11.2 Theories of Business Cycles
5 min read•august 15, 2024
Business cycles are like economic rollercoasters, with ups and downs that affect our lives. Economists have different ideas about what causes these swings. Some think it's about how much we spend, others focus on money, and some look at how productive we are.
These theories help us understand why the economy changes and what we can do about it. They give us tools to predict future ups and downs and figure out how to make the ride smoother for everyone.
Theories of Business Cycles
Keynesian, Monetarist, and Real Business Cycle Theories
Top images from around the web for Keynesian, Monetarist, and Real Business Cycle Theories
G. Mick Smith, PhD: Honors Business Economics: 17 May 2011 View original
Is this image relevant?
Reading: The Business Cycle: Definition and Phases | Introduction to Business View original
Is this image relevant?
Business Cycles | Macroeconomics with Prof. Dolar View original
Is this image relevant?
G. Mick Smith, PhD: Honors Business Economics: 17 May 2011 View original
Is this image relevant?
Reading: The Business Cycle: Definition and Phases | Introduction to Business View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Keynesian, Monetarist, and Real Business Cycle Theories
G. Mick Smith, PhD: Honors Business Economics: 17 May 2011 View original
Is this image relevant?
Reading: The Business Cycle: Definition and Phases | Introduction to Business View original
Is this image relevant?
Business Cycles | Macroeconomics with Prof. Dolar View original
Is this image relevant?
G. Mick Smith, PhD: Honors Business Economics: 17 May 2011 View original
Is this image relevant?
Reading: The Business Cycle: Definition and Phases | Introduction to Business View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- emphasizes the role of shocks, such as changes in investment or government spending, in driving business cycle fluctuations
- Assumes prices and wages are sticky in the short run, leading to adjustments in output and employment
- focuses on the role of money supply and in causing business cycles
- Assumes changes in the money supply have a direct impact on aggregate demand and that the economy is inherently stable in the long run
- Real Business Cycle (RBC) theory attributes business cycle fluctuations to real factors, such as and changes in productivity
- Assumes prices and wages are flexible and that the economy is always in equilibrium
- Keynesian and Monetarist theories emphasize demand-side factors, while RBC theory focuses on supply-side factors as the primary drivers of business cycles
Comparing and Contrasting Business Cycle Theories
- Keynesian theory focuses on demand-side factors (investment, government spending), while RBC theory emphasizes supply-side factors (technology shocks, )
- Monetarist theory highlights the role of money supply and monetary policy, while Keynesian theory stresses the importance of
- Keynesian and Monetarist theories assume some degree of price and wage stickiness, while RBC theory assumes perfect price and wage flexibility
- Keynesian theory suggests government intervention can stabilize the economy, while RBC theory argues that business cycles are the result of the economy's optimal response to real shocks
Assumptions of Business Cycle Theories
Keynesian Theory Assumptions and Mechanisms
- Assumes prices and wages are sticky in the short run, leading to adjustments in output and employment rather than prices
- Emphasizes the role of aggregate demand shocks, such as changes in investment (new factories, equipment) or government spending (infrastructure projects), in driving business cycle fluctuations
- Suggests government intervention through fiscal policies (tax cuts, increased spending) and monetary policies (lower interest rates) can help stabilize the economy during recessions
Monetarist Theory Assumptions and Mechanisms
- Assumes changes in the money supply have a direct impact on aggregate demand and that the economy is inherently stable in the long run
- Emphasizes the role of monetary policy in causing business cycles, with expansionary policy (increasing money supply) leading to booms and contractionary policy (decreasing money supply) leading to recessions
- Suggests maintaining a stable growth rate of the money supply can help prevent business cycle fluctuations
Real Business Cycle Theory Assumptions and Mechanisms
- Assumes prices and wages are flexible and that the economy is always in equilibrium
- Attributes business cycle fluctuations to real factors, such as technology shocks (new inventions, innovations) and changes in productivity (efficiency of production)
- Suggests business cycles are the result of the economy's optimal response to changes in real factors and that government intervention is unnecessary and potentially harmful
Strengths and Weaknesses of Business Cycle Theories
Evaluating Keynesian Theory
- Strengths: Provides a framework for understanding the role of aggregate demand in driving business cycles and the potential for government intervention to stabilize the economy
- Weaknesses: Assumes price and wage stickiness, which may not always hold in reality, and may underestimate the importance of supply-side factors
Evaluating Monetarist Theory
- Strengths: Highlights the importance of monetary policy in influencing business cycles and provides a long-run perspective on economic stability
- Weaknesses: May oversimplify the relationship between money supply and aggregate demand and neglect the role of other factors, such as fiscal policy (tax rates, government spending) and supply-side shocks (oil price changes)
Evaluating Real Business Cycle Theory
- Strengths: Offers a coherent explanation for business cycles based on real factors and emphasizes the economy's ability to self-correct in response to shocks
- Weaknesses: Assumes perfect price and wage flexibility, which may not hold in the short run, and may underestimate the role of demand-side factors (consumer confidence, investor sentiment) and the potential for market failures (externalities, information asymmetries)
Applying Business Cycle Theories to Real-World Examples
The Great Depression of the 1930s
- Analyzed through the lens of Keynesian theory, which suggests that a severe decline in aggregate demand, caused by a fall in investment and consumption, led to a prolonged
- Keynesian policies, such as government spending (New Deal programs) and monetary expansion (abandoning the gold standard), were eventually used to stimulate the economy
The Stagflation of the 1970s
- Examined using Monetarist theory, which attributes the combination of high and high unemployment to excessive growth in the money supply
- Monetarist policies, such as targeting a stable growth rate of the money supply, were implemented to combat stagflation
The Great Recession of 2008-2009
- Analyzed using insights from both Keynesian and Monetarist theories
- Initial downturn attributed to a decline in aggregate demand, caused by a housing market crash and financial crisis (subprime mortgage crisis), consistent with Keynesian theory
- Subsequent slow recovery and challenges faced by monetary policy in stimulating the economy explained by Monetarist and RBC theories, which emphasize the role of real factors (deleveraging, structural changes) and the limitations of government intervention
The COVID-19 Recession of 2020
- Examined using Keynesian theory, as the pandemic-induced lockdowns and social distancing measures led to a sharp decline in aggregate demand
- Governments around the world implemented large-scale fiscal stimulus packages (direct payments, enhanced unemployment benefits) and expansionary monetary policies (interest rate cuts, quantitative easing) to support their economies, in line with Keynesian prescriptions
Key Terms to Review (22)
AD-AS Model: The AD-AS model, or Aggregate Demand-Aggregate Supply model, is a framework used to analyze the overall economy by depicting the relationship between total spending (aggregate demand) and total production (aggregate supply). This model helps explain price levels, output, and economic fluctuations, making it essential for understanding various macroeconomic concepts, such as shifts in demand and supply, business cycles, and the impact of fiscal and monetary policies.
Aggregate Demand: Aggregate demand represents the total demand for all goods and services in an economy at a given overall price level and in a given time period. It is a critical component in understanding how various factors, including consumption, investment, and government spending, interact to influence economic activity and overall demand in the economy.
Cyclical unemployment: Cyclical unemployment refers to the type of unemployment that occurs due to fluctuations in the economic cycle, specifically during periods of economic downturn or recession. When the economy slows down, demand for goods and services declines, leading to reduced production and consequently, layoffs and higher unemployment rates. This form of unemployment is directly linked to changes in the business cycle and is an important aspect of understanding broader economic dynamics.
Demand-driven cycles: Demand-driven cycles refer to fluctuations in economic activity that are primarily influenced by changes in aggregate demand. These cycles occur when shifts in consumer and business spending lead to variations in production, employment, and overall economic growth, highlighting the importance of demand-side factors in the economy's ups and downs.
Economic fluctuations: Economic fluctuations refer to the periodic ups and downs in economic activity, characterized by changes in real GDP, employment, and production levels over time. These fluctuations are often driven by various factors such as changes in investment, consumer spending, and external shocks, and can have significant impacts on overall economic stability and growth.
Fiscal Policy: Fiscal policy refers to the use of government spending and taxation to influence the economy. It plays a crucial role in managing economic activity, affecting levels of demand, inflation, and overall economic growth by adjusting public expenditure and revenue collection.
Friedrich Hayek: Friedrich Hayek was an influential Austrian economist and political philosopher known for his defense of classical liberalism and free-market capitalism. His ideas challenged the Keynesian perspective on economic policy, particularly regarding the business cycle, emphasizing the role of information and individual decision-making in a decentralized economy.
GDP: Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is the total monetary value of all finished goods and services produced within a country's borders in a specific time period, typically annually or quarterly. It serves as a comprehensive measure of a nation's overall economic activity and is crucial for understanding economic health, influencing policy decisions, and analyzing business cycles.
Inflation: Inflation is the rate at which the general level of prices for goods and services rises, eroding purchasing power. It reflects the decrease in the purchasing value of a nation's currency and impacts various economic measures, influencing everything from consumer behavior to investment decisions.
Inflationary Gap: An inflationary gap occurs when the actual output of an economy exceeds its potential output, leading to upward pressure on prices. This situation often arises during periods of economic expansion, where demand outstrips supply, causing inflation to rise. An inflationary gap indicates that resources are being utilized beyond their sustainable limits, resulting in increased production costs and potentially unsustainable economic growth.
IS-LM Model: The IS-LM model represents the interaction between the goods market and the money market in an economy, showing how interest rates and output are determined simultaneously. It helps explain how fiscal and monetary policy can influence overall economic activity, connecting essential concepts like aggregate demand and supply shifts, crowding out effects, and the phases of the business cycle.
John Maynard Keynes: John Maynard Keynes was a British economist whose ideas fundamentally changed the theory and practice of macroeconomics, particularly during the 20th century. He is best known for advocating that government intervention is necessary to stabilize economic cycles and to promote full employment and economic growth.
Keynesian Theory: Keynesian Theory is an economic theory that emphasizes the role of government intervention and aggregate demand in influencing economic activity and managing business cycles. It posits that during periods of economic downturn, increased government spending and lower taxes can stimulate demand, helping to reduce unemployment and boost economic growth.
Monetarist Theory: Monetarist theory is an economic theory that emphasizes the role of governments in controlling the amount of money in circulation. It posits that variations in the money supply have major influences on national output in the short run and the price level over longer periods. This perspective is essential in understanding business cycles, as it highlights how changes in monetary policy can lead to fluctuations in economic activity and inflation.
Monetary Policy: Monetary policy refers to the actions taken by a country's central bank to manage the money supply and interest rates in order to achieve specific economic goals, such as controlling inflation, stabilizing currency, and fostering economic growth. This policy plays a crucial role in influencing overall economic activity and can be adjusted to respond to changing economic conditions.
Productivity changes: Productivity changes refer to the variations in the efficiency with which inputs are transformed into outputs within an economy. These changes can significantly influence economic growth, employment levels, and business cycles, as shifts in productivity often lead to fluctuations in overall economic performance and stability.
Real Business Cycle Theory: Real Business Cycle Theory is an economic theory that explains fluctuations in economic activity as a result of real (rather than monetary) shocks, such as changes in technology or productivity. This theory posits that these shocks lead to changes in the labor supply and productivity, which in turn drive the business cycle phases, highlighting the importance of microeconomic foundations in macroeconomic analysis.
Recession: A recession is defined as a significant decline in economic activity that lasts for an extended period, typically recognized by a decrease in GDP, rising unemployment rates, and reduced consumer spending. During a recession, businesses often experience lower sales and profits, leading to cost-cutting measures such as layoffs. This economic downturn can influence various aspects of the economy, including the components of GDP, job markets, and theories explaining business cycles.
Stagnation: Stagnation refers to a prolonged period of little or no economic growth, where an economy experiences a slowdown in productivity, investment, and demand. It often leads to higher unemployment rates, underutilization of resources, and can occur even when inflation is present, leading to stagnation accompanied by inflation, known as stagflation.
Supply-driven cycles: Supply-driven cycles refer to economic fluctuations that arise primarily due to changes in supply-side factors rather than demand-side influences. These cycles occur when variations in the production capacity, technological advancements, or resource availability impact the overall economy, leading to shifts in employment, income, and output levels. Understanding these cycles helps in analyzing how external shocks or changes in productivity can shape the business environment over time.
Technology shocks: Technology shocks refer to unexpected changes in the level of technology that can have significant impacts on productivity and economic output. These shocks can lead to rapid shifts in production capabilities, influencing business cycles by either enhancing or disrupting economic activities, which in turn affects employment, investment, and overall economic growth.
Unemployment rate: The unemployment rate is the percentage of the labor force that is unemployed and actively seeking employment. It serves as a key indicator of economic health, reflecting how effectively an economy utilizes its workforce and signaling potential issues in labor markets.