Glossary

12.2 Closed-loop geothermal systems

12 min read•august 21, 2024

Closed-loop geothermal systems are a key technology in sustainable heating and cooling. These systems use underground pipes filled with fluid to exchange heat with the earth, providing efficient temperature control for buildings year-round.

Understanding closed-loop systems is crucial for geothermal engineers. This section covers system types, components, design considerations, installation methods, and efficiency factors to help optimize performance and maximize energy savings.

Types of closed-loop systems

  • Closed-loop geothermal systems circulate fluid through sealed underground pipes to exchange heat with the earth
  • These systems form the backbone of many geothermal heating and cooling applications in residential and commercial settings
  • Understanding different closed-loop configurations helps engineers optimize system design for specific site conditions and energy requirements

Vertical closed-loop systems

Top images from around the web for Vertical closed-loop systems

  • Geothermal Heating and Cooling | Sustainability: A Comprehensive Foundation View original

    Is this image relevant?

  • Geothermal Home Heating And Cooling - Thermal Systems View original

    Is this image relevant?

  • Geothermal Heating and Cooling | Sustainability: A Comprehensive Foundation View original

    Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Vertical closed-loop systems

  • Geothermal Heating and Cooling | Sustainability: A Comprehensive Foundation View original

    Is this image relevant?

  • Geothermal Home Heating And Cooling - Thermal Systems View original

    Is this image relevant?

  • Geothermal Heating and Cooling | Sustainability: A Comprehensive Foundation View original

    Is this image relevant?

1 of 3
  • Consist of U-shaped pipes installed in deep vertical boreholes (typically 100-400 feet deep)
  • Require less land area compared to horizontal systems, making them suitable for urban environments
  • Provide consistent performance due to stable ground temperatures at greater depths
  • Installation involves specialized drilling equipment and techniques (rotary drilling, down-the-hole hammer)

Horizontal closed-loop systems

  • Utilize pipes laid in trenches at shallower depths (typically 4-6 feet)
  • Cover larger land areas but are less expensive to install than vertical systems
  • Configurations include:
    • Single pipe
    • Multiple pipes (slinky coil)
    • Parallel pipe arrangements
  • More susceptible to seasonal temperature fluctuations due to shallower depth

Pond and lake loops

  • Leverage existing water bodies as heat exchange mediums
  • Coiled pipe arrangements submerged in ponds or lakes (minimum 8 feet deep)
  • Highly efficient due to excellent heat transfer properties of water
  • Require less excavation and drilling compared to other closed-loop systems
  • Limited by availability of suitable water bodies and environmental regulations

Components of closed-loop systems

  • Closed-loop geothermal systems comprise several interconnected components that work together to facilitate heat exchange
  • Understanding these components is crucial for system design, installation, and maintenance in geothermal engineering
  • Proper selection and integration of components ensure optimal system performance and longevity

Heat exchangers

  • Transfer heat between the fluid and the building's HVAC system
  • Types include:
    • Plate heat exchangers (compact and efficient)
    • Shell-and-tube heat exchangers (suitable for larger systems)
  • Materials chosen for corrosion resistance and thermal conductivity (stainless steel, copper)
  • Sizing based on system capacity and temperature differentials

Circulation pumps

  • Move heat transfer fluid through the ground loop and building distribution system
  • Variable speed pumps allow for more efficient operation by adjusting flow rates
  • Sized based on system flow requirements and pressure drop calculations
  • Redundant pumps often installed for system reliability

Piping materials

  • High-density polyethylene (HDPE) commonly used for ground loops due to durability and flexibility
  • Copper or other metals used for interior piping and connections
  • Pipe diameter selected based on flow rates and pressure drop considerations
  • Insulation required for above-ground portions to minimize heat loss

Heat transfer fluids

  • Circulate through the closed-loop system to transfer heat between the ground and building
  • Water-based solutions with antifreeze additives (propylene glycol, ethanol) to prevent freezing
  • Properties to consider:
    • Freezing point
    • Viscosity
    • Thermal conductivity
    • Environmental impact

Design considerations

  • Proper design of closed-loop geothermal systems requires careful analysis of site-specific factors and system requirements
  • Geothermal engineers must balance performance, efficiency, and cost when designing these systems
  • Accurate design calculations and modeling ensure optimal system sizing and long-term performance

Thermal conductivity of soil

  • Measures the soil's ability to conduct heat, affecting heat transfer efficiency
  • Varies with soil type, moisture content, and density
  • Determined through:
    • In-situ thermal response tests
    • Laboratory analysis of soil samples
  • Higher thermal conductivity allows for shorter loop lengths or fewer boreholes

Ground temperature variations

  • Affect system performance and efficiency throughout the year
  • Factors influencing ground temperature:
    • Depth (temperature stabilizes below 30-50 feet)
    • Seasonal changes (more pronounced in shallow systems)
    • Geothermal gradient (typically 1-3°F per 100 feet of depth)
  • Accurate temperature data crucial for proper system sizing and performance predictions

Loop sizing calculations

  • Determine the required length of ground loop to meet heating and cooling loads
  • Factors considered:
    • Building load profile
    • Ground thermal properties
    • Heat pump efficiency
    • Design temperatures
  • Methods include:
    • Rule of thumb estimates (150-200 feet per ton of capacity)
    • Detailed software simulations (GLHEPRO, GLD)

Borehole spacing requirements

  • Prevent thermal interference between adjacent boreholes in vertical systems
  • Typical spacing ranges from 15-20 feet for residential systems
  • Larger commercial systems may require greater spacing (20-30 feet)
  • Influenced by:
    • Soil thermal properties
    • System load balance
    • Long-term temperature effects

Installation methods

  • Proper installation of closed-loop geothermal systems is critical for system performance and longevity
  • Installation methods vary depending on the type of system and site conditions
  • Geothermal engineers must work closely with drilling contractors and installers to ensure proper techniques are employed

Drilling techniques

  • systems require specialized drilling methods
  • Common techniques include:
    • Rotary drilling (suitable for most soil types)
    • Down-the-hole hammer drilling (effective in hard rock formations)
    • Mud rotary drilling (useful in unstable soil conditions)
  • Drilling depth and diameter determined by system design and local geology

Trenching vs boring

  • Horizontal systems typically installed using methods
  • Trenching options:
    • Chain trenchers (for long, straight runs)
    • Backhoes (for more complex layouts or rocky soil)
  • Horizontal directional drilling () used for:
    • Minimizing surface disturbance
    • Installing loops under existing structures or landscaping
    • Crossing obstacles (driveways, utilities)

Grouting procedures

  • Essential for vertical systems to ensure good thermal contact and environmental protection
  • Grout composition typically includes:
    • Bentonite (for sealing properties)
    • Sand or other aggregates (to enhance thermal conductivity)
    • Cement (for structural stability)
  • Grouting methods:
    • Tremie pipe method (bottom-up filling)
    • Pressure grouting (for challenging geological conditions)

Pressure testing

  • Verifies the integrity of the ground loop before and after installation
  • Typical test pressure: 100 psi for 30 minutes to 24 hours
  • Helps detect leaks or weak points in the system
  • Pressure and flow tests also conducted on the entire system after completion

Heat transfer mechanisms

  • Understanding heat transfer mechanisms is fundamental to the design and operation of closed-loop geothermal systems
  • These processes govern the efficiency of heat exchange between the ground and the circulating fluid
  • Geothermal engineers must consider all three mechanisms to optimize system performance

Conduction in soil

  • Primary mode of heat transfer in the ground surrounding the loop
  • Governed by Fourier's Law: q=−k∇Tq = -k \nabla T
    • q: heat flux
    • k: thermal conductivity of the soil
    • ∇T: temperature gradient
  • Affected by soil composition, moisture content, and compaction
  • Higher thermal conductivity soils (saturated clays, rock) facilitate better heat transfer

Convection in fluid

  • Dominant heat transfer mechanism within the circulating fluid
  • Described by Newton's Law of Cooling: q=hA(Ts−Tf)q = h A (T_s - T_f)
    • h: convective heat transfer coefficient
    • A: surface area
    • T_s: surface temperature
    • T_f: fluid temperature
  • Enhanced by turbulent flow within the pipes
  • Influenced by fluid properties (viscosity, thermal conductivity) and flow rate

Thermal interference between loops

  • Occurs when heat transfer from one loop affects the temperature field of adjacent loops
  • More pronounced in vertical systems with closely spaced boreholes
  • Long-term effects can lead to:
    • Decreased system efficiency
    • Ground temperature imbalance
  • Mitigated through proper borehole spacing and system load balancing

System efficiency factors

  • Efficiency metrics are crucial for evaluating the performance of closed-loop geothermal systems
  • These factors help engineers compare different system designs and optimize operation
  • Understanding efficiency metrics is essential for accurate cost-benefit analysis and system sizing

Coefficient of performance (COP)

  • Ratio of useful heating or cooling provided to electrical energy consumed
  • Calculated as: COP=QWCOP = \frac{Q}{W}
    • Q: useful heat transfer
    • W: work input (electrical energy)
  • Typical COP ranges:
    • Heating mode: 3.0 - 5.0
    • Cooling mode: 4.0 - 6.0
  • Higher COP indicates greater energy efficiency

Energy efficiency ratio (EER)

  • Measure of cooling efficiency at specific operating conditions
  • Calculated as: EER=CoolingOutput(BTU/h)PowerInput(W)EER = \frac{Cooling Output (BTU/h)}{Power Input (W)}
  • Used primarily in the United States
  • Higher EER values indicate better efficiency
  • Typical EER ranges for geothermal systems: 15 - 30

Seasonal performance factor (SPF)

  • Represents the overall system efficiency over an entire heating or cooling season
  • Accounts for variations in operating conditions and part-load performance
  • Calculated as: SPF=TotalEnergyOutputTotalEnergyInputSPF = \frac{Total Energy Output}{Total Energy Input}
  • Provides a more comprehensive view of system performance than instantaneous COP or EER
  • Influenced by factors such as:
    • Climate conditions
    • Building load profile
    • System design and controls

Environmental impacts

  • Closed-loop geothermal systems generally have lower environmental impacts compared to conventional HVAC systems
  • However, careful consideration of potential environmental effects is crucial in system design and installation
  • Geothermal engineers must balance performance with environmental stewardship

Land disturbance

  • Temporary disruption during installation, especially for horizontal systems
  • Vertical systems require less surface area but may impact deeper soil layers
  • Mitigation strategies:
    • Careful site planning and restoration
    • Use of horizontal directional drilling to minimize surface impacts
    • Integration with landscaping or other site features

Groundwater protection

  • Proper grouting of vertical boreholes prevents:
    • Cross-contamination between aquifers
    • Surface contaminant infiltration
  • Use of non-toxic heat transfer fluids minimizes risk in case of leaks
  • Regular system monitoring helps detect potential issues early

Antifreeze solution considerations

  • Selection of environmentally friendly antifreeze solutions (propylene glycol, ethanol)
  • Proper concentration to balance freeze protection and system efficiency
  • Regular testing and maintenance of fluid chemistry
  • Safe disposal procedures for used antifreeze solutions

Maintenance and troubleshooting

  • Regular maintenance and effective troubleshooting are essential for ensuring long-term performance and reliability of closed-loop geothermal systems
  • Geothermal engineers must develop comprehensive maintenance plans and be prepared to diagnose and resolve system issues
  • Proactive maintenance can prevent costly repairs and system downtime

Leak detection methods

  • Regular pressure testing to identify potential leaks in the ground loop
  • Use of tracer dyes or gases to locate leaks in accessible portions of the system
  • Monitoring of fluid levels and makeup water requirements
  • Advanced techniques:
    • Acoustic leak detection
    • Thermal imaging for above-ground components

Fluid replacement procedures

  • Periodic testing of heat transfer fluid properties (pH, antifreeze concentration, corrosion inhibitors)
  • Flushing and cleaning of the system to remove sediment and scale buildup
  • Proper disposal of used heat transfer fluids following environmental regulations
  • Refilling the system with fresh, properly mixed heat transfer solution

System performance monitoring

  • Continuous data logging of key parameters:
    • Inlet and outlet temperatures
    • Flow rates
    • Energy consumption
  • Regular analysis of performance metrics (COP, EER, SPF)
  • Comparison of actual performance to design expectations
  • Use of building automation systems for real-time monitoring and fault detection

Closed-loop vs open-loop systems

  • Understanding the differences between closed-loop and open-loop geothermal systems is crucial for selecting the most appropriate system for a given site
  • Each type has its own advantages and limitations, impacting system design, performance, and environmental considerations
  • Geothermal engineers must carefully evaluate site conditions and project requirements when choosing between these systems

Efficiency comparison

  • Closed-loop systems:
    • Generally lower efficiency due to additional heat transfer step through pipe walls
    • More consistent performance year-round
    • Typical COP range: 3.0 - 5.0
  • Open-loop systems:
    • Higher efficiency due to direct use of groundwater
    • Performance may vary with groundwater temperature and quality
    • Typical COP range: 3.5 - 5.5

Installation cost differences

  • Closed-loop systems:
    • Higher initial costs due to extensive ground loop installation
    • Costs vary with loop configuration (vertical systems typically more expensive)
    • Less site-dependent, suitable for a wider range of locations
  • Open-loop systems:
    • Lower installation costs if suitable aquifer is available
    • May require well drilling and water disposal systems
    • Costs can increase significantly if water treatment is necessary

Site suitability factors

  • Closed-loop systems:
    • Require adequate land area for loop installation
    • Soil thermal properties impact system sizing
    • Less dependent on groundwater availability
  • Open-loop systems:
    • Require sufficient groundwater supply and quality
    • Need appropriate disposal options for used water
    • Subject to more stringent environmental regulations

Regulatory considerations

  • Geothermal system installations are subject to various regulations at local, state, and federal levels
  • Compliance with these regulations is crucial for project approval and long-term operation
  • Geothermal engineers must stay informed about relevant regulations and work closely with regulatory agencies throughout the project lifecycle

Permitting requirements

  • Vary by jurisdiction and system type
  • Common permits include:
    • Drilling permits for vertical boreholes
    • Construction permits for system installation
    • Environmental impact assessments for larger projects
  • Coordination with local building departments and environmental agencies
  • Documentation of system design, installation procedures, and safety measures

Environmental regulations

  • Groundwater protection laws (particularly relevant for open-loop systems)
  • Regulations governing the use and disposal of heat transfer fluids
  • Soil and erosion control requirements during installation
  • Noise regulations for heat pump equipment
  • Compliance with local and state renewable energy standards

Building codes compliance

  • Integration with existing HVAC codes and standards
  • Energy efficiency requirements (ASHRAE 90.1, IECC)
  • Safety standards for electrical and mechanical systems
  • Proper labeling and documentation of geothermal system components
  • Compliance with local zoning regulations and setback requirements

Economic aspects

  • Economic considerations play a crucial role in the adoption and implementation of closed-loop geothermal systems
  • Geothermal engineers must conduct thorough economic analyses to justify system investments and optimize designs
  • Understanding the economic aspects helps in making informed decisions about system feasibility and long-term value

Installation costs

  • Major components of initial costs:
    • Ground loop installation (drilling or trenching)
    • Heat pump equipment
    • Interior HVAC modifications
  • Factors affecting installation costs:
    • System size and capacity
    • Loop configuration (vertical vs horizontal)
    • Site conditions (geology, accessibility)
  • Typical range: 10,000−10,000 - 30,000 per ton of capacity for residential systems
  • Economies of scale for larger commercial installations

Operational expenses

  • Primary ongoing costs:
    • Electricity for heat pump and pumps
    • Regular maintenance and inspections
    • Occasional fluid replacement or treatment
  • Factors influencing operational costs:
    • System efficiency (COP, EER)
    • Local electricity rates
    • Climate conditions and building load profile
  • Generally lower than conventional HVAC systems due to higher efficiency

Payback period analysis

  • Calculation of time required to recoup initial investment through energy savings
  • Factors considered in payback analysis:
    • Installation costs
    • Annual energy savings compared to conventional systems
    • Maintenance costs
    • Energy price projections
  • Typical payback periods:
    • Residential systems: 5-10 years
    • Commercial systems: 3-8 years
  • Influenced by available incentives (tax credits, rebates, grants)

Integration with buildings

  • Successful integration of closed-loop geothermal systems with building HVAC infrastructure is crucial for optimal performance and occupant comfort
  • Geothermal engineers must work closely with architects, mechanical engineers, and building operators to ensure seamless integration
  • Proper integration maximizes energy efficiency and system longevity

HVAC system coupling

  • Compatibility with various distribution systems:
    • Forced air (most common in residential applications)
    • Radiant floor heating
    • Fan coil units
  • Sizing of air handlers and ductwork for geothermal heat pump output
  • Integration with existing heating and cooling equipment for hybrid systems
  • Consideration of supplemental heating for extreme cold climates

Controls and automation

  • Advanced control systems for optimizing geothermal system performance
  • Integration with building management systems (BMS) for centralized control
  • Features of modern control systems:
    • Adaptive learning algorithms
    • Remote monitoring and diagnostics
    • Occupancy-based temperature setbacks
    • Integration with renewable energy sources (solar PV)

Hybrid system configurations

  • Combination of geothermal with other heating and cooling technologies
  • Common hybrid configurations:
    • Geothermal + gas boiler for peak heating loads
    • Geothermal + air-source heat pump for balanced loads
    • Geothermal + solar thermal for domestic hot water
  • Benefits of hybrid systems:
    • Reduced initial costs compared to full geothermal sizing
    • Improved efficiency and flexibility in meeting varying loads
    • Potential for further energy savings and carbon reduction

Key Terms to Review (18)

American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE): ASHRAE is a global professional organization founded in 1894 that focuses on advancing the arts and sciences of heating, refrigerating, and air-conditioning engineering. It plays a vital role in setting industry standards and guidelines that enhance the design and operation of thermal systems, including closed-loop geothermal systems. ASHRAE also promotes sustainable practices in HVAC systems, ensuring they are efficient and environmentally friendly.
Boring: Boring refers to the process of drilling a hole into the ground to create a well or to install piping for geothermal systems. In the context of closed-loop geothermal systems, boring is crucial as it allows for the installation of ground loops that transfer heat between the building and the earth. The design and execution of boring directly affect the efficiency and effectiveness of the geothermal system, making it a key component in harnessing geothermal energy.
Carnot Cycle: The Carnot Cycle is a theoretical thermodynamic cycle that represents the most efficient possible engine cycle operating between two heat reservoirs. It consists of four reversible processes: two isothermal processes where heat is exchanged with the reservoirs and two adiabatic processes where the working substance expands or contracts without heat exchange. This cycle serves as a benchmark for all real heat engines, including those used in closed-loop geothermal systems, as it establishes the maximum efficiency achievable under given conditions.
Circulation: Circulation in the context of closed-loop geothermal systems refers to the movement of a heat transfer fluid through a closed piping network to absorb and distribute thermal energy from the ground. This process is vital for effectively transferring heat to or from a building, ensuring that the system maintains a stable temperature for heating or cooling. The efficiency of circulation impacts the overall performance of the geothermal system, affecting energy consumption and comfort levels.
Coefficient of performance (COP): The coefficient of performance (COP) is a measure of the efficiency of heating or cooling systems, defined as the ratio of useful heating or cooling provided to the work input required. A higher COP indicates a more efficient system, which is especially important in applications like space heating and cooling, geothermal heat pumps, district heating systems, and both closed-loop and hybrid geothermal systems. Understanding COP helps evaluate system performance and energy consumption in various contexts.
Deep geothermal: Deep geothermal refers to the extraction of heat energy from the Earth's crust at depths typically greater than 400 meters (about 1,300 feet) for direct use or for conversion into electricity. This form of energy relies on the natural heat stored in the Earth, which can be harnessed through various technologies, making it a reliable and sustainable energy source with low greenhouse gas emissions.
Enthalpy: Enthalpy is a thermodynamic property that represents the total heat content of a system, defined as the sum of its internal energy and the product of its pressure and volume. This concept is crucial in understanding energy transfer processes, especially in geothermal systems where heat extraction and conversion are involved.
Ground loop: A ground loop is a system of pipes buried underground that circulates a fluid to transfer heat between a building and the ground. This method is essential for geothermal heat pumps, as it allows for the efficient exchange of heat, utilizing the earth's relatively stable temperatures. Ground loops can be installed in various configurations, significantly impacting the performance and efficiency of heating and cooling systems.
Heat Exchanger: A heat exchanger is a device that transfers heat between two or more fluids without mixing them. This process is crucial in various applications, allowing for efficient thermal energy transfer, which plays a significant role in geothermal systems, enhancing overall energy conversion and utilization.
Heat Transfer: Heat transfer is the process of thermal energy moving from one physical system to another due to a temperature difference. This movement can occur through conduction, convection, or radiation and is essential for understanding how geothermal systems operate, especially regarding energy extraction and utilization.
Horizontal closed-loop: A horizontal closed-loop system is a type of geothermal heating and cooling system where the loop of piping is installed horizontally beneath the ground surface. This design allows for the efficient transfer of heat between the ground and the fluid circulating within the pipes, optimizing energy usage for heating and cooling applications. Horizontal closed-loop systems are particularly beneficial in areas with sufficient land space, as they can be installed with relative ease compared to vertical systems.
International Ground Source Heat Pump Association (IGSHPA): The International Ground Source Heat Pump Association (IGSHPA) is a non-profit organization dedicated to promoting the use of ground source heat pump technology for residential, commercial, and industrial applications. It serves as a key resource for professionals in the geothermal industry, providing training, standards, and support to enhance the understanding and implementation of closed-loop geothermal systems.
Reduced carbon footprint: A reduced carbon footprint refers to the decrease in the total greenhouse gas emissions produced directly and indirectly by an individual, organization, or activity. This concept is crucial for addressing climate change and can be achieved through various strategies that promote energy efficiency, renewable energy sources, and sustainable practices. Achieving a reduced carbon footprint is essential in various applications, including heating systems and geothermal technologies, which significantly lower environmental impact.
Seasonal Performance Factor (SPF): The Seasonal Performance Factor (SPF) is a measure of the efficiency of heating and cooling systems, specifically in relation to how much energy they consume versus how much heating or cooling they provide over a typical seasonal period. It reflects the effectiveness of a system in utilizing energy for space heating and cooling by averaging the performance across varying conditions throughout the season, making it particularly relevant for understanding closed-loop geothermal systems.
Shallow geothermal: Shallow geothermal refers to the utilization of the earth's near-surface thermal energy, typically found within the first 10 to 400 feet below the surface, for heating and cooling purposes. This technology leverages stable ground temperatures, making it an efficient and renewable source of energy for residential, commercial, and agricultural applications.
Sustainability: Sustainability refers to the ability to maintain or improve systems and processes over the long term without depleting resources or causing harm to the environment. This concept is crucial in energy production, as it emphasizes the importance of using renewable resources efficiently and responsibly to meet current needs while ensuring that future generations can also meet their own needs.
Trenching: Trenching is the process of digging a narrow excavation in the ground, typically to install or repair underground utilities or systems. In the context of geothermal systems, trenching is crucial for laying down the ground loops of closed-loop geothermal systems, which facilitate the transfer of heat to and from the earth. Proper trenching techniques ensure efficient installation and maintenance of these systems, impacting their overall performance and sustainability.
Vertical closed-loop: A vertical closed-loop system is a type of geothermal heat pump setup where the loop of piping is installed vertically in the ground to exchange heat with the earth. This system typically consists of a series of boreholes drilled deep into the ground, allowing for efficient heat transfer and utilization of the earth's relatively stable temperature, making it an effective option for heating and cooling buildings.
© 2024 Fiveable Inc. All rights reserved.
AP® and SAT® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse this website.
Back
Practice QuizGlossary
Practice QuizGlossary
Next guide