11.3 Comparative linguistics
9 min read•august 21, 2024
investigates language relationships and evolution, providing crucial insights into cognitive processes underlying language. By examining similarities and differences across languages, this field reveals how languages develop and diverge over time, informing theories of acquisition and processing.
The systematically reconstructs earlier language stages and establishes . Through analysis of , vocabulary, and grammatical structures, researchers uncover patterns of language change and gain understanding of historical linguistic processes.
Origins of comparative linguistics
- Comparative linguistics emerged as a systematic approach to studying language relationships and evolution
- This field forms a crucial foundation for understanding language development and structure in the context of Psychology of Language
- Comparative methods reveal insights into cognitive processes underlying language acquisition and use
Historical development
Top images from around the web for Historical development
Greek and Latin Roots: Part I – Latin – Open Textbook View original
Is this image relevant?
§4. The Indo-European Family of Languages – Greek and Latin Roots: Part I – Latin View original
Is this image relevant?
Read Strategically: Diversify Your Vocabulary | Writing Skills Lab View original
Is this image relevant?
Greek and Latin Roots: Part I – Latin – Open Textbook View original
Is this image relevant?
§4. The Indo-European Family of Languages – Greek and Latin Roots: Part I – Latin View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Historical development
Greek and Latin Roots: Part I – Latin – Open Textbook View original
Is this image relevant?
§4. The Indo-European Family of Languages – Greek and Latin Roots: Part I – Latin View original
Is this image relevant?
Read Strategically: Diversify Your Vocabulary | Writing Skills Lab View original
Is this image relevant?
Greek and Latin Roots: Part I – Latin – Open Textbook View original
Is this image relevant?
§4. The Indo-European Family of Languages – Greek and Latin Roots: Part I – Latin View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Originated in the late 18th century with the discovery of similarities between Sanskrit, Greek, and Latin
- Gained momentum in the 19th century as scholars applied scientific methods to language study
- Evolved from focusing solely on languages to encompassing a global perspective
- Influenced by advances in philology, leading to more rigorous comparative techniques
Key figures and contributions
- Sir William Jones proposed the existence of a common ancestor for Sanskrit, Greek, and Latin in 1786
- Jacob Grimm formulated Grimm's Law, explaining systematic sound changes in Germanic languages
- August Schleicher developed the for representing language relationships
- Antoine Meillet expanded comparative methods to include social and cultural factors in language change
Principles of language comparison
- Language comparison involves analyzing similarities and differences across languages to understand their relationships
- This process illuminates how languages evolve and diverge over time, informing theories of language acquisition and processing
- Comparative principles provide a framework for investigating universal and language-specific cognitive mechanisms
Genetic relationships
- Based on the concept of languages descending from a common ancestor ()
- Identified through systematic similarities in vocabulary, grammar, and sound systems
- Represented using family trees or more complex models ()
- Genetic relationships reveal patterns of historical population movements and cultural interactions
Typological similarities
- Focus on structural features shared across languages, regardless of historical connections
- Include word order patterns (Subject-Object-Verb, Subject-Verb-Object)
- Examine morphological characteristics (agglutinative, fusional, isolating)
- Analyze phonological features (tonal systems, consonant clusters)
Areal influences
- Result from language contact and geographical proximity
- Lead to shared features among unrelated or distantly related languages
- Include borrowed words, sounds, or grammatical structures
- Form linguistic areas or Sprachbunds (Balkan Sprachbund)
Comparative method
- Systematic approach to reconstructing earlier stages of languages and establishing genetic relationships
- Crucial for understanding language evolution and the cognitive processes involved in language change
- Provides insights into historical sound changes and semantic shifts
Sound correspondences
- Regular patterns of sound differences between related languages
- Reflect systematic changes that occurred during language evolution
- Identified by comparing across languages
- Used to reconstruct proto-sounds and establish genetic relationships
Reconstruction of proto-languages
- Process of inferring the characteristics of ancestral languages
- Based on systematic comparisons of descendant languages
- Involves reconstructing phonology, morphology, syntax, and vocabulary
- Utilizes the principle of economy to propose the most likely ancestral forms
Family trees vs wave models
- Family tree model represents language relationships as branching diagrams
- Assumes clear-cut divisions between languages and discrete splitting events
- Wave model depicts language change as spreading outward from innovation centers
- Accounts for gradual transitions and ongoing mutual influences between languages
Lexical comparison
- Involves analyzing vocabulary similarities and differences across languages
- Provides insights into historical relationships, cultural contact, and cognitive categorization
- Informs theories of lexical acquisition and semantic processing in language psychology
Cognates and loanwords
- Cognates are words with a common etymological origin (night, Nacht, nuit)
- are borrowed from one language into another (sushi, algebra, robot)
- Distinguish between true cognates and false friends (similar form, different meaning)
- Analyze patterns of borrowing to understand cultural and linguistic influences
Basic vocabulary lists
- Compilations of core vocabulary items assumed to be resistant to borrowing
- Swadesh list is a widely used example with 100-200 words
- Include terms for body parts, natural phenomena, and basic actions
- Used in comparative studies to assess language relationships and divergence times
Glottochronology
- Controversial method for dating language divergence based on vocabulary retention rates
- Assumes a constant rate of basic vocabulary change over time
- Calculates divergence times using percentage of shared cognates
- Criticized for oversimplifying complex processes of language change
Phonological comparison
- Examines sound systems and patterns across languages to identify relationships and universal tendencies
- Provides insights into speech perception and production mechanisms in language psychology
- Reveals how different languages organize and utilize phonological features
Sound changes and laws
- Systematic alterations in pronunciation that occur over time
- Include processes like assimilation, dissimilation, and metathesis
- Grimm's Law describes consonant shifts in Germanic languages
- Verner's Law accounts for exceptions to Grimm's Law based on stress patterns
Phoneme inventories
- Sets of distinctive sound units used in a language
- Vary in size and composition across languages (Rotokas has 11 phonemes, !Xóõ has over 100)
- Often display implicational universals (presence of /g/ implies presence of /k/)
- Reflect cognitive constraints on speech perception and production
Prosodic features
- Suprasegmental elements of speech (stress, tone, intonation)
- Vary significantly across languages in their use and function
- Include tonal systems (Mandarin Chinese), pitch accent (Japanese), and stress patterns (English)
- Interact with syntactic and semantic aspects of language
Morphological comparison
- Analyzes word structure and formation processes across languages
- Reveals cognitive strategies for encoding grammatical information and creating new words
- Informs theories of morphological processing and representation in language psychology
Word formation patterns
- Processes used to create new words or modify existing ones
- Include affixation, compounding, and internal modification
- Vary in productivity and prevalence across languages
- Reflect cognitive principles of information packaging and processing
Inflectional vs derivational morphology
- modifies words to express (tense, number, case)
- creates new words or changes word class
- Languages differ in their reliance on inflectional vs derivational processes
- Agglutinative languages (Turkish) use extensive inflectional morphology
Grammatical categories
- Linguistic features that express various semantic and syntactic functions
- Include tense, aspect, mood, person, number, gender, and case
- Vary in their presence and expression across languages
- Reflect cognitive categorizations of time, space, and social relationships
Syntactic comparison
- Examines sentence structure and word order patterns across languages
- Provides insights into universal principles of grammar and language-specific variations
- Informs theories of sentence processing and production in language psychology
Word order typology
- Classification of languages based on the order of subject, object, and verb
- Six possible orders (SVO, SOV, VSO, VOS, OVS, OSV) with varying frequencies
- English uses SVO order, Japanese uses SOV order
- Word order correlates with other syntactic features (prepositions vs postpositions)
Alignment systems
- Ways languages mark the relationships between subjects and objects
- Include nominative-accusative, ergative-absolutive, and active-stative systems
- Affect case marking, verb agreement, and syntactic constructions
- Reflect different cognitive strategies for encoding event participants
Clause structure
- Organization of elements within sentences and subordinate clauses
- Includes patterns of embedding, coordination, and subordination
- Varies in complexity and prevalence across languages
- Reveals cognitive constraints on sentence processing and production
Semantic comparison
- Analyzes meaning structures and relationships across languages
- Provides insights into conceptual organization and cultural influences on language
- Informs theories of semantic processing and representation in language psychology
Semantic fields
- Groups of words related by a common conceptual domain
- Vary in organization and boundaries across languages
- Color terms differ in number and categorization (basic color terms theory)
- Kinship terms reflect cultural variations in family structure and relationships
Metaphor and metonymy
- Cognitive mechanisms for extending meaning through comparison or association
- Vary in their specific manifestations across languages and cultures
- Conceptual metaphors (ARGUMENT IS WAR) may have universal and culture-specific aspects
- Reveal cognitive strategies for understanding abstract concepts through concrete experiences
Conceptual universals
- Semantic categories or structures believed to be shared across all languages
- Include basic ontological categories (object, action, property)
- Proposed universal semantic primes (Wierzbicka's Natural Semantic Metalanguage)
- Reflect potential innate cognitive structures or shared human experiences
Applications in language classification
- Utilizes comparative methods to group languages into families and subgroups
- Provides a framework for understanding language diversity and historical relationships
- Informs theories of language evolution and cognitive diversity in language psychology
Language families
- Groups of genetically related languages descended from a common ancestor
- Major families include Indo-European, , and Niger-Congo
- Vary in size, time depth, and degree of internal diversity
- Reflect historical patterns of population movement and cultural contact
Isolates and unclassified languages
- are languages with no demonstrable genetic relationships (Basque)
- lack sufficient data for reliable classification
- May represent remnants of earlier or unique linguistic developments
- Challenge assumptions about universal patterns of language relationships
Controversial groupings
- Proposed language families or relationships lacking widespread acceptance
- Include macro-families like Nostratic or Amerind
- Altaic hypothesis (grouping Turkic, Mongolic, and Tungusic languages) remains debated
- Reflect challenges in distinguishing deep genetic relationships from
Comparative linguistics and other disciplines
- Comparative linguistics intersects with various fields, enhancing our understanding of language and cognition
- This interdisciplinary approach provides a broader context for language study in psychology
- Integration of multiple perspectives enriches theories of language acquisition, processing, and use
Historical linguistics
- Focuses on language change over time and reconstruction of earlier language stages
- Utilizes comparative methods to trace sound changes and semantic shifts
- Informs theories of language evolution and historical
- Provides insights into cognitive mechanisms underlying language change
Anthropological linguistics
- Examines relationships between language, culture, and society
- Utilizes comparative data to explore linguistic relativity and universals
- Investigates connections between language structure and cultural practices
- Informs theories of cultural cognition and language socialization
Cognitive linguistics
- Studies relationships between language, mind, and embodied experience
- Applies comparative insights to investigate conceptual metaphors and image schemas
- Explores cross-linguistic variations in spatial language and event conceptualization
- Informs theories of embodied cognition and cognitive semantics
Challenges and limitations
- Comparative linguistics faces various obstacles in its pursuit of understanding language relationships
- These challenges highlight the complexity of language as a cognitive and social phenomenon
- Addressing these limitations requires innovative methodologies and interdisciplinary approaches
Data scarcity
- Many languages lack comprehensive documentation or historical records
- Extinct languages often have limited available data for comparison
- Uneven distribution of data across language families and geographical regions
- Challenges in reconstructing proto-languages and establishing distant relationships
Language contact effects
- Borrowing and areal influences can obscure genetic relationships
- Difficulty in distinguishing inherited features from contact-induced similarities
- Creole languages pose challenges for traditional comparative methods
- Requires integration of sociolinguistic and historical data in comparative analyses
Methodological debates
- Disagreements over the validity of long-range comparison methods
- Controversies surrounding and lexicostatistics
- Debates over the appropriateness of tree models vs wave models for language relationships
- Challenges in establishing objective criteria for language classification
Modern approaches
- Contemporary comparative linguistics incorporates new technologies and interdisciplinary perspectives
- These approaches enhance the precision and scope of language comparison studies
- Modern methods provide new insights into cognitive aspects of language structure and change
Computational methods
- Utilize algorithms and statistical models for language comparison and classification
- Include phylogenetic methods borrowed from evolutionary biology
- Employ machine learning techniques for pattern recognition in linguistic data
- Enable analysis of large-scale datasets and testing of complex hypotheses
Quantitative techniques
- Apply statistical methods to assess language relationships and structural patterns
- Include Bayesian inference for dating language divergences
- Utilize network analysis to model complex language relationships
- Provide more rigorous evaluations of proposed language groupings and universal tendencies
Interdisciplinary perspectives
- Integrate insights from genetics, archaeology, and cognitive science
- Correlate linguistic data with population genetics to trace language spread
- Incorporate neurolinguistic findings to inform theories of language processing and change
- Explore connections between linguistic diversity and cognitive diversity
Key Terms to Review (44)
Alignment Systems: Alignment systems refer to the mechanisms in language that enable speakers to synchronize their speech, gestures, and other communicative behaviors during interactions. This synchronization helps establish a shared understanding between participants and enhances the effectiveness of communication, particularly in contexts where meaning is negotiated.
Areal influences: Areal influences refer to the effects that geographical proximity and interaction between different languages and cultures have on one another, leading to similarities in vocabulary, grammar, and phonetics. These influences occur when languages are spoken in close proximity, resulting in borrowing and shared linguistic features that can shape the development of these languages over time.
Clause structure: Clause structure refers to the way in which clauses are formed and organized within sentences, encompassing the arrangement of subjects, predicates, and objects. Understanding clause structure is crucial for analyzing sentence complexity, syntactic variation, and how different languages express similar ideas through varying grammatical frameworks.
Cognates: Cognates are words in different languages that have a common etymological origin, meaning they are derived from the same ancestral word. They often share similar meanings and forms across languages, making them a key concept in understanding language relationships and linguistic evolution. Recognizing cognates can also facilitate bilingual communication and help in language acquisition, as they create links between known and unknown vocabulary.
Comparative linguistics: Comparative linguistics is the scientific study of the similarities and differences between languages in order to understand their historical relationships and developments. This field focuses on reconstructing ancient languages, establishing language families, and examining the evolution of phonetic, grammatical, and lexical features across different languages.
Comparative method: The comparative method is a research approach used in linguistics to compare languages in order to establish their historical relationships and to understand how they have evolved over time. By systematically analyzing similarities and differences between languages, this method helps linguists reconstruct aspects of ancient languages and trace language change through time, revealing insights about language families and the processes involved in linguistic evolution.
Computational methods: Computational methods refer to a set of mathematical and algorithmic techniques used to analyze, model, and interpret linguistic data, often through the use of computer software. These methods are essential in comparative linguistics, as they enable researchers to systematically investigate language structures and relationships across different languages, providing insights into historical language development and linguistic patterns.
Conceptual universals: Conceptual universals are the underlying cognitive structures and principles that are common across different languages and cultures, shaping how people think and communicate. These universals suggest that despite linguistic diversity, there are shared conceptual frameworks that influence meaning-making and understanding in human communication.
Controversial groupings: Controversial groupings refer to classifications or categorizations of languages that provoke debate among linguists, often due to differing interpretations of linguistic features, genetic relationships, or cultural contexts. These groupings can result in contentious discussions regarding the historical and structural connections between languages, as well as their sociolinguistic implications.
Derivational morphology: Derivational morphology is the process of creating new words by adding prefixes or suffixes to base words, changing their meanings or grammatical categories. This process is vital in understanding how language evolves and how new terms are formed, allowing for a rich diversity in vocabulary and expression.
Dialectology: Dialectology is the scientific study of regional dialects and variations in language, focusing on how these dialects differ in pronunciation, grammar, and vocabulary. This field examines the social and geographical factors that contribute to these variations and helps to understand how language evolves over time.
Family Tree Model: The family tree model is a way to represent the historical relationships between languages, illustrating how they have evolved from common ancestors over time. This model emphasizes the branching nature of language development, similar to a family tree showing lineage and descent, where each branch represents a different language that has diverged from its parent language.
Ferdinand de Saussure: Ferdinand de Saussure was a Swiss linguist whose ideas laid the foundation for many significant developments in modern linguistics, particularly in the study of language structure and meaning. His work emphasized the importance of understanding language as a system of signs, where the relationship between signifiers (the form of a word) and signifieds (the concept it represents) is arbitrary. Saussure's theories are crucial for comparative linguistics, as they provide a framework for analyzing how different languages relate to one another.
Generative grammar: Generative grammar is a theory of grammar that aims to describe the implicit knowledge that speakers of a language possess, allowing them to generate and understand an infinite number of sentences. This approach emphasizes the underlying structure of language and how it can be systematically generated from a limited set of rules or principles, revealing the deep connections between different languages and their structures.
Genetic relationships: Genetic relationships refer to the connections and similarities between languages that arise from a common ancestral language. These relationships help linguists understand how different languages have evolved over time, leading to classifications of language families based on shared features, vocabulary, and grammatical structures.
Glottochronology: Glottochronology is a method used to estimate the time of divergence between languages by analyzing their vocabulary changes over time. It operates on the assumption that languages change at a consistent rate and allows linguists to infer how long ago two languages branched off from a common ancestor. This technique is integral to comparative linguistics, as it aids in understanding language evolution and relationships.
Grammatical categories: Grammatical categories are features of language that convey grammatical information about nouns, verbs, adjectives, and other parts of speech. These categories help to classify words and determine their syntactic and morphological behavior within sentences, impacting meaning and structure across languages.
Historical linguistics: Historical linguistics is the branch of linguistics that studies the development and evolution of languages over time. It focuses on understanding how languages change, the relationships between different languages, and the processes that lead to linguistic divergence and convergence. This field is crucial for comparative linguistics, which compares languages to reconstruct their histories and establish connections among them.
Indo-European: Indo-European refers to a large family of languages that are spoken across Europe and parts of Asia, originating from a common ancestral language known as Proto-Indo-European. This language family includes many modern languages such as English, Spanish, Russian, and Hindi, highlighting the historical connections and shared characteristics among these diverse languages.
Inflectional morphology: Inflectional morphology is the study of how words change form to express different grammatical categories, such as tense, number, mood, and case. This type of morphology focuses on the modifications made to a base form of a word to fit into specific grammatical contexts, which is crucial for understanding the structure and function of language in communication. Inflectional changes can signal important information about the relationships between words in a sentence and help convey nuanced meanings.
Isolates: Isolates are languages that have no known relation to any other languages, meaning they do not belong to any language family. These unique languages often stand alone in terms of their linguistic features and structures, making them particularly interesting in the study of language development and evolution.
Language death: Language death occurs when a language loses its last native speakers and ceases to be used in daily communication. This phenomenon often results from factors like cultural assimilation, globalization, and the dominance of more widely spoken languages, leading to significant impacts on cultural identity and heritage.
Language families: Language families are groups of languages that share a common ancestral language, known as a proto-language. These families categorize languages based on their historical and structural relationships, allowing linguists to trace the evolution of languages over time and understand their similarities and differences.
Linguistic divergence: Linguistic divergence refers to the process by which languages evolve and become increasingly different from one another over time, often due to factors such as geographical separation, social interactions, and cultural influences. This phenomenon leads to the development of distinct dialects or languages that can trace their roots back to a common ancestor. Understanding linguistic divergence is essential for exploring how languages adapt and change in response to various social and environmental factors.
Loanwords: Loanwords are words that are borrowed from one language and incorporated into another, often with little or no modification in form. This linguistic phenomenon reflects cultural exchange and the influence of one language on another, showcasing how languages evolve over time as they come into contact with each other through trade, migration, and globalization.
Metaphor and metonymy: Metaphor and metonymy are two significant figures of speech that help in understanding and expressing complex ideas through simpler terms. A metaphor involves comparing two unrelated things by stating that one is the other, while metonymy refers to substituting the name of one thing with the name of something closely associated with it. Both concepts play a critical role in comparative linguistics as they provide insights into how different languages and cultures use language to convey meaning.
Morphological analysis: Morphological analysis is the study of the structure and formation of words by examining their smallest meaningful units, called morphemes. This approach helps in understanding how different languages construct words and how those structures relate to each other, making it a crucial aspect in comparative linguistics. By breaking down words into their components, researchers can identify patterns and similarities across languages, revealing insights into their historical and functional relationships.
Noam Chomsky: Noam Chomsky is a renowned linguist, cognitive scientist, and philosopher, widely considered the father of modern linguistics. His groundbreaking theories on language acquisition and structure have profoundly influenced our understanding of how humans learn language and the innate capacities that facilitate this process.
Phoneme Inventories: Phoneme inventories refer to the complete set of phonemes that a language uses to create distinct sounds and meanings. Each language has its unique phoneme inventory, which plays a crucial role in its phonology, the study of how sounds function within that language. Understanding these inventories allows linguists to compare languages, identify patterns, and explore the ways in which different languages structure their sound systems.
Phonetic change: Phonetic change refers to the alteration in the sounds of a language over time, which can occur through various processes such as assimilation, dissimilation, and lenition. These changes can affect how words are pronounced and lead to differences in phonemes, impacting communication and language evolution. Understanding phonetic change is crucial for examining how languages transform and influence each other through time and across different cultures.
Prosodic features: Prosodic features refer to the vocal elements that accompany speech, including intonation, stress, rhythm, and tone. These features play a crucial role in conveying meaning beyond just the words themselves, as they can indicate emotions, attitudes, and emphasis within spoken language.
Proto-language: A proto-language is a hypothetical, reconstructed ancestral language from which a group of related languages is derived. It serves as the common root of a language family and is identified through comparative linguistics, which examines similarities and systematic differences among languages to trace their evolution and development over time.
Quantitative techniques: Quantitative techniques refer to systematic methods used to analyze numerical data and derive meaningful insights through statistical analysis. These techniques play a vital role in comparing linguistic features across languages, allowing researchers to assess similarities and differences in a structured way. They provide a foundation for rigorous scientific research in comparative linguistics, facilitating the development of theories regarding language evolution and relationships.
Reconstruction of proto-languages: The reconstruction of proto-languages is the method used by linguists to hypothesize about the features of a common ancestor language from which related languages have evolved. This process involves analyzing similarities and differences among languages to infer the phonetics, grammar, and vocabulary of these ancestral forms. Understanding proto-languages is crucial for comparative linguistics as it helps in tracing the historical development and relationships between languages.
Semantic fields: Semantic fields refer to a set of words or expressions that share a common meaning or are related in some way, often representing a specific concept or category. This grouping helps us understand how language functions and how different words interact with each other to convey nuanced meanings, especially when comparing languages or analyzing linguistic structures.
Sino-Tibetan: The Sino-Tibetan language family is a large and diverse group of languages primarily spoken in East Asia, Southeast Asia, and parts of South Asia. This family includes over 400 languages, with Mandarin Chinese being the most widely spoken. The classification of Sino-Tibetan languages is significant in comparative linguistics as it highlights the historical and structural relationships among these languages.
Sociolinguistics: Sociolinguistics is the study of how language varies and changes in social contexts, examining the relationship between language and society. It explores how factors like region, class, gender, and ethnicity influence language use and perception, shedding light on social identity and cultural norms.
Sound correspondences: Sound correspondences are systematic relationships between sounds in different languages or dialects, where a particular sound in one language consistently matches a particular sound in another language. This concept is essential for understanding how languages evolve and relate to each other, particularly in the study of historical linguistics and comparative analysis.
Structuralism: Structuralism is an intellectual movement that emerged in the early 20th century, focusing on understanding language and culture as systems of signs and structures that shape human experience. By analyzing the underlying structures that govern communication, structuralism seeks to uncover the rules and patterns that define meaning in language, highlighting the relationships between words, sounds, and meanings rather than the individual components themselves.
Typology: Typology refers to the systematic classification of languages based on their structural features and the relationships among them. It focuses on categorizing languages into different types according to shared characteristics, such as word order, morphological structure, and phonological patterns, allowing researchers to understand the diversity and similarities across languages.
Unclassified languages: Unclassified languages are those that cannot be definitively categorized into any established language family due to a lack of clear relationships with other languages. This situation arises when a language's origins, historical connections, or structural features are not adequately understood, making it challenging to link them to known linguistic groups.
Universal Grammar: Universal Grammar is a theory that suggests the ability to acquire language is innate to humans and that all languages share a common underlying structure. This concept implies that regardless of the specific language being learned, there are fundamental principles and rules inherent in the human brain that facilitate language acquisition. This perspective highlights not only the cognitive capabilities necessary for language development but also offers insights into the nature of language itself, suggesting deep connections across diverse languages.
Wave model: The wave model is a theoretical framework used in linguistics to describe how languages spread and change over time, likening the process to waves that radiate out from a source. This model emphasizes the idea that language variations and changes emerge from a central point and propagate outward, affecting surrounding linguistic communities in a ripple effect.
Word order typology: Word order typology refers to the systematic study of the different ways that languages organize the arrangement of words in sentences. This typological classification typically focuses on the positions of the subject, verb, and object within a sentence and identifies common patterns across languages, which can influence syntactic structure and meaning.