1.3 Sources of Trademark Law: Lanham Act and Common Law
3 min read•july 25, 2024
U.S. law stems from multiple sources, including the , common law, state statutes, and international treaties. These sources work together to create a comprehensive system of trademark protection, balancing federal and state interests.
The Lanham Act provides strong federal protection through registration, while common law rights arise from use. Each system has advantages and limitations, with federal registration offering broader protection but common law providing immediate, localized rights without formalities.
Federal and Common Law Sources of Trademark Protection
Sources of US trademark law
Top images from around the web for Sources of US trademark law
Trademark Law - Free of Charge Creative Commons Legal Engraved image View original
Is this image relevant?
Sources of American Law – Open Textbook View original
Is this image relevant?
Trademark Law - Free of Charge Creative Commons Legal Engraved image View original
Is this image relevant?
Sources of American Law – Open Textbook View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 2
Top images from around the web for Sources of US trademark law
Trademark Law - Free of Charge Creative Commons Legal Engraved image View original
Is this image relevant?
Sources of American Law – Open Textbook View original
Is this image relevant?
Trademark Law - Free of Charge Creative Commons Legal Engraved image View original
Is this image relevant?
Sources of American Law – Open Textbook View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 2
- Lanham Act (Trademark Act of 1946) serves as primary federal statute governing trademarks, service marks, and unfair competition codified in 15 U.S.C. §§ 1051 et seq
- Common law developed through court decisions and precedents varies by state (California, New York)
- State trademark statutes complement federal law and common law ()
- International treaties shape global trademark protection (, )
Provisions of Lanham Act
- Registration of trademarks on provides stronger protection and for descriptive marks
- Protects various types of marks including trademarks (Nike swoosh), service marks (McDonald's golden arches), certification marks (USDA Organic), and collective marks (CPA for accountants)
- Establishes causes of action for , , , and
- Provides remedies such as , , and in exceptional cases
- Recognizes defenses including (nominative, descriptive), , and
- Grants initial protection term of 10 years, renewable indefinitely with proper use and maintenance
Common law in trademark rights
- Establishes rights through use based on first-to-use principle without requiring registration
- Limits geographic scope of protection to areas of actual use or reputation
- Provides state-specific protections through anti-dilution statutes and unfair competition laws
- Expands protectable subject matter to include (Coca-Cola bottle shape) and
- Develops new doctrines such as and
- Influences interpretation and application of Lanham Act provisions leading to circuit splits on various issues
Federal registration vs common law
- Federal registration advantages:
- Grants nationwide constructive notice of trademark rights
- Provides prima facie evidence of validity in legal proceedings
- Allows for incontestability after five years of continuous use
- Secures federal court jurisdiction for trademark disputes
- Permits use of ® symbol
- Serves as basis for foreign registrations
- Federal registration limitations:
- Involves costs for obtaining and maintaining registration
- Subjects mark to potential cancellation or opposition proceedings
- Common law protection advantages:
- Offers immediate protection upon use without registration
- Eliminates registration fees and maintenance requirements
- Protects marks that may not qualify for federal registration (local business names)
- Common law protection limitations:
- Restricts geographic scope of protection
- Places burden of proving ownership and validity on trademark owner
- Excludes access to certain statutory damages or remedies
- Concurrent use considerations address conflicts between federal registrants and common law users, including junior users in remote geographic areas
Key Terms to Review (29)
Abandonment: Abandonment in trademark law refers to the loss of rights to a trademark due to non-use or failure to maintain it, indicating that the owner no longer intends to use the mark in commerce. This concept is essential for understanding how trademark rights can be forfeited, impacting various legal processes and rights associated with trademarks.
Attorney's fees: Attorney's fees refer to the costs associated with legal representation that a party may be required to pay to their attorney for services rendered. These fees can arise in trademark disputes under both the Lanham Act and common law, where prevailing parties may seek reimbursement for legal expenses as part of a court judgment or settlement agreement. The rules governing attorney's fees vary significantly depending on the jurisdiction and the specific legal framework applicable to the trademark case.
Certification Mark: A certification mark is a type of trademark that indicates that a product or service meets certain standards set by the certifying organization. Unlike traditional trademarks that distinguish the source of goods or services, certification marks focus on the quality, material, mode of manufacture, or other characteristics of the goods or services. They play a critical role in providing consumers with assurance regarding the attributes of products, connecting them to broader consumer protection and quality assurance practices.
Collective Mark: A collective mark is a type of trademark used by members of a collective group, association, or organization to identify and distinguish their goods or services from those of non-members. It serves to promote the interests of the group and signifies a specific quality or characteristic associated with the products or services offered by its members.
Cybersquatting: Cybersquatting is the practice of registering, trafficking in, or using a domain name with the intent to profit from the goodwill of a trademark belonging to someone else. This unethical behavior often exploits brand recognition and can lead to confusion among consumers, making it a significant issue in trademark law.
Dilution: Dilution refers to the weakening of a trademark's distinctiveness or uniqueness due to unauthorized use by others, which can lead to confusion among consumers. This concept is vital in maintaining the integrity of well-known trademarks as it ensures that their brand identity remains strong and recognizable in the marketplace, even amidst competing products.
Fair use: Fair use is a legal doctrine that allows limited use of copyrighted material without requiring permission from the rights holders. This concept is crucial in balancing the interests of creators with public access to information, especially in contexts like criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, or research.
False designation of origin: False designation of origin refers to a misleading representation regarding the source or origin of goods or services, which can lead consumers to believe that a product comes from a different source than it actually does. This concept plays a crucial role in trademark law, as it protects both consumers from deception and trademark owners from unfair competition. The Lanham Act provides a legal framework for addressing false designations of origin, allowing affected parties to seek remedies against those who misrepresent their goods or services.
Florida Trademark Act: The Florida Trademark Act is a state law that governs the registration and protection of trademarks within the state of Florida. This act provides a framework for businesses to secure their trademarks at the state level, offering remedies and procedures for trademark disputes that may not be covered by federal law under the Lanham Act.
Genericness: Genericness refers to the status of a trademark when it becomes widely used by the public to describe a general class of goods or services rather than identifying a specific source. When a term is deemed generic, it loses its trademark protection, making it available for anyone to use. This concept is crucial in understanding the boundaries of trademark rights and the process of maintaining distinctiveness.
Initial interest confusion: Initial interest confusion refers to a situation where a consumer is misled into believing that a product or service is associated with or endorsed by a trademark owner, even if the confusion is resolved before a purchase is made. This type of confusion can occur in various contexts, such as misleading domain names, online marketplaces, and the application of trademark law, which collectively highlight the importance of protecting consumers from deceptive practices.
Injunctive Relief: Injunctive relief is a legal remedy that requires a party to do or refrain from doing a specific act, often used in trademark law to prevent ongoing or imminent harm from trademark infringement or dilution. This type of relief is crucial in stopping unlawful activities quickly, especially when monetary damages would be insufficient to remedy the harm caused by trademark violations.
Lanham Act: The Lanham Act is a federal statute enacted in 1946 that governs trademarks, service marks, and unfair competition in the United States. It provides a comprehensive legal framework for the registration, protection, and enforcement of trademarks, ensuring consumers can identify the source of goods and services while allowing businesses to safeguard their brand identity.
Likelihood of Confusion: Likelihood of confusion is a legal standard used to determine whether consumers might mistakenly believe that goods or services come from the same source due to similar trademarks. This concept is central in trademark law, as it influences decisions on registration, infringement claims, and overall brand protection.
Monetary damages: Monetary damages refer to the financial compensation awarded to a plaintiff in a legal case, intended to compensate for losses incurred due to wrongful acts such as trademark infringement or dilution. This form of remedy is crucial in trademark law as it helps restore the financial position of the injured party and serves as a deterrent against future infringements.
Paris Convention: The Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property is an international treaty that was first established in 1883 to provide a framework for protecting industrial property, including trademarks. It promotes cooperation among member countries to ensure that trademark rights are recognized and protected across borders, setting important standards for trademark registration and enforcement internationally.
Post-sale confusion: Post-sale confusion refers to the phenomenon where consumers mistakenly believe that a product is associated with or endorsed by a trademark owner after they have purchased the product. This type of confusion occurs not just at the point of sale, but also during the product's use, leading to potential harm to the trademark owner’s brand reputation and value. The concept is significant in understanding trademark rights as it can extend liability for infringement beyond the immediate sale context, highlighting the importance of protecting consumer perception.
Principal Register: The Principal Register is the primary register for trademarks maintained by the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO), providing a higher level of legal protection for marks that are distinctive and used in commerce. Registration on this list grants trademark owners significant advantages, such as nationwide priority, presumptive evidence of ownership, and the right to use the federal registration symbol ®. This register is crucial for establishing acquired distinctiveness and secondary meaning in the context of trademark law.
Product Configurations: Product configurations refer to the distinctive shapes, designs, and overall appearance of a product that help consumers recognize and differentiate it from others. These configurations can be vital in establishing brand identity and can be protected under trademark law to prevent consumer confusion. Such protections ensure that competitors cannot mimic the unique aspects of a product’s design, which plays a significant role in consumer purchasing decisions and brand loyalty.
Renewal: Renewal in trademark law refers to the process of extending the protection of a trademark after its initial registration period has expired. This process is crucial for maintaining exclusive rights to use the mark and ensuring ongoing legal protection against infringement. Renewal not only serves to refresh the trademark's registration but also requires that the trademark continues to be used in commerce, reinforcing its significance in the marketplace.
Secondary meaning: Secondary meaning refers to the acquired distinctiveness of a mark that enables it to identify the source of a product or service rather than simply describing the product itself. This concept plays a vital role in trademark law, as it allows certain marks that may not initially qualify for protection to gain legal recognition over time through extensive use and consumer association.
Service Mark: A service mark is a type of trademark that specifically identifies and distinguishes the source of a service rather than a product. This legal protection helps businesses establish their brand in the marketplace, and it plays a crucial role in various legal frameworks and international agreements designed to protect intellectual property rights.
State common law: State common law refers to the body of law developed through judicial decisions and legal precedents established by state courts, as opposed to statutory law enacted by legislative bodies. It plays a significant role in trademark law, particularly in areas not explicitly covered by federal law, allowing courts to interpret and enforce trademark rights based on established principles and local customs.
Supplemental register: The supplemental register is a secondary trademark registration option available through the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) for marks that do not meet the requirements for registration on the principal register. This register allows owners of descriptive or non-distinctive marks to secure some federal protections while they build distinctiveness over time, thereby connecting their brands with their goods or services.
Trade dress: Trade dress refers to the visual appearance and overall image of a product or its packaging that signifies the source of the product to consumers. It encompasses features such as shape, color, design, and layout, playing a significant role in brand identity and consumer recognition.
Trademark: A trademark is a recognizable sign, design, or expression that distinguishes products or services of one entity from those of others. Trademarks serve to protect brand identity and help consumers identify the source of goods, ensuring that they can make informed purchasing decisions. By preventing confusion in the marketplace, trademarks also contribute to fair competition and consumer trust.
Trademark infringement: Trademark infringement occurs when a party uses a trademark that is identical or confusingly similar to a registered trademark owned by another party, without permission. This unauthorized use can lead to consumer confusion regarding the source of goods or services, undermining the trademark's distinctiveness and value.
Trademark Modernization Act: The Trademark Modernization Act is a significant piece of legislation enacted in 2020 aimed at updating and enhancing trademark law in the United States. This Act introduces new measures to streamline the registration process, reduce fraudulent registrations, and address concerns surrounding the protection of trademarks, thereby strengthening the overall trademark system.
TRIPS Agreement: The TRIPS Agreement, or Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights, is a comprehensive international treaty administered by the World Trade Organization (WTO) that establishes minimum standards for the protection and enforcement of intellectual property rights, including trademarks. This agreement connects to historical developments in trademark law and provides a framework for member countries to adhere to consistent protections, facilitating international trade and addressing counterfeiting concerns in online marketplaces.