6.4 Compare and Contrast Traditional and Activity-Based Costing Systems
3 min read•june 18, 2024
Traditional and systems differ in how they allocate . Traditional systems use a single , potentially leading to inaccurate product costs. (ABC) uses multiple cost drivers, providing more precise cost information but requiring more data analysis.
The choice between these systems impacts accuracy and decision-making. is simpler but may distort costs in complex environments. ABC offers better insights into and , supporting improved cost management and strategic choices.
Traditional vs. Activity-Based Costing Systems
Traditional vs activity-based costing systems
Top images from around the web for Traditional vs activity-based costing systems
Costeo Basado en Actividades - ABC View original
Is this image relevant?
Kostenoptimalisatie en architectuur? – Organisatieontwerp.nl View original
Is this image relevant?
Activity-Based Life-Cycle Costing applied to an innovative forestry company product portfolio ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Costeo Basado en Actividades - ABC View original
Is this image relevant?
Kostenoptimalisatie en architectuur? – Organisatieontwerp.nl View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Traditional vs activity-based costing systems
Costeo Basado en Actividades - ABC View original
Is this image relevant?
Kostenoptimalisatie en architectuur? – Organisatieontwerp.nl View original
Is this image relevant?
Activity-Based Life-Cycle Costing applied to an innovative forestry company product portfolio ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Costeo Basado en Actividades - ABC View original
Is this image relevant?
Kostenoptimalisatie en architectuur? – Organisatieontwerp.nl View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Traditional costing systems allocate overhead costs based on a single (direct labor hours or machine hours), assuming products consume overhead resources in proportion to the chosen cost driver, often leading to over-costing or under-costing of products (high-volume vs low-volume) when overhead costs are not directly related to the chosen cost driver
- Activity-based costing (ABC) systems allocate overhead costs based on multiple cost drivers or activities that cause the costs to be incurred, identifying the specific activities that consume overhead resources and assigning costs to products based on their consumption of these activities, providing more accurate product costs by recognizing the diverse resource demands of different products (specialized equipment vs standard machinery) but requiring more data collection and analysis compared to traditional costing systems
- ABC systems provide a more accurate representation of resource consumption by products, leading to improved
Advantages of costing methods
- Traditional costing is simpler and less costly to implement and maintain, requires less data collection and analysis, and may be sufficient for companies with a homogeneous product mix (similar products) and simple production processes
- ABC provides more accurate product costs by recognizing the diverse resource demands of different products, helps identify non-value-added activities (unnecessary steps) and opportunities for cost reduction, and supports better decision-making by providing more reliable cost information
- Traditional costing can lead to inaccurate product costs, especially in complex manufacturing environments (multiple products and processes), may result in poor decision-making based on distorted cost information, and does not provide insights into the true causes of overhead costs
- ABC is more complex and costly to implement and maintain, requires extensive data collection and analysis, and may not be cost-effective for companies with simple production processes or homogeneous product mix
- ABC is particularly beneficial for companies with high , as it can more accurately capture the costs associated with diverse product lines
Impact on high vs low-volume products
- Under traditional costing, tend to be over-costed because they are allocated a larger share of overhead costs based on the single cost driver, while tend to be under-costed because they are allocated a smaller share of overhead costs based on the single cost driver
- Under ABC, high-volume products are likely to have lower calculated costs because they consume fewer overhead resources per unit (less setup time) compared to traditional costing, while low-volume products are likely to have higher calculated costs because they consume more overhead resources per unit (more setup time) compared to traditional costing
- Switching from traditional to ABC costing reveals the true cost structure of the company's products, may lead to changes in pricing, product mix, and profitability analysis (discontinuing unprofitable products), and helps managers make more informed decisions based on accurate cost information
Cost Allocation and Overhead
- Traditional costing systems use a single predetermined for , which can lead to in complex manufacturing environments
- ABC systems use multiple cost drivers to allocate overhead costs, resulting in more accurate product costing
- The choice of costing system impacts the accuracy of product costs and the effectiveness of managerial decision-making in areas such as pricing and product mix
Key Terms to Review (23)
Activity-based costing: Activity-Based Costing (ABC) is a costing method that assigns overhead and indirect costs to related products and services. It identifies specific activities within an organization and assigns the cost of each activity to all products and services according to the actual consumption by each.
Activity-Based Costing: Activity-based costing (ABC) is a costing methodology that identifies activities in an organization and assigns the cost of each activity with resources to the various products and services according to the actual consumption by each. It is a more accurate way of allocating overhead costs compared to traditional volume-based costing methods.
Cost Accuracy: Cost accuracy refers to the degree of precision and reliability in the measurement and allocation of costs within an organization's costing system. It is a critical factor in evaluating the effectiveness of traditional and activity-based costing approaches in providing meaningful cost information for decision-making.
Cost Allocation: Cost allocation is the process of assigning indirect or overhead costs to specific cost objects, such as products, services, or departments, based on a rational and systematic method. It is a crucial concept in managerial accounting that helps organizations accurately determine the true cost of their operations and make informed decisions.
Cost Distortion: Cost distortion refers to the inaccuracies or biases that can arise in the allocation of overhead costs to individual products or services within a traditional costing system. This can lead to some products being overcosted while others are undercosted, resulting in distorted profitability information and potentially poor decision-making.
Cost driver: A cost driver is a factor that causes or influences the cost of an activity. It helps in identifying and allocating costs more accurately in cost accounting and management.
Cost Driver: A cost driver is a factor or activity that directly influences the incurrence of a particular cost within an organization. It is a key concept in understanding and managing costs, as it helps identify the underlying causes of cost behavior and guides decision-making processes.
Cost Object: A cost object is any item, such as a product, service, or activity, for which costs are measured and assigned. It serves as the target for which costs are accumulated and analyzed, allowing organizations to understand the financial implications of their operations.
Cost pool: A cost pool is an aggregation of individual costs, typically by department or service center, from which cost allocations are made later. It simplifies the process of assigning costs to various products or services.
Cost Pool: A cost pool is a grouping of individual cost items or cost centers that are similar in nature and can be allocated to cost objects using the same allocation base. Cost pools are an essential component in both traditional and activity-based costing systems, as they facilitate the accurate assignment of overhead costs to products or services.
High-Volume Products: High-volume products refer to items that are produced and sold in large quantities within a company's product portfolio. These products typically account for a significant portion of a firm's revenue and are often the focus of traditional costing systems, which allocate overhead costs based on volume-related drivers like direct labor hours or machine hours.
Indirect Costs: Indirect costs are expenses incurred in the production of goods or services that cannot be easily traced to a specific cost object, such as a product or a department. These costs are not directly attributable to the manufacture of a particular item but are necessary for the overall operation of a business. Indirect costs are an important consideration in various managerial accounting topics, including the computation of a predetermined overhead rate, the preparation of journal entries for a job order cost system, the application of a job order cost system to a nonmanufacturing environment, the calculation of predetermined overhead and total cost under the traditional allocation method, and the comparison of traditional and activity-based costing systems.
Low-Volume Products: Low-volume products refer to items that are produced in small quantities, typically due to low customer demand or specialized nature. These products often have a higher per-unit cost compared to high-volume items, as the fixed costs are spread across a smaller number of units. Understanding the characteristics of low-volume products is crucial in the context of comparing traditional and activity-based costing systems.
Manufacturing overhead costs: Manufacturing overhead costs are indirect costs associated with the production process but not directly traceable to a specific product. They include expenses like utilities, depreciation, and factory supplies.
Non-Value-Added Activities: Non-value-added activities are business processes or tasks that consume resources but do not directly contribute to the creation of a product or service that the customer is willing to pay for. These activities do not add any value from the customer's perspective and should be minimized or eliminated to improve efficiency and profitability.
Overhead Costs: Overhead costs are indirect expenses incurred by a business that cannot be directly attributed to the production of a specific product or service. These costs support the overall operations of the organization but are not directly related to the manufacturing or delivery of a particular item. Overhead costs are an important consideration in various cost accounting topics, including traditional cost allocation methods, cost driver identification, and activity-based costing systems.
Overhead rate: The overhead rate is a calculation used to allocate indirect costs to products or job orders. It is determined by dividing estimated overhead costs by an allocation base such as direct labor hours or machine hours.
Overhead Rate: The overhead rate is a metric used to allocate indirect costs, such as rent, utilities, and administrative expenses, to the production of goods or services. It represents the amount of overhead costs that are assigned to each unit of output or activity. The overhead rate is a critical component in both traditional and activity-based costing systems, as well as in the preparation of operating budgets.
Product Complexity: Product complexity refers to the degree of intricacy and multifaceted nature of a product, which can impact the manufacturing process, cost, and overall management of the product within a company. It is a crucial consideration in the comparison and contrast of traditional and activity-based costing systems.
Product Costing: Product costing is the process of determining the total cost associated with producing a specific product or service. It involves identifying and allocating all the relevant costs, including direct materials, direct labor, and overhead expenses, to the individual products or services. Product costing is a fundamental concept in managerial accounting, as it provides essential information for decision-making, pricing, and performance evaluation.
Resource Consumption: Resource consumption refers to the utilization and depletion of various resources, both tangible and intangible, required for the production of goods and services. It is a fundamental concept in understanding the efficiency and cost structures of an organization's operations.
Traditional allocation: Traditional allocation is a costing method where overhead costs are assigned to products based on a single cost driver, typically direct labor hours or machine hours. It is simpler but may not accurately reflect the actual resources consumed by different products.
Traditional Costing: Traditional costing is an approach to cost accounting that allocates overhead costs to products based on a single volume-based cost driver, such as direct labor hours or machine hours. This method is in contrast to activity-based costing, which utilizes multiple cost drivers to more accurately assign overhead costs to products.