9.3 Gendered aspects of policy-making and implementation
3 min read•july 22, 2024
Policy-making is deeply influenced by and . These shape which issues are prioritized and how policies impact different genders. aims to integrate gender perspectives into all stages of policy development.
play a crucial role in advocating for gender equality in government. However, they often face challenges like underfunding and resistance from opposing groups. Effective policy-making requires addressing these gendered dimensions.
Gendered Dimensions of Policy-Making
Gender influence on policy priorities
Top images from around the web for Gender influence on policy priorities
.jpg.&w=1080&q=75)
2017 Women's March - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
19th Century Feminist Movements | Introduction to Women Gender Sexuality Studies View original
Is this image relevant?
19th Century Feminist Movements | Introduction to Women Gender Sexuality Studies View original
Is this image relevant?
2017 Women's March - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
19th Century Feminist Movements | Introduction to Women Gender Sexuality Studies View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Gender influence on policy priorities
2017 Women's March - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
19th Century Feminist Movements | Introduction to Women Gender Sexuality Studies View original
Is this image relevant?
19th Century Feminist Movements | Introduction to Women Gender Sexuality Studies View original
Is this image relevant?
2017 Women's March - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
19th Century Feminist Movements | Introduction to Women Gender Sexuality Studies View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Gender norms and stereotypes shape perceptions of important issues influence which problems are prioritized on policy agendas (childcare, education)
- affects policy areas seen as "women's issues" leads to underrepresentation of women's interests in traditionally male-dominated domains (defense, finance)
- Composition of decision-making bodies with and executive branches may overlook gender-specific concerns while increased can bring attention to gender equality issues (, )
- Influence of and advocacy groups pressure governments to address gender inequalities and women's rights raise awareness about gendered implications of policies (, )
Gendered impact of policies
- like affect women's labor force participation and career advancement while and persist (service sector, care work)
- with eligibility criteria and benefit levels may disadvantage women (part-time workers, ) and cuts to social services disproportionately impact women who rely on these services more
- on like access to and primarily affect women along with gender disparities in health insurance coverage and healthcare access
- with may create disincentives for women's employment while on basic goods place higher burden on women managing household budgets
Effectiveness of gender mainstreaming
- Gender mainstreaming integrates a gender perspective into all stages of the policy process assessing implications for women and men
- Institutional mechanisms for gender mainstreaming include:
- for policymakers and civil servants
- Challenges in implementation involve limited and resources, within institutions, and difficulty translating gender equality goals into concrete policy actions
- Measuring impact of gender mainstreaming requires to assess progress towards gender equality and collecting and analyzing to inform policy decisions
Role of women's policy agencies
- Types of women's policy agencies include government ministries dedicated to women's affairs (), , and
- Functions of women's policy agencies involve advocating for gender equality in policy-making, providing expertise on gender issues to government bodies, and monitoring implementation of gender equality policies and legislation
- Women's policy agencies influence by raising the profile of gender equality issues within government, collaborating with women's organizations to inform policy, and holding governments accountable for gender equality commitments
- Limitations and challenges faced by women's policy agencies include being underfunded and marginalized within government structures and facing resistance or backlash from actors opposing gender equality measures (, )
Key Terms to Review (49)
Abortion: Abortion is the medical termination of a pregnancy, either through surgical procedures or the use of medication. This complex issue encompasses a wide range of ethical, legal, and health-related debates and is deeply intertwined with women's rights, reproductive autonomy, and public policy. The ways in which abortion is regulated and understood can vary greatly depending on cultural, political, and gendered contexts, affecting access and attitudes toward women's health and bodily autonomy.
Accountability for gender equality commitments: Accountability for gender equality commitments refers to the mechanisms and processes that ensure organizations, governments, and institutions are held responsible for their promises and actions toward achieving gender equality. This accountability can take many forms, including monitoring, reporting, and evaluation, which are crucial in assessing progress and identifying gaps in policies and practices aimed at promoting gender equity.
Advisory Councils on Gender Equality: Advisory councils on gender equality are specialized bodies formed to provide expert advice and recommendations to governments and organizations regarding policies that promote gender equity. These councils aim to ensure that gender considerations are integrated into decision-making processes, enhancing the representation of women's interests in policy formulation and implementation.
Advisory councils on gender equality: Advisory councils on gender equality are specialized bodies or groups established to provide guidance and recommendations on policies and practices related to gender equality within various sectors. These councils play a critical role in ensuring that gender considerations are integrated into policy-making and implementation processes, thereby promoting equitable outcomes for all genders.
Advisory councils on gender equality: Advisory councils on gender equality are bodies established to provide guidance, recommendations, and expertise to governments or organizations on issues related to gender equality. These councils often include diverse stakeholders such as activists, academics, and representatives from various sectors, working together to influence policy-making and ensure that gender perspectives are integrated into decision-making processes.
Capacity-building: Capacity-building refers to the process of developing and strengthening the skills, abilities, and resources of individuals, organizations, and communities to enhance their effectiveness and sustainability. This concept is particularly important in policy-making and implementation, as it helps ensure that gender perspectives are integrated and that various stakeholders can actively engage in the decision-making processes.
Conservative Groups: Conservative groups are organizations or movements that advocate for traditional values, often resisting social changes related to gender and sexuality. These groups play a significant role in shaping policies and influencing political discourse by promoting the preservation of established norms and institutions, particularly regarding gender roles and family structures. Their stance often leads to a notable impact on policy-making processes, especially concerning gendered issues.
Consumption taxes: Consumption taxes are taxes levied on the sale of goods and services, typically paid by consumers at the point of purchase. These taxes can take various forms, including sales taxes, value-added taxes (VAT), and excise taxes, and they play a significant role in government revenue. In relation to gendered aspects of policy-making and implementation, consumption taxes can disproportionately affect different genders, particularly in how they impact low-income households and the distribution of economic burdens.
Contraception: Contraception refers to the methods and devices used to prevent pregnancy during sexual intercourse. It plays a crucial role in reproductive health, allowing individuals to make informed decisions about family planning, timing of children, and sexual relationships. The availability and accessibility of contraception are significantly influenced by policy-making and can reflect broader gender dynamics in society.
Employment policies: Employment policies are guidelines and regulations that govern the hiring, treatment, and termination of employees within an organization or government. These policies aim to promote fairness, equality, and non-discrimination in the workplace while addressing various aspects such as recruitment, wages, benefits, and workplace safety. The development and implementation of employment policies often reflect broader societal values and can have gendered implications that shape the workforce dynamics.
Feminist movements: Feminist movements refer to organized efforts aimed at advocating for women's rights, gender equality, and challenging societal norms that perpetuate gender-based discrimination. These movements have evolved over time, addressing various issues such as suffrage, reproductive rights, workplace equality, and violence against women, significantly influencing policies and social attitudes related to gender.
Gender impact assessments: Gender impact assessments are systematic evaluations that analyze the potential effects of policies, programs, or projects on individuals of different genders. These assessments aim to ensure that gender equality is considered in decision-making processes, helping to identify any disparities and promote equitable outcomes for all genders. By assessing how policies might differently affect men, women, and non-binary individuals, these evaluations play a crucial role in shaping more inclusive and effective governance.
Gender issues expertise: Gender issues expertise refers to the specialized knowledge and skills related to understanding, analyzing, and addressing the various dimensions of gender inequalities and their implications in different contexts. This expertise enables individuals to critically assess how gender dynamics influence policy-making processes and the implementation of decisions, ensuring that gender considerations are integrated into all aspects of governance and public administration.
Gender mainstreaming: Gender mainstreaming is a strategic approach to promoting gender equality by integrating gender considerations into the design, implementation, monitoring, and evaluation of policies and programs. This approach recognizes that gender inequalities can influence outcomes and aims to ensure that both women's and men's interests are considered in decision-making processes.
Gender norms: Gender norms are the societal expectations and behaviors associated with being male or female, shaped by cultural, historical, and social contexts. These norms dictate what is considered appropriate behavior, interests, and roles for each gender, influencing individuals from a young age and impacting their interactions and identities throughout life.
Gender wage gaps: Gender wage gaps refer to the difference in earnings between individuals of different genders, often highlighting the disparity in pay that women receive compared to men for similar work. This term is crucial for understanding how economic policies and practices can impact individuals based on gender, revealing systemic inequalities in the workforce and the influence of societal norms on compensation.
Gender-responsive budgeting: Gender-responsive budgeting is an approach that ensures budgetary processes are inclusive of gender considerations, aiming to promote gender equality and address the different needs of women, men, and non-binary individuals. This process integrates a gender perspective into all levels of budgeting, from planning and implementation to monitoring and evaluation, highlighting how financial resources can impact different genders and ultimately foster equitable outcomes in policy-making and implementation.
Gendered division of labor: The gendered division of labor refers to the way in which work tasks and roles are distributed based on gender, often leading to distinct expectations for men and women in both domestic and professional settings. This division can be seen in various aspects of society, where traditionally, men are associated with paid work outside the home, while women are often relegated to unpaid domestic work or roles that are stereotypically viewed as 'feminine.'
Health policies: Health policies are decisions, goals, and actions that guide the planning, implementation, and evaluation of health-related initiatives within a society. These policies can affect the accessibility, quality, and equity of healthcare services, and often take into account various gendered aspects that influence health outcomes. Understanding these policies is crucial because they play a significant role in addressing disparities and improving overall public health.
Joint taxation systems: Joint taxation systems refer to tax structures where married couples or partners file their income taxes together as a single unit, combining their income and deductions for tax purposes. This system can create distinct financial implications for couples, particularly in how it affects overall tax liabilities and the distribution of benefits or burdens between partners. The design of these systems can have gendered effects, influencing economic inequalities based on marital status and gender roles within households.
Male-dominated legislatures: Male-dominated legislatures refer to governmental bodies where men significantly outnumber women in positions of power and decision-making. This imbalance can lead to the marginalization of women's voices and perspectives in the legislative process, often resulting in policies that do not adequately address gender-specific issues or the needs of women.
Ministry of Women: The Ministry of Women refers to a governmental body or agency dedicated to promoting gender equality and addressing issues specifically related to women. This ministry plays a vital role in shaping policies, programs, and initiatives that aim to empower women and integrate their perspectives into broader governmental agendas, thus influencing how policies are formulated and implemented.
Ministry of women: The ministry of women refers to a governmental body or agency that is specifically tasked with addressing issues related to women's rights, gender equality, and the empowerment of women within a nation. This ministry plays a crucial role in shaping policies and implementing programs that promote women's social, economic, and political rights, often advocating for gender-sensitive approaches in all areas of governance.
Monitoring and evaluation frameworks: Monitoring and evaluation frameworks are structured systems used to assess the effectiveness, efficiency, and impact of policies and programs. These frameworks help in systematically collecting data, analyzing results, and making informed decisions to improve outcomes, particularly concerning how gender perspectives are integrated into policy-making and implementation processes.
Occupational Segregation: Occupational segregation refers to the distribution of workers across and within occupations based on demographic characteristics, particularly gender. This phenomenon often results in certain jobs being dominated by one gender, leading to disparities in employment opportunities and economic outcomes, as well as reinforcing societal norms around gender roles.
Ombudspersons for women's rights: Ombudspersons for women's rights are independent officials or advocates appointed to address and resolve issues related to gender equality and women's rights within various sectors, including government, workplaces, and communities. They play a crucial role in ensuring that policies and practices are implemented fairly and effectively while advocating for systemic changes to promote gender equity. Their work often involves monitoring compliance, providing guidance, and serving as a resource for individuals seeking support in matters related to discrimination and gender-based violence.
Parental leave: Parental leave refers to the time that parents can take off from work to care for their newborn or newly adopted child. This leave is crucial for promoting family well-being and gender equality in the workplace, as it allows both mothers and fathers to share the responsibilities of childcare. By providing paid or unpaid time away from work, parental leave policies can influence gender representation in political institutions and impact the ways policies are crafted and implemented regarding family support.
Parental leave: Parental leave refers to the time off work that parents can take to care for their newborn or newly adopted child, allowing them to bond and provide essential care during the early stages of the child's life. This concept is closely tied to discussions about gender equality in the workplace, as the policies surrounding parental leave often reflect societal attitudes towards gender roles, caregiving responsibilities, and the balance between work and family life.
Pay Equity: Pay equity refers to the principle of ensuring that individuals are compensated fairly for their work, regardless of gender, race, or other characteristics. This concept highlights the need to address wage disparities between different groups and is crucial for promoting economic justice and equality in the workplace. Achieving pay equity involves analyzing pay structures, addressing biases in hiring and promotions, and implementing policies that foster transparency and fairness in compensation.
Policy advocacy: Policy advocacy refers to the active support and promotion of specific policies or changes in legislation aimed at addressing societal issues, particularly those affecting marginalized groups. This process involves engaging with stakeholders, policymakers, and the public to influence decisions that shape laws and regulations. It often highlights the gendered dimensions of issues, aiming to create equitable outcomes for all genders in policy-making and implementation.
Policy outcomes: Policy outcomes refer to the results or effects that follow the implementation of policies, particularly how they impact different groups in society. These outcomes can be measured in terms of effectiveness, efficiency, and equity, and are often influenced by the processes of policy-making and implementation, especially regarding gendered perspectives. Understanding policy outcomes is essential for evaluating how well policies address the needs of diverse populations and whether they perpetuate or alleviate existing inequalities.
Policy priorities: Policy priorities refer to the specific goals or objectives that guide decision-making in policy formulation and implementation. These priorities can influence which issues receive attention and resources, often reflecting the values and interests of those in power. In the context of gendered aspects, understanding policy priorities is essential as they can significantly shape the experiences and opportunities of different genders in society.
Political Will: Political will refers to the commitment of political leaders and institutions to implement policies and take actions that address certain issues, often reflecting a desire for change or reform. It encompasses the motivations, intentions, and resolve of decision-makers to prioritize particular agendas, especially those related to social justice and equality. In the context of policy-making, political will can significantly influence the effectiveness and outcomes of gender-related policies and their implementation.
Religious institutions: Religious institutions are structured organizations that are formed around shared beliefs and practices related to spirituality and faith. They play a critical role in shaping social norms, values, and cultural identities, often influencing policies and community behaviors, especially regarding gender roles and expectations.
Representation of women: The representation of women refers to the way in which women's roles, experiences, and perspectives are depicted and acknowledged in various forms of media, politics, and society at large. This concept highlights the importance of including women's voices and experiences in decision-making processes and policy development, recognizing that their representation is crucial for achieving gender equality and addressing issues that uniquely affect women.
Reproductive health: Reproductive health refers to a state of complete physical, mental, and social well-being in all matters relating to the reproductive system at all stages of life. It emphasizes the importance of access to safe and effective family planning, reproductive health services, education, and the ability to make informed choices about reproduction. This concept plays a critical role in shaping policies and addressing the multifaceted connections between gender, health outcomes, and socioeconomic factors.
Reproductive rights: Reproductive rights refer to the legal rights and freedoms relating to reproduction and reproductive health, including the right to access contraception, family planning, and safe abortion services. These rights are essential for ensuring bodily autonomy, enabling individuals to make informed decisions about their reproductive health without coercion or discrimination. Recognizing reproductive rights highlights the intersection of gender equality, healthcare access, and social justice.
Resistance to Change: Resistance to change refers to the behaviors, attitudes, and feelings that individuals or groups exhibit when faced with new policies, practices, or cultural shifts. In the context of gendered aspects of policy-making and implementation, this resistance can stem from deeply ingrained social norms and institutional structures that favor traditional gender roles and power dynamics. Understanding resistance is crucial for implementing effective policies that promote gender equality, as it highlights the barriers that need to be addressed for successful change.
Resistance to gender equality measures: Resistance to gender equality measures refers to the opposition or reluctance to adopt policies and practices aimed at promoting equal rights and opportunities for all genders. This resistance can manifest at various levels, including individual, organizational, and institutional, often rooted in societal norms, power dynamics, and cultural beliefs that uphold traditional gender roles. Understanding this resistance is crucial in analyzing how policies are formulated and implemented in a way that either supports or hinders gender equality.
Sex-disaggregated data: Sex-disaggregated data refers to data that is broken down by sex, allowing for the analysis of differences and disparities between males and females. This type of data is crucial in understanding how policies and programs affect different genders, enabling more effective policy-making and implementation that considers the unique needs of each sex. It provides insights into gender-specific trends, access to resources, and outcomes in various sectors such as health, education, and employment.
Single Mothers: Single mothers are women who raise their children without a partner, often shouldering the responsibility for their family's financial and emotional needs. This situation can arise from various circumstances, including divorce, separation, or the decision to bear children outside of a traditional family structure. The challenges faced by single mothers can be amplified by class and socioeconomic status, influencing access to resources and support systems. Furthermore, policy-making and implementation significantly affect the welfare and rights of single mothers, often shaping their access to healthcare, education, and financial assistance.
Social welfare policies: Social welfare policies are government initiatives and programs designed to provide support and assistance to individuals and families in need, addressing issues such as poverty, healthcare, education, and housing. These policies can have significant gendered implications, as they often reflect and reinforce societal norms related to gender roles, responsibilities, and access to resources.
Stereotypes: Stereotypes are oversimplified and generalized beliefs or ideas about a particular group of people, often based on characteristics such as gender, race, or sexual orientation. These mental shortcuts can lead to prejudiced views and discriminatory behavior, affecting how individuals are perceived and treated in society. Stereotypes can contribute to stigma and discrimination, particularly for marginalized groups like LGBTQ+ individuals, as well as influence policy-making processes by reinforcing traditional gender roles and biases.
Tax policies: Tax policies are the laws and regulations that govern how taxes are levied, collected, and managed by a government. These policies can significantly influence economic behavior and societal structures, particularly in relation to income distribution, public services, and social equity. In the context of gendered aspects of policy-making and implementation, tax policies can reflect and reinforce gender inequalities by favoring certain groups over others, affecting women's economic status and participation in the workforce.
Tax Policies: Tax policies are the regulations and guidelines that govern how taxes are levied, collected, and managed by the government. These policies can significantly impact economic behavior and social equity, shaping who pays taxes and how much they pay, which can lead to varied effects on different gender groups depending on their economic roles and responsibilities.
Training and capacity-building: Training and capacity-building refer to processes aimed at enhancing the skills, knowledge, and abilities of individuals or groups, particularly in the context of policy-making. These efforts empower people to effectively participate in decision-making, implement policies, and navigate institutional frameworks, especially regarding gender equality. Strengthening these capacities is crucial for creating inclusive environments where diverse perspectives can contribute to effective policy development and implementation.
Underfunding of women's policy agencies: The underfunding of women's policy agencies refers to the inadequate financial support and resources allocated to organizations and government bodies that focus on developing and implementing policies aimed at advancing gender equality and addressing women's issues. This lack of funding often hinders their ability to effectively carry out initiatives, conduct research, provide services, and advocate for necessary changes in legislation and public policy.
Violence against women: Violence against women encompasses any act of gender-based violence that results in, or is likely to result in, physical, sexual, or psychological harm or suffering to women. This term includes a range of abusive behaviors, from domestic violence and sexual assault to harassment and harmful cultural practices, reflecting deep-rooted societal norms and inequalities.
Women's policy agencies: Women's policy agencies are specialized governmental organizations that focus on addressing issues related to gender equality and women's rights in public policy. These agencies play a critical role in the policy-making process by promoting women's perspectives, advocating for legislative changes, and ensuring that women's needs are considered in various policy areas. Their work involves research, analysis, and the development of programs aimed at improving the socio-economic status of women and combating discrimination.