💸Principles of Economics Unit 12 – Environmental Protection & Negative Externalities

Key Concepts

• Environmental economics studies the economic impact of environmental policies and the effect of economic activity on the environment
• Negative externalities occur when the actions of an individual or firm impose costs on a third party (air pollution from a factory)
• Market failure arises when the market fails to allocate resources efficiently, often due to externalities or public goods
• Command-and-control regulations involve direct regulation of behavior, such as emissions standards or technology requirements
• Market-based policies use economic incentives to encourage desired behavior (emissions taxes, tradable permits)
• Cost-benefit analysis weighs the costs and benefits of a policy or project to determine its net impact on social welfare
  • Involves monetizing costs and benefits, including non-market values (health, ecosystem services)
• Sustainability focuses on meeting current needs without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their needs

Environmental Challenges

• Air pollution from industrial emissions, transportation, and energy production contributes to respiratory illnesses and climate change
• Water pollution from agricultural runoff, industrial waste, and sewage threatens aquatic ecosystems and human health
  • Eutrophication occurs when excess nutrients stimulate algal blooms, depleting oxygen and creating "dead zones"
• Deforestation driven by agriculture, logging, and urbanization leads to biodiversity loss, soil erosion, and climate change
• Overfishing has depleted many fish stocks, disrupting marine food webs and threatening the livelihoods of fishing communities
• Climate change, largely driven by greenhouse gas emissions, leads to rising sea levels, more extreme weather events, and shifts in ecosystems
  • Poses risks to agriculture, infrastructure, and human health
• Plastic pollution accumulates in the environment, harming wildlife and potentially entering the food chain
• Invasive species introduced through global trade and travel can disrupt native ecosystems and cause economic damage

Market Failure and Externalities

• Externalities arise when the actions of an individual or firm affect the well-being of a third party not involved in the transaction
  • Negative externalities (pollution) impose costs on society, while positive externalities (education) provide benefits
• In the presence of externalities, market prices do not reflect the full social costs or benefits of a good or activity
• Negative externalities lead to overproduction and overconsumption of the good, as the market price is lower than the social cost
  • Example: A factory that pollutes a river does not bear the full cost of its actions, leading to more pollution than is socially optimal
• Positive externalities lead to underproduction and underconsumption, as the market price does not capture the full social benefits
• Public goods, such as clean air and national defense, are non-excludable and non-rival, leading to free-rider problems and underprovision by the market
• Information asymmetries, where one party has more information than the other, can also lead to market failures (adverse selection, moral hazard)

Policy Instruments

• Command-and-control regulations directly regulate behavior through standards, bans, or technology requirements
  • Examples include emissions standards for vehicles, energy efficiency standards for appliances, and bans on certain chemicals
• Market-based policies use economic incentives to encourage desired behavior and discourage undesired behavior
• Pigouvian taxes (named after economist Arthur Pigou) are taxes on activities that generate negative externalities, designed to internalize the external cost
  • An emissions tax on a polluting factory would force it to consider the full social cost of its actions
• Subsidies can be used to encourage activities that generate positive externalities, such as renewable energy or research and development
• Tradable permits, also known as cap-and-trade systems, set a total limit on emissions and allow firms to trade permits among themselves
  • Firms with low abatement costs can reduce emissions and sell permits to firms with high abatement costs
• Voluntary agreements and information disclosure can also play a role in environmental policy (eco-labeling, corporate social responsibility)
• Property rights and legal liability can be used to address environmental issues (assigning property rights to fisheries, holding polluters liable for damages)

Cost-Benefit Analysis

• Cost-benefit analysis (CBA) is a tool for evaluating the net social impact of a policy or project by comparing its costs and benefits
• Involves identifying and quantifying all relevant costs and benefits, including both market and non-market values
  • Market values have observable prices (construction costs, fuel savings), while non-market values do not (health benefits, ecosystem services)
• Costs and benefits occurring in the future are discounted to present values using a discount rate that reflects time preferences and opportunity costs
• Challenges in CBA include monetizing non-market values, selecting an appropriate discount rate, and dealing with uncertainty and distributional impacts
• Sensitivity analysis tests how results change with different assumptions about key parameters
• CBA can inform decision-making but should not be the sole basis for policy choices, as it has limitations and involves value judgments
  • Other considerations include equity, sustainability, and precautionary principles

Case Studies

• The US Acid Rain Program, a cap-and-trade system for sulfur dioxide emissions, has successfully reduced acid rain at a lower cost than traditional regulations
• The Montreal Protocol, an international treaty to phase out ozone-depleting substances, has helped the ozone layer recover
  • Demonstrates the potential for global cooperation on environmental issues
• The EU Emissions Trading System, the world's largest cap-and-trade program for greenhouse gases, has had mixed results due to oversupply of permits and low prices
• China's National Sword policy, which restricted imports of certain recyclable materials, disrupted global recycling markets and highlighted the need for improved domestic recycling
• The Flint water crisis in Michigan, caused by a switch to a corrosive water source, underscores the importance of safe drinking water infrastructure and environmental justice
• The Deepwater Horizon oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico demonstrates the risks of offshore drilling and the challenges of holding polluters accountable
• The Paris Agreement, a global accord to limit climate change, relies on voluntary commitments and has faced challenges in implementation

Global Perspectives

• Environmental issues cross national boundaries and require international cooperation to address effectively
• The principle of common but differentiated responsibilities recognizes that countries have contributed differently to environmental problems and have different capacities to address them
  • Calls for developed countries to take the lead in reducing emissions and providing support to developing countries
• The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) provides a forum for international negotiations on climate change
  • The Kyoto Protocol and Paris Agreement are key milestones in global climate policy
• The Basel Convention regulates the transboundary movement and disposal of hazardous waste
• The Convention on Biological Diversity aims to conserve biodiversity, sustainably use its components, and share benefits from genetic resources
• International trade can have both positive and negative environmental impacts (scale, composition, and technique effects)
  • Trade agreements increasingly incorporate environmental provisions
• Environmental justice recognizes that environmental harms and benefits are often distributed unequally across different communities and countries

Future Trends and Innovations

• The transition to a low-carbon economy will require significant changes in energy systems, transportation, and land use
  • Renewable energy technologies (solar, wind, hydro) are becoming increasingly cost-competitive with fossil fuels
• Energy storage solutions (batteries, pumped hydro) can help integrate variable renewable energy sources into the grid
• Smart grids and demand response can improve energy efficiency and reduce peak demand
• Electric vehicles are gaining market share and have the potential to reduce transportation emissions, especially when powered by clean electricity
• Circular economy approaches aim to minimize waste and keep materials in use through reuse, repair, and recycling
  • Examples include product-as-a-service models, industrial symbiosis, and closed-loop supply chains
• Nature-based solutions, such as reforestation and wetland restoration, can provide both environmental and social benefits
• Precision agriculture uses data and technology to optimize inputs and reduce environmental impacts
• Sustainable finance, including green bonds and ESG investing, can channel capital towards environmentally friendly projects and companies