✍️Craft of Film Writing Unit 5 – Genres and Subversion in Film

Film genres provide familiar frameworks for storytelling, but subverting these conventions can lead to fresh, engaging narratives. This unit explores how filmmakers break genre expectations to surprise audiences and convey deeper themes, examining techniques in action, romance, horror, sci-fi, and comedy films. By understanding classic genre tropes and how to twist them, writers can create more complex, layered stories. Famous examples like Pulp Fiction and Scream demonstrate how subversion can breathe new life into tired formulas, offering insights for aspiring screenwriters to apply in their own work.

What's This Unit All About?

  • Explores the concept of film genres and how they can be subverted to create unique and compelling stories
  • Examines the conventions and tropes associated with various film genres (action, romance, horror)
  • Delves into the ways in which filmmakers can break away from traditional genre expectations to surprise and engage audiences
  • Discusses the impact of genre subversion on storytelling and how it can be used to convey deeper themes and messages
  • Provides examples of famous films that have successfully subverted genre conventions and analyzes their techniques
  • Offers insights into how aspiring screenwriters can apply the principles of genre subversion to their own work

Key Genres We're Diving Into

  • Action: Fast-paced, high-stakes stories featuring physical conflict and daring heroes (Die Hard, The Matrix)
    • Often involves a clear protagonist facing off against a formidable antagonist
    • Relies heavily on thrilling set pieces, chase sequences, and explosive confrontations
  • Romance: Focuses on the development of a romantic relationship between two characters (Titanic, The Notebook)
    • Typically follows a "boy meets girl" structure with obstacles that test the strength of their love
    • Explores themes of passion, sacrifice, and the transformative power of love
  • Horror: Aims to evoke fear, terror, and suspense in the audience (The Shining, A Nightmare on Elm Street)
    • Often features supernatural or psychologically disturbing elements
    • Plays on primal fears and the unknown to create a sense of unease and dread
  • Science Fiction: Speculative stories that explore the impact of advanced technology, alternate realities, or future societies (Blade Runner, Inception)
    • Frequently delves into philosophical questions about the nature of humanity and our place in the universe
  • Comedy: Designed to elicit laughter and amusement from the audience through humorous situations, dialogue, and characters (Bridesmaids, Anchorman)
    • Can range from slapstick and physical comedy to more sophisticated forms of satire and irony

Classic Genre Conventions

  • Each genre has its own set of established conventions and tropes that audiences have come to expect
  • These conventions help to quickly establish the tone, setting, and characters of a film
  • Examples of classic genre conventions include:
    • The tough, wisecracking hero in action films
    • The "meet-cute" and grand romantic gestures in romance films
    • The jump scares and creepy atmospheres in horror films
    • The advanced technology and dystopian futures in science fiction films
    • The misunderstandings and awkward situations in comedy films
  • Adhering to these conventions can make a film feel familiar and accessible to audiences
  • However, strictly following genre conventions can also lead to predictability and a lack of originality

Subversion: Flipping the Script

  • Genre subversion involves taking the established conventions of a genre and twisting them in unexpected ways
  • This can be done by introducing elements from other genres, inverting traditional character roles, or upending audience expectations
  • Subversion can breathe new life into tired genre tropes and create a sense of surprise and novelty for viewers
  • Examples of genre subversion include:
    • An action film where the hero is an unlikely or unconventional figure (The Incredibles)
    • A romance that explores the darker, more toxic aspects of relationships (Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind)
    • A horror film that subverts the "final girl" trope by having her turn the tables on the killer (You're Next)
  • Subversion can also be used to comment on or critique the assumptions and values embedded within a genre
  • When done effectively, genre subversion can lead to more complex, nuanced, and thought-provoking stories

Famous Films That Break the Mold

  • Pulp Fiction (1994): Subverts the crime thriller genre with its non-linear structure, quirky characters, and unexpected moments of humor and violence
  • Scream (1996): Deconstructs the slasher horror genre by featuring self-aware characters who openly discuss horror movie tropes and clichés
  • The Princess Bride (1987): Playfully subverts the fairy tale romance genre with its irreverent humor, meta-commentary, and genre-blending elements
  • Cabin in the Woods (2011): Turns the horror genre on its head by revealing a complex, behind-the-scenes mythology that controls and manipulates the characters' fates
  • Groundhog Day (1993): Puts a unique spin on the romantic comedy formula by trapping its protagonist in a time loop, forcing him to confront his flaws and grow as a person
  • Get Out (2017): Blends elements of horror, satire, and social commentary to create a subversive thriller that tackles issues of race and privilege in America

How Subversion Impacts Storytelling

  • Genre subversion allows filmmakers to tell more complex, layered stories that challenge audience expectations
  • By breaking free from the constraints of genre conventions, writers can explore new narrative possibilities and delve into deeper themes
  • Subversion can make a story feel fresh and unpredictable, keeping audiences engaged and invested in the characters and their journeys
  • It can also be used to comment on social issues, critique cultural norms, or offer new perspectives on familiar topics
  • However, subversion must be handled carefully to avoid alienating audiences or losing sight of the story's core emotional truths
  • Effective subversion requires a deep understanding of genre conventions and a clear vision for how to twist them in meaningful ways

Applying This to Your Own Writing

  • When incorporating genre subversion into your own screenwriting, start by identifying the key conventions and tropes of your chosen genre
  • Consider which elements you want to embrace, which ones you want to subvert, and why those choices serve your story and themes
  • Look for opportunities to blend elements from different genres in unexpected ways, creating a unique and compelling narrative
  • Develop complex, multi-dimensional characters that challenge stereotypes and defy easy categorization
  • Use subversion to explore deeper themes and ideas that might be difficult to address within the confines of a traditional genre story
  • Be mindful of your audience's expectations and find ways to surprise them without completely alienating them from the story
  • Remember that subversion should always serve the story and the characters, not just be used for the sake of being different or shocking

Beyond the Basics: Advanced Techniques

  • Subverting genre conventions can be taken even further by playing with narrative structure, tone, and style
  • Experimenting with non-linear storytelling, unreliable narrators, or meta-fictional elements can add additional layers of complexity and subversion to a story
  • Mixing tones and styles within a single film can create a sense of unease or disorientation that enhances the subversive effect (Parasite, which blends elements of comedy, thriller, and social drama)
  • Subversion can also be achieved through the use of unconventional filmmaking techniques, such as breaking the fourth wall, using unexpected visual or sound design, or employing unusual editing patterns
  • Advanced genre subversion often requires a high level of technical skill and a willingness to take creative risks
  • Filmmakers who successfully push the boundaries of genre and storytelling can create truly groundbreaking and memorable works that redefine the medium (Mulholland Drive, Memento, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind)
  • However, it's important to remember that not every story needs to be subversive or genre-defying; sometimes, embracing and perfecting the conventions of a genre can be just as effective and satisfying for audiences


© 2024 Fiveable Inc. All rights reserved.
AP® and SAT® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse this website.

© 2024 Fiveable Inc. All rights reserved.
AP® and SAT® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse this website.