10.2 Factors Affecting Transfer of Motor Skills
9 min read•july 30, 2024
Transfer of motor skills is a crucial aspect of learning and performance. It involves how previous experiences influence the acquisition of new skills. Various factors, including individual differences, practice conditions, and task similarity, can significantly impact the transfer process.
Understanding these factors is essential for optimizing skill development and performance. By considering elements like age, expertise, , and feedback, learners and instructors can enhance the transfer of motor skills across different contexts and tasks.
Factors influencing skill transfer
Transfer of learning and its types
Top images from around the web for Transfer of learning and its types
The Learning Ecology Framework: Moving from Instructor Control to Learner Control – BCcampus View original
Is this image relevant?
Venn Diagram of 3 Learning Styles | Venn Diagram of three di… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Skills Acquisition Cycle • Toolbox • Gender and Diversity in Teaching View original
Is this image relevant?
The Learning Ecology Framework: Moving from Instructor Control to Learner Control – BCcampus View original
Is this image relevant?
Venn Diagram of 3 Learning Styles | Venn Diagram of three di… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Transfer of learning and its types
The Learning Ecology Framework: Moving from Instructor Control to Learner Control – BCcampus View original
Is this image relevant?
Venn Diagram of 3 Learning Styles | Venn Diagram of three di… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Skills Acquisition Cycle • Toolbox • Gender and Diversity in Teaching View original
Is this image relevant?
The Learning Ecology Framework: Moving from Instructor Control to Learner Control – BCcampus View original
Is this image relevant?
Venn Diagram of 3 Learning Styles | Venn Diagram of three di… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Transfer of learning refers to the influence of previous experiences or skills on the acquisition of new skills
- Transfer can be positive (facilitates learning), negative (interferes with learning), or neutral (no effect on learning) depending on the similarity between the tasks and the individual's characteristics
- occurs when prior learning enhances the acquisition of new skills (playing piano improves typing ability)
- happens when previous experiences hinder the learning of new skills (driving on the left side of the road after moving from a right-side driving country)
- indicates that prior learning has no impact on the acquisition of new skills (learning to play chess does not affect swimming performance)
Individual differences and practice conditions
- Individual differences, such as age, expertise, and cognitive abilities, can significantly impact the transfer of motor skills
- Younger learners may exhibit greater transfer due to their increased neural plasticity (children adapt more easily to new sports)
- Experts may show more specific transfer within their domain of expertise (professional tennis players learning badminton)
- Practice conditions, including the amount, variability, and specificity of practice, can influence the transfer of motor skills
- Varied practice and exposure to different task variations can enhance transfer (practicing tennis on different court surfaces)
- Highly specific practice may limit transfer to dissimilar tasks (practicing free throws in basketball may not transfer to jump shots)
- The amount of practice can influence the transfer of motor skills
- Extensive practice on the original task can lead to the development of and facilitate transfer to similar tasks (mastering touch typing improves speed in using a numeric keypad)
- Variability of practice, which involves practicing a skill under different conditions or with variations, can enhance transfer by promoting the development of flexible and adaptable motor representations
Feedback and its impact on transfer
- Feedback provided during skill acquisition can affect the transfer of motor skills
- Feedback that focuses on the underlying principles and strategies of the task can promote transfer (emphasizing proper body mechanics in weightlifting)
- Feedback that emphasizes specific movement patterns may hinder transfer to different contexts (focusing on a specific golf swing technique may not transfer to other clubs)
- The timing and frequency of feedback can impact the transfer of motor skills
- Frequent feedback during skill acquisition may lead to feedback dependency and hinder transfer (relying on a coach's constant guidance)
- Reduced feedback frequency can promote the development of intrinsic error-detection mechanisms and facilitate transfer (allowing learners to self-correct their mistakes)
- The type of feedback provided can influence transfer
- Process-oriented feedback that focuses on the underlying mechanisms and strategies of the task can enhance transfer (providing feedback on the force and angle of a tennis serve)
- Outcome-oriented feedback that emphasizes the end result may limit transfer to different contexts (focusing solely on the accuracy of a dart throw)
- Augmented feedback, such as visual or auditory guidance, can be used to facilitate skill acquisition and transfer
- However, the reliance on augmented feedback should be gradually reduced to promote the development of intrinsic feedback mechanisms and enhance transfer (fading out the use of training wheels when learning to ride a bicycle)
Task similarity and skill transfer
Assessing task similarity
- Task similarity can be assessed along various dimensions, such as the perceptual, cognitive, and motor demands of the tasks
- Perceptual similarity refers to the sensory information required to perform the tasks (visual, auditory, tactile)
- Cognitive similarity involves the mental processes and strategies used in the tasks (decision-making, problem-solving)
- Motor similarity relates to the physical movements and coordination patterns required by the tasks (fine motor skills, gross motor skills)
- The more similar the tasks are along these dimensions, the greater the potential for positive transfer
- For example, learning to play the piano may transfer more readily to playing the organ due to the similarities in perceptual (reading music), cognitive (understanding harmony), and motor (finger dexterity) demands
Identical elements theory and near/far transfer
- suggests that transfer occurs when the tasks share common elements or components
- The more elements the tasks have in common, the greater the transfer between them
- For instance, the skills acquired in playing volleyball (jumping, hitting, serving) may transfer to basketball due to the shared elements of jumping and hand-eye coordination
- Near transfer refers to the transfer between highly similar tasks, while far transfer involves the transfer between tasks that are less similar or belong to different domains
- Near transfer is more likely to occur than far transfer due to the greater overlap in task characteristics
- Learning to drive a car may exhibit near transfer to driving a truck, as both tasks involve similar perceptual, cognitive, and motor skills
- Far transfer, such as the transfer of problem-solving skills from chess to business strategy, is less common and requires the abstraction of underlying principles
Negative transfer and its occurrence
- Negative transfer can occur when the previously learned skills interfere with the acquisition of new skills
- This is more likely to happen when the tasks share similar elements but require different responses or strategies
- For example, a tennis player learning to play table tennis may experience negative transfer due to the differences in the size of the court, the height of the net, and the speed of the ball
- Negative transfer can also arise when the learned habits or patterns from one task are inappropriate or detrimental to the performance of another task
- A golfer who has mastered a specific putting technique may struggle to adapt to a different green speed or surface, leading to negative transfer
Individual differences in skill transfer
Age and its influence on transfer
- Age can influence the transfer of motor skills due to differences in cognitive abilities, prior experiences, and neural plasticity
- Children and older adults may exhibit different patterns of transfer compared to young adults
- Children's developing cognitive abilities and limited prior experiences may lead to more generalized transfer (learning to throw a ball may transfer to throwing a frisbee)
- Older adults' declining cognitive functions and reduced neural plasticity may hinder transfer, especially in complex or novel tasks (learning a new dance style may be more challenging for older individuals)
- The optimal age for skill transfer may vary depending on the nature of the tasks and the individual's developmental stage
- For instance, learning a second language may be easier for children due to their heightened neural plasticity, while acquiring advanced mathematical skills may be more efficient for young adults with fully developed cognitive abilities
Expertise and its impact on transfer
- Expertise in a particular domain can affect the transfer of motor skills within and across domains
- Experts may show greater transfer within their domain of expertise due to their well-developed knowledge structures and problem-solving strategies
- An experienced pianist may find it easier to learn a new musical instrument compared to a novice
- A skilled soccer player may adapt more quickly to playing futsal, a variant of soccer played on a smaller court
- However, expertise can also lead to specific transfer, where the skills are highly specialized and may not transfer readily to dissimilar tasks
- A world-class sprinter may not necessarily excel in long-distance running due to the specific training and physiological adaptations required for each event
Cognitive abilities and their role in transfer
- Cognitive abilities, such as working memory capacity and attention, can impact the transfer of motor skills
- Individuals with higher cognitive abilities may be better able to extract relevant information from the task and apply it to new situations
- A person with high working memory capacity may be able to hold and manipulate multiple pieces of information simultaneously, facilitating the transfer of complex skills (learning to fly a plane)
- Someone with better attentional control may be able to focus on the critical aspects of the task and filter out irrelevant information, enhancing transfer (transferring golf putting skills to croquet)
- Cognitive abilities also influence the ability to recognize patterns, draw analogies, and apply abstract principles, which are crucial for far transfer
- An individual with strong problem-solving skills may be able to identify the underlying strategies in chess and apply them to strategic decision-making in business
Prior experiences and existing motor skills
- Prior experiences and existing motor skills can influence the transfer of new skills
- Individuals with a broader range of experiences and a diverse skill set may exhibit greater transfer due to their ability to draw upon multiple sources of knowledge
- A person who has played various sports (basketball, volleyball, tennis) may find it easier to learn a new sport (badminton) due to the transferable skills and experiences
- An artist who has worked with different media (painting, sculpting, digital art) may be more adaptable when learning a new artistic technique
- Existing motor skills can serve as a foundation for acquiring new skills, facilitating positive transfer
- A skilled typist may learn to play the piano more quickly due to the existing finger dexterity and hand-eye coordination
- A dancer may find it easier to learn martial arts due to the pre-existing balance, flexibility, and body control
Practice and feedback on skill transfer
Amount and specificity of practice
- The amount of practice can influence the transfer of motor skills
- Extensive practice on the original task can lead to the development of automaticity and facilitate transfer to similar tasks
- For example, a person who has spent countless hours practicing chess moves may be able to transfer those skills more readily to other strategy games like Go or Shogi
- Specificity of practice refers to the degree to which the practice conditions match the target task
- Highly specific practice may limit transfer to dissimilar tasks
- Practicing a specific tennis serve technique may not transfer well to serving in volleyball
- Practice that emphasizes the underlying principles and strategies can promote transfer
- Learning the principles of balance and weight transfer in martial arts may transfer to other sports or activities that require stability and body control
- Highly specific practice may limit transfer to dissimilar tasks
Variability of practice and its effects
- Variability of practice involves practicing a skill under different conditions or with variations
- Practicing a golf swing with different clubs, stances, and ball positions
- Rehearsing a dance routine to various tempos and musical styles
- Varied practice can enhance transfer by promoting the development of flexible and adaptable motor representations
- Exposure to different task variations helps learners develop a broader understanding of the skill and its application in various contexts
- Variability in practice conditions encourages learners to explore different strategies and develop problem-solving skills, facilitating transfer to novel situations
Feedback timing, frequency, and type
- The timing and frequency of feedback can impact the transfer of motor skills
- Frequent feedback during skill acquisition may lead to feedback dependency and hinder transfer
- Constantly relying on a coach's guidance may limit a learner's ability to self-correct and adapt to new situations
- Reduced feedback frequency can promote the development of intrinsic error-detection mechanisms and facilitate transfer
- Allowing learners to practice without constant feedback encourages them to develop their own internal feedback systems, enhancing transfer to unsupervised contexts
- Frequent feedback during skill acquisition may lead to feedback dependency and hinder transfer
- The type of feedback provided can influence transfer
- Process-oriented feedback focuses on the underlying mechanisms and strategies of the task and can enhance transfer
- Providing feedback on the body mechanics and force application in a golf swing can help learners understand the fundamental principles that transfer to other golf shots
- Outcome-oriented feedback emphasizes the end result and may limit transfer to different contexts
- Focusing solely on the accuracy of a basketball shot may not transfer well to shooting from different distances or angles
- Process-oriented feedback focuses on the underlying mechanisms and strategies of the task and can enhance transfer
Augmented feedback and its role in transfer
- Augmented feedback refers to additional sensory information provided to the learner, such as visual or auditory guidance
- Using a metronome to provide auditory feedback on the timing of a dance routine
- Displaying a virtual trajectory of a golf swing to offer visual feedback on the movement pattern
- Augmented feedback can be used to facilitate skill acquisition and transfer by highlighting relevant cues and providing immediate corrective information
- However, the reliance on augmented feedback should be gradually reduced to promote the development of intrinsic feedback mechanisms and enhance transfer
- Fading out the use of training wheels when learning to ride a bicycle encourages the development of balance and coordination skills that transfer to riding without support
- Gradually reducing the frequency of augmented feedback in a musical performance allows learners to internalize the rhythm and melody, facilitating transfer to performing without external cues
Key Terms to Review (19)
Automaticity: Automaticity refers to the ability to perform a task with little to no conscious effort, often resulting from extensive practice and skill development. This process allows individuals to execute motor skills efficiently while minimizing cognitive load, leading to enhanced performance, especially in complex tasks or dual-task scenarios.
Blocked Practice: Blocked practice is a motor learning strategy where a learner practices the same skill repeatedly for a set period of time, focusing on one task or variation before moving on to another. This approach can enhance performance during practice sessions but may not translate as effectively to real-world settings or game situations compared to more varied practice methods.
Closed Skills: Closed skills are motor skills performed in a predictable environment, where the timing and execution can be controlled by the performer. These skills are often practiced under stable conditions, making it easier for individuals to refine their techniques. They contrast with open skills, which occur in dynamic settings that require adaptability and response to external changes.
Contextual interference: Contextual interference refers to the phenomenon where varying practice conditions enhance the learning and retention of motor skills, often leading to better performance in the long run. This concept is crucial for understanding how different practice schedules, such as random or blocked practice, influence memory and transfer of skills.
Declarative knowledge: Declarative knowledge refers to the understanding of facts, concepts, and information that can be verbally expressed or declared. This type of knowledge is crucial in learning motor skills, as it involves knowing what to do, why to do it, and how to articulate the information related to the skill. In the context of transferring motor skills, declarative knowledge plays a significant role in how well an individual can apply learned skills from one context to another.
Gentile: In the context of motor learning, 'gentile' refers to a framework developed by Nancy Gentile that describes the classification of motor skills and their transfer. This framework emphasizes the importance of understanding the characteristics of both the task and the environment when considering how motor skills transfer from one context to another, thereby influencing learning and performance.
Identical elements theory: Identical elements theory suggests that the transfer of learning from one motor skill to another depends on the number of common elements shared between the two skills. The more similarities in movement patterns, body mechanics, and environmental context, the greater the likelihood that skills learned in one context will positively influence performance in another. This theory highlights the importance of understanding how skills are related to optimize practice and enhance learning.
Negative Transfer: Negative transfer occurs when learning or performing one motor skill hinders the acquisition or performance of another skill. This phenomenon highlights the importance of understanding how different skills can interfere with each other, impacting a person's ability to learn and perform effectively. Recognizing negative transfer can help in structuring practice sessions to minimize interference and enhance overall skill acquisition.
Neutral transfer: Neutral transfer refers to a situation where practicing one motor skill has no positive or negative impact on the performance of another motor skill. This concept is important for understanding how different skills interact during learning and practice, indicating that certain skills do not interfere with or enhance each other, allowing learners to develop each skill independently.
Open Skills: Open skills refer to motor skills that are performed in dynamic and unpredictable environments, where the performer must adapt their movements based on external factors. These skills are typically influenced by variables such as the actions of opponents or changes in the environment, making them distinct from closed skills, which are performed in stable and predictable conditions. Mastering open skills requires continuous decision-making and quick adjustments to achieve success.
Positive Transfer: Positive transfer refers to the phenomenon where learning or performance of one motor skill enhances the learning or performance of another motor skill. This concept is crucial for understanding how skills can be effectively taught and mastered, as it highlights the interrelatedness of motor tasks and how prior experience can be beneficial in acquiring new skills.
Practice variability: Practice variability refers to the range of different movements and contexts that learners encounter during practice sessions, which can enhance learning and performance. This concept is important because varying practice conditions helps learners develop a more adaptable motor skill set, leading to improved retention and transfer of skills in real-world situations.
Retention Tests: Retention tests are assessments designed to measure the persistence of learned motor skills over time, highlighting how well individuals can recall and perform a skill after a period of no practice. These tests provide insights into the effectiveness of practice methods and the stability of motor learning, connecting to concepts like practice schedules, skill decomposition, transfer abilities, and motor programming.
Richard Schmidt: Richard Schmidt is a prominent figure in the field of motor learning and control, known for his significant contributions to understanding how humans acquire and refine motor skills. His work emphasizes the importance of feedback, practice variability, and the theoretical frameworks that explain how motor skills are learned and executed.
Similarity of skills: Similarity of skills refers to the extent to which two or more motor skills share common elements, making it easier for a learner to transfer knowledge and abilities from one skill to another. This concept is important because the more similar skills are, the more likely that practice in one will positively affect performance in the other, thus enhancing overall learning efficiency.
Skill level: Skill level refers to the proficiency or competence an individual has in performing a motor skill, which can range from novice to expert. Understanding skill level is crucial because it influences how feedback is given during practice and how well skills transfer from one context to another. Higher skill levels often correlate with more effective learning strategies and a better ability to adapt skills to new tasks.
Task Complexity: Task complexity refers to the intricacy and difficulty level of a motor skill, influenced by the number of components involved and how they interact during performance. This complexity impacts various learning processes, such as attention allocation, memory retention, and skill acquisition strategies.
Transfer tests: Transfer tests are assessments used to evaluate how well a learner can apply acquired skills or knowledge in new or different contexts. These tests are crucial for understanding the effectiveness of practice methods, as they highlight the ability to transfer learning from one situation to another. The design of transfer tests can help identify the similarities and differences between practiced skills and new tasks, revealing insights into learning processes and performance outcomes.
Transfer Theory: Transfer theory refers to the concept that skills learned in one context can influence performance in another context, either positively or negatively. This idea highlights how previous experiences with motor skills can aid or hinder the learning of new skills, depending on the similarities or differences between the tasks and environments involved.