9.1 Economic Sanctions as a Tool of Foreign Policy
3 min read•august 7, 2024
Economic sanctions are a powerful tool in foreign policy, used to pressure countries into changing their behavior. From targeted measures against individuals to affecting entire economies, these penalties can have far-reaching consequences.
Sanctions can be imposed unilaterally or multilaterally, with varying degrees of effectiveness. While they can signal international disapproval and impose , sanctions often raise concerns about and unintended consequences on global trade and diplomacy.
Types of Economic Sanctions
Targeted vs. Comprehensive Sanctions
Top images from around the web for Targeted vs. Comprehensive Sanctions
US Sanctions Are Designed to Kill | Op-Eds & Columns | CEPR View original
Is this image relevant?
Economic Sanctions | All About World Politics View original
Is this image relevant?
9.2. Intermediate Sanctions – SOU-CCJ230 Introduction to the American Criminal Justice System View original
Is this image relevant?
US Sanctions Are Designed to Kill | Op-Eds & Columns | CEPR View original
Is this image relevant?
Economic Sanctions | All About World Politics View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Targeted vs. Comprehensive Sanctions
US Sanctions Are Designed to Kill | Op-Eds & Columns | CEPR View original
Is this image relevant?
Economic Sanctions | All About World Politics View original
Is this image relevant?
9.2. Intermediate Sanctions – SOU-CCJ230 Introduction to the American Criminal Justice System View original
Is this image relevant?
US Sanctions Are Designed to Kill | Op-Eds & Columns | CEPR View original
Is this image relevant?
Economic Sanctions | All About World Politics View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Economic sanctions are penalties imposed by countries or international organizations against a target country, entity, or individual to coerce a change in behavior
- () focus on specific individuals, organizations, or sectors to minimize the impact on the general population (freezing assets, travel bans, arms embargoes)
- Comprehensive sanctions broadly target an entire country's economy, including trade restrictions, , and investment prohibitions (, Cuba)
- Comprehensive sanctions often lead to significant humanitarian consequences for the civilian population (food and medicine shortages, economic hardship)
Unilateral vs. Multilateral Sanctions
- are imposed by a single country against a without the cooperation or support of other nations ()
- involve the coordination and participation of multiple countries, increasing the pressure on the target state to comply
- are a form of multilateral sanctions imposed by the UN Security Council, binding all UN member states to enforce them (, Libya, North Korea)
- Multilateral sanctions are generally considered more effective than unilateral measures due to the collective pressure and international legitimacy
Actors in Economic Sanctions
Sender and Target States
- The target state is the country, entity, or individual against whom the sanctions are imposed, with the goal of changing their behavior or policies
- The is the country or group of countries imposing the sanctions, often in response to violations of international norms or threats to peace and security
- Sender states aim to inflict economic costs on the target state to pressure them into compliance with specific demands (ending , halting )
- Target states may seek to evade or counteract sanctions through various means (, , )
Impact and Consequences of Sanctions
Effectiveness and Humanitarian Concerns
- The in achieving their intended goals is often debated, with success rates varying depending on the specific case and context
- Sanctions can be effective in signaling international disapproval, isolating the target state, and imposing economic costs, but may not always lead to the desired policy changes
- Humanitarian impact is a major concern with comprehensive sanctions, as they can lead to shortages of essential goods, reduced access to healthcare and education, and increased poverty
- Critics argue that sanctions often disproportionately affect vulnerable populations while failing to change the behavior of the targeted regime or individuals
Secondary Sanctions and Global Impact
- are penalties imposed on third-party countries, entities, or individuals for engaging in transactions with the primary target of sanctions ()
- Secondary sanctions aim to deter other actors from undermining the effectiveness of the primary sanctions by threatening them with penalties for non-compliance
- The use of secondary sanctions can lead to tensions between the sender state and its allies or trading partners, as they may view them as an
- The global impact of sanctions can be significant, disrupting international trade, financial flows, and diplomatic relations, with potential spillover effects on regional stability and global economic growth
Key Terms to Review (25)
Alternative Trade Routes: Alternative trade routes refer to pathways or channels that countries or regions use to conduct trade when conventional routes are blocked, restricted, or economically unfavorable. These routes can emerge due to geopolitical conflicts, economic sanctions, or infrastructural changes, providing nations with options to maintain commerce and connect with global markets.
Comprehensive sanctions: Comprehensive sanctions are a type of economic penalty imposed by one or more countries against a target nation, entity, or individual, aiming to restrict trade, financial transactions, and economic activities. These sanctions are broad in scope, covering a wide array of goods, services, and investments, with the intent to exert pressure on the target government or influence its behavior. By isolating the target economically and politically, comprehensive sanctions serve as a tool for foreign policy to promote change without direct military intervention.
Cuban Trade Embargo: The Cuban Trade Embargo is a series of economic sanctions imposed by the United States on Cuba, beginning in 1960, that restricts trade and economic activities with the island nation. This embargo was established primarily as a response to Cuba's nationalization of American businesses and properties, aiming to pressure the Cuban government to change its policies and promote democracy. The embargo has been a pivotal aspect of U.S.-Cuba relations, significantly impacting Cuba's economy and the geopolitical landscape of the region.
Domestic Production: Domestic production refers to the creation of goods and services within a country, contributing to its economy and affecting trade balances. This process plays a significant role in shaping national economic policies, influencing foreign relations, and impacting the effectiveness of economic sanctions as a tool of foreign policy.
Economic costs: Economic costs refer to the total expenses incurred by a country when implementing economic sanctions, including both direct financial losses and indirect impacts on trade, investment, and overall economic stability. These costs can affect not only the targeted nation but also the sanctioning country, as trade relationships are disrupted and market dynamics shift, leading to broader implications for international relations.
Effectiveness of sanctions: The effectiveness of sanctions refers to the degree to which economic penalties imposed by one or more countries achieve their intended goals, such as changing the behavior of a targeted state or influencing its policy decisions. The evaluation of these sanctions often considers factors like their ability to impact the economy, political landscape, and the overall stability of the targeted nation. Various elements such as the type of sanctions, the resilience of the target nation, and international support play crucial roles in determining their success.
Extraterritorial application of domestic law: Extraterritorial application of domestic law refers to the ability of a country to enforce its laws beyond its own borders, often impacting foreign entities and individuals. This concept connects closely with the use of economic sanctions, where a state may impose restrictions on foreign nations or businesses that violate its laws, even when those actions occur outside its jurisdiction. Such practices can lead to international disputes and challenge the principles of sovereignty and non-interference in the affairs of other states.
Financial sanctions: Financial sanctions are restrictive measures imposed by countries or international organizations to limit the financial activities of specific individuals, entities, or countries, aimed at achieving foreign policy objectives. These sanctions can include asset freezes, restrictions on access to financial markets, and prohibitions on certain transactions, all designed to pressure the targeted parties into changing their behavior or policies.
Human rights abuses: Human rights abuses refer to violations of the fundamental rights and freedoms to which every individual is entitled, often carried out by governments or organizations. These abuses can manifest in various forms, such as torture, discrimination, unlawful detention, and extrajudicial killings, significantly impacting the dignity and well-being of individuals. The connection to economic sanctions arises when countries impose these measures in response to such violations, aiming to pressure governments to adhere to international human rights standards.
Humanitarian impact: Humanitarian impact refers to the effects that actions, policies, or events have on the well-being and dignity of individuals and communities, especially in crisis situations. This concept is crucial in assessing the outcomes of foreign policy tools, like economic sanctions, as they can lead to unintended consequences that may exacerbate human suffering or disrupt essential services.
Multilateral sanctions: Multilateral sanctions are punitive measures imposed by multiple countries or international organizations against a target state, group, or individual to influence behavior and achieve foreign policy objectives. These sanctions aim to create a unified front, increasing their effectiveness by isolating the target from the global economy and political community while minimizing the risk of backlash against any single country imposing them.
Nuclear proliferation: Nuclear proliferation refers to the spread of nuclear weapons and technology to countries that do not currently possess them. This phenomenon raises concerns about international security, as it can lead to increased tensions between nations, heighten the risk of nuclear conflict, and complicate global nonproliferation efforts aimed at controlling the spread of these destructive capabilities.
Sanctions against Iraq: Sanctions against Iraq refer to a series of economic and military restrictions imposed primarily by the United Nations following Iraq's invasion of Kuwait in 1990. These sanctions were intended to compel Iraq to withdraw its forces from Kuwait and adhere to international law while aiming to limit its ability to develop weapons of mass destruction. The sanctions had profound effects on the Iraqi economy and civilian population, highlighting the challenges and effectiveness of using economic sanctions as a tool of foreign policy.
Sanctions Against Libya: Sanctions against Libya refer to a series of economic and political measures imposed by the international community, particularly the United Nations and the United States, in response to Libya's involvement in terrorism and human rights abuses. These sanctions aimed to pressure the Libyan government to change its behavior, specifically regarding its support for terrorist organizations and its controversial policies. By restricting trade, investment, and diplomatic relations, these sanctions were intended to isolate Libya and compel it to comply with international norms.
Secondary sanctions: Secondary sanctions are punitive measures imposed by one country on entities or individuals from a third country that conduct business with a sanctioned country. These sanctions extend the reach of a primary country's sanctions, discouraging international trade and investment in the targeted state by threatening penalties on those who interact with it, thus serving as a powerful tool of economic diplomacy.
Sender State: A sender state refers to a country that imposes economic sanctions or other forms of coercive measures against another state to influence its behavior or policy. The sender state utilizes these tools as part of its foreign policy strategy to achieve specific objectives, often in response to perceived threats or violations of international norms.
Smart sanctions: Smart sanctions are targeted economic measures designed to minimize the humanitarian impact of sanctions while still exerting pressure on specific individuals, entities, or sectors within a country. These sanctions aim to hold specific parties accountable without broadly affecting the general population, making them a more nuanced tool of foreign policy.
Smuggling: Smuggling refers to the illegal movement of goods or people across borders, often to evade customs duties or legal restrictions. This practice can undermine economic sanctions, which are designed to restrict trade and resources from reaching specific countries or entities. Smuggling can occur in various forms, such as transporting prohibited items or bypassing regulated trade routes, and can significantly impact international relations and security.
Target State: A target state refers to a nation or entity that is the focus of a particular foreign policy action, often as a subject of economic sanctions or other forms of coercive diplomacy. This concept is crucial in understanding how states seek to influence the behavior of other countries by imposing restrictions or penalties, typically in response to perceived violations of international norms or threats to national security.
Targeted sanctions: Targeted sanctions are specific measures imposed by countries or international organizations aimed at individuals, entities, or sectors within a state to influence behavior without affecting the broader population. These sanctions can include asset freezes, travel bans, and restrictions on specific trade or economic activities, and are designed to minimize humanitarian impact while compelling a change in the targeted parties' actions or policies.
U.S. Sanctions Against Iran: U.S. sanctions against Iran are economic and political restrictions imposed by the United States aimed at curbing Iran's nuclear program, limiting its influence in the Middle East, and addressing human rights abuses. These sanctions can include measures such as trade restrictions, asset freezes, and financial penalties, which serve as tools of foreign policy to compel behavioral changes in the Iranian government.
U.S. Sanctions Against North Korea: U.S. sanctions against North Korea are economic and political measures imposed by the United States in response to North Korea's nuclear weapons program, human rights violations, and aggressive behavior. These sanctions aim to pressure the North Korean government to denuclearize and adhere to international norms while also signaling disapproval of its actions on the global stage.
U.S. Secondary Sanctions Related to Iran: U.S. secondary sanctions related to Iran are measures that target non-U.S. individuals and entities doing business with Iran, effectively pressuring them to cease their economic activities with the country. These sanctions serve as an extension of U.S. foreign policy and aim to isolate Iran economically, particularly in sectors like energy and finance, by disincentivizing global partnerships that could support the Iranian regime.
Unilateral sanctions: Unilateral sanctions are economic measures imposed by one country against another without the support of international organizations or other nations. These sanctions aim to influence the target country's behavior, often in response to actions deemed unacceptable, such as human rights violations or aggression. Unilateral sanctions can affect trade, financial transactions, and diplomatic relations, serving as a tool of foreign policy to exert pressure without military intervention.
United Nations Sanctions: United Nations sanctions are measures imposed by the UN Security Council against countries or entities to maintain or restore international peace and security. These sanctions can include economic restrictions, arms embargoes, travel bans, and other diplomatic actions aimed at influencing the behavior of a state or group that poses a threat to global stability. They serve as a crucial tool of foreign policy to pressure governments to comply with international norms and resolutions.