Glossary

8.2 Analysis methods for indeterminate structures

4 min read•august 9, 2024

Indeterminate structures require advanced analysis methods to solve for unknown forces and displacements. This section covers classical approaches like force and displacement methods, as well as flexibility and stiffness techniques for tackling complex structural systems.

We'll also look at moment distribution and slope methods, which offer practical ways to analyze continuous beams and frames. These techniques, along with and , form the foundation for modern computational structural analysis.

Classical Methods

Force and Displacement Methods

Top images from around the web for Force and Displacement Methods

  • Müller-Breslau's principle - Wikipedia View original

    Is this image relevant?

  • Energy and the Simple Harmonic Oscillator | Physics View original

    Is this image relevant?

  • Müller-Breslau's principle - Wikipedia View original

    Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Force and Displacement Methods

  • Müller-Breslau's principle - Wikipedia View original

    Is this image relevant?

  • Energy and the Simple Harmonic Oscillator | Physics View original

    Is this image relevant?

  • Müller-Breslau's principle - Wikipedia View original

    Is this image relevant?

1 of 3
  • determines unknown forces in statically indeterminate structures
    • Releases redundant supports to create statically determinate structure
    • Applies unknown forces at released supports
    • Calculates displacements using
    • Solves system of equations to find unknown forces
  • focuses on unknown displacements at joints
    • Assumes all joints are fixed against displacement
    • Applies unknown displacements at joints
    • Calculates forces using
    • Solves system of equations to find unknown displacements
  • Both methods require solving simultaneous equations
    • Number of equations equals degree of indeterminacy
    • Complexity increases with structure's indeterminacy

Flexibility and Stiffness Methods

  • (also called force method) analyzes indeterminate structures
    • Determines flexibility coefficients relating forces to displacements
    • Creates flexibility matrix for entire structure
    • Solves matrix equation to find unknown forces
    • Useful for structures with few redundant members
  • (also called displacement method) widely used in structural analysis
    • Determines stiffness coefficients relating displacements to forces
    • Creates stiffness matrix for entire structure
    • Solves matrix equation to find unknown displacements
    • Adaptable to computer-based analysis
    • Preferred for structures with many degrees of freedom

Moment Distribution and Slope Deflection

Moment Distribution Method

  • Iterative technique for analyzing continuous beams and frames
    • Developed by Hardy Cross in 1930
    • Distributes unbalanced moments at joints to adjacent members
    • Continues until all joints reach moment equilibrium
  • Process of moment distribution includes
    • Calculating fixed-end moments for all spans
    • Distributing unbalanced moments using distribution factors
    • Carrying over moments to far ends of members
    • Repeating distribution and carryover until convergence
  • Advantages of
    • Can be performed without solving simultaneous equations
    • Allows for quick approximate solutions
    • Provides insight into structural behavior

Slope Deflection Method

  • Analyzes indeterminate beams and frames using slope-deflection equations
    • Relates end moments to rotations and displacements of joints
    • Considers both flexural and axial deformations
  • Key steps in
    • Write slope-deflection equations for each member
    • Apply equilibrium conditions at each joint
    • Solve resulting system of equations for unknown rotations and displacements
  • Slope-deflection equation for a beam member: MAB=2EIL(2θA+θB−3ψ)+FEMABM_{AB} = \frac{2EI}{L}(2\theta_A + \theta_B - 3\psi) + FEM_{AB}
    • Where EE = modulus of elasticity, II = moment of inertia
    • LL = length of member, θ\theta = end rotations, ψ\psi = chord rotation
    • FEMFEM = fixed-end moment
  • Useful for both manual calculations and computer implementation
    • Provides a systematic approach to frame analysis
    • Forms basis for matrix formulation of structural analysis

Advanced Analysis Techniques

Matrix Analysis Methods

  • Matrix methods provide efficient framework for structural analysis
    • Represent structure's behavior using matrices
    • Utilize linear algebra techniques for solution
  • Direct stiffness method most common matrix analysis approach
    • Assembles global stiffness matrix from element stiffness matrices
    • Solves matrix equation [K]d=F[K]{d} = {F} for unknown displacements
    • [K][K] = global stiffness matrix, d{d} = displacement vector, F{F} = force vector
  • Matrix analysis advantages
    • Easily implemented in computer programs
    • Handles complex structures with many degrees of freedom
    • Provides foundation for finite element analysis

Energy Methods in Structural Analysis

  • Energy principles form basis for advanced analysis techniques
    • Principle of virtual work relates external and internal virtual work
    • Castigliano's theorems relate strain energy to displacements and forces
  • Unit load method derives from principle of virtual work
    • Applies unit load at point of interest
    • Calculates displacement using virtual work equation
    • Useful for determining influence lines and deflections
  • Minimum total potential energy principle
    • States that equilibrium configuration minimizes total potential energy
    • Used in variational methods and finite element formulations
  • Energy methods provide powerful tools for indeterminate structure analysis
    • Often yield simpler solutions than force or displacement methods
    • Form theoretical basis for many numerical techniques

Finite Element Method

  • Powerful numerical technique for analyzing complex structures
    • Divides structure into small elements connected at nodes
    • Approximates continuous structure with discrete model
  • Key steps in finite element analysis
    • Discretize structure into finite elements
    • Select appropriate element types and shape functions
    • Formulate element stiffness matrices and load vectors
    • Assemble global equations and apply boundary conditions
    • Solve system for nodal displacements
    • Calculate element stresses and strains
  • applications
    • Handles structures with complex geometries and loading conditions
    • Analyzes non-linear behavior and dynamic responses
    • Used in various fields (structural, thermal, fluid dynamics)
  • Advantages of finite element analysis
    • Versatile and adaptable to wide range of problems
    • Provides detailed stress and deformation information
    • Integrates well with computer-aided design (CAD) systems

Key Terms to Review (22)

Compatibility conditions: Compatibility conditions are mathematical requirements ensuring that the displacements or deformations in a structure are consistent with the internal forces and moments acting within it. These conditions are essential in maintaining equilibrium and ensuring that the structure behaves as intended under applied loads, affecting how internal force diagrams, degrees of indeterminacy, and various analysis methods are approached.
Deflection: Deflection refers to the displacement of a structural element from its original position due to applied loads. It is a crucial concept in understanding how structures respond to forces, influencing the design and performance of various structural elements under different loading conditions.
Displacement method: The displacement method is a structural analysis technique used to determine the displacements and internal forces in structures, particularly for indeterminate structures. This method focuses on the compatibility of displacements at the joints and uses equilibrium equations to find the unknown forces in the structure. It is crucial for analyzing continuous beams and frames, addressing redundancy in structural systems, and understanding how forces are distributed and transferred through the structure.
E. L. A. K. D. W. McKenzie: E. L. A. K. D. W. McKenzie is a method used in the analysis of indeterminate structures, focusing on the equilibrium and compatibility of displacements to solve for unknown forces and moments in structures that have more supports than necessary to maintain stability. This approach utilizes various analytical techniques, such as virtual work and energy methods, to derive solutions that are accurate for complex structures.
Elastic Modulus: Elastic modulus is a measure of a material's ability to deform elastically when a force is applied. It quantifies the relationship between stress (force per unit area) and strain (deformation) in a material, indicating how stiff or flexible the material is under load. This concept is crucial in analyzing indeterminate structures, as it helps engineers determine how these structures will respond to various loads and conditions.
Energy Methods: Energy methods refer to a set of analytical techniques in structural analysis that utilize principles of energy conservation to determine the behavior of structures under various loads. These methods are particularly useful for analyzing indeterminate structures, where traditional force methods may be cumbersome or impractical. By focusing on energy concepts, such as strain energy and potential energy, these techniques can provide powerful insights into the deflections and reactions of complex structures.
Equilibrium equations: Equilibrium equations are mathematical expressions that represent the balance of forces and moments acting on a structure. These equations ensure that a structure is stable and that it does not experience any unbalanced forces or moments, which is crucial for analyzing reactions, internal forces, and overall structural behavior.
Finite element method: The finite element method (FEM) is a numerical technique used to obtain approximate solutions to boundary value problems for partial differential equations. It divides complex structures into smaller, simpler parts called elements, which can be easily analyzed, making it especially useful for structural analysis in engineering.
Flexibility method: The flexibility method is a structural analysis technique used to solve indeterminate structures by focusing on the relationships between the displacements and the forces acting on the structure. This method emphasizes compatibility conditions, allowing engineers to determine the internal redundant forces in structures and their corresponding deflections, making it essential for analyzing continuous beams and complex frames.
Force method: The force method is a structural analysis technique used to analyze indeterminate structures by introducing redundant forces to ensure compatibility of displacements in addition to equilibrium. This approach allows engineers to systematically address the complexity of structures that cannot be solved using simple equilibrium equations alone, making it essential for understanding how redundant forces interact within the structure, especially in scenarios involving external loads, support conditions, and temperature variations.
Internal Forces: Internal forces are the forces that develop within a structure as a response to external loads, supporting the equilibrium of the structure. These forces are crucial for understanding how structures behave under loads and help determine the distribution of stresses throughout members.
Load Factor: Load factor is a numerical measure used in structural engineering that represents the ratio of the maximum load to the actual load for a given structure or component. It helps engineers determine the safety and reliability of structures by considering the variability of loads they may experience throughout their lifespan. By applying load factors in analysis, engineers can better account for uncertainties, ensuring that structures can safely withstand not only typical loads but also extreme conditions.
Matrix analysis: Matrix analysis is a mathematical technique used to solve systems of linear equations and analyze structures by representing their relationships in matrix form. This approach simplifies the calculations for complex structural problems, making it easier to derive reactions, internal forces, and displacements. It's particularly useful in analyzing indeterminate structures, where traditional methods may be cumbersome or ineffective.
Moment Distribution Method: The moment distribution method is a structural analysis technique used to analyze indeterminate structures by distributing moments at the joints until equilibrium is achieved. This method allows for the consideration of both fixed and pinned supports, enabling engineers to solve for internal forces and moments in continuous beams and frames effectively.
S. P. Timoshenko: S. P. Timoshenko was a prominent engineer and educator known for his significant contributions to the field of structural analysis and mechanics of materials. His work laid the foundation for modern theories of elasticity and structural stability, making a lasting impact on how engineers analyze indeterminate structures.
Serviceability Limit State: The serviceability limit state refers to the conditions under which a structure remains functional and comfortable for users, without any significant damage or deformation that could affect its use. It is crucial for ensuring that buildings and other structures perform adequately throughout their service life, maintaining acceptable levels of deflection, vibration, and durability under expected loads. This concept is integral to evaluating structural performance during normal usage and helps inform load combinations and analysis methods employed in design.
Slope deflection method: The slope deflection method is a structural analysis technique used to determine the internal forces and displacements of indeterminate beams and frames by relating the slopes and deflections at the supports and joints to the bending moments. This method incorporates the principles of equilibrium, compatibility, and material behavior, allowing for the analysis of structures that have more supports or constraints than can be solved using simple methods. It is particularly useful in analyzing rigid frames and in dealing with statically indeterminate structures where traditional methods fall short.
Stiffness method: The stiffness method is a structural analysis technique used to analyze indeterminate structures by relating the displacements of a structure to the forces acting on it through stiffness matrices. This approach focuses on the deformation of structures and provides a systematic way to derive the internal forces and support reactions, making it especially useful for analyzing complex structures that cannot be solved by simpler methods.
Stress-strain relationship: The stress-strain relationship describes how materials deform under applied forces, defining the relationship between stress (force per unit area) and strain (deformation per unit length). This relationship is crucial for understanding how structures behave when subjected to loads, especially in indeterminate structures where internal forces and moments must be calculated to ensure stability and safety.
Superposition Principle: The superposition principle states that in a linear system, the total response at any point is equal to the sum of the individual responses caused by each load acting independently. This concept helps simplify the analysis of structures by allowing engineers to assess the effects of multiple loads separately before combining their effects to understand the overall behavior of the structure.
Ultimate limit state: The ultimate limit state refers to a condition beyond which a structure or structural member ceases to fulfill its intended purpose due to failure, collapse, or excessive deformation. This concept is crucial in ensuring safety and reliability in structural design, as it helps engineers assess load combinations and potential failure modes during the analysis of indeterminate structures.
Virtual work method: The virtual work method is a powerful analytical technique used to determine displacements in structures by applying the principle of virtual work. This method is grounded in the idea that the work done by external forces on a virtual displacement is equal to the internal work done by the structure's internal forces. By applying this principle, one can analyze complex structures and obtain crucial information about deflections and slopes, making it essential for understanding structural behavior.
© 2024 Fiveable Inc. All rights reserved.
AP® and SAT® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse this website.
Back
Practice QuizGlossary
Practice QuizGlossary
Next guide