rather aspects of the same reality.
Neo-platonism: Neo-platonism is a philosophical system that emerged in the 3rd century AD, rooted in the teachings of Plato and later expanded by philosophers like Plotinus. This school of thought emphasizes the existence of a single, transcendent source of reality known as 'the One' and posits a hierarchy of being that includes the intellect and the material world. Neo-platonism has significantly influenced various intellectual traditions, particularly during the Renaissance, where it shaped artistic expression and spiritual thought.
Ontology: Ontology is the philosophical study of the nature of being, existence, and reality. It seeks to answer questions about what entities exist and how they can be categorized and related within a hierarchy of being. In Greek philosophy, ontology explores the fundamental nature of reality, examining concepts such as substance, essence, and the relationship between mind and matter.
Parmenides: Parmenides was a pre-Socratic Greek philosopher known for his influential ideas about being and existence, particularly articulated in his poem 'On Nature.' He is often credited with laying the groundwork for metaphysics by arguing that reality is unchanging and that change and multiplicity are illusions. His work contrasts sharply with other philosophical perspectives that emphasize the importance of sensory experience.
Plato: Plato was an ancient Greek philosopher, a student of Socrates, and the teacher of Aristotle, known for his foundational contributions to Western philosophy. His works explored various topics, including ethics, politics, metaphysics, and epistemology, making him a central figure in Greek philosophy. His ideas laid the groundwork for many philosophical discussions that followed and introduced significant concepts like ideal forms and the theory of knowledge.
Plato's Dialogues: Plato's Dialogues are a series of written works in which the philosopher Plato explores various philosophical concepts through conversations, primarily featuring Socrates as a central character. These dialogues serve as a critical medium for philosophical discourse, allowing Plato to discuss ideas about ethics, politics, knowledge, and the nature of reality in an engaging and dynamic format. They reflect the Socratic method, emphasizing questioning and dialogue as a way to stimulate critical thinking and illuminate complex topics.
Pluralism: Pluralism is the recognition and acceptance of diversity within a given setting, emphasizing the coexistence of various perspectives, beliefs, and values. In philosophical discussions, it often relates to the idea that multiple viewpoints can contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of truth and knowledge, rather than adhering to a singular perspective. This concept highlights the importance of dialogue and tolerance among differing ideologies, fostering a richer intellectual environment.
Republic: A republic is a form of government in which power resides with the people and their elected representatives, rather than a monarch. This political structure emphasizes the rule of law and typically features a system of checks and balances to prevent any one branch of government from becoming too powerful. In ancient Greece, the concept of a republic began to take shape, influencing later political thought and systems.
Skepticism: Skepticism is a philosophical approach that questions the validity of knowledge claims and encourages critical examination of beliefs and assumptions. It emphasizes doubt and inquiry, urging individuals to consider evidence before accepting any assertion as true. This outlook was foundational in shaping both Greek and Roman philosophies, as it encouraged a departure from dogmatism and the development of rational thought.
Socrates: Socrates was a classical Greek philosopher credited as one of the founders of Western philosophy and known for his contributions to ethics and epistemology. He is most famous for his method of questioning, which aimed to stimulate critical thinking and illuminate ideas, emphasizing the importance of self-awareness and virtue in human life.
Socratic Method: The Socratic Method is a form of cooperative argumentative dialogue that uses questioning to stimulate critical thinking and illuminate ideas. This method encourages participants to explore complex concepts by asking and answering questions, ultimately leading them to discover their own beliefs and assumptions. It emphasizes the importance of self-reflection and dialogue in the pursuit of knowledge, making it particularly relevant in discussions about personal identity and self-discovery.
Sophocles' Oedipus Rex: Oedipus Rex, also known as Oedipus the King, is a tragedy written by the ancient Greek playwright Sophocles, which tells the story of King Oedipus's quest to rid Thebes of a plague while unknowingly fulfilling a prophecy that foretells his own downfall. This play exemplifies key themes such as fate versus free will, the nature of human suffering, and the search for truth, all of which resonate deeply within the realm of Greek philosophy.
Stoicism: Stoicism is an ancient Greek philosophy that teaches the development of self-control and fortitude as a means to overcome destructive emotions. It emphasizes rationality, the importance of virtue, and living in harmony with nature, encouraging individuals to focus on what they can control while accepting what they cannot. This philosophy later evolved and found prominence in Roman thought, blending with ideas of ethics and personal resilience.
Symposium: A symposium is a formal gathering for discussion, often centered around philosophical topics, where participants engage in dialogue, debate, and the sharing of ideas. In ancient Greece, symposia were significant cultural events that combined intellectual discourse with social interaction, showcasing the importance of conversation in shaping philosophical thought.
Thales of Miletus: Thales of Miletus was a pre-Socratic philosopher from ancient Greece, often regarded as the first philosopher in Western history. He is best known for his belief that water is the fundamental substance of the universe and for initiating a rational approach to understanding the natural world, which marked a shift from mythological explanations to philosophical inquiry.
The One: The One is a philosophical concept originating from ancient Greek thought, particularly associated with the ideas of Parmenides and Plato. It refers to the notion of a singular, ultimate reality or principle that unifies all existence, contrasting with the perception of a fragmented world made up of multiple entities. This idea of unity plays a crucial role in discussions about the nature of being, change, and knowledge.
Theory of forms: The theory of forms, proposed by Plato, posits that non-material abstract forms, or ideals, represent the most accurate reality. This philosophy suggests that the material world is just a shadow or reflection of these ideal forms, which exist in a higher realm and can only be understood through philosophical reasoning. This theory is foundational in understanding Plato's ideas on knowledge, reality, and existence, as it asserts a dualistic view of the world where the physical and the ideal are distinct yet interconnected.
Virtue ethics: Virtue ethics is an ethical theory that emphasizes the role of an individual's character and virtues in determining moral behavior, rather than focusing solely on rules or consequences. This approach encourages individuals to develop good character traits, or virtues, that enable them to live a fulfilling and moral life. Virtue ethics connects deeply with concepts of human flourishing and the pursuit of a good life, playing a significant role in philosophical discussions about morality and the nature of good versus evil.
© 2024 Fiveable Inc. All rights reserved.
AP® and SAT® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse this website.