9.1 Contract drafting
10 min read•august 21, 2024
Contract drafting is a critical skill in legal writing, requiring precision and attention to detail. This section explores the key elements of effective contracts, from structure and language to boilerplate provisions and substantive clauses.
Mastering contract drafting techniques helps create clear, enforceable agreements. We'll examine strategies for risk allocation, negotiation considerations, and ethical obligations, as well as the role of technology in modern contract creation.
Elements of contract drafting
- Contract drafting forms a crucial component of Legal Method and Writing, encompassing the creation of legally binding agreements
- Effective contract drafting requires attention to detail, clarity, and a thorough understanding of legal principles
- This section explores the fundamental elements that contribute to well-crafted contracts
Key components of contracts
Top images from around the web for Key components of contracts
Design of the Blockchain Smart Contract: A Use Case for Real Estate View original
Is this image relevant?
Contracts - 1L Survival Guide - Research Guides at Florida State University College of Law ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Contract Law - Highlighted Words and Phrases View original
Is this image relevant?
Design of the Blockchain Smart Contract: A Use Case for Real Estate View original
Is this image relevant?
Contracts - 1L Survival Guide - Research Guides at Florida State University College of Law ... View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Key components of contracts
Design of the Blockchain Smart Contract: A Use Case for Real Estate View original
Is this image relevant?
Contracts - 1L Survival Guide - Research Guides at Florida State University College of Law ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Contract Law - Highlighted Words and Phrases View original
Is this image relevant?
Design of the Blockchain Smart Contract: A Use Case for Real Estate View original
Is this image relevant?
Contracts - 1L Survival Guide - Research Guides at Florida State University College of Law ... View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- and establish the mutual agreement between parties
- involves the exchange of something of value (money, goods, services)
- ensures all parties have the legal ability to enter into the contract
- confirms the contract's purpose aligns with applicable laws
- demonstrates both parties understand and agree to the terms
Structure and organization
- Introduction includes the title, date, and parties involved
- Recitals provide background information and context for the agreement
- Operative provisions outline the specific terms and conditions
- Signature blocks allow parties to formally execute the contract
- Exhibits or schedules attach additional relevant documents or information
Clarity and precision
- Use specific and unambiguous language to convey exact meanings
- Define technical terms or industry-specific jargon within the contract
- Employ numbered sections and subsections for easy reference
- Include concrete examples or formulas when necessary (calculation of interest rates)
- Avoid vague or open-ended statements that could lead to misinterpretation
Language and style
- Language and style in contract drafting significantly impact the document's effectiveness and enforceability
- Clear, concise, and consistent language helps prevent disputes and ensures all parties understand their obligations
- This section examines the linguistic aspects of contract drafting and their importance in Legal Method and Writing
Plain language vs legalese
- Plain language prioritizes clarity and readability for non-legal audiences
- Legalese involves traditional legal terminology and complex sentence structures
- Plain language reduces misunderstandings and improves contract accessibility
- Legalese can provide precision and adherence to established legal conventions
- Balancing both approaches ensures contracts remain legally sound and comprehensible
Defined terms and definitions
- Capitalized terms indicate defined words or phrases within the contract
- Definitions section provides clear explanations of key terms used throughout
- Consistent use of defined terms enhances precision and reduces ambiguity
- Cross-referencing definitions helps maintain coherence across the document
- Avoid circular definitions that reference other undefined terms
Consistency in terminology
- Use identical terms to refer to the same concept throughout the contract
- Avoid synonyms or variations that could introduce confusion or ambiguity
- Maintain consistent verb tenses and grammatical structures
- Ensure defined terms are used consistently in their defined form
- Review the entire document to identify and rectify any inconsistencies
Boilerplate provisions
- Boilerplate provisions play a crucial role in contract drafting within Legal Method and Writing
- These standardized clauses address common legal and administrative aspects of agreements
- Understanding boilerplate provisions helps create comprehensive and legally sound contracts
Common boilerplate clauses
- specifies which jurisdiction's laws apply to the contract
- outlines procedures for handling disagreements (, )
- allows unenforceable provisions to be removed without invalidating the entire contract
- prevents prior negotiations from superseding the written contract
- establishes how formal communications between parties should be made
Customizing standard clauses
- Tailor boilerplate language to fit the specific needs of the transaction
- Modify standard clauses to address unique circumstances or industry requirements
- Consider client preferences and risk tolerance when adapting boilerplate provisions
- Ensure customized clauses remain legally enforceable and consistent with the contract's overall purpose
- Review modified boilerplate with legal counsel to confirm appropriateness
Importance of boilerplate
- Provides legal protection by addressing common contractual issues
- Saves time and resources by utilizing pre-drafted, tested language
- Ensures consistency across multiple agreements within an organization
- Reduces the risk of overlooking important legal considerations
- Facilitates smoother negotiations by providing a familiar starting point
Substantive provisions
- Substantive provisions form the core of a contract, detailing the specific rights and obligations of the parties
- These clauses are crucial in Legal Method and Writing as they define the essence of the agreement
- Drafting effective substantive provisions requires a deep understanding of the transaction and legal implications
Obligations and rights
- Clearly state each party's responsibilities and entitlements
- Use action verbs to describe specific duties (deliver, pay, perform)
- Include timelines or deadlines for fulfilling obligations
- Specify any conditions that must be met before rights can be exercised
- Address consequences for failure to meet obligations or violation of rights
Conditions and contingencies
- Identify events or circumstances that trigger specific contractual outcomes
- Use
structures to clearly link conditions to consequencesif...then - Include both precedent conditions (must occur before performance) and subsequent conditions (affect ongoing obligations)
- Specify timeframes for meeting conditions or addressing contingencies
- Consider including provisions for waiving or modifying conditions if necessary
Representations and warranties
- Representations state facts about the parties or subject matter of the contract
- Warranties provide assurances about the quality or condition of goods or services
- Include statements about legal capacity, authority to enter the agreement, and compliance with laws
- Address specific industry or transaction-related representations (financial statements, intellectual property ownership)
- Specify remedies for breach of representations or warranties (indemnification, termination rights)
Drafting techniques
- Effective drafting techniques are essential in Legal Method and Writing to create clear, enforceable contracts
- These techniques help prevent ambiguity, enhance readability, and ensure the contract accurately reflects the parties' intentions
- Mastering these drafting skills is crucial for producing high-quality legal documents
Use of shall vs will
traditionally indicates a mandatory obligation or dutyShall
often describes future actions or events without implying a legal obligationWill- Some modern drafting approaches favor
for obligations to avoid potential ambiguity withmustshall - Use
for actions that are expected to occur but are not contractual requirementswill - Maintain consistency in usage throughout the document to prevent confusion
Active vs passive voice
- Active voice emphasizes the subject performing the action (The buyer shall pay the purchase price)
- Passive voice focuses on the recipient of the action (The purchase price shall be paid by the buyer)
- Active voice generally improves clarity and readability in contract drafting
- Use passive voice sparingly, typically when the actor is unknown or unimportant
- Combine active and passive voice strategically to emphasize certain aspects of the agreement
Avoiding ambiguity
- Use precise language and avoid words with multiple meanings
- Clearly define terms that could be subject to interpretation
- Employ parallel structure in lists and enumerations to ensure consistency
- Use qualifiers and modifiers judiciously to prevent unintended limitations or expansions
- Include specific examples or formulas when necessary to clarify complex concepts
Risk allocation
- Risk allocation plays a crucial role in contract drafting within Legal Method and Writing
- Properly distributing risk between parties helps prevent disputes and protects clients' interests
- This section explores key provisions used to allocate risk in contractual agreements
Indemnification clauses
- Define the scope of indemnification, specifying covered losses and events
- Clarify which party bears the responsibility for indemnification
- Include procedural requirements for invoking indemnification (notice, control of defense)
- Address limitations on indemnification obligations (caps, exclusions)
- Consider reciprocal indemnification provisions when appropriate
Limitation of liability
- Specify types of damages excluded from recovery (consequential, indirect)
- Set caps on liability based on contract value or other agreed-upon metrics
- Carve out exceptions for certain types of breaches or misconduct (gross negligence, willful misconduct)
- Address the interplay between and indemnification provisions
- Consider industry standards and regulatory requirements when drafting limitations
Force majeure provisions
- Define force majeure events (natural disasters, government actions, pandemics)
- Outline the impact of force majeure on contractual obligations
- Specify notice requirements and timelines for invoking force majeure
- Address the duration of force majeure relief and potential termination rights
- Include provisions for mitigating the effects of force majeure events
Negotiation considerations
- Negotiation considerations are integral to the contract drafting process in Legal Method and Writing
- Understanding negotiation dynamics helps create agreements that balance the interests of all parties
- This section explores key aspects of negotiation that influence contract drafting
Identifying client objectives
- Conduct thorough client interviews to understand their goals and priorities
- Analyze the business context and potential risks associated with the transaction
- Determine key deal points and non-negotiable terms for the client
- Consider long-term implications and potential future scenarios
- Align contract provisions with the client's overall business strategy
Anticipating counterparty concerns
- Research the counterparty's industry, business model, and typical contracting practices
- Identify potential areas of disagreement or conflicting interests
- Draft provisions that address likely counterparty objections or requests
- Prepare alternative language or fallback positions for contentious clauses
- Consider including explanatory notes or comments to justify certain provisions
Drafting for flexibility
- Use defined terms that allow for easy updates or modifications
- Include mechanisms for adjusting key terms based on changing circumstances (price escalation clauses)
- Draft provisions that accommodate potential changes in law or regulations
- Consider incorporating options or rights of first refusal for future transactions
- Balance specificity with flexibility to allow for reasonable adaptations over time
Ethics in contract drafting
- Ethical considerations play a vital role in contract drafting within Legal Method and Writing
- Adhering to ethical standards ensures the integrity of the legal profession and protects clients' interests
- This section examines key ethical obligations relevant to contract drafting
Duty of competence
- Maintain up-to-date knowledge of relevant laws and regulations
- Seek assistance or consultation when dealing with unfamiliar areas of law
- Conduct thorough research and due diligence for each drafting project
- Utilize appropriate resources and tools to enhance drafting accuracy
- Continuously improve drafting skills through professional development and feedback
Avoiding conflicts of interest
- Identify potential conflicts before accepting a drafting assignment
- Disclose any relevant relationships or prior dealings with involved parties
- Obtain informed consent when appropriate to proceed despite potential conflicts
- Maintain clear boundaries between representation of different clients
- Implement systems to check for conflicts in ongoing and past representations
Confidentiality obligations
- Safeguard client information and sensitive contract details
- Use secure methods for storing and transmitting draft contracts
- Limit access to contract documents on a need-to-know basis
- Obtain client approval before sharing contract information with third parties
- Adhere to ethical rules regarding inadvertent disclosure of confidential information
Review and revision
- Review and revision are critical stages in the contract drafting process within Legal Method and Writing
- Thorough review ensures accuracy, consistency, and effectiveness of the final agreement
- This section explores strategies for refining and perfecting contract drafts
Proofreading strategies
- Read the document aloud to catch awkward phrasing or missing words
- Use text-to-speech software to hear the contract read back for a fresh perspective
- Review the document in reverse order to focus on individual sentences
- Create a checklist of common errors or issues to systematically review
- Allow time between drafting and proofreading to approach the document with fresh eyes
Collaborative editing
- Utilize track changes features in word processing software to document revisions
- Establish clear roles and responsibilities for each reviewer
- Set deadlines and milestones for the review process
- Implement a system for consolidating and addressing conflicting edits
- Conduct in-person or virtual meetings to discuss significant changes or complex issues
Version control
- Implement a consistent naming convention for draft versions
- Maintain a log of major changes between versions
- Use document management software to track revision history
- Clearly mark draft status and version numbers on each document
- Establish protocols for archiving and retrieving previous versions
Technology in contract drafting
- Technology plays an increasingly important role in contract drafting within Legal Method and Writing
- Leveraging technological tools can enhance efficiency, accuracy, and consistency in the drafting process
- This section explores key technological applications in modern contract drafting
Contract management software
- Centralizes contract storage and organization for easy access and retrieval
- Automates workflow processes for contract review and approval
- Tracks key dates and deadlines for contract renewals or terminations
- Generates reports and analytics on contract performance and compliance
- Integrates with other business systems for seamless data flow
Automated drafting tools
- Utilizes templates and clause libraries for rapid document assembly
- Implements logic-based systems to generate context-specific language
- Incorporates artificial intelligence for contract analysis and risk assessment
- Provides real-time suggestions for improving clarity and consistency
- Automates cross-referencing and definition usage throughout the document
E-signature considerations
- Ensures compliance with electronic signature laws and regulations
- Implements secure authentication methods for signatories
- Provides audit trails and tamper-evident seals for signed documents
- Facilitates remote signing capabilities for geographically dispersed parties
- Integrates with contract management systems for seamless execution and storage
Key Terms to Review (28)
Acceptance: Acceptance is the agreement to the terms of an offer, indicating a willingness to enter into a contract. It is a crucial element of contract law that signifies the final step in the agreement process, establishing a mutual understanding between parties. When acceptance is communicated clearly and unambiguously, it creates a binding obligation that can be enforced in a court of law.
Arbitration: Arbitration is a method of resolving disputes outside of the courtroom, where a neutral third party, known as an arbitrator, makes a binding decision after hearing both sides. This process is often outlined in contracts, providing a way for parties to avoid lengthy and costly litigation. Arbitration is commonly used in commercial disputes and employment agreements, making it an essential tool for conflict resolution in various industries.
Bilateral contract: A bilateral contract is a mutual agreement between two parties where each party commits to fulfilling their respective obligations. In this type of contract, both sides exchange promises, making it a reciprocal arrangement that ensures that both parties have something to gain and lose. The clarity in obligations is crucial, as it allows each party to understand their duties and the consequences of non-performance.
Capacity: Capacity refers to the legal ability of an individual or entity to enter into a contract. This means that the party must have the mental and legal competence to understand the terms and consequences of the agreement they are entering into. Factors affecting capacity can include age, mental state, and legal status, all of which ensure that the parties are capable of making informed decisions.
Compensatory damages: Compensatory damages are monetary awards given to a plaintiff to compensate for losses suffered due to a breach of contract or other wrongful act. The primary goal is to restore the injured party to the position they would have been in had the breach not occurred. This type of damages is essential in ensuring that the party who suffered loss receives fair compensation, which can include actual losses and any consequential damages that arise directly from the breach.
Consideration: Consideration is a fundamental principle in contract law that refers to something of value that is exchanged between parties in a contract, which can be a promise, service, or item. It ensures that each party has something to gain from the agreement, making it legally binding. Without consideration, a contract may be deemed unenforceable, as it reflects the mutuality of obligations essential for any valid contract.
Contemporaneous exchange: Contemporaneous exchange refers to a simultaneous transaction where each party provides their performance at the same time or within a short time frame, often ensuring that the benefits and obligations are balanced. This concept is crucial in contract law as it establishes mutual consideration, which is necessary for a valid contract. The timing of the exchange can affect enforceability and the parties' rights in case of breach.
Contra proferentem: Contra proferentem is a legal doctrine that states when there is ambiguity in a contract, the interpretation should be against the party that drafted it. This principle helps to ensure fairness by placing the burden on the drafting party to make the terms clear. It plays a crucial role in contract disputes, guiding courts on how to resolve uncertainties in contractual language.
Dispute resolution: Dispute resolution refers to the various processes and methods used to resolve conflicts and disagreements between parties. These processes can include negotiation, mediation, arbitration, and litigation, each offering different levels of formality and involvement of third parties. Understanding these methods is essential for effective contract drafting, as it helps parties anticipate potential disputes and agree on mechanisms for resolution in advance.
Entire Agreement Clause: An entire agreement clause is a provision in a contract that states that the written contract constitutes the complete and final agreement between the parties, superseding any prior negotiations, agreements, or understandings. This clause serves to prevent any party from claiming that there were additional terms or agreements outside of the written document, thus providing clarity and certainty in contract enforcement.
Force majeure provisions: Force majeure provisions are contractual clauses that excuse a party from fulfilling their contractual obligations due to unforeseen events that are beyond their control. These events, such as natural disasters, wars, or pandemics, must typically make it impossible or impractical to perform the contract as originally intended. The inclusion of these provisions helps parties manage risk and allocate responsibilities when unexpected situations arise.
Governing Law: Governing law refers to the set of legal principles and rules that dictate how a contract will be interpreted and enforced. It establishes which jurisdiction's laws apply to the agreement, influencing how disputes are resolved and the rights and obligations of the parties involved. The choice of governing law can affect various aspects of the contract, including liability, damages, and remedies available in case of a breach.
Indemnification clauses: Indemnification clauses are provisions in contracts that require one party to compensate the other for certain damages or losses incurred due to specific events, typically involving third-party claims. These clauses are essential in managing risk by specifying who is responsible for covering costs associated with legal actions, thereby providing financial protection and encouraging compliance with agreed-upon standards.
Indemnity Clause: An indemnity clause is a contractual provision where one party agrees to compensate another party for certain damages or losses that may arise during the performance of the contract. This clause is crucial in allocating risk between the parties, defining who is responsible for specific liabilities and protecting one party from financial harm caused by the actions of the other. Indemnity clauses can cover a range of issues, including negligence, breach of contract, and third-party claims.
Legality: Legality refers to the quality or state of being in accordance with the law. In contract drafting, legality ensures that the terms of the contract are enforceable and comply with existing legal statutes and regulations. A contract that involves illegal activities or violates public policy is void and cannot be enforced in a court of law.
Limitation of Liability: Limitation of liability is a contractual provision that restricts the amount of damages one party can recover from another in the event of a breach of contract or other wrongful act. This concept is crucial in contract drafting, as it helps to allocate risk and protect parties from excessive claims, fostering clearer expectations and encouraging parties to engage in business relationships without the fear of unlimited financial exposure.
Liquidated Damages: Liquidated damages are a predetermined amount of money that parties agree upon in a contract, to be paid if one party fails to fulfill their contractual obligations. This concept helps provide certainty and clarity in contracts, as it specifies the compensation amount for breach of contract instead of leaving it open to interpretation or litigation.
Mediation: Mediation is a process in which a neutral third party helps disputing parties reach a mutually agreeable solution. This informal dispute resolution method encourages collaboration and communication between the involved parties, often leading to more satisfactory outcomes than traditional litigation. Mediation is commonly used in various contexts, including family law, business disputes, and labor negotiations, allowing parties to maintain control over the resolution process.
Mutual assent: Mutual assent is the agreement between parties that is necessary to form a valid contract, often demonstrated through an offer and acceptance. It signifies that both parties have a shared understanding and intention to enter into a contractual relationship, which is essential for any binding agreement. The concept ensures that all parties are on the same page regarding the terms and conditions, reducing ambiguity and potential disputes.
Non-compete clause: A non-compete clause is a contractual provision that restricts an individual or entity from engaging in business activities that compete with another party for a specified period and within a defined geographical area. This clause is commonly included in employment contracts to protect the employer’s business interests, including trade secrets, client relationships, and proprietary information, by preventing employees from joining or starting competing businesses after leaving their position.
Notices Clause: A notices clause is a provision in a contract that outlines how formal communications between the parties should be conducted. This clause specifies the methods of delivering notices, such as by mail, email, or personal delivery, and may include details on where notices should be sent. It ensures that both parties are aware of their obligations to inform each other regarding critical issues arising from the contract.
Offer: An offer is a clear proposal made by one party to another, indicating a willingness to enter into a contract under specified terms. This proposal must be definite and communicated to the offeree, allowing them the opportunity to accept, reject, or propose a counter-offer. The ability of an offer to form the basis of a binding contract relies heavily on its clarity, intent, and communication.
Parol Evidence Rule: The parol evidence rule is a legal principle that prevents parties in a contract from presenting extrinsic evidence of prior agreements or negotiations that contradict, modify, or vary the written terms of the contract. This rule emphasizes the importance of the final written agreement as the sole source of the parties' intentions and obligations, thereby promoting clarity and certainty in contractual relationships.
Reasonable person standard: The reasonable person standard is a legal concept used to determine how an average, rational individual would act in a given situation. This standard is often used to evaluate whether a party's conduct is negligent, as it reflects societal expectations of behavior. It serves as a benchmark for assessing actions in various contexts, including the drafting of contracts and identifying potential legal issues.
Rescission: Rescission is a legal remedy that cancels a contract, returning the parties involved to their pre-contractual state. This remedy is typically sought when one party has been misled, coerced, or when the contract is deemed voidable for reasons such as fraud or mutual mistake. Understanding rescission is essential in contract law as it highlights the circumstances under which parties can dissolve agreements and the importance of consent in contractual obligations.
Severability: Severability refers to a legal concept where certain provisions of a contract or agreement can be separated from the whole without affecting the validity of the remaining provisions. This allows a contract to remain enforceable even if one part is deemed invalid or unenforceable, promoting fairness and upholding the parties' intentions. Understanding severability is crucial in drafting contracts and settlement agreements to ensure that any unenforceable terms do not invalidate the entire document.
Specific performance: Specific performance is a legal remedy in contract law that compels a party to fulfill their obligations under a contract, typically when monetary damages are inadequate to resolve the breach. This remedy is most commonly sought in situations involving unique items or properties, where simply awarding money would not fully compensate the injured party. The availability of specific performance often depends on the nature of the contract and the circumstances surrounding the breach.
Unilateral contract: A unilateral contract is a type of agreement where one party makes a promise in exchange for an act performed by another party. In this kind of contract, only one side is obligated to fulfill their promise, while the other party's acceptance is completed through their performance of the requested act. This type of contract often arises in situations like rewards or contests, where the offeror binds themselves to an obligation once the offeree completes the task.