7.4 Higher Education Policy
6 min read•july 30, 2024
Higher education policy is a complex issue with far-reaching impacts. It tackles challenges like access, affordability, and completion rates, which vary widely across different student populations. These issues are deeply intertwined with broader societal inequalities and economic trends.
Federal and state governments play crucial roles in shaping higher education through funding, financial aid, and policy decisions. The rising cost of college and growing student debt have become major concerns, sparking debates about the value and of higher education for all Americans.
Higher Education Policy Challenges
Access and Affordability Barriers
Top images from around the web for Access and Affordability Barriers
Federal student loan debt burden of noncompleters: Statistics in brief - Journalist's Resource View original
Is this image relevant?
Progressive Charlestown: Biden could cancel student debt View original
Is this image relevant?
The Rising Non-Instructional Cost of College Exemplified By University of Minnesota -e-Literate View original
Is this image relevant?
Federal student loan debt burden of noncompleters: Statistics in brief - Journalist's Resource View original
Is this image relevant?
Progressive Charlestown: Biden could cancel student debt View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Access and Affordability Barriers
Federal student loan debt burden of noncompleters: Statistics in brief - Journalist's Resource View original
Is this image relevant?
Progressive Charlestown: Biden could cancel student debt View original
Is this image relevant?
The Rising Non-Instructional Cost of College Exemplified By University of Minnesota -e-Literate View original
Is this image relevant?
Federal student loan debt burden of noncompleters: Statistics in brief - Journalist's Resource View original
Is this image relevant?
Progressive Charlestown: Biden could cancel student debt View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Access to higher education is a critical issue with significant disparities based on factors such as race, ethnicity, socioeconomic status, and geography
- These disparities are often rooted in systemic inequalities and historical discrimination (redlining, segregation)
- Affordability is a major barrier to higher education access and completion with rising tuition costs and limited financial aid options making it difficult for many students to pursue and complete degrees
- The cost of higher education has increased significantly in recent decades, outpacing inflation and wage growth
- This has led to a growing reliance on student loans and increased student debt burdens (average student loan debt of $30,000)
- Financial aid policies, such as grants (), scholarships, and , play a crucial role in making higher education more affordable for students, particularly those from low-income backgrounds
- The cost of higher education has increased significantly in recent decades, outpacing inflation and wage growth
Completion and Success Challenges
- College completion rates vary widely across different student populations and institution types with significant gaps based on factors such as race, ethnicity, and socioeconomic status
- Many students face challenges in completing their degrees, such as financial pressures, academic difficulties, and personal or family responsibilities
- These challenges can be particularly acute for non-traditional students, such as adult learners and part-time students (working parents, veterans)
- Institutions and policymakers have implemented various strategies to improve completion rates, such as providing targeted support services (tutoring, mentoring), reforming remedial education, and creating more flexible and accessible degree pathways (online courses, accelerated programs)
- Many students face challenges in completing their degrees, such as financial pressures, academic difficulties, and personal or family responsibilities
Federal and State Roles in Higher Education
Funding and Financial Aid
- Federal and state governments play a significant role in funding higher education through a combination of direct appropriations, grants, and student aid programs
- The federal government provides the majority of student financial aid through programs such as Pell Grants, subsidized and unsubsidized loans, and work-study
- State governments are the primary funders of public colleges and universities, but state funding for higher education has declined in many states in recent years
- This has led to increased tuition costs and greater reliance on student tuition and fees (in-state vs. out-of-state tuition)
- Federal and state policies also shape the structure and delivery of financial aid, including eligibility criteria, award amounts, and repayment terms
- , such as Pell Grants, are designed to provide access to higher education for low-income students
- , such as some state scholarship programs (), are awarded based on academic achievement or other criteria
Student Debt Concerns
- The growth of student debt has become a major policy concern, with total outstanding student loan debt in the United States exceeding $1.7 trillion
- High levels of student debt can have negative impacts on individual financial well-being, as well as broader economic consequences, such as delayed homeownership and reduced consumer spending
- Student loan policies, such as interest rates, repayment plans, and forgiveness programs, can have a significant impact on student debt burdens and the ability of borrowers to manage their loans
- Policymakers have proposed various solutions to address student debt, such as loan forgiveness programs (), , and increased funding for need-based aid
Higher Education Impact on Society
Social Mobility and Economic Opportunity
- Higher education is often seen as a key driver of social mobility, providing individuals with the knowledge, skills, and credentials needed to access higher-paying jobs and improve their socioeconomic status
- Research has shown that college graduates typically earn higher incomes and have lower unemployment rates than those without degrees
- However, the returns to higher education can vary based on factors such as field of study (STEM vs. humanities) and institution type (public vs. private, for-profit vs. non-profit)
- The rising cost of higher education and the growth of student debt have raised concerns about the accessibility and affordability of higher education for disadvantaged populations, potentially limiting its ability to promote social mobility
- Research has shown that college graduates typically earn higher incomes and have lower unemployment rates than those without degrees
Workforce Development and Economic Growth
- Higher education plays a critical role in workforce development, preparing students for careers in a rapidly changing economy and providing the skills and knowledge needed to drive innovation and productivity
- Many employers require or prefer candidates with college degrees for a growing number of jobs, particularly in fields such as healthcare, technology, and professional services
- Higher education institutions also play a key role in conducting research and developing new technologies and innovations that can drive economic growth and competitiveness (university research parks, technology transfer)
- The overall economic impact of higher education is significant, with colleges and universities contributing to local and regional economies through research, employment, and student spending
- Studies have shown that states and regions with higher levels of educational attainment tend to have stronger economies, higher wages, and lower unemployment rates
- However, the distribution of these economic benefits can be uneven, with some communities and populations experiencing greater gains from higher education than others (urban vs. rural, high-income vs. low-income)
Strategies for Improving Higher Education Outcomes
Student Success Interventions
- Colleges and universities have implemented a range of strategies to improve student success and completion rates, such as , academic advising, and early alert systems to identify and support struggling students
- Research has shown that these types of interventions can be effective in improving retention and , particularly for underrepresented and disadvantaged student populations
- However, the effectiveness of these strategies can vary based on factors such as institutional resources, student needs, and program design and implementation (scalability, sustainability)
Access and Affordability Initiatives
- Policymakers and higher education leaders have pursued initiatives aimed at increasing access and affordability, such as promise programs that provide free or reduced tuition to eligible students (), and efforts to simplify and streamline financial aid application processes ()
- These types of initiatives have shown promise in increasing college enrollment and completion rates, particularly for low-income and first-generation students
- However, the long-term impacts and sustainability of these programs can be challenging, particularly in the face of budget constraints and competing policy priorities
Equity and Inclusion Efforts
- Efforts to improve equity in higher education have focused on addressing disparities in access, affordability, and outcomes for underrepresented and disadvantaged student populations, such as students of color, low-income students, and first-generation students
- Strategies have included targeted outreach and recruitment efforts, need-based financial aid programs, and support services designed to address the unique challenges and barriers faced by these student populations (cultural centers, mentorship programs)
- While some progress has been made in improving equity in higher education, significant gaps and challenges remain, particularly in terms of completion rates and post-college outcomes for disadvantaged student populations
Evaluation and Research
- Evaluating the effectiveness of these strategies and initiatives requires a comprehensive and nuanced approach, taking into account a range of metrics and indicators, such as enrollment, retention, completion, and post-college outcomes, as well as the experiences and perspectives of students, faculty, and staff
- Rigorous research and evaluation, including randomized controlled trials and quasi-experimental studies, can provide valuable insights into the impacts and effectiveness of different interventions and approaches
- However, the complex and multifaceted nature of higher education means that there is no one-size-fits-all solution, and strategies and initiatives must be tailored to the specific needs and contexts of individual institutions and student populations (community colleges vs. four-year universities, urban vs. rural institutions)
Key Terms to Review (28)
Accessibility: Accessibility refers to the ease with which individuals can obtain and participate in educational opportunities, regardless of their background or personal circumstances. It encompasses factors such as affordability, availability of resources, and the removal of barriers that prevent individuals from accessing quality education. This term is crucial in understanding how educational policies strive to create equitable environments for all learners, especially in discussions around higher education and alternative schooling options.
Accreditation agencies: Accreditation agencies are organizations that evaluate and recognize educational institutions and programs for meeting certain standards of quality and effectiveness. They play a critical role in higher education by ensuring that institutions provide education that meets specific criteria, which helps maintain public trust in the quality of education and informs students and employers about the value of degrees.
Board of Trustees: A board of trustees is a group of individuals who are responsible for overseeing the governance and strategic direction of an educational institution, such as a college or university. This board typically has authority over major decisions, including budget approvals, policy formation, and the appointment of key administrators, thereby playing a crucial role in shaping higher education policy and ensuring institutional accountability.
College readiness: College readiness refers to the level of preparation a high school graduate needs to succeed in college-level courses without needing remedial education. It encompasses a mix of academic skills, study habits, and personal attributes that enable students to thrive in a higher education environment. Achieving college readiness is crucial for students aiming to pursue post-secondary education and directly ties into educational policies aimed at improving access and success in higher education.
Equity in Education: Equity in education refers to the principle of fairness and justice in educational opportunities and outcomes, ensuring that all students have access to the resources, support, and quality education they need to succeed, regardless of their background or circumstances. This concept emphasizes the need to address disparities in funding, access to qualified teachers, and educational materials, aiming to create a level playing field for all students, particularly those from marginalized or disadvantaged groups.
FAFSA Simplification: FAFSA simplification refers to the process of making the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) easier to complete and understand for students and families seeking financial aid for higher education. This initiative aims to streamline the application process by reducing the number of questions, clarifying instructions, and improving access to information, thereby encouraging more students to apply for aid and ultimately increasing college enrollment rates.
Federal student aid: Federal student aid refers to financial assistance provided by the U.S. government to help students cover the costs of their higher education. This aid comes in various forms, including grants, loans, and work-study opportunities, designed to make college more accessible and affordable for students from diverse backgrounds. By reducing the financial barriers to education, federal student aid plays a crucial role in shaping higher education policy and ensuring that students have the resources necessary to pursue their academic goals.
First-year experience programs: First-year experience programs are structured initiatives designed to support students transitioning into college by providing resources, guidance, and community-building opportunities. These programs aim to enhance academic success, social integration, and personal development during a critical period in students' educational journeys, often addressing challenges unique to new college students.
For-Profit Colleges: For-profit colleges are educational institutions that operate on a profit-driven basis, meaning they aim to generate financial returns for their owners and shareholders. These colleges often offer vocational and career-oriented programs and are known for their flexible course offerings, but they also face scrutiny regarding their cost, quality of education, and student outcomes. Their presence in the higher education landscape has raised important questions about access, affordability, and the role of education in society.
Georgia's HOPE Scholarship: Georgia's HOPE Scholarship is a state-funded financial aid program designed to help students cover the cost of tuition for post-secondary education in Georgia. It was established to encourage academic achievement among high school students and to promote access to higher education by providing financial assistance based on academic performance.
GI Bill: The GI Bill, officially known as the Servicemen’s Readjustment Act of 1944, is a landmark piece of legislation that provides various benefits to eligible military veterans, including financial support for education and housing. This program has played a crucial role in shaping higher education policy by significantly increasing access to college and vocational training for returning service members, helping them transition back into civilian life and contributing to the post-war economic boom.
Graduation Rates: Graduation rates refer to the percentage of students who successfully complete their degree programs within a specified timeframe, typically measured over four, five, or six years for undergraduate programs. These rates are crucial indicators of the effectiveness and accessibility of higher education institutions, reflecting both student success and institutional performance in retaining and graduating students.
Grants and Scholarships: Grants and scholarships are forms of financial aid that help students cover the costs of their education, specifically in higher education. Unlike loans, these funds do not need to be repaid, making them vital resources for many students seeking to manage the high costs associated with college tuition and fees. These financial support mechanisms can come from various sources, including federal and state governments, educational institutions, and private organizations, each with different eligibility criteria and application processes.
Higher Education Act: The Higher Education Act (HEA) is a significant piece of legislation in the United States, first enacted in 1965, that aims to improve access to higher education and enhance the quality of postsecondary institutions. It provides federal funding for college students through various financial aid programs, including grants, loans, and work-study opportunities, while also establishing regulations for educational institutions to promote accountability and student success.
Income-Driven Repayment Plans: Income-driven repayment plans are a set of federal student loan repayment options that adjust monthly payment amounts based on the borrower’s income and family size. These plans aim to make student loan repayment more manageable by capping payments at a percentage of discretionary income and extending the repayment term, often resulting in lower monthly payments for borrowers who may struggle to pay their loans otherwise.
Incrementalism: Incrementalism is a policy-making approach that emphasizes small, gradual changes over large, sweeping reforms. This method allows for adjustments based on previous outcomes and avoids the risks associated with radical shifts in policy, making it particularly relevant in complex areas like education and governance.
Merit-based aid programs: Merit-based aid programs are financial assistance initiatives designed to support students based on their academic achievements, talents, or other specific criteria rather than financial need. These programs aim to encourage and reward high-performing students, often through scholarships that cover tuition, fees, or other educational expenses. They can play a crucial role in promoting access to higher education for talented individuals, regardless of their economic background.
Need-based aid programs: Need-based aid programs are financial assistance initiatives designed to help students pay for their education based on their financial situation. These programs evaluate a student's need for financial support by considering various factors, such as family income and assets, to determine the amount of aid a student qualifies for. They play a crucial role in making higher education accessible to students from diverse economic backgrounds.
Online education: Online education refers to a system of learning that takes place over the internet, allowing students to access courses, materials, and instructors from anywhere with an internet connection. This mode of education has gained popularity due to its flexibility and convenience, enabling learners to pursue degrees and skills at their own pace while balancing other commitments. It plays a significant role in shaping higher education policy as institutions adapt to technological advancements and changing student needs.
Pell Grants: Pell Grants are federal financial aid awards provided to low-income undergraduate students to help cover the cost of their education. Unlike loans, Pell Grants do not have to be repaid, making them a crucial resource for students from disadvantaged backgrounds seeking higher education opportunities. These grants play a significant role in shaping access to education and addressing inequalities in funding and resources within the educational system.
Policy evaluation: Policy evaluation is the systematic assessment of the design, implementation, and outcomes of a public policy to determine its effectiveness and efficiency. This process involves collecting and analyzing data to understand whether the policy is meeting its intended goals, how well it is being executed, and what changes might be necessary for improvement. It plays a critical role in informing future policy decisions and adjustments.
Policy Implementation: Policy implementation is the process of putting specific public policies into action through various means, such as regulations, funding, and administrative procedures. It involves translating policy decisions into practical outcomes and requires collaboration among different stakeholders, including government agencies, non-profit organizations, and the private sector. Effective policy implementation is crucial for achieving the intended goals of public policies and ensuring that they have a meaningful impact on society.
Public Service Loan Forgiveness: Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) is a federal program designed to forgive the remaining balance on eligible federal student loans for borrowers who have made 120 qualifying monthly payments while working full-time in a qualifying public service job. This program aims to encourage individuals to pursue careers in public service, such as education, healthcare, and government, by alleviating the financial burden of student loan debt.
Rational Choice Theory: Rational choice theory is a framework for understanding social and economic behavior, which assumes that individuals make decisions by maximizing their utility based on preferences and constraints. It emphasizes that people weigh the costs and benefits of their options to make informed choices, influencing various aspects of policy development and evaluation.
Student loan forgiveness: Student loan forgiveness refers to the cancellation or reduction of a borrower's outstanding student loan debt, often provided under specific conditions or programs aimed at alleviating the financial burden of higher education. This concept is a significant aspect of higher education policy, as it seeks to address issues of affordability and access to education while impacting borrowers' financial stability and the broader economy.
Tennessee Promise: Tennessee Promise is a scholarship program that provides free tuition to students attending community college or technical school in Tennessee, aiming to increase access to higher education. This initiative not only covers the cost of tuition but also supports students with mentoring and guidance throughout their education journey, ultimately promoting a more educated workforce in the state.
Tuition-free college: Tuition-free college refers to educational institutions that do not charge students for tuition, allowing them to pursue higher education without the financial burden typically associated with college costs. This concept is often linked to policies aimed at increasing access to education and reducing student debt, and it plays a significant role in discussions about higher education reform and equity in educational opportunities.
Work-Study Programs: Work-study programs are financial aid initiatives that provide students with part-time job opportunities to help cover their educational expenses while attending college. These programs aim to promote access to higher education by allowing students to earn money through campus or community jobs, often related to their field of study. They not only alleviate financial burdens but also enhance students' work experience and skills, fostering a connection between academic learning and practical application.