1.3 Key Concepts and Theories in Multinational Management
5 min read•july 31, 2024
Multinational management involves navigating complex global business environments. Key concepts include , , and international business theories. These frameworks help managers make decisions on , , and in diverse cultural contexts.
Understanding and global patterns is crucial for multinational managers. Classical and explain why countries trade and how competitive advantages arise. These insights guide decisions on market selection, sourcing strategies, and production location choices in the global marketplace.
Global Strategy for Multinationals
Strategic Approaches and Components
Top images from around the web for Strategic Approaches and Components
Creating Strategy: Common Approaches | Boundless Management View original
Is this image relevant?
Stages and Types of Strategy | Principles of Management View original
Is this image relevant?
Strategic Opportunity Matrix | Principles of Marketing View original
Is this image relevant?
Creating Strategy: Common Approaches | Boundless Management View original
Is this image relevant?
Stages and Types of Strategy | Principles of Management View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Strategic Approaches and Components
Creating Strategy: Common Approaches | Boundless Management View original
Is this image relevant?
Stages and Types of Strategy | Principles of Management View original
Is this image relevant?
Strategic Opportunity Matrix | Principles of Marketing View original
Is this image relevant?
Creating Strategy: Common Approaches | Boundless Management View original
Is this image relevant?
Stages and Types of Strategy | Principles of Management View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Global strategy guides organizations in competing and expanding operations worldwide by integrating and coordinating activities across national boundaries
- Primary goal achieves sustainable competitive advantage in global marketplace through economies of scale, scope, and learning
- Key components include market selection, entry mode choices, and configuration/coordination of value chain activities across borders
- Global integration and local responsiveness shape firm's global strategy, leading to different approaches (global, multidomestic, transnational, international)
- Standardization vs. adaptation decisions crucial for product offerings and marketing strategies (McDonald's adapts menu items to local tastes while maintaining global brand identity)
- Management of global supply chains requires coordination of sourcing, production, and distribution across multiple countries (Apple's global supply chain spans dozens of countries)
- Development of global innovation capabilities involves leveraging diverse knowledge sources and talent pools worldwide (Procter & Gamble's "Connect and Develop" open innovation strategy)
Challenges and Implications
- Cultural differences impact management practices and communication styles across global operations (Japanese companies often emphasize consensus-building, while American firms may prioritize individual decision-making)
- Diverse political and legal environments necessitate adapting business practices to comply with local regulations (Google's challenges in operating in China due to censorship laws)
- Balancing global efficiency with local market needs requires careful consideration of centralization vs. decentralization (Unilever's "local for local" strategy in emerging markets)
- Currency fluctuations and exchange rate risks affect pricing strategies and profitability of international operations (hedging strategies used by multinational corporations)
- Managing global talent pools involves addressing issues of expatriate assignments, cross-cultural training, and developing local leadership (HSBC's international manager program)
- Ethical considerations in global operations include dealing with varying labor standards and environmental regulations across countries (Nike's efforts to improve labor practices in its global supply chain)
Cultural Dimensions in International Business
Hofstede's Cultural Dimensions
- Geert Hofstede's model widely recognized framework for understanding and comparing national cultures
- Power distance measures extent to which less powerful members accept unequal power distribution (high in Malaysia, low in Denmark)
- Individualism vs. collectivism assesses degree of interdependence among society members (high individualism in USA, high collectivism in China)
- Masculinity vs. femininity reflects societal emphasis on achievement vs. caring (high masculinity in Japan, high femininity in Sweden)
- Uncertainty avoidance indicates society's tolerance for ambiguity and uncertainty (high in Greece, low in Singapore)
- Long-term vs. short-term orientation measures focus on future vs. present/past (long-term orientation in South Korea, short-term in Nigeria)
- Indulgence vs. restraint reflects extent to which people try to control desires and impulses (high indulgence in Brazil, high restraint in Russia)
Impact on International Business Practices
- Leadership styles vary across cultures (participative leadership more effective in low power distance cultures)
- Organizational structures influenced by cultural dimensions (hierarchical structures common in high power distance cultures)
- Negotiation tactics differ based on cultural norms (relationship-building crucial in collectivist cultures before business discussions)
- Marketing strategies require adaptation to cultural preferences (individualistic appeals effective in Western markets, group harmony emphasized in East Asian advertising)
- Cross-cultural communication strategies developed based on understanding of cultural dimensions (high-context vs. low-context communication styles)
- (CQ) emerges as critical skill for managers in diverse cultural environments
- Critics argue cultural dimension models may oversimplify complex realities and fail to account for within-country variations and subcultures
Theories for Multinational Management
Eclectic Paradigm (OLI Framework)
- Explains firm's choice of entry mode and international production based on Ownership, Location, and Internalization advantages
- Ownership advantages comprise firm-specific assets and capabilities giving competitive edge in foreign markets (brand reputation, proprietary technology)
- Location advantages include country-specific factors making it attractive to locate activities (labor costs, market size, government incentives)
- Internalization advantages determine whether firm should internalize foreign operations or use market-based mechanisms (licensing, franchising)
- Application helps managers decide on market entry strategies (wholly-owned subsidiary vs. joint venture)
- Guides resource allocation decisions across different international markets
- Informs organizational structure choices for multinational operations
Uppsala Model and Other Theories
- describes internationalization as gradual, incremental approach based on knowledge acquisition and increasing resource commitments
- Firms typically begin internationalization in psychically close markets, expanding to distant markets with experience (Swedish firms expanding first to Nordic countries)
- Emphasizes role of experiential knowledge in reducing uncertainty and driving further internationalization
- (RBV) focuses on firm-specific resources and capabilities as sources of competitive advantage (Honda's expertise in small engine technology)
- (TCE) provides insights into governance structure choices (make-or-buy decisions in international operations)
- Integration-responsiveness (I-R) framework helps balance global integration and local responsiveness pressures (Nestlé's "glocalization" strategy)
Trade Theories and Global Patterns
Classical and Neoclassical Trade Theories
- (Adam Smith) explains trade based on countries' ability to produce goods more efficiently (Portugal producing wine, England producing cloth)
- (David Ricardo) shows benefits of trade even when one country has absolute advantage in all goods (opportunity cost concept)
- considers factor endowments as basis for trade patterns (labor-abundant countries export labor-intensive goods)
- explains intra-industry trade and role of economies of scale (automobile trade between USA and Germany)
- predicts bilateral trade flows based on economic sizes and distance between trading partners (explaining high trade volumes between neighboring countries)
Modern Trade Theories and Applications
- explains national competitive advantage in specific industries (Italian competitive advantage in luxury goods and fashion)
- links product stages to patterns of international production and trade (shift of manufacturing from developed to developing countries)
- These theories inform multinational managers' decisions on market selection (identifying attractive export markets)
- Guide sourcing strategies (selecting optimal locations for production based on factor endowments)
- Influence location choices for production facilities (balancing proximity to markets with production costs)
- Limitations include assumptions of perfect competition, full employment, and factor immobility
- Real-world complexities like trade barriers, technological changes, and geopolitical factors affect global trade patterns beyond theoretical predictions
Key Terms to Review (29)
Absolute advantage: Absolute advantage refers to the ability of a country or entity to produce a good or service more efficiently than another country or entity, using fewer resources. This concept highlights how certain countries can excel in specific industries or products due to factors such as natural resources, technological advancements, or skilled labor. Understanding absolute advantage is crucial for evaluating how multinational companies can strategize their operations and expand globally.
C.K. Prahalad: C.K. Prahalad was a prominent management thinker known for his work on core competencies and the concept of the Bottom of the Pyramid (BoP) markets. His ideas emphasize the importance of leveraging a firm's unique capabilities while also addressing the needs of low-income consumers, demonstrating how businesses can profitably engage with these markets while creating social value.
Classical Trade Theories: Classical trade theories are foundational concepts in international trade that explain how countries engage in trade based on their comparative advantages. These theories emphasize the benefits of specialization and free trade, arguing that nations can enhance their economic welfare by focusing on the production of goods they can produce more efficiently than others, thereby promoting global economic growth.
Comparative Advantage: Comparative advantage is an economic theory that describes how countries or entities can benefit from specializing in the production of goods or services for which they have a lower opportunity cost than others. By focusing on their strengths, these entities can trade effectively, creating a more efficient allocation of resources and enhancing overall economic welfare in the global market.
Cross-Border Mergers: Cross-border mergers refer to the consolidation of companies from different countries, resulting in a single corporate entity. These transactions often aim to create synergies, gain access to new markets, and leverage resources across borders, playing a crucial role in the strategies of multinational corporations seeking global expansion and competitive advantage.
Cultural Dimensions: Cultural dimensions refer to the framework used to understand the differences in cultures across various societies, often used to analyze how these differences impact behavior, values, and communication styles. This concept is essential for navigating the complexities of global business, as it influences management practices, international relationships, and market strategies in diverse cultural contexts.
Cultural Intelligence: Cultural intelligence is the capability to relate and work effectively across cultures. It involves understanding the nuances of cultural differences, adapting behaviors, and leveraging these insights to foster successful interactions in a global context.
Foreign Direct Investment: Foreign direct investment (FDI) refers to an investment made by a company or individual in one country into business interests located in another country, typically involving a significant degree of control or ownership. FDI plays a crucial role in international business as it reflects the commitment of investors to a foreign market, driving economic growth and development in host countries while allowing investors to access new markets and resources.
Global functional structure: A global functional structure is an organizational framework where a multinational corporation groups its operations based on specialized functions such as marketing, finance, production, and human resources. This setup allows companies to streamline operations across various countries while maintaining a focus on functional expertise and efficiency. It enhances communication and decision-making within departments but may face challenges in coordination between different functions operating in diverse regions.
Global strategy: Global strategy refers to a plan of action that companies employ to achieve competitive advantage and operate effectively across international markets. It encompasses the decisions regarding how to compete globally, including market entry strategies, product offerings, and resource allocation, while considering factors such as local preferences and global trends. A well-defined global strategy helps multinational corporations align their operations, capitalize on economies of scale, and respond to competitive pressures in various markets.
Gravity model: The gravity model is a theoretical framework used to predict bilateral trade flows between two countries based on their economic sizes and distance apart. This model suggests that larger economies are likely to trade more with each other, while geographical distance can inhibit trade, acting like gravity pulling them closer or pushing them apart. By applying this model, multinational management can better understand market dynamics and the factors influencing international trade patterns.
Heckscher-Ohlin Model: The Heckscher-Ohlin Model is an economic theory that explains how countries export and import goods based on their factor endowments, such as labor, land, and capital. It emphasizes that a country will specialize in producing and exporting goods that utilize its abundant factors of production, while importing goods that require factors that are scarce. This model plays a significant role in understanding trade patterns and is crucial for analyzing multinational management strategies.
Henri Mintzberg: Henri Mintzberg is a prominent management theorist known for his work on organizational structure and management roles. His contributions are critical in understanding how multinational organizations operate and manage complexity across different environments. Mintzberg's frameworks emphasize the importance of managerial roles and how they influence decision-making and strategy within global firms.
Hofstede's Cultural Dimensions: Hofstede's Cultural Dimensions is a framework for understanding how cultural values influence behavior in the workplace and beyond, based on six dimensions that describe different aspects of culture. These dimensions help in navigating the complexities of global business by highlighting variations in communication styles, management practices, and organizational behavior across different cultures.
Integration-Responsiveness Framework: The integration-responsiveness framework is a strategic model used by multinational companies to balance global integration and local responsiveness in their operations. It helps firms navigate the trade-offs between standardizing products and practices across markets for efficiency and adapting them to meet local needs for effectiveness. This framework is essential for understanding how multinational organizations formulate strategies, structure their operations, and make decisions about market entry and competition.
Just-in-time production: Just-in-time production is a management strategy that aligns raw-material orders from suppliers directly with production schedules. This approach minimizes inventory costs and waste by receiving goods only as they are needed in the production process. By reducing excess inventory, companies can improve efficiency and responsiveness to changes in demand, making it a key principle in modern manufacturing and supply chain management.
Market Entry: Market entry refers to the strategy or methods used by a company to start selling its products or services in a new market. This process involves understanding local conditions, customer preferences, and competition while choosing the right mode of entry, which can include exporting, licensing, franchising, or establishing joint ventures. The success of market entry strategies relies heavily on aligning with broader business goals and forming strategic partnerships.
Matrix Structure: A matrix structure is an organizational design that creates a grid-like framework, allowing employees to report to multiple managers rather than a single supervisor. This setup promotes flexibility and collaboration, enabling organizations to efficiently allocate resources and adapt to changing business environments.
Modern Trade Theories: Modern trade theories encompass various economic frameworks that explain how and why countries engage in international trade, focusing on comparative advantages and the benefits of specialization. These theories build upon classical trade concepts by incorporating factors like economies of scale, technology, and market structures, thereby providing a more comprehensive understanding of global commerce and its implications for multinational management.
New Trade Theory: New Trade Theory is an economic concept that emphasizes the role of increasing returns to scale and network effects in international trade, suggesting that countries can benefit from specializing in certain industries regardless of their factor endowments. This theory highlights how economies of scale and market size can influence trade patterns, allowing firms to achieve lower average costs and expand their reach globally.
Organizational Structure: Organizational structure refers to the way in which a company or organization arranges its roles, responsibilities, and communication pathways to achieve its goals. It plays a critical role in defining how decisions are made, how information flows, and how employees collaborate within the organization, directly impacting efficiency and effectiveness in multinational management.
Outsourcing: Outsourcing is the practice of delegating specific business processes or functions to third-party companies, often in different countries, to reduce costs and improve efficiency. This approach allows businesses to focus on core activities while leveraging external expertise and resources, ultimately enhancing competitiveness in the global market.
Porter's Diamond Model: Porter's Diamond Model is a framework that explains why certain industries within particular nations are competitive internationally. It highlights four key factors: factor conditions, demand conditions, related and supporting industries, and firm strategy, structure, and rivalry. This model connects to important concepts in multinational management and global strategy formulation by providing insights into how national advantages can shape competitive success in international markets.
Product Life Cycle Theory: Product Life Cycle Theory describes the stages a product goes through from its introduction to the market until it is retired. This theory highlights how products evolve over time, influencing marketing strategies, sales, and profitability as they progress through various phases such as introduction, growth, maturity, and decline.
Resource Allocation: Resource allocation refers to the process of distributing available resources—such as capital, personnel, and technology—among various projects or business units to optimize efficiency and effectiveness. This involves making strategic decisions that prioritize certain initiatives over others based on organizational goals, potential returns, and risk assessments, particularly in a multinational context where diverse markets and regulations must be navigated.
Resource-based view: The resource-based view (RBV) is a management framework that emphasizes the importance of a firm's internal resources and capabilities in achieving competitive advantage. This perspective suggests that unique resources—such as intellectual property, skilled personnel, and advanced technology—are essential for a company to outperform its rivals and adapt to changing market conditions. By focusing on internal strengths, firms can develop strategies that leverage these resources effectively across various international operations and partnerships.
Trade Theories: Trade theories are frameworks that explain the reasons behind international trade patterns and the benefits countries derive from trading with one another. These theories help in understanding how goods and services are exchanged across borders and why some nations are more competitive than others. They also provide insights into policy decisions and the economic relationships between countries.
Transaction Cost Economics: Transaction Cost Economics is a framework that analyzes the costs associated with exchanging goods and services, focusing on the costs of making an economic exchange rather than just the price of the goods themselves. This concept plays a significant role in understanding how firms structure their operations and decide whether to outsource or produce internally, which is especially relevant in a global business context.
Uppsala Model: The Uppsala Model is a theoretical framework that explains how companies gradually increase their international involvement, emphasizing the importance of learning and experience in foreign markets. It highlights the process of internationalization as a step-by-step approach, where firms start with low-risk entry modes and gradually advance to more significant commitments based on acquired knowledge about foreign markets.