6.5 Cosmogenic nuclide dating
8 min read•august 21, 2024
Cosmogenic nuclide dating is a powerful tool in isotope geochemistry for determining surface exposure ages and rates. This technique relies on measuring isotopes produced when cosmic rays interact with Earth's atmosphere and surface materials, providing crucial insights into landscape evolution.
The method involves careful sampling, precise measurement of trace isotopes, and complex age calculations. By accounting for factors like latitude, elevation, and shielding, scientists can date glacial landforms, fault scarps, and quantify long-term erosion rates across various geomorphic settings.
Principles of cosmogenic nuclides
- Cosmogenic nuclides form key components in isotope geochemistry used to date surface exposure and erosion rates
- Understanding cosmic ray interactions with Earth's atmosphere and surface materials underpins cosmogenic dating techniques
- Cosmogenic nuclide production varies with latitude, elevation, and other factors requiring careful calibration
Formation of cosmogenic nuclides
Top images from around the web for Formation of cosmogenic nuclides
PAGES - Past Global Changes - PAGES Magazine - Products - PAGES Magazine articles - Science ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Cosmic ray spallation - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
PAGES - Past Global Changes - PAGES Magazine - Products - PAGES Magazine articles - Science ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Cosmic ray spallation - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 2
Top images from around the web for Formation of cosmogenic nuclides
PAGES - Past Global Changes - PAGES Magazine - Products - PAGES Magazine articles - Science ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Cosmic ray spallation - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
PAGES - Past Global Changes - PAGES Magazine - Products - PAGES Magazine articles - Science ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Cosmic ray spallation - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 2
- Cosmic rays interact with atoms in Earth's atmosphere and surface to produce cosmogenic nuclides
- Secondary cosmic ray cascades generate neutrons and muons that produce nuclides in rock minerals
- Spallation reactions break apart target nuclei to form lighter cosmogenic isotopes
- Thermal neutron capture produces some cosmogenic nuclides like 36Cl in certain minerals
Common cosmogenic isotopes
- 10Be forms primarily in quartz and has a half-life of 1.39 million years
- 26Al also produced in quartz with 0.71 million year half-life enables paired dating with 10Be
- 36Cl forms in calcite and feldspar with 0.30 million year half-life
- 14C has 5,730 year half-life allowing dating of younger surfaces
- 3He and 21Ne stable noble gas isotopes accumulate over time without decay
Cosmic ray flux variations
- Primary cosmic ray flux varies with the 11-year solar cycle
- Geomagnetic field strength affects cosmic ray flux reaching Earth's surface
- Long-term variations in cosmic ray flux require calibration of production rates
- Galactic cosmic ray flux considered relatively constant over past few million years
Surface exposure dating
- Measures accumulation of cosmogenic nuclides to determine how long a surface has been exposed
- Enables dating of geomorphic surfaces like glacial moraines, lava flows, and fault scarps
- Requires assumptions about initial nuclide concentrations and erosion rates
Accumulation of cosmogenic nuclides
- increases with exposure time following exponential saturation curve
- Accumulation rate depends on production rate and radioactive decay for unstable isotopes
- Stable noble gas isotopes accumulate linearly without reaching saturation
- Nuclide concentration reaches equilibrium when production balances radioactive decay
Erosion rate effects
- Surface erosion removes cosmogenic nuclides and reduces apparent exposure age
- Steady state erosion results in constant nuclide concentration at surface
- Erosion rates can be calculated from nuclide concentrations assuming steady state
- Complex erosion histories require multi-nuclide approaches to resolve
Burial dating applications
- Measures decay of previously accumulated cosmogenic nuclides after burial
- Allows dating of sediments and cave deposits shielded from cosmic rays
- Requires initial nuclide ratio assumptions based on surface production rates
- Paired isotopes like 26Al/10Be enable determination of complex exposure-burial histories
Sampling strategies
- Proper sample collection and preparation crucial for accurate cosmogenic dating results
- Site selection and sampling methods aim to minimize geological uncertainties
- Sample preparation isolates target minerals and removes meteoric components
Site selection criteria
- Choose stable, well-preserved surfaces with simple exposure histories
- Avoid areas with significant erosion, burial, or prior shielding
- Select multiple samples to assess reproducibility and spatial variability
- Consider bedrock vs boulder samples based on geomorphic context
Sample collection methods
- Collect from upper few centimeters of rock surface to maximize cosmogenic signal
- Use hammer and chisel or rock saw to obtain ~500g of rock per sample
- Record sample location, elevation, topographic shielding, and site characteristics
- Photograph sample site and surrounding landscape for documentation
Sample preparation techniques
- Crush and sieve samples to isolate target grain size fraction (typically 250-500 μm)
- Perform mineral separation to isolate quartz or other target minerals
- Acid etching removes meteoric 10Be and atmospheric contaminants
- Carrier addition and chemical processing to extract and purify target isotopes
Measurement techniques
- High-sensitivity methods required to measure trace amounts of cosmogenic nuclides
- Different analytical approaches used for various cosmogenic isotope systems
- Advances in measurement precision enable dating of younger surfaces and lower concentrations
Accelerator mass spectrometry
- Separates and counts individual atoms based on mass and charge
- Enables measurement of rare long-lived radionuclides like 10Be, 26Al, and 36Cl
- Accelerates ions to MeV energies to eliminate molecular interferences
- Achieves isotope ratio precision of 2-5% for typical cosmogenic dating samples
Noble gas mass spectrometry
- Measures concentrations of stable cosmogenic noble gases (3He, 21Ne)
- Static vacuum systems with high-sensitivity detectors achieve sub-femtomole precision
- Step-heating extracts gases and separates cosmogenic component from other sources
- Enables dating of very old surfaces and determination of complex exposure histories
Isotope ratio analysis
- Measures relative abundances of different isotopes of same element
- Thermal ionization mass spectrometry used for some radiogenic systems
- Multicollector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry enables high-precision ratios
- Internal standardization and sample-standard bracketing improve measurement accuracy
Age calculation methods
- Convert measured nuclide concentrations to exposure ages or erosion rates
- Account for variations in production rate due to location and sample characteristics
- Apply appropriate scaling factors and corrections to derive final ages
Production rate determination
- Site-specific production rates calibrated using independently dated surfaces
- Global production rate databases compiled from multiple calibration sites
- Time-dependent production rate models account for geomagnetic field variations
- Muogenic production becomes significant for deeply buried samples
Scaling factors for latitude
- Cosmic ray flux increases with latitude due to geomagnetic field effects
- Scaling factors derived from neutron monitor data and theoretical models
- Latitude scaling more pronounced at low elevations
- Time-dependent scaling accounts for paleomagnetic field variations
Scaling factors for elevation
- Cosmic ray flux increases with elevation due to less atmospheric shielding
- Exponential increase in production rate with atmospheric depth
- Scaling factors based on atmospheric pressure rather than elevation
- Local hypsometry affects production rates in high-relief landscapes
Topographic shielding corrections
- Surrounding topography blocks portion of cosmic ray flux reaching sample
- Shielding calculated from horizon measurements or digital elevation models
- Corrections typically <10% for most samples but can be significant in deep valleys
- Self-shielding within sample accounted for in production rate depth profiles
Applications in geomorphology
- Cosmogenic nuclide dating provides powerful tool for quantifying landscape evolution
- Enables direct dating of landforms and determination of long-term erosion rates
- Applications span wide range of geomorphic processes and timescales
Glacial landform dating
- Dates exposure of glacially transported boulders on moraines
- Reconstructs ice retreat chronologies and paleoclimate records
- Accounts for complex exposure histories of reworked glacial deposits
- Combines with other dating methods to constrain glacial-interglacial cycles
Fault scarp dating
- Measures exposure ages of bedrock fault scarps or offset alluvial fans
- Determines timing and recurrence intervals of past earthquakes
- Accounts for gradual scarp degradation and erosion over time
- Combines with fault slip rates to assess seismic hazards
Landscape evolution studies
- Quantifies long-term erosion rates in various geomorphic settings
- Determines sediment generation rates and catchment-averaged denudation
- Assesses relative stability of different landscape elements
- Provides input for numerical landscape evolution models
Limitations and uncertainties
- Various factors introduce uncertainties in cosmogenic exposure dating results
- Understanding and quantifying sources of error crucial for data interpretation
- Ongoing research aims to refine methods and reduce uncertainties
Inheritance issues
- Prior exposure of sample results in overestimation of true exposure age
- Particularly problematic for surfaces with complex exposure histories
- Addressed through careful site selection and sampling of multiple clasts
- Depth profile sampling can help quantify inherited nuclide component
Erosion rate assumptions
- Unknown erosion history introduces uncertainty in exposure age calculations
- Steady state erosion assumption may not apply in all geomorphic settings
- Erosion rates can be constrained using multi-nuclide approaches
- Sensitivity analysis assesses impact of erosion rate uncertainty on ages
Atmospheric pressure variations
- Long-term changes in atmospheric pressure affect cosmogenic nuclide production
- Paleoclimate variations can alter effective elevation of sample sites
- Corrections based on independent paleoclimate proxies introduce additional uncertainty
- Effect most significant for high-elevation sites and old exposure ages
Multi-nuclide approaches
- Measurement of multiple cosmogenic nuclides in same sample provides additional constraints
- Enables resolution of complex exposure histories and erosion rates
- Requires consideration of different production rates and decay constants
Paired isotope dating
- Compares ratios of two nuclides with different half-lives (26Al/10Be)
- Identifies samples with simple exposure histories vs complex burial-exposure
- Burial dating possible for sediments shielded from cosmic rays
- Graphical methods using two-isotope diagrams aid data interpretation
Depth profile analysis
- Measures nuclide concentrations at multiple depths below surface
- Constrains both exposure age and erosion rate simultaneously
- Helps identify inherited nuclide component in depositional settings
- Requires careful sampling and consideration of deposit characteristics
Complex exposure histories
- Combines multiple nuclides to resolve periods of exposure and burial
- Identifies samples affected by past cover by ice, soil, or volcanic deposits
- Enables dating of surfaces with intermittent exposure histories
- Requires sophisticated modeling approaches to interpret data
Recent advances
- Ongoing research expands applications and improves accuracy of cosmogenic dating
- New analytical techniques enable measurement of additional cosmogenic nuclides
- Refined production rate models and scaling factors reduce systematic uncertainties
In situ vs meteoric nuclides
- In situ nuclides form within mineral lattices of surface rocks
- Meteoric nuclides delivered by precipitation and dust accumulate on surfaces
- Meteoric 10Be in soil profiles used to quantify erosion rates
- Combining in situ and meteoric approaches provides complementary information
Cosmogenic paleothermometry
- Measures cosmogenic 3He diffusion in quartz to reconstruct thermal histories
- Enables quantification of surface temperature changes over time
- Requires careful calibration of 3He diffusion kinetics in quartz
- Combines with other thermochronometers to constrain landscape thermal evolution
Developments in data interpretation
- Bayesian statistical approaches incorporate multiple sources of uncertainty
- Monte Carlo simulations assess impact of input parameter uncertainties
- Machine learning algorithms aid in complex multi-nuclide data interpretation
- Open-source software tools standardize data reduction and age calculations
Integration with other techniques
- Combining cosmogenic dating with other geochronological methods provides robust age constraints
- Multi-method approaches help validate assumptions and identify discrepancies
- Integrating different techniques enables comprehensive reconstruction of landscape histories
Luminescence dating comparison
- Optically stimulated luminescence dates burial of sediments
- Complements cosmogenic burial dating of cave deposits and terraces
- Provides independent check on cosmogenic erosion rate estimates
- Enables dating of younger surfaces beyond range of some cosmogenic systems
Radiocarbon dating vs cosmogenic
- 14C dating applies to organic materials up to ~50,000 years old
- Cosmogenic 14C in rock surfaces allows dating of younger exposures
- Combining radiocarbon and longer-lived cosmogenic nuclides constrains recent histories
- Helps identify recent erosion or burial events affecting older surfaces
Thermochronology applications
- Low-temperature thermochronology constrains rock cooling and exhumation histories
- Combining with cosmogenic data provides erosion rates at different timescales
- Apatite (U-Th)/He dating complements cosmogenic 3He in quartz
- Integrating methods helps reconstruct long-term landscape evolution trajectories
Key Terms to Review (22)
Altitude effect: The altitude effect refers to the variation in the concentration of cosmogenic nuclides in geological materials as a function of elevation. As altitude increases, the production of these nuclides from cosmic ray interactions tends to rise, influencing dating techniques that rely on cosmogenic nuclides to determine the age of landforms and sediments.
Aluminum-26: Aluminum-26 is a radioactive isotope of aluminum with a half-life of about 730,000 years. It is significant in cosmogenic nuclide dating as it forms in the Earth's atmosphere through cosmic ray interactions and can be used to date geological processes and events, such as sedimentation and erosion rates.
Beryllium-10: Beryllium-10 is a cosmogenic nuclide produced when cosmic rays interact with oxygen and nitrogen in the Earth's atmosphere, resulting in its formation in various environmental settings. This isotope has a half-life of about 1.39 million years, making it a valuable tool for dating and understanding geological processes, as well as studying surface processes and erosion rates. Its detection and measurement are often achieved using advanced techniques like accelerator mass spectrometry.
Carbon-14: Carbon-14 is a radioactive isotope of carbon, with an atomic mass of 14, that is formed in the atmosphere through the interaction of cosmic rays with nitrogen. This isotope plays a crucial role in dating organic materials and understanding various natural processes, connecting it to radiometric dating methods and the carbon cycle.
Chlorine-36: Chlorine-36 is a radioactive isotope of chlorine with a half-life of about 301,000 years, produced through cosmic rays interacting with argon in the atmosphere. This isotope is significant in various scientific fields, serving as a cosmogenic nuclide for dating ice and sediments, a tracer in hydrology to study water movement and age, and an important marker for assessing groundwater contamination levels.
Cosmogenic production rate: The cosmogenic production rate refers to the rate at which cosmic rays interact with the Earth's atmosphere and surface to create isotopes known as cosmogenic nuclides. This production rate is crucial for understanding the age of geological materials and surfaces, as it directly influences the accumulation of these isotopes over time. By measuring the concentration of cosmogenic nuclides in samples, scientists can infer the duration of exposure to cosmic radiation, helping to establish timelines in earth science and archaeology.
Decay Constant: The decay constant is a fundamental parameter that quantifies the rate at which a radioactive isotope decays over time. It is directly related to the half-life of a radioactive isotope and indicates how likely an unstable nucleus is to undergo decay in a given time period. Understanding the decay constant is crucial for comprehending various radioactive decay processes, the calculation of age in radiometric dating, and the relationships between parent and daughter isotopes.
Erosion: Erosion is the process through which soil and rock are removed from one location and transported to another by natural forces such as wind, water, or ice. This process is essential in shaping landscapes and can significantly impact geological features over time, influencing everything from sediment distribution to the formation of valleys and mountains.
Error propagation: Error propagation refers to the process of determining the uncertainty in a calculated result based on the uncertainties in the measurements used to obtain that result. It is crucial in fields like geochemistry, where precise measurements are necessary for accurate dating and analysis, such as in cosmogenic nuclide dating. Understanding how errors combine allows scientists to provide more reliable data interpretation and assess the validity of their results.
Exposure age dating: Exposure age dating is a method used to determine the length of time that a rock or sediment has been exposed at the Earth's surface to cosmic radiation. This technique is particularly important in understanding geological and geomorphological processes, as it helps establish timelines for landscape evolution, glaciation events, and soil development.
Glacial retreat: Glacial retreat refers to the process where glaciers lose mass and shrink in size, often as a result of increased temperatures and climate change. This phenomenon not only indicates the loss of ice but also reveals critical information about past climate conditions, as the rate of retreat can be linked to broader environmental changes over time.
Helium-3: Helium-3 is a rare isotope of helium that has two protons and one neutron, making it distinct from the more common helium-4. This isotope is significant in various scientific applications, especially in cosmogenic nuclide dating and contaminant source identification, as it can provide insights into processes occurring in the Earth's atmosphere and subsurface environments. Its unique properties allow researchers to trace cosmic ray interactions and assess the origins of environmental pollutants.
In situ cosmogenic nuclide dating: In situ cosmogenic nuclide dating is a geochronological method used to determine the age of rocks and sediments by measuring the concentration of cosmogenic isotopes that are produced when cosmic rays interact with the Earth's surface. This technique allows scientists to date geological features and processes, such as glacial movement and erosion, based on the accumulation of these isotopes in situ, meaning within their original location without being disturbed.
Isotopic ratios: Isotopic ratios refer to the relative abundance of different isotopes of an element, expressed as a ratio between two or more isotopes. These ratios provide valuable information about processes such as radioactive decay and the formation of nuclides in various environments, which can help us understand geological time scales and the age of materials. Isotopic ratios are crucial for interpreting decay chains and secular equilibrium as well as for methods like cosmogenic nuclide dating, both of which rely on the changes in isotopic abundances over time.
Landform analysis: Landform analysis is the study of the physical features of the Earth's surface and how they have been shaped by natural processes over time. This includes examining the processes that create landforms, their spatial distribution, and how they affect human activities and ecosystems. Understanding landform analysis helps in interpreting geological history, assessing natural hazards, and managing land use effectively.
Latitude effect: The latitude effect refers to the variation in the intensity of cosmic rays at different latitudes on Earth, which directly impacts the production of cosmogenic nuclides. This phenomenon is significant because it influences the rate at which these isotopes are formed in various environments, affecting the accuracy and interpretation of cosmogenic nuclide dating methods.
Neon-21: Neon-21 is a stable isotope of neon, which is a noble gas with the atomic number 10. This isotope has gained significance in cosmogenic nuclide dating as it is produced through the interaction of cosmic rays with certain target materials, particularly in the Earth's atmosphere and on the surface of terrestrial objects. Understanding the production and decay of neon-21 helps researchers determine exposure ages of geological samples, contributing to insights in earth sciences and climate studies.
Nuclide concentration: Nuclide concentration refers to the amount of a specific nuclide present in a given volume or mass of material. This concept is crucial in understanding the behavior and distribution of isotopes within various environments, particularly in processes like cosmogenic nuclide dating, where it helps determine the age of geological samples based on the accumulation of isotopes produced by cosmic radiation.
Paleoenvironment reconstruction: Paleoenvironment reconstruction is the process of using geological and biological evidence to infer past environmental conditions and changes over time. This approach helps scientists understand how ecosystems and climates have evolved, providing insights into historical climate fluctuations, extinction events, and species adaptations in response to changing environments.
Paul Bierman: Paul Bierman is a prominent geochemist known for his contributions to cosmogenic nuclide dating, a technique used to date geological and geomorphological processes by measuring the concentrations of isotopes produced by cosmic rays in materials. His research has significantly advanced the understanding of landscape evolution, erosion rates, and the timing of geological events through innovative applications of cosmogenic isotopes, linking geology and climate change.
Radiocarbon calibration: Radiocarbon calibration is the process of adjusting radiocarbon dating results to account for variations in atmospheric carbon-14 levels over time, leading to more accurate age estimations for organic materials. This technique is essential because the concentration of carbon-14 in the atmosphere has fluctuated due to factors such as solar activity and human influence, causing discrepancies between radiocarbon dates and actual calendar years.
William Libby: William Libby was an American physicist known for his pioneering work in radiocarbon dating, a technique that revolutionized archaeology and geology. His development of this method, which measures the decay of carbon-14 isotopes in organic materials, enabled scientists to accurately determine the age of ancient artifacts and geological samples, thus transforming our understanding of time scales in natural history.