6.2 Challenges Faced by Third Parties
2 min read•july 25, 2024
Third parties face steep challenges in the US political system. From electoral rules favoring two dominant parties to limited resources and media coverage, these obstacles make it hard for alternative voices to gain traction.
Voter psychology also plays a role. Many fear "wasting" their vote on a third party, while others use it as a protest. The entrenched two-party system further cements this dynamic, absorbing popular third-party ideas to maintain dominance.
Institutional and Systemic Challenges
Barriers to third-party success
Top images from around the web for Barriers to third-party success
The Presidential Election Process – American Government (2e) View original
Is this image relevant?
Political Participation: Campaigns and the Voting Process | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
Political Participation: How do we select and elect a president? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
The Presidential Election Process – American Government (2e) View original
Is this image relevant?
Political Participation: Campaigns and the Voting Process | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Barriers to third-party success
The Presidential Election Process – American Government (2e) View original
Is this image relevant?
Political Participation: Campaigns and the Voting Process | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
Political Participation: How do we select and elect a president? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
The Presidential Election Process – American Government (2e) View original
Is this image relevant?
Political Participation: Campaigns and the Voting Process | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Electoral College system winner-take-all allocation in most states favors two dominant parties (California, Texas)
- voting encourages strategic voting and discourages support for third-party candidates
- requirements vary by state often more stringent for third parties (signature thresholds, filing deadlines)
- Debate participation thresholds set by Commission on Presidential Debates typically require 15% support in national polls
- Campaign finance regulations tie public funding to previous election performance making it harder for third parties to qualify
Challenges for third-party resources
- Limited fundraising capabilities stem from smaller donor base and less access to large donors and PACs
- Reduced media coverage results in less airtime on major networks and minimal inclusion in political discussions
- Ballot access challenges include high signature requirements short time frames for petition gathering and legal challenges from major parties
- Limited party infrastructure means fewer volunteers and staff and less established grassroots networks
Voter Behavior and Political Landscape
Voter psychology for third parties
- leads voters to fear indirectly helping least-preferred major party candidate
- Lack of viability perception reinforces belief that third-party candidates can't win
- Ideological purity vs pragmatism creates tension between voting principles and electoral strategy
- Protest voting supports third parties to express dissatisfaction with major parties (Ross Perot 1992, Ralph Nader 2000)
- Information scarcity results in less voter familiarity with third-party platforms and candidates
Two-party system vs third parties
- explains tendency of plurality voting systems to favor two dominant parties
- Major party co-optation absorbs popular third-party ideas into major party platforms ( ideas into New Deal)
- blames third parties for major party losses ( in 2000 election)
- perpetuates two-party control of legislative and electoral processes
- frames elections as two-party contests limiting exposure for third-party candidates
- Historical precedent of no successful third-party presidencies reinforces two-party dominance
Key Terms to Review (18)
Ballot access: Ballot access refers to the legal and procedural requirements that political parties and candidates must meet to appear on election ballots. These requirements can vary widely by state and can include petitioning processes, filing fees, and adherence to specific deadlines. The complexities surrounding ballot access can create significant challenges for third parties trying to compete against the established major parties.
Duverger's Law: Duverger's Law states that single-member plurality electoral systems tend to favor a two-party system, while proportional representation systems encourage multiparty systems. This concept highlights how the structure of electoral systems impacts party competition and voter behavior, resulting in significant political polarization and influencing the viability of third parties within the political landscape.
Filibuster: A filibuster is a legislative tactic used in the United States Senate to prolong debate or delay a vote on a bill, often through prolonged speech or other means. This strategy allows minority groups, including those holding conservative or liberal ideologies, to exert influence over legislation, effectively shaping the political landscape. While filibusters are a tool for minority factions to voice their concerns, they can also contribute to significant challenges in passing legislation and exacerbate gridlock within the policymaking process.
First-past-the-post: First-past-the-post is an electoral system where the candidate with the most votes in a single-member district wins, regardless of whether they achieve an absolute majority. This system is simple and straightforward, often leading to a quick resolution of elections. However, it can result in significant disparities between the percentage of votes received by parties and the number of seats they secure, influencing party competition, polarization, and the dynamics of party systems.
Green Party: The Green Party is a political party in the United States that emphasizes environmental issues, social justice, grassroots democracy, and nonviolence. It is part of the global Green movement, advocating for policies that address climate change and promote sustainability, which connects it to various political dynamics and electoral contexts.
Institutional entrenchment: Institutional entrenchment refers to the process through which certain political parties, especially major ones, establish themselves within the political system, making it difficult for new parties to gain traction. This occurs through a combination of existing laws, electoral systems, and established practices that favor those entrenched parties. As these parties become deeply rooted in the political landscape, they often create barriers that challenge the emergence and success of third parties.
Libertarian Party: The Libertarian Party is a political party in the United States that emphasizes individual liberty, limited government, and free-market principles. Founded in 1971, it stands as one of the most significant third parties in American politics, advocating for civil liberties, personal responsibility, and non-interventionist foreign policy. The party's platform raises discussions on the advantages and disadvantages of third parties, their historical significance, the challenges they face, and their impact on electoral outcomes and policy-making.
Majority requirements: Majority requirements refer to the need for a candidate or a party to receive more than half of the votes cast in an election in order to win. This concept is crucial in shaping electoral processes, especially in the context of third parties, as they often struggle to meet this threshold, leading to significant challenges in gaining representation and influence in a political landscape dominated by two major parties.
Media bias: Media bias refers to the perceived or real partiality of journalists and news organizations in the coverage of events and issues, which can shape public perception and opinion. This bias can manifest through selective reporting, framing of news stories, and the choice of which events to cover or ignore, ultimately influencing how different political parties and campaigns are represented in the media.
Partisan Polarization: Partisan polarization refers to the increasing divide between political parties, particularly in terms of ideology, policy preferences, and political behavior. This growing chasm has significant implications for governance, electoral dynamics, and the overall functioning of democracy, as it often leads to gridlock and diminishes the possibility of bipartisan cooperation.
Party Platform: A party platform is a formal set of principles and goals that a political party advocates for during elections and throughout its governance. It outlines the party's stance on various issues and serves as a guiding document for party members, influencing their positions and actions in the political arena.
Perception of legitimacy: Perception of legitimacy refers to the belief held by the public that a government or political system has the right to rule and is deserving of authority. This concept is crucial in understanding how various political entities, including third parties, gain or lose support based on how legitimate they are perceived to be by voters. The perception of legitimacy can significantly impact a party's ability to compete effectively in elections, as people are more likely to support parties they see as credible and trustworthy.
Progressive Party: The Progressive Party was a political movement that emerged in the early 20th century, primarily during the Progressive Era, advocating for social reforms, government regulation of the economy, and increased democracy. It played a key role in challenging the established two-party system, often focusing on issues like workers' rights, women's suffrage, and political corruption.
Reform Party: The Reform Party is a political party in the United States that was founded in the early 1990s, primarily focused on promoting government accountability, political reform, and fiscal responsibility. It emerged as a response to disillusionment with the existing two-party system and aimed to attract voters seeking alternatives to traditional parties. This party has played a notable role in highlighting the significance of third parties in American politics, as well as facing unique challenges in establishing itself and maintaining relevance.
Spoiler effect: The spoiler effect occurs when a third-party candidate runs in an election and draws votes away from a major party candidate, ultimately altering the outcome of the election. This phenomenon can lead to situations where the presence of the third-party candidate causes a major party to lose, even if that party might have won had the third-party candidate not participated. It highlights the complexities and challenges that third parties face in a predominantly two-party system, impacting electoral dynamics and voter behavior.
Vote-splitting: Vote-splitting occurs when multiple candidates or parties compete for the same voter base, leading to a division of votes that can prevent a candidate from winning an election. This phenomenon is particularly relevant for third parties, as their presence in an election can siphon off votes from major party candidates, increasing the chances of a less popular candidate winning. It highlights the strategic complexities of elections, where the presence of multiple similar candidates can undermine the overall effectiveness of voter support.
Wasted vote syndrome: Wasted vote syndrome refers to the phenomenon where voters feel their votes are ineffective because they believe their preferred candidate has little chance of winning. This perception often leads individuals to either abstain from voting or choose a less preferred but more viable candidate, particularly in systems dominated by two major parties. As a result, third-party candidates struggle to gain traction and recognition, exacerbating the challenges faced by these alternative political movements.
Winner-takes-all system: A winner-takes-all system is an electoral system in which the candidate who receives the most votes in a constituency wins the election, and all other candidates receive no representation. This system often leads to a two-party dominance, making it difficult for third parties to gain traction or influence. As a result, the dynamics of political competition are heavily skewed, contributing to both the historical significance and the ongoing challenges faced by third parties in the political landscape.