Keynesian economics emerged in the 1930s as a response to the . It challenged classical economic theories by emphasizing government's role in managing economic cycles and advocating for active intervention to stimulate growth and employment during downturns.
This approach revolutionized macroeconomic thought in the Modern Period. Keynes argued that insufficient leads to unemployment, proposing fiscal and monetary policies to boost spending and stabilize the economy, influencing policy-making worldwide for decades.
Origins of Keynesian economics
Emerged in the early 20th century as a response to economic instability and unemployment
Challenged traditional economic theories by emphasizing the role of government in managing economic cycles
Revolutionized macroeconomic thought during the Modern Period, influencing policy-making worldwide
Historical context
Top images from around the web for Historical context
The Stock Market Crash of 1929 | United States History II: Since 1865 View original
Is this image relevant?
Why It Matters: Keynesian and Neoclassical Economics | Macroeconomics View original
Is this image relevant?
TKAMmilieuWIKI - Stock Market Crash and Great Depression View original
Is this image relevant?
The Stock Market Crash of 1929 | United States History II: Since 1865 View original
Is this image relevant?
Why It Matters: Keynesian and Neoclassical Economics | Macroeconomics View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Historical context
The Stock Market Crash of 1929 | United States History II: Since 1865 View original
Is this image relevant?
Why It Matters: Keynesian and Neoclassical Economics | Macroeconomics View original
Is this image relevant?
TKAMmilieuWIKI - Stock Market Crash and Great Depression View original
Is this image relevant?
The Stock Market Crash of 1929 | United States History II: Since 1865 View original
Is this image relevant?
Why It Matters: Keynesian and Neoclassical Economics | Macroeconomics View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Developed by British economist in the 1930s
Arose from the economic turmoil following World War I and the stock market crash of 1929
Responded to the limitations of classical economic theory in explaining persistent unemployment
Influenced by earlier economists like Thomas Malthus and John Hobson
Great Depression influence
Severe economic downturn of the 1930s exposed flaws in classical economic thinking
Widespread unemployment and deflation contradicted Say's Law (supply creates its own demand)
Keynes argued for active to stimulate economic recovery
Proposed and public works programs to boost aggregate demand
in the United States partially reflected Keynesian ideas
Classical economics vs Keynesianism
Classical economics emphasized free markets and minimal government intervention
Keynesians advocated for active fiscal and monetary policies to manage economic fluctuations
Challenged classical notion of full employment equilibrium in the long run
Introduced the concept of "" as a key driver of economic activity
Shifted focus from microeconomic to macroeconomic analysis of the economy as a whole
Key principles of Keynesianism
Emphasizes the importance of total spending in the economy to determine output and employment
Argues that market economies do not automatically tend towards full employment
Proposes active government policies to stabilize economic fluctuations and promote growth
Aggregate demand focus
Considers total spending (consumption, investment, government expenditure, and net exports) as the primary driver of economic activity
Argues that insufficient aggregate demand leads to unemployment and economic downturns
Proposes stimulating aggregate demand through various policy measures to achieve full employment
Introduces the concept of the "paradox of thrift" where increased saving can reduce overall economic activity
Government intervention role
Advocates for active government involvement in managing the economy
Proposes countercyclical fiscal policies to smooth out economic fluctuations
Supports public investment in infrastructure and social programs to boost employment and growth
Argues for the use of deficit spending during recessions to stimulate economic activity
Emphasizes the importance of (unemployment benefits, progressive taxation)
Multiplier effect concept
Describes how an initial increase in spending leads to a larger overall increase in economic output
Based on the idea that one person's spending becomes another's income, creating a ripple effect
Calculated as Multiplier=1−MPC1 where MPC is the marginal propensity to consume
Suggests that government spending can have a magnified impact on the overall economy
Varies depending on factors such as the marginal propensity to consume and import propensity
Fiscal policy in Keynesianism
Focuses on using government spending and taxation to influence economic conditions
Aims to stabilize the economy by managing aggregate demand during different phases of the business cycle
Plays a central role in Keynesian approach to macroeconomic management
Government spending importance
Viewed as a crucial tool for stimulating economic growth and combating recessions
Includes both direct government purchases and transfer payments to individuals
Advocates for increased spending during economic downturns to boost aggregate demand
Proposes public works projects and infrastructure investments to create jobs and stimulate economic activity
Suggests reducing government spending during periods of high to cool down the economy
Tax policy implications
Considers taxation as a means to influence consumer and business behavior
Advocates for progressive taxation to reduce income inequality and stabilize the economy
Proposes tax cuts during recessions to increase disposable income and boost consumer spending
Suggests raising taxes during periods of high inflation to reduce aggregate demand
Emphasizes the role of automatic stabilizers in tax policy (progressive tax rates, corporate tax structure)
Automatic stabilizers
Economic mechanisms that help counteract fluctuations in the business cycle without requiring explicit government action
Include progressive income tax systems, unemployment insurance, and welfare programs
Increase government spending and reduce tax revenue during economic downturns
Help to maintain aggregate demand during recessions by supporting incomes
Operate in reverse during economic expansions, helping to prevent overheating
Monetary policy perspectives
Considers the role of central banks and money supply in managing economic conditions
Emphasizes the importance of in influencing investment and consumption decisions
Recognizes limitations of monetary policy, especially during severe economic downturns
Interest rates and investment
Views interest rates as a key determinant of business investment and consumer spending
Argues that lower interest rates encourage borrowing and stimulate economic activity
Introduces the concept of the "" where very low interest rates become ineffective
Suggests that monetary policy may be less effective than fiscal policy during deep recessions
Recognizes the potential for crowding out private investment through government borrowing
Liquidity preference theory
Explains the demand for money and its relationship to interest rates
Identifies three motives for holding money (transactions, precautionary, and speculative)
Argues that the speculative demand for money increases as interest rates fall
Introduces the concept of "liquidity preference" as a key factor in determining interest rates
Suggests that monetary policy can influence economic activity by affecting liquidity preferences
Monetary vs fiscal policy
Recognizes both monetary and fiscal policies as important tools for economic management
Argues that fiscal policy may be more effective during severe recessions or liquidity traps
Suggests that monetary policy can be more flexible and quicker to implement than fiscal measures
Emphasizes the potential for coordination between monetary and fiscal authorities
Recognizes potential conflicts between monetary and fiscal objectives ()
Keynesian models and concepts
Developed various analytical frameworks to explain economic relationships and policy effects
Introduced new ways of modeling macroeconomic variables and their interactions
Provided tools for policymakers to analyze and respond to economic fluctuations
IS-LM model
Integrates goods market (IS curve) and money market (LM curve) to determine equilibrium output and interest rates
IS curve represents combinations of interest rates and output levels where investment equals saving
LM curve shows combinations where money demand equals money supply
Used to analyze the effects of monetary and fiscal policies on output and interest rates
Demonstrates potential policy trade-offs and the concept of crowding out
Aggregate demand-aggregate supply
Provides a framework for analyzing macroeconomic equilibrium and policy effects
Aggregate demand (AD) curve shows the relationship between price level and total spending
Aggregate supply (AS) curve represents the relationship between price level and total output
Short-run AS curve is upward-sloping due to sticky prices and wages
Long-run AS curve is vertical, representing potential output level
Used to analyze the impacts of various shocks and policy interventions on output and prices
Sticky prices and wages
Assumes that prices and wages do not adjust immediately to changes in economic conditions
Explains why the economy can deviate from full employment equilibrium in the short run
Attributes wage stickiness to factors such as long-term contracts and efficiency wage theories
Argues that price stickiness results from and imperfect competition
Provides a rationale for the effectiveness of demand-side policies in the short run
Criticisms of Keynesian economics
Faced various challenges and critiques from different schools of economic thought
Led to refinements and adaptations of Keynesian theory over time
Sparked ongoing debates about the role of government in economic management
Monetarist challenges
Led by economists like Milton Friedman, emphasized the importance of money supply
Argued that inflation is primarily a monetary phenomenon, not driven by demand
Criticized the effectiveness of fiscal policy, favoring monetary policy instead
Introduced the concept of the natural rate of unemployment, challenging the
Proposed rules-based monetary policy rather than discretionary interventions
New classical economics critique
Emphasized rational expectations and efficient markets
Argued that systematic government policies would be anticipated and neutralized by economic agents
Introduced the , challenging the use of historical data for policy analysis
Developed , attributing economic fluctuations to supply-side shocks
Questioned the effectiveness of demand management policies in the long run
Public choice theory objections
Applied economic analysis to political decision-making processes
Argued that government intervention may be driven by self-interest rather than public welfare
Introduced concepts like rent-seeking and regulatory capture
Questioned the ability of policymakers to implement optimal economic policies
Highlighted potential inefficiencies and unintended consequences of government interventions
Modern interpretations
Evolved in response to critiques and new economic challenges
Incorporated insights from other schools of thought while maintaining core Keynesian principles
Continued to influence policy debates and economic research in the Modern Period
New Keynesian economics
Developed in response to new classical critiques, incorporating rational expectations
Provides microeconomic foundations for Keynesian macroeconomic models
Emphasizes the role of market imperfections and nominal rigidities in explaining economic fluctuations
Introduces concepts like menu costs, , and
Supports the effectiveness of monetary policy in the short run while recognizing long-run neutrality
Post-Keynesian school
Emphasizes uncertainty, expectations, and the role of money in the economy
Rejects the notion of general equilibrium and emphasizes path dependence
Focuses on issues of income distribution and effective demand
Advocates for financial regulation and control of speculative capital flows
Supports active fiscal policy and skepticism towards monetary policy effectiveness
Keynesianism vs neoliberalism
Represents ongoing debates about the role of government in economic management
Keynesianism advocates for active government intervention to stabilize the economy
emphasizes free markets, deregulation, and limited government intervention
Debates center on issues like privatization, trade liberalization, and fiscal austerity
Influences policy choices in areas such as labor markets, social welfare, and financial regulation
Global impact of Keynesianism
Shaped economic policies and institutions in many countries during the 20th and 21st centuries
Influenced the development of international economic cooperation and governance
Continues to inform debates about global economic challenges and policy responses
Post-war economic policies
Guided reconstruction efforts in Europe and Japan after World War II
Influenced the creation of institutions like the International Monetary Fund and World Bank
Supported the development of welfare states and social safety nets in many countries
Contributed to the "" with high growth and low unemployment in the 1950s and 1960s
Faced challenges in the 1970s with stagflation and the breakdown of the
International monetary system
Influenced the design of the Bretton Woods system of fixed exchange rates
Supported the use of capital controls to maintain monetary policy autonomy
Informed debates about exchange rate regimes and international financial stability
Contributed to the development of theories of optimal currency areas
Continues to influence discussions about global financial architecture and reform
Developing economies applications
Adapted Keynesian ideas to address challenges faced by developing countries
Supported import substitution industrialization strategies in some countries
Influenced debates about the role of the state in promoting economic development
Informed discussions about structural adjustment programs and their alternatives
Contributes to ongoing debates about poverty reduction and sustainable development strategies
Keynesian responses to crises
Provided frameworks for understanding and responding to major economic shocks
Influenced policy responses to various crises in the Modern Period
Continues to evolve in response to new economic challenges and global issues
Great Recession interventions
Inspired large-scale programs in many countries (American Recovery and Reinvestment Act)
Supported unconventional monetary policies like quantitative easing
Emphasized the importance of coordinated international responses to the crisis
Renewed debates about financial regulation and the role of central banks
Led to reassessments of macroeconomic models and policy frameworks
COVID-19 economic measures
Influenced massive fiscal support programs to maintain incomes and prevent economic collapse
Supported unprecedented monetary policy interventions to stabilize financial markets
Emphasized the importance of public health measures in economic recovery
Renewed debates about the role of government in crisis management and social protection
Sparked discussions about building more resilient and inclusive economic systems
Climate change policy proposals
Informs debates about the role of government in addressing long-term environmental challenges
Supports arguments for large-scale public investments in green technologies and infrastructure
Influences discussions about carbon pricing and other market-based environmental policies
Contributes to debates about the potential economic impacts of climate change mitigation
Informs proposals for "Green New Deal" programs combining environmental and economic objectives
Key Terms to Review (32)
Aggregate demand: Aggregate demand is the total amount of goods and services demanded across all levels of an economy at a given overall price level and in a given time period. It encompasses the total spending from households, businesses, government, and foreign buyers, providing insight into the overall economic health. Understanding aggregate demand helps to analyze economic fluctuations and the effectiveness of fiscal and monetary policies.
Automatic stabilizers: Automatic stabilizers are economic policies and programs that automatically help stabilize an economy without the need for explicit government intervention. These mechanisms work by increasing government spending or decreasing taxes when the economy slows down, and vice versa during periods of growth. They play a crucial role in smoothing out fluctuations in economic activity, helping to maintain overall economic stability.
Bretton Woods System: The Bretton Woods System was a monetary order established in 1944 that aimed to promote international economic stability and prevent the competitive devaluation of currencies after World War II. It created a framework for fixed exchange rates, where currencies were pegged to the U.S. dollar, which was convertible to gold, facilitating international trade and investment. This system influenced economic policies and development theories by emphasizing the need for cooperation among nations.
Credit rationing: Credit rationing occurs when lenders limit the amount of credit available to borrowers, even if they are willing to pay higher interest rates. This situation typically arises in an environment of asymmetric information, where lenders cannot accurately assess the risk profile of borrowers, leading to a reluctance to provide loans. In such cases, financial institutions may impose stricter criteria for lending or allocate limited funds among applicants based on perceived risk rather than pure market demand.
Crowding out effect: The crowding out effect occurs when increased government spending leads to a reduction in private sector spending and investment. This typically happens when the government borrows money to finance its expenditures, which raises interest rates and makes it more expensive for individuals and businesses to borrow, ultimately discouraging private investment.
Deficit spending: Deficit spending is the practice of a government spending more money than it collects in revenue, leading to a budget deficit. This approach is often used to stimulate economic growth during downturns by injecting funds into the economy, which can help boost consumer demand and create jobs. While it can provide short-term benefits, prolonged deficit spending can lead to higher national debt and long-term economic challenges.
Effective Demand: Effective demand refers to the level of demand for goods and services that is backed by the ability and willingness to pay for them. It highlights the actual purchasing power in the economy, emphasizing that demand alone is not sufficient; it must be effective or realized through purchases. This concept is central to understanding how economic activity is influenced by consumer behavior and the overall health of the economy.
Efficiency Wages: Efficiency wages are higher-than-market wages paid by employers to boost worker productivity and morale, ultimately benefiting the company. This concept suggests that paying workers more than the equilibrium wage can lead to reduced turnover, increased loyalty, and a more motivated workforce, which helps to enhance overall economic efficiency.
Fiscal stimulus: Fiscal stimulus refers to the use of government spending and tax policies to encourage economic growth, particularly during periods of recession or economic slowdown. This approach aims to increase aggregate demand by injecting money into the economy, which can lead to job creation, increased consumer spending, and overall economic recovery. Fiscal stimulus is closely tied to the ideas of Keynesian economics, which emphasize the role of government intervention in stabilizing economic fluctuations.
Golden age of capitalism: The golden age of capitalism refers to the period of robust economic growth and prosperity experienced in many Western countries, particularly from the late 1940s to the early 1970s. This era was characterized by high levels of investment, rising wages, and increasing consumer demand, driven largely by the post-World War II recovery, the expansion of the welfare state, and significant advances in technology and productivity. The period is often associated with Keynesian economics, which emphasized government intervention in the economy to ensure full employment and stabilize economic fluctuations.
Government intervention: Government intervention refers to the actions taken by a government to influence or regulate the economy, particularly in times of economic distress. This can include fiscal policies, such as government spending and taxation, and monetary policies, like controlling the money supply and interest rates. Such interventions are often aimed at stabilizing the economy, promoting growth, and addressing issues like unemployment and inflation.
Great Depression: The Great Depression was a severe worldwide economic downturn that lasted from 1929 to the late 1930s, marked by a dramatic decline in industrial output, mass unemployment, and widespread poverty. It significantly influenced the political landscape, leading to changes in government policies and economic theories as nations grappled with its profound social and economic consequences.
Inflation: Inflation is the rate at which the general level of prices for goods and services rises, eroding purchasing power. It reflects the decrease in the purchasing power of a nation's currency, which can be caused by various factors, including demand-pull and cost-push dynamics. Understanding inflation is essential for grasping how economic policies are designed to stabilize the economy and promote growth, especially in the context of Keynesian economics.
Interest rates: Interest rates are the cost of borrowing money or the return on savings, expressed as a percentage of the principal amount. They play a crucial role in economic activities, influencing consumer spending, investment decisions, and overall economic growth. In the context of Keynesian economics, interest rates are pivotal in shaping aggregate demand and managing economic fluctuations.
IS-LM Model: The IS-LM model is a macroeconomic tool that illustrates the relationship between interest rates and real output in the goods and services market and the money market. It combines the investment-savings (IS) curve, which shows equilibrium in the goods market, and the liquidity preference-money supply (LM) curve, which shows equilibrium in the money market, helping to analyze how changes in fiscal and monetary policy affect overall economic activity.
John Maynard Keynes: John Maynard Keynes was a British economist whose ideas fundamentally changed the theory and practice of macroeconomics and the economic policies of governments. He is best known for advocating government intervention to stabilize economic fluctuations, particularly during times of recession, which has led to the development of Keynesian economics and the concept of mixed economies that blend market mechanisms with government oversight.
Liquidity preference theory: Liquidity preference theory is an economic theory proposed by John Maynard Keynes that suggests individuals prefer to hold their wealth in liquid form, such as cash, rather than in illiquid assets. This preference for liquidity stems from the desire for security and the need to respond quickly to changing circumstances. The theory emphasizes the role of interest rates in balancing the demand for money and the supply of money, influencing overall economic activity.
Liquidity trap: A liquidity trap is an economic situation where monetary policy becomes ineffective because interest rates are already at or near zero, and individuals hoard cash instead of spending or investing it. In this scenario, even when central banks increase the money supply, it fails to stimulate economic activity, as people prefer to hold onto their liquid assets rather than risk investing in low-return opportunities. This situation often leads to stagnation in economic growth, as demand remains subdued.
Lucas Critique: The Lucas Critique is an economic theory proposed by Robert Lucas that challenges the effectiveness of traditional Keynesian economics in predicting the outcomes of policy changes. It argues that economic agents adjust their expectations based on past experiences and information, making it essential to consider these expectations when assessing the impact of policy measures. This critique has significant implications for how economists understand the relationship between policy interventions and economic behavior.
Menu costs: Menu costs refer to the expenses incurred by firms when they change their prices, which can include printing new menus, updating price lists, or re-tagging items. This concept is tied to the broader effects of inflation and economic fluctuations, where businesses may hesitate to adjust prices frequently due to these costs, ultimately affecting the overall economy. The reluctance to change prices can lead to price stickiness, impacting how monetary policy influences aggregate demand and supply.
Monetarist challenges: Monetarist challenges refer to the criticisms and counterarguments made against Keynesian economics by monetarists, particularly concerning the role of money supply in influencing economic activity. Monetarists argue that controlling the money supply is crucial for managing inflation and ensuring economic stability, which contrasts with the Keynesian emphasis on government spending and fiscal policy as primary tools for stimulating the economy. This debate has significant implications for economic policy and the understanding of inflationary processes.
Multiplier effect: The multiplier effect refers to the concept in economics where an initial increase in spending leads to a greater overall increase in economic activity. This occurs because the initial spending generates income for businesses and workers, who then spend a portion of their income, thereby creating additional demand and stimulating further economic activity. Essentially, it shows how one dollar of spending can lead to multiple dollars of economic growth through successive rounds of spending.
Neoliberalism: Neoliberalism is an economic and political ideology that emphasizes the importance of free markets, minimal government intervention, and individual entrepreneurship. It promotes deregulation, privatization of state-owned enterprises, and trade liberalization as means to foster economic growth and efficiency. This approach has significantly shaped global economic policies since the late 20th century and has important implications for various aspects of international trade, industrialization, and economic development theories.
New Deal Policies: New Deal policies refer to a series of programs and reforms implemented by President Franklin D. Roosevelt in response to the Great Depression, aimed at providing relief, recovery, and reform to the struggling American economy. These policies included various initiatives such as job creation programs, financial reforms, and social safety nets that sought to stabilize the economy and reduce unemployment while also addressing the needs of the poorest Americans. The New Deal marked a significant shift in the role of government in economic affairs, moving toward greater federal intervention and support for citizens.
New Keynesian Economics: New Keynesian Economics is a school of thought that builds upon the original ideas of John Maynard Keynes, emphasizing the importance of price and wage stickiness in explaining economic fluctuations. It incorporates microeconomic foundations to support the Keynesian view that markets do not always clear, leading to prolonged periods of unemployment and underutilized resources. This approach highlights the role of government intervention and monetary policy in stabilizing the economy during downturns.
Phillips Curve: The Phillips Curve is an economic concept that illustrates the inverse relationship between the rate of inflation and the rate of unemployment within an economy. Essentially, it suggests that when inflation is high, unemployment tends to be low, and vice versa. This relationship provides insight into how inflationary policies can influence employment levels, particularly in the context of Keynesian economics, where demand management is emphasized to stabilize the economy.
Post-world war ii economic boom: The post-World War II economic boom refers to the period of significant economic growth and prosperity experienced in many Western countries from the late 1940s to the early 1970s. This era was characterized by increased industrial production, rising consumer spending, and substantial improvements in living standards, fueled by government policies and a shift towards Keynesian economics that promoted active intervention in the economy.
Public Choice Theory: Public choice theory is an economic theory that applies the principles of economics to political science, analyzing how decisions are made in the public sector and the behavior of public officials. It emphasizes that individuals in government make choices based on self-interest, just like those in the private market, leading to outcomes that may not align with the public good. This perspective helps explain the inefficiencies and failures in government policies, connecting closely with economic theories related to demand management and development strategies.
Public goods: Public goods are resources or services that are made available to all members of a society, regardless of their contribution to the cost of providing them. They are characterized by non-excludability, meaning that no one can be effectively excluded from using them, and non-rivalry, meaning that one person's use does not diminish the availability for others. These qualities make public goods crucial in economic discussions about how to stimulate growth and stabilize economies.
Real Business Cycle Theory: Real Business Cycle Theory is an economic theory that suggests fluctuations in economic output are primarily driven by real (rather than monetary) shocks to the economy, such as changes in technology or resource availability. This theory posits that these shocks affect productivity, leading to cycles of expansion and contraction, and emphasizes the role of supply-side factors over demand-side factors, contrasting with Keynesian economics.
Spending multiplier: The spending multiplier is an economic concept that describes how an initial change in spending can lead to a more than proportional change in overall economic output. It is based on the idea that when one entity spends money, it creates income for others, which can then be spent again, resulting in a cascading effect throughout the economy. This concept is central to understanding the impact of fiscal policy and government spending in Keynesian economics.
Unemployment rate: The unemployment rate is the percentage of the labor force that is unemployed and actively seeking employment. It serves as a key indicator of economic health, reflecting the number of individuals who are willing and able to work but cannot find jobs. Changes in the unemployment rate can signal shifts in economic conditions, such as recessions or expansions, and are crucial for shaping government policies and interventions.