11.4 Case studies of influential television critics and their work
4 min read•august 16, 2024
Television criticism has evolved significantly since TV became a dominant cultural medium. Critics use various approaches, from to , to analyze content. Their writing styles range from academic to conversational, balancing depth with accessibility for different audiences.
The landscape of TV criticism has changed with the rise of online platforms and social media. Critics have adapted their methods to address new genres, cultural shifts, and socio-political issues. Their work continues to shape public discourse, influence industry practices, and contribute to TV's cultural legitimization.
Critical Approaches of Television Critics
Analytical Frameworks and Writing Styles
Top images from around the web for Analytical Frameworks and Writing Styles
Cultural Studies Curriculum – ICA Social Research Center View original
Is this image relevant?
Pragmatism, Critical Theory and Post-structuralism | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Analyzing Two Categories of Academic Writing Styles View original
Is this image relevant?
Cultural Studies Curriculum – ICA Social Research Center View original
Is this image relevant?
Pragmatism, Critical Theory and Post-structuralism | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Analytical Frameworks and Writing Styles
Cultural Studies Curriculum – ICA Social Research Center View original
Is this image relevant?
Pragmatism, Critical Theory and Post-structuralism | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Analyzing Two Categories of Academic Writing Styles View original
Is this image relevant?
Cultural Studies Curriculum – ICA Social Research Center View original
Is this image relevant?
Pragmatism, Critical Theory and Post-structuralism | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Television criticism employs various approaches (formalist, ideological, feminist, cultural studies) providing unique analytical frameworks for evaluating TV content
- Critics develop distinctive writing styles ranging from academic to conversational influencing reader engagement and conveying complex ideas
- Evolution of criticism shifted from newspaper-based reviews to online platforms, blogs, and social media affecting format and tone
- Balancing analytical depth with accessibility appeals to both academic and general audiences
- Critics often specialize in specific genres or programming types developing expertise informing their approach and style
- Use of (humor, sarcasm, personal anecdotes) defines a critic's style and contributes to influence and readership
Adapting to Media Landscape Changes
- Emergence of television criticism coincided with TV becoming dominant cultural medium in mid-20th century
- Cultural shifts like and significantly impacted critics' work and analytical approaches
- Socio-political climate of different eras influenced focus and tone of criticism addressing issues like and
- Evolving relationship between critics and television industry affected access, independence, and nature of critiques
- Development of academic television studies influenced methodologies and theoretical frameworks employed by critics
- Changes in and audience engagement shaped critics' roles as and
Historical and Cultural Contexts of Television Criticism
Evolution of Critical Practice
- Shift from primarily newspaper-based reviews to online platforms altered format and tone of critical writing
- Advent of cable television and transition to digital platforms impacted critics' analytical approaches
- Socio-political climate influenced critics' focus on issues like representation, diversity, and social justice
- Relationship between critics and television industry evolved affecting access, independence, and nature of critiques
- Academic television studies development influenced methodologies and theoretical frameworks
- Media consumption changes shaped critics' roles as cultural intermediaries
Influential Factors on Criticism
- Rise of television as dominant cultural medium in mid-20th century coincided with emergence of television criticism
- Cultural shifts (cable TV, digital platforms) significantly impacted critics' work
- Socio-political climate of different eras influenced criticism focus and tone
- Television industry relationship evolution affected critics' access and independence
- Academic television studies influenced critical methodologies and frameworks
- Changing media consumption patterns shaped critics' cultural intermediary roles
Legacy of Television Criticism
Enduring Impact on Television Studies
- Seminal works established and evolved critical frameworks for analyzing television as medium and cultural force
- Influential critics shaped public discourse about programming affecting audience reception and industry practices
- Critics' legacy evident in influence on subsequent generations of critics and scholars
- Significant works contributed to cultural legitimization of television as art form worthy of serious attention
- Impact on industry practices (programming decisions, content creation) traced through historical case studies
- Enduring relevance demonstrated by continued citation and discussion in contemporary scholarship and criticism
Shaping Television Culture
- Critics played role in shaping public discourse about programming influencing audience reception
- Criticism contributed to cultural legitimization of television as art form
- Impact on industry practices included influencing programming decisions and content creation
- Critics' work helped establish television as subject worthy of serious academic and critical attention
- Historical case studies reveal criticism's influence on industry practices over time
- Continued relevance of critical works evident in contemporary television scholarship and criticism
Applying Critical Insights to Television
Developing Personal Critical Practice
- Study influential critics' approaches to inform development of own critical voice and analytical strategies
- Balance subjective interpretation with objective analysis in critical writing
- Adapt practices to changing media landscapes and audience expectations
- Address ethical considerations (maintaining critical independence, navigating industry relationships)
- Develop deep understanding of television history, production processes, and industry dynamics
- Apply insights from case studies to contemporary issues of representation, diversity, and social impact
Leveraging Historical Context
- Examine evolution of television criticism to adapt practices to changing media landscapes
- Use historical context to inform approaches to representation, diversity, and social impact issues
- Develop understanding of television history to produce informed and insightful criticism
- Study case studies to navigate ethical considerations in critical practice
- Apply lessons from influential critics to balance analysis depth with accessibility
- Utilize historical examples to develop strategies for engaging diverse audiences
Key Terms to Review (28)
Academic writing: Academic writing is a formal style of writing used in universities and scholarly publications that prioritizes clear, concise, and objective communication of ideas. It often follows specific conventions and structures to present research findings, arguments, and critiques in a way that is accessible to a knowledgeable audience. This style is crucial for establishing credibility and rigor in scholarly discussions, particularly when analyzing influential critics and their contributions to television studies.
Auteur theory: Auteur theory is a concept in film and television criticism that posits the director as the primary creative force behind a work, asserting that their personal style and vision are evident throughout their body of work. This theory highlights how a director's unique artistic fingerprint shapes the narrative, themes, and visual aesthetics of the productions they helm, allowing critics to analyze television texts with an understanding of the director's influence.
Cable television: Cable television is a system of delivering television programming to consumers via coaxial or fiber-optic cables, providing access to a wide range of channels and content beyond traditional broadcast television. This medium has significantly influenced how social issues and marginalized groups are represented, while also shaping the work of television critics who analyze and evaluate programming through various lenses.
Conversational Writing: Conversational writing is a style that mimics the natural flow and tone of spoken language, making text feel more relatable and engaging to readers. This writing approach often employs a casual tone, simple sentence structures, and personal anecdotes to create a connection between the writer and the audience, making complex ideas more accessible. By using everyday language and a friendly voice, conversational writing can effectively draw in readers and hold their attention.
Cultural intermediaries: Cultural intermediaries are individuals or organizations that play a critical role in the mediation, interpretation, and dissemination of cultural products, including television shows. They influence how audiences perceive and engage with media by shaping public discourse and opinion through their critiques, analyses, and recommendations.
Cultural studies: Cultural studies is an interdisciplinary field that examines the cultural practices, artifacts, and institutions of society, analyzing how they shape and reflect social identities and power dynamics. This approach emphasizes the importance of context, including historical, social, and political factors, in understanding media content and its impact on audiences.
Digital platforms: Digital platforms are online services that facilitate the distribution and consumption of content, allowing users to access media through various devices. These platforms have transformed how television critics operate, providing them with new avenues to share their insights, reviews, and analyses, as well as enabling audience interaction and feedback.
Emmy Awards for Journalism: The Emmy Awards for Journalism are prestigious accolades that honor outstanding achievements in the field of journalism, particularly in television. These awards recognize the vital role that journalism plays in informing the public, highlighting excellence in reporting, production, and storytelling across various media platforms. The Emmys celebrate journalists and media organizations that contribute to the advancement of the craft and uphold the integrity of journalistic practices.
Entertainment Weekly: Entertainment Weekly is a prominent American magazine that covers film, television, music, and popular culture. Launched in 1990, it provides insightful reviews, industry news, and features that engage fans while also shaping public perception of entertainment media. The publication has played a significant role in the evolution of television criticism by providing a platform for critics to share their analysis and opinions on various shows and films.
Feminist theory: Feminist theory is an analytical framework that seeks to understand and critique the ways in which gender influences social structures, cultural representations, and power dynamics. It emphasizes the importance of women's experiences and voices, aiming to address issues of inequality, representation, and identity in various contexts, including media.
Formalist: A formalist approach focuses on the structure, style, and aesthetic elements of a television show, emphasizing how these components contribute to the overall meaning and experience of the work. This perspective often involves a close analysis of visual composition, editing techniques, narrative structure, and sound design to understand how they shape viewer perception and interpretation.
Genre theory: Genre theory is a framework for understanding and categorizing different types of media, including television, based on shared conventions, styles, and thematic elements. It helps analyze how these genres evolve over time, influence audience expectations, and shape production practices.
Ideological criticism: Ideological criticism is a method of analyzing media texts, particularly television, by examining the underlying beliefs, values, and ideologies that are promoted or challenged within them. This approach reveals how media shapes our understanding of social issues, power dynamics, and cultural narratives, and it often critiques the ways in which certain ideologies dominate public discourse. By analyzing the work of influential television critics, we can see how ideological criticism has evolved and impacted the broader landscape of television studies.
Influence on programming: Influence on programming refers to the impact that various factors, including critics, audiences, and cultural trends, have on the creation, development, and airing of television shows. This influence can shape the themes, narratives, and even the success of programs by responding to viewer preferences or by critiquing content in a way that pushes creators toward innovation or change.
Janet Maslin: Janet Maslin is a prominent American film and television critic known for her work with The New York Times, where she has contributed extensively to the critique and analysis of television shows and films. Her insights have shaped public opinion and industry standards, and she is recognized for her eloquent writing style and keen observations that often blend cultural commentary with critical reviews.
Media consumption patterns: Media consumption patterns refer to the habits and trends of how audiences engage with various forms of media, including television, online streaming, and social media. These patterns are influenced by factors such as demographics, technological advancements, and cultural trends, which shape how content is accessed and consumed. Understanding these patterns helps critics analyze the impact of television on society and how it reflects or shapes public perceptions.
Pulitzer Prize for Criticism: The Pulitzer Prize for Criticism is an esteemed American award that recognizes distinguished work in the field of criticism, including that of television critics. This award honors critics whose writing exemplifies excellence and has a significant impact on public opinion about the arts, especially in media like television. Winning this prize highlights the critic's ability to analyze and interpret media in ways that resonate with audiences and influence broader cultural conversations.
Ratings impact: Ratings impact refers to the effect that television ratings have on the programming decisions, production choices, and overall strategy of networks and content creators. High ratings can lead to renewed series, increased budgets, and more promotional support, while low ratings can result in cancellations, changes in direction, or shifts in target audiences. This term connects closely with the influence of critics and their reviews, as these factors often contribute to shaping viewer perceptions and ultimately affect a show's ratings.
Representation: Representation refers to the ways in which various groups, identities, and issues are depicted and portrayed in media, particularly television. It plays a crucial role in shaping perceptions and understanding of social dynamics, influencing how individuals view themselves and others within society.
Rhetorical devices: Rhetorical devices are techniques used by writers and speakers to persuade, inform, or entertain an audience. They enhance the effectiveness of communication by emphasizing ideas, evoking emotions, and making arguments more compelling. Understanding these devices helps to analyze how influential television critics construct their arguments and engage viewers.
Roger Ebert: Roger Ebert was a prominent American film critic known for his insightful and influential reviews of movies, which he wrote for the Chicago Sun-Times and later became the first film critic to win a Pulitzer Prize for Criticism. His work shaped how films were perceived by audiences and contributed to the rise of film criticism as a respected profession, connecting film analysis to broader cultural conversations.
Social justice: Social justice refers to the concept of fair and just relations between individuals and society, emphasizing the need for equality, rights, and opportunities for all people, regardless of their backgrounds. This idea is deeply connected to the role media plays in shaping perspectives on marginalized groups, influencing public discourse and the work of critics who analyze and critique these representations in television.
Tastemakers: Tastemakers are individuals or groups that have significant influence over cultural trends, particularly in the realms of fashion, music, art, and television. They shape public opinion and preferences through their recommendations and critiques, often leading audiences to new discoveries in entertainment. Tastemakers can be critics, bloggers, or social media influencers who have established credibility and a following, thereby impacting what content becomes popular or widely accepted.
Television: a love story: The phrase 'television: a love story' captures the intricate relationship between viewers and the medium of television, highlighting how it serves as a powerful storytelling platform that fosters emotional connections. It reflects on how television not only entertains but also shapes cultural narratives, influences societal values, and creates shared experiences among audiences. This concept delves into the ways critics have interpreted and analyzed these connections to understand television's impact on personal and collective identities.
The impact of the internet on criticism: The impact of the internet on criticism refers to the profound changes in how television shows are analyzed and discussed, driven by digital platforms and social media. This shift has democratized the landscape, allowing both professional critics and everyday viewers to share their opinions widely, leading to a more diverse range of voices in television criticism. Additionally, online platforms enable immediate feedback and interaction, reshaping the relationship between critics and audiences.
The medium is the massage: The phrase 'the medium is the massage' suggests that the way information is delivered is just as important, if not more so, than the content itself. This concept emphasizes that the characteristics and technologies of the medium influence how messages are perceived and understood. The idea challenges traditional views that prioritize content over delivery, encouraging a critical examination of the role of media in shaping our experiences and interpretations.
The New York Times TV critic: The New York Times TV critic refers to the influential television reviewers employed by one of the most prestigious newspapers in the United States, known for their insightful analyses and cultural commentary on television programming. Their reviews often shape public opinion and can significantly impact a show's success or failure, reflecting the broader trends in television and society.
The rise of television in the 1950s: The rise of television in the 1950s refers to the explosive growth of TV as a dominant medium for entertainment, news, and culture in American society. This era saw a rapid increase in the number of households with televisions, changing how people consumed media and interacted with each other. The cultural impact was profound, influencing everything from advertising to politics, and shaping the way critics approached television as a serious art form worthy of analysis and commentary.