8.2 Analysis of split-plot experiments
3 min read•august 7, 2024
Split-plot experiments analyze two factors: whole plot and subplot. They're useful when one factor is harder to change than the other. This design allows researchers to study interactions between factors while accounting for different levels of experimental control.
Analysis of split-plot experiments involves partitioning variation and conducting hypothesis tests. separates whole plot and subplot effects, using different error terms for each. Graphical tools like help visualize results and check assumptions.
ANOVA for Split-Plot Designs
Decomposing Variation in Split-Plot Designs
Top images from around the web for Decomposing Variation in Split-Plot Designs
Chapter 14 One-way ANOVA | MSc Conversion in Psychological Studies View original
Is this image relevant?
Oneway ANOVA Explanation and Example in R – 9/18/2017 | Chuck Powell View original
Is this image relevant?
statistics - Two Factor ANOVA Errorbar plot in R - Stack Overflow View original
Is this image relevant?
Chapter 14 One-way ANOVA | MSc Conversion in Psychological Studies View original
Is this image relevant?
Oneway ANOVA Explanation and Example in R – 9/18/2017 | Chuck Powell View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Decomposing Variation in Split-Plot Designs
Chapter 14 One-way ANOVA | MSc Conversion in Psychological Studies View original
Is this image relevant?
Oneway ANOVA Explanation and Example in R – 9/18/2017 | Chuck Powell View original
Is this image relevant?
statistics - Two Factor ANOVA Errorbar plot in R - Stack Overflow View original
Is this image relevant?
Chapter 14 One-way ANOVA | MSc Conversion in Psychological Studies View original
Is this image relevant?
Oneway ANOVA Explanation and Example in R – 9/18/2017 | Chuck Powell View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- ANOVA for split-plot designs partitions the total variation into components corresponding to the whole plot and subplot factors
- Whole plot error represents the variation among whole plot experimental units within each level of the whole plot factor
- Used to test the significance of the whole plot factor
- Calculated as the mean square for the whole plot error term in the ANOVA table
- Subplot error represents the variation among subplot experimental units within each whole plot
- Used to test the significance of the subplot factor and the interaction between the whole plot and subplot factors
- Calculated as the mean square for the subplot error term in the ANOVA table
Hypothesis Testing in Split-Plot Designs
- Degrees of freedom for the whole plot factor, subplot factor, and their interaction are determined based on the design and number of replicates
- Whole plot factor df = (number of whole plot levels - 1)
- Subplot factor df = (number of subplot levels - 1)
- Interaction df = (whole plot factor df) × (subplot factor df)
- F-tests are conducted to assess the significance of the whole plot factor, subplot factor, and their interaction
- Whole plot factor F-test:
- Subplot factor F-test:
- Interaction F-test:
- Mean squares (MS) for each factor and error term are calculated by dividing the sum of squares by the corresponding degrees of freedom
Graphical Analysis
Interaction Plots
- Interaction plots display the means for each combination of whole plot and subplot factor levels
- Used to visually assess the presence and nature of the interaction between the whole plot and subplot factors
- Parallel lines indicate no interaction, while non-parallel or crossing lines suggest an interaction
- Example: In a split-plot experiment with irrigation method (whole plot) and fertilizer type (subplot), an interaction plot can show how the effect of fertilizer type varies across different irrigation methods
Main Effect Plots
- display the means for each level of a factor, averaged across the levels of the other factor
- Used to visually assess the of the whole plot and subplot factors
- Differences in the heights of the points or lines indicate the magnitude of the main effect
- Example: In the irrigation method and fertilizer type experiment, a main effect plot for irrigation method would show the average response for each irrigation method, averaged across all fertilizer types
Residual Analysis
- Residual analysis is used to assess the adequacy of the ANOVA model assumptions
- Residuals are calculated as the differences between the observed values and the fitted values from the ANOVA model
- Plots of residuals vs. fitted values, residuals vs. factors, and normal probability plots of residuals are used to check for patterns, outliers, and normality
- Violations of assumptions may require data transformations or alternative analysis methods
Post-ANOVA Procedures
Multiple Comparisons
- Multiple comparisons procedures are used to compare specific treatment means after a significant F-test in the ANOVA
- Common methods include Tukey's HSD (Honestly Significant Difference), Bonferroni, and Dunnett's test
- These methods control the familywise error rate (FWER) or the false discovery rate (FDR) when making multiple pairwise comparisons
- Example: If the interaction between irrigation method and fertilizer type is significant, Tukey's HSD can be used to compare the means of specific treatment combinations (e.g., drip irrigation with organic fertilizer vs. sprinkler irrigation with synthetic fertilizer)
Key Terms to Review (15)
Agricultural research: Agricultural research refers to the systematic study aimed at improving agricultural practices, crop yields, livestock productivity, and overall food production. This field encompasses a wide range of studies, including the development of new farming techniques, pest management strategies, and crop breeding efforts. By applying scientific methods to agriculture, researchers aim to address challenges such as food security, sustainability, and environmental impacts.
ANOVA: ANOVA, or Analysis of Variance, is a statistical method used to test differences between two or more group means. This technique helps determine if at least one of the group means is significantly different from the others, making it a powerful tool in experimental design for comparing multiple treatments or conditions.
Blocking: Blocking is a technique used in experimental design to reduce the impact of variability among experimental units by grouping similar units together. This method allows researchers to control for specific variables, ensuring that comparisons between treatment groups are more accurate and reliable. By minimizing extraneous variability, blocking can enhance the precision of the experiment and improve the validity of conclusions drawn from the data.
Industrial experiments: Industrial experiments refer to systematic trials conducted in industrial settings to test hypotheses, optimize processes, or evaluate the performance of products. These experiments are often complex due to the involvement of multiple factors and the need to ensure that findings are relevant and applicable in real-world manufacturing environments.
Interaction Effects: Interaction effects occur when the effect of one independent variable on a dependent variable changes depending on the level of another independent variable. This concept is crucial for understanding how different factors work together to influence outcomes in experimental designs.
Interaction Plots: Interaction plots are graphical representations used to visualize the interaction between two or more independent variables on a dependent variable in an experimental design. They help to illustrate how the effect of one variable changes at different levels of another variable, highlighting whether the interaction is significant and how it influences the outcome.
Main Effect Plots: Main effect plots are graphical representations used to illustrate the influence of individual factors on the response variable in an experimental design. These plots help in visualizing how changes in a particular factor affect the outcomes, revealing trends and allowing researchers to interpret the effects of each factor while holding others constant. In split-plot experiments, main effect plots play a crucial role in analyzing both whole-plot and sub-plot factors, providing insights into interactions and main effects.
Main Effects: Main effects refer to the individual impact of each independent variable on the dependent variable in an experimental design. Understanding main effects is crucial for interpreting the results of experiments, as they indicate how changes in a factor influence the outcome, independent of other factors in a study.
Mixed model: A mixed model is a statistical model that incorporates both fixed effects and random effects, allowing for the analysis of complex data structures that arise in experimental designs. This approach is particularly useful when dealing with data that have multiple sources of variation, enabling researchers to account for both systematic factors and random variability.
Nested Effects: Nested effects refer to a situation in experimental design where one factor is embedded within another factor, meaning that the levels of one factor are not independent but are instead contained within the levels of another. This concept is crucial for understanding how variations in a primary treatment can lead to different responses based on the sub-factors that are influenced by it, impacting the analysis and interpretation of experimental data.
Randomization: Randomization is the process of assigning participants or experimental units to different groups using random methods, which helps eliminate bias and ensures that each participant has an equal chance of being placed in any group. This technique is crucial in experimental design, as it enhances the validity of results by reducing the influence of confounding variables and allowing for fair comparisons between treatments.
Split-plot design: A split-plot design is a type of experimental design that involves multiple levels of experimental units, allowing researchers to study two or more factors simultaneously while accounting for the variability at different levels. This design is particularly useful when some factors are harder or more costly to manipulate than others, making it necessary to control these factors at a larger scale while manipulating others at a finer scale. This flexibility connects it to various principles and applications in experimental research.
Subplots: In experimental design, subplots refer to smaller experimental units within a larger plot or treatment group. They are commonly used in split-plot designs where there are two levels of experimental units, allowing researchers to study the effects of one or more factors at a finer level of detail while controlling for the variability at the main plot level. Subplots help in understanding interactions between treatments and can provide more precise estimates of treatment effects.
Treatment effects: Treatment effects refer to the impact or influence that a specific treatment or intervention has on the subjects in a study. Understanding treatment effects is crucial when designing experiments, as it allows researchers to assess the effectiveness of various treatments and make comparisons between groups. This concept is particularly important when considering factors like variability and potential confounding variables, especially in designs that incorporate blocking or split-plot structures.
Whole plots: Whole plots are the larger experimental units in split-plot designs, which allow for the investigation of multiple factors at different levels of variability. They serve as a crucial component in experimental layouts where one factor is assigned to whole plots while another is applied to subplots, leading to more efficient designs when certain factors are difficult to manipulate or measure. Understanding whole plots helps clarify how different levels of treatment can be effectively applied and analyzed in experiments.