11.2 Modern experimental confirmations
4 min read•august 7, 2024
Modern physics has revolutionized our understanding of space and time. Experiments like and observations of binary have confirmed Einstein's predictions about and with incredible precision.
These tests push the boundaries of experimental physics, using ultra-precise gyroscopes and . They provide compelling evidence for general relativity, validating our current model of gravity and .
Experimental Tests of Frame-Dragging
Gravity Probe B Experiment
Top images from around the web for Gravity Probe B Experiment
Two Views on Gravity Part 2: Geometry | Star Stryder View original
Is this image relevant?
Two Views on Gravity Part 2: Geometry | Star Stryder View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 1
Top images from around the web for Gravity Probe B Experiment
Two Views on Gravity Part 2: Geometry | Star Stryder View original
Is this image relevant?
Two Views on Gravity Part 2: Geometry | Star Stryder View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 1
- Gravity Probe B launched in 2004 to measure frame-dragging and geodetic effects
- Consisted of four gyroscopes in a satellite orbiting Earth at an altitude of about 640 km
- Gyroscopes were nearly perfect spheres coated with superconducting niobium (precision of 0.5 micrometers)
- Measured the precession of the gyroscopes due to the curvature of spacetime (geodetic effect) and the dragging of spacetime by Earth's rotation (frame-dragging)
- Confirmed the predicted geodetic effect to an accuracy of 0.28% and frame-dragging to an accuracy of 19%
Frame-Dragging and the Lense-Thirring Effect
- Frame-dragging is a phenomenon predicted by general relativity where a rotating massive object "drags" spacetime along with it
- Causes nearby objects and light to be "dragged" in the direction of the rotation
- Also known as the , named after Austrian physicists Josef Lense and Hans Thirring who first described it in 1918
- Effect is very small and difficult to measure (precession of a gyroscope in Earth's orbit is only 0.042 arcseconds per year)
- Has been measured by Gravity Probe B and observations of pulsars in binary systems
Measuring Frame-Dragging with Pulsar Timing
- Pulsars are rapidly rotating that emit beams of electromagnetic radiation
- Act as precise cosmic clocks due to their extremely stable rotation periods (can be measured to within a few microseconds over years)
- In a binary system with another neutron star or white dwarf, the pulsar's orbit is affected by frame-dragging
- Precise timing of the pulsar's pulses can reveal these relativistic effects
- , a double pulsar system, has provided some of the most stringent tests of general relativity and frame-dragging
Geodetic Effects and Equivalence Principle
Geodetic Effect and Spacetime Curvature
- Geodetic effect is the precession of a gyroscope's spin axis due to the curvature of spacetime
- Caused by the motion of the gyroscope through the curved spacetime around a massive object like Earth
- Predicted by general relativity and measured by Gravity Probe B to an accuracy of 0.28%
- Effect is larger than frame-dragging (precession of 6.6 arcseconds per year for a gyroscope in Earth's orbit)
Testing the Strong Equivalence Principle
- states that the outcome of any local non-gravitational experiment should be independent of where and when it is performed
- Implies that self-gravitating objects (like planets or stars) should follow the same trajectories as test particles in a gravitational field
- measures the distance between Earth and the Moon with centimeter precision using retroreflectors placed on the Moon by Apollo astronauts
- Has tested the strong equivalence principle to a few parts in by comparing the free-fall accelerations of the Moon and Earth towards the Sun
Very Long Baseline Interferometry (VLBI)
- VLBI is a technique that combines radio telescopes across the globe to create a virtual telescope with a size equal to the maximum separation between the telescopes
- Provides extremely precise measurements of the positions of distant astronomical objects (accuracy better than 1 milliarcsecond)
- Used to measure the geodetic effect by observing the apparent positions of quasars as the Earth moves through the curved spacetime around the Sun
- Has confirmed the predictions of general relativity to within a few parts in
Binary Pulsar Observations
The Hulse-Taylor Binary (PSR B1913+16)
- Discovered in 1974 by Russell Hulse and Joseph Taylor, it was the first binary pulsar system found
- Consists of two neutron stars orbiting each other with a period of about 7.75 hours
- One of the neutron stars is a pulsar with a spin period of 59 milliseconds
- Observations of the pulsar's timing have revealed relativistic effects such as the decay of the orbit due to
- Provided the first indirect evidence for the existence of and won Hulse and Taylor the 1993 Nobel Prize in Physics
Testing General Relativity with Pulsar Timing
- Binary pulsars provide unique laboratories for testing general relativity in strong gravitational fields
- Relativistic effects cause deviations from the predicted Keplerian orbit, which can be measured through precise timing of the pulsar's pulses
- Effects include perihelion precession, , and the (delay of light passing through the gravitational well of the companion star)
- The double pulsar system PSR J0737-3039A/B has allowed tests of general relativity to a precision of better than 0.05%
Frame-Dragging and the Strong Equivalence Principle in Binary Pulsars
- Binary pulsars can also be used to measure frame-dragging and test the strong equivalence principle
- Frame-dragging causes a precession of the orbit, which can be detected through long-term timing observations
- The strong equivalence principle predicts that the neutron stars' self-gravity should not affect their orbital motion
- Observations of the double pulsar system have verified the strong equivalence principle to within 0.01%, providing one of the most stringent tests to date
Key Terms to Review (17)
Cosmic clocks: Cosmic clocks are natural phenomena that can be used to measure time across vast distances in the universe, providing a way to understand the passage of time in different gravitational fields and relative velocities. They are essential in testing theories of relativity, particularly in observing how time is affected by gravity and motion, which has been confirmed through various modern experiments.
Frame-dragging: Frame-dragging is a phenomenon predicted by General Relativity where a massive rotating body, like a planet or a star, drags the spacetime around it as it spins. This effect demonstrates how mass and motion influence the structure of spacetime itself, leading to fascinating applications in both astrophysics and particle physics, as well as providing experimental confirmation of the predictions made by Einstein's theory.
Geodetic Effects: Geodetic effects refer to the phenomena predicted by general relativity that describe how mass and energy influence the geometry of spacetime, leading to observable consequences for the motion of objects. These effects, such as the curvature of space around massive bodies, play a crucial role in our understanding of gravity and have been confirmed through various modern experiments, showcasing the validity of Einstein's theories.
Gravitational wave emission: Gravitational wave emission refers to the production of ripples in spacetime caused by accelerating masses, such as colliding black holes or neutron stars. These waves propagate at the speed of light and can carry information about their cataclysmic origins, making them essential for understanding phenomena in the universe. The detection of gravitational waves provides a new way of observing astronomical events, complementing traditional electromagnetic observations.
Gravitational Waves: Gravitational waves are ripples in spacetime caused by some of the most violent and energetic processes in the universe, such as merging black holes or neutron stars. They carry information about their origins and the nature of gravity, connecting deeply to concepts like the historical development of relativity, applications in astrophysics, and modern experimental confirmations.
Gravity Probe B: Gravity Probe B is a satellite-based experiment launched by NASA in 2004 to test two predictions of Einstein's general theory of relativity: the geodetic effect and frame-dragging. By measuring the tiny changes in the direction of spin of ultra-precise gyroscopes as they orbited the Earth, Gravity Probe B aimed to provide experimental confirmation of these effects predicted by relativity and enhance our understanding of gravity's influence on spacetime.
Hulse-Taylor Binary: The Hulse-Taylor binary refers to a pair of neutron stars, PSR B1913+16, that orbit each other, providing a natural laboratory for testing the predictions of general relativity. Discovered by Russell Hulse and Joseph Taylor in 1974, this system has been pivotal in confirming the existence of gravitational waves and supporting key aspects of modern physics.
Lense-Thirring Effect: The Lense-Thirring effect refers to the phenomenon where a rotating massive body, such as Earth, drags the spacetime around it as it spins. This effect is a key prediction of general relativity and highlights how mass and rotation can influence the motion of nearby objects, particularly affecting satellites in orbit. Understanding this effect helps confirm the predictions of relativity through modern experiments and observations.
Lunar laser ranging: Lunar laser ranging is a precise measurement technique used to determine the distance between the Earth and the Moon by reflecting laser beams off retroreflectors left on the lunar surface during the Apollo missions. This method has provided key evidence supporting various aspects of modern physics, particularly in confirming the predictions of general relativity.
Neutron stars: Neutron stars are incredibly dense remnants of massive stars that have undergone a supernova explosion, collapsing under their own gravity. Composed mainly of neutrons, these stars exhibit extreme physical properties such as strong magnetic fields and rapid rotation. The unique characteristics of neutron stars have important implications in understanding gravitational time dilation, applications in advanced technologies, and modern experimental confirmations of relativistic physics.
PSR J0737-3039A/B: PSR J0737-3039A/B is a binary pulsar system located approximately 2,400 light-years from Earth, consisting of two neutron stars. It is significant because it provides a unique laboratory for testing general relativity and exploring the nature of gravity in extreme conditions due to its precise timing and strong gravitational interactions.
Pulsars: Pulsars are highly magnetized, rotating neutron stars that emit beams of electromagnetic radiation out of their magnetic poles. These beams are observed as pulses when they sweep across the Earth, similar to a lighthouse beam, due to the star's rapid rotation. Pulsars play a significant role in understanding fundamental physics and astrophysical phenomena, including the study of extreme states of matter and the testing of general relativity.
Shapiro Delay: Shapiro delay is the phenomenon where light takes longer to travel near a massive object due to the curvature of spacetime caused by that object's gravity. This effect demonstrates how gravity can influence the path of light, leading to measurable delays that have practical applications in navigation systems and astrophysical observations.
Spacetime curvature: Spacetime curvature is a fundamental concept in general relativity that describes how the presence of mass and energy causes the fabric of spacetime to bend or curve. This curvature affects the motion of objects, causing them to follow paths called geodesics, which are the equivalent of straight lines in curved space. The degree of curvature depends on the mass and energy content of a region, highlighting the relationship between gravity and the geometry of spacetime.
Strong equivalence principle: The strong equivalence principle states that the effects of gravity are locally indistinguishable from acceleration, meaning that in a small enough region of space and time, the laws of physics are the same for all observers, regardless of their state of motion. This principle extends the weak equivalence principle by asserting that not only does gravity affect mass, but it also influences all forms of energy and momentum, leading to profound implications in the understanding of gravity and spacetime.
Time dilation: Time dilation is a phenomenon predicted by the theory of relativity, where time is observed to pass at different rates for observers in different frames of reference. This effect becomes significant at high velocities or in strong gravitational fields, leading to consequences such as the differences in aging between twins and the way we perceive simultaneous events.
Very long baseline interferometry: Very long baseline interferometry (VLBI) is an advanced astronomical technique that utilizes multiple radio telescopes located at great distances from each other to observe astronomical objects. By synchronizing the data collected from these telescopes, VLBI enables researchers to achieve high-resolution imaging and precise measurements of celestial phenomena. This method is crucial for confirming aspects of relativistic theories, especially those related to the behavior of light and gravitational waves.