3.2 Classical Hollywood narrative and alternative narrative forms
4 min read•august 15, 2024
Classical Hollywood narrative follows a with linear progression and character-driven plots. It aims for clarity, closure, and wide appeal through familiar storytelling techniques. This approach has dominated mainstream cinema for decades.
Alternative narrative forms challenge these conventions. Non-linear, fragmented, or open-ended structures disrupt traditional storytelling, encouraging active viewer engagement. These approaches offer unique experiences that subvert expectations and explore new storytelling possibilities.
Classical Hollywood Narrative Structure
Three-Act Structure and Linear Progression
Top images from around the web for Three-Act Structure and Linear Progression
5 Ways to Stand Out when Applying for a UX Job - UX Mastery View original
Is this image relevant?
Category:Plot (narrative) - Wikimedia Commons View original
Is this image relevant?
Three act structure: http://tinyurl.com/ywveuj | Captured an… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
5 Ways to Stand Out when Applying for a UX Job - UX Mastery View original
Is this image relevant?
Category:Plot (narrative) - Wikimedia Commons View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Three-Act Structure and Linear Progression
5 Ways to Stand Out when Applying for a UX Job - UX Mastery View original
Is this image relevant?
Category:Plot (narrative) - Wikimedia Commons View original
Is this image relevant?
Three act structure: http://tinyurl.com/ywveuj | Captured an… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
5 Ways to Stand Out when Applying for a UX Job - UX Mastery View original
Is this image relevant?
Category:Plot (narrative) - Wikimedia Commons View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Follows a three-act structure with a clear beginning, middle, and end
- Events progress linearly, with each scene or event logically leading to the next
- Establishes a clear cause-and-effect relationship between story elements
- Designed to be easily comprehensible to a wide audience (clear exposition, rising action, climax, falling action, and resolution)
Character-Driven Narrative
- Driven by a central conflict or goal, often involving a protagonist who faces obstacles and ultimately achieves a resolution
- Character motivations and actions are well-defined and consistent throughout the narrative
- Protagonists often undergo a transformative journey or (Luke Skywalker in Star Wars)
Closure and Continuity
- Achieves closure at the end of the story, with the resolution of the central conflict and a sense of equilibrium restored
- Employs techniques to maintain a smooth, uninterrupted flow of the story (match cuts, eye-line matches, establishing shots)
- Aims to create a seamless, immersive narrative experience for the audience (invisible editing, adherence to the 180-degree rule)
Alternative Narrative Forms
Non-Linear and Fragmented Narratives
- Non-linear narratives disrupt the chronological order of events (flashbacks, flash-forwards, parallel storylines)
- Fragmented narratives present story elements in a discontinuous or disjointed manner (Pulp Fiction, Memento)
- Challenge viewers to actively reconstruct the story and draw connections between disparate elements
Episodic and Ensemble Narratives
- Episodic narratives are composed of loosely connected or self-contained segments (anthology films, television series)
- Ensemble narratives focus on multiple characters and their intersecting storylines (Nashville, Magnolia)
- Often lack a clear central protagonist and may prioritize exploring a theme or milieu over a tightly structured plot
Open-Ended and Interactive Narratives
- Open-ended narratives lack a definitive resolution or closure, leaving the audience to interpret the story's conclusion (The Sopranos, Inception)
- Interactive narratives allow the audience to participate in or influence the progression of the story (Black Mirror: Bandersnatch, Choose Your Own Adventure books)
- Blur the line between viewer and creator, challenging traditional notions of authorship and control
Experimental and Hybrid Narratives
- Experimental narratives challenge traditional storytelling conventions, often prioritizing abstract or symbolic elements over a coherent plot (Un Chien Andalou, Eraserhead)
- Hybrid narratives combine elements from different narrative forms or genres (Booksmart, Shaun of the Dead)
- Create unique and unconventional storytelling experiences that subvert audience expectations
Classical vs Alternative Narrative Structures
Clarity and Ambiguity
- Classical narratives prioritize clarity and coherence, ensuring that the story is easily understandable to a wide audience
- Alternative narratives often embrace ambiguity and open-endedness, encouraging multiple interpretations and active viewer engagement
Linearity and Fragmentation
- Classical narratives rely on a linear, cause-and-effect driven plot, with events unfolding in a logical, chronological order
- Alternative narratives may employ non-linear, episodic, or fragmented structures that disrupt the traditional flow of the story
Character Focus and Ensemble Casts
- Classical narratives often center on a single protagonist, with supporting characters serving to advance the main character's journey
- Alternative narratives may feature ensemble casts or lack a clear central character, allowing for a more diverse range of perspectives and storylines
Emotional Engagement and Intellectual Exploration
- Classical narratives aim for emotional engagement and catharsis, with the audience invested in the protagonist's struggles and ultimate triumph
- Alternative narratives may prioritize intellectual or artistic exploration, challenging the audience to grapple with complex themes or unconventional storytelling techniques
Genre Conventions and Subversion
- Classical narratives often adhere to established genre conventions, providing familiar story beats and character archetypes (romantic comedies, action films)
- Alternative narratives may subvert or blend genre expectations, creating hybrid or genre-defying works that challenge traditional categorization
Closure and Interpretive Challenges
- Classical narratives typically provide a sense of closure and resolution, with conflicts resolved and character arcs completed
- Alternative narratives may leave the audience with unresolved questions or interpretive challenges, encouraging ongoing discussion and personal reflection
Narrative Form and Audience Engagement
Accessibility and Intellectual Engagement
- Linear, classical narratives may be more accessible and emotionally engaging for a wide audience, as they provide a clear, familiar structure
- Non-linear or fragmented narratives may challenge viewers to actively reconstruct the story, leading to increased intellectual engagement and multiple interpretations
Resolution and Ongoing Discussion
- Open-ended narratives may frustrate audiences seeking clear resolution but can also inspire ongoing discussion and personal reflection
- The lack of definitive answers encourages viewers to draw their own conclusions and engage in dialogue with others
Character Identification and Empathy
- Ensemble narratives may allow for a more diverse range of character identification and empathy, as viewers connect with multiple perspectives
- The absence of a clear protagonist can also challenge traditional notions of character identification and force the audience to consider a broader range of experiences
Agency and Investment
- Interactive narratives can create a sense of agency and investment in the story, as the audience's choices shape the narrative outcome
- The participatory nature of these narratives blurs the line between viewer and creator, fostering a deeper connection to the story world
Niche Appeal and Cultural Context
- Experimental narratives may alienate some viewers who prefer conventional storytelling but can also attract niche audiences seeking innovative or challenging works
- The impact of narrative form on engagement and interpretation can vary widely depending on individual viewer preferences, expectations, and cultural backgrounds
Key Terms to Review (18)
Alfred Hitchcock: Alfred Hitchcock was a renowned British film director and producer, often referred to as the 'Master of Suspense' for his innovative techniques in thriller films. His distinct style and thematic concerns have significantly influenced both film and media theory, particularly in how narrative and visual elements converge to create tension and emotional impact.
Character Arc: A character arc refers to the transformation or inner journey of a character throughout a story, showing how they evolve in response to the events and conflicts they encounter. This journey often highlights the character's growth or decline, making it integral to understanding both plot development and thematic depth. The arc connects deeply with narrative structure, illustrating how characters embody and drive the story's central themes.
Continuity editing: Continuity editing is a film editing technique that ensures a seamless flow of action and maintains spatial and temporal coherence in a narrative. This approach aims to create a logical and smooth connection between shots, allowing the audience to easily follow the story without confusion. By focusing on consistency in visual elements, it supports the classical storytelling format, which often relies on clear character motivations and straightforward plot progression.
David Lynch: David Lynch is a renowned American filmmaker, artist, and musician known for his distinctive style that blends surrealism, psychological horror, and complex narratives. His works often challenge traditional storytelling, inviting viewers into dreamlike worlds filled with mystery and ambiguity. Lynch's approach to filmmaking emphasizes the director as a crucial authorial figure, shaping not just the story but the entire aesthetic and emotional landscape of his films.
Focalization: Focalization refers to the perspective through which a narrative is presented, determining whose viewpoint the audience experiences. It shapes how information is revealed to the audience, influencing their emotional engagement and understanding of characters and events within both classical and alternative narrative forms.
Fragmented narrative: Fragmented narrative refers to a storytelling technique where the narrative is presented in a non-linear or disjointed manner, often breaking the chronological order of events. This approach can create a sense of disorientation and compel viewers to actively engage with the material as they piece together the storyline. By presenting events out of sequence or from multiple perspectives, fragmented narratives challenge traditional storytelling norms and invite deeper interpretations.
Genre formula: A genre formula refers to a set of conventions and tropes that define a specific film genre, helping to create predictable patterns in storytelling, character types, and visual style. These formulas are essential in guiding filmmakers and audiences alike, as they establish expectations for narratives while allowing for variations and innovations within those frameworks. Understanding genre formulas can shed light on the differences between Classical Hollywood narrative styles and alternative narrative forms, highlighting how both approaches utilize or subvert established conventions.
Iconography: Iconography refers to the visual imagery and symbolic representation in art and film that conveys specific meanings or themes. This concept helps to unpack how images can signify more than their literal meaning, allowing viewers to interpret denotation and connotation, recognize narrative structures, and understand the codes and conventions that shape film language.
Intertextuality: Intertextuality refers to the relationship between texts, where one text references, influences, or echoes another. This concept highlights how films and other media communicate through shared themes, symbols, and narrative structures, creating layers of meaning that enrich audience interpretation.
Linear narrative: A linear narrative is a storytelling format that presents events in a chronological order, following a straight path from beginning to end. This structure typically includes a clear exposition, rising action, climax, falling action, and resolution, making it easy for audiences to follow the plot. The simplicity of a linear narrative often contrasts with more complex narrative forms that might involve non-linear storytelling or multiple perspectives.
Montage: Montage is a filmmaking technique that involves editing together a series of shots to condense space, time, and information, creating a narrative or emotional impact. This technique is crucial for shaping a film's storytelling and visual language, often enhancing the connection between scenes and characters while establishing a rhythm and pacing in the narrative.
Narrative voice: Narrative voice refers to the perspective or point of view from which a story is told, shaping how the audience perceives the plot, characters, and themes. It plays a crucial role in establishing tone and guiding audience engagement, influencing how viewers connect with the story and characters. The way a narrative voice is constructed can impact identification and emotional resonance with characters, as well as how the audience interprets visual elements within the film.
Non-linear storytelling: Non-linear storytelling is a narrative technique that presents events out of chronological order, allowing for a more complex and layered exploration of characters and themes. This approach encourages viewers to piece together the narrative, often leading to a more engaging experience that reflects the complexity of memory and perception. It can also highlight the interconnectedness of different plotlines, especially in stories involving multiple perspectives or timelines.
Postmodernism: Postmodernism is a cultural, artistic, and intellectual movement that emerged in the mid-20th century, characterized by a skepticism towards grand narratives and ideologies, embracing fragmentation, irony, and self-reflexivity. It challenges traditional structures and conventions in art, literature, and media, reflecting a shift in how narratives are constructed and understood.
Protagonist vs. Antagonist: The protagonist is the main character in a story, often facing challenges and driving the narrative forward, while the antagonist opposes the protagonist, creating conflict and tension. This dynamic is crucial in storytelling, as it shapes character development and thematic exploration, particularly within narrative structures.
Spectatorship: Spectatorship refers to the process of viewing and interpreting films and media, emphasizing the role of the audience in shaping meaning. This concept highlights how viewers engage with visual narratives, how their personal experiences influence their understanding, and how social, cultural, and ideological factors affect their reactions.
Structuralism: Structuralism is an intellectual movement that focuses on understanding the underlying structures that shape cultural phenomena, including language, literature, and film. It emphasizes the relationships between elements rather than the elements themselves, proposing that meaning is constructed through these relationships. This approach connects to various aspects of film and media, including narrative forms, semiotic analysis, and the broader theoretical framework of media studies.
Three-act structure: The three-act structure is a storytelling framework commonly used in film and literature that divides a narrative into three distinct parts: setup, confrontation, and resolution. This structure helps to organize the plot, develop characters, and create a satisfying emotional arc, making it a foundational element in both classical and contemporary storytelling.