10.3 Describing function analysis
8 min read•august 20, 2024
analysis is a powerful tool in control theory for analyzing . It approximates complex behaviors with linear models, enabling and controller design for systems with saturation, dead-zones, and hysteresis.
This technique assumes sinusoidal inputs and focuses on the fundamental frequency component of the system's response. By neglecting higher harmonics, it simplifies analysis and allows for the application of linear control techniques to nonlinear systems.
Describing function concept
- Describing function analysis is a powerful technique used in control theory to analyze the behavior of nonlinear systems by approximating them with linear models
- It allows for the application of linear control techniques to nonlinear systems, enabling stability analysis and controller design
Nonlinear systems
Top images from around the web for Nonlinear systems
Chaos theory - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
nonlinear system - Equilibrium Points and Linearization - Mathematics Stack Exchange View original
Is this image relevant?
Chaos theory - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
nonlinear system - Equilibrium Points and Linearization - Mathematics Stack Exchange View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 2
Top images from around the web for Nonlinear systems
Chaos theory - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
nonlinear system - Equilibrium Points and Linearization - Mathematics Stack Exchange View original
Is this image relevant?
Chaos theory - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
nonlinear system - Equilibrium Points and Linearization - Mathematics Stack Exchange View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 2
- Nonlinear systems exhibit complex behaviors that cannot be adequately described by linear models
- They may exhibit phenomena such as multiple equilibrium points, , and chaotic behavior
- Examples of nonlinear systems include saturation, dead-zone, and hysteresis
Quasi-linearization
- is the process of approximating a nonlinear system with a linear model around a specific operating point
- It involves linearizing the nonlinear system equations using techniques such as Taylor series expansion
- The resulting linear model is valid only in the vicinity of the operating point
Sinusoidal input assumption
- The describing function method assumes that the input to the nonlinear system is a sinusoidal signal
- This assumption simplifies the analysis by focusing on the fundamental frequency component of the system's response
- The output of the nonlinear system is assumed to consist of the fundamental frequency component and higher harmonics
Describing function derivation
- The describing function is derived by representing the nonlinear system's input-output relationship using a Fourier series expansion
- It involves expressing the output of the nonlinear system as a sum of sinusoidal components with different frequencies
Fourier series representation
- The of a periodic signal consists of a sum of sinusoidal components with frequencies that are integer multiples of the fundamental frequency
- The coefficients of the Fourier series determine the amplitude and phase of each frequency component
- The Fourier series representation allows for the analysis of the nonlinear system's response in the frequency domain
Fundamental component
- The is the sinusoidal component of the Fourier series with the same frequency as the input signal
- It represents the linear approximation of the nonlinear system's response at the fundamental frequency
- The describing function is defined as the complex ratio of the fundamental component of the output to the input sinusoid
Higher harmonics neglection
- The describing function method neglects the higher harmonics of the nonlinear system's response
- It assumes that the higher harmonics have negligible effect on the system's behavior compared to the fundamental component
- This simplification allows for the application of linear analysis techniques to the approximated system
Types of nonlinearities
- Nonlinearities can be classified into different categories based on their input-output characteristics
- Understanding the types of nonlinearities is crucial for selecting the appropriate describing function and analyzing the system's behavior
Single-valued nonlinearities
- have a unique output value for each input value
- Examples of single-valued nonlinearities include saturation, dead-zone, and ideal relay
- The describing function for single-valued nonlinearities can be derived analytically or graphically
Saturation nonlinearity
- occurs when the output of a system is limited to a specific range
- It is characterized by a linear region followed by a constant output beyond a certain input threshold
- The describing function for saturation nonlinearity exhibits a decreasing gain with increasing input amplitude
Dead-zone nonlinearity
- refers to a system where the output remains zero for a range of input values around zero
- It is commonly encountered in mechanical systems with backlash or in control valves with hysteresis
- The describing function for dead-zone nonlinearity has a phase lag and a reduced gain compared to the linear case
Ideal relay nonlinearity
- represents a system that switches abruptly between two output levels based on the input signal
- It is often used to model on-off controllers or bang-bang control systems
- The describing function for ideal relay nonlinearity has a phase lag of 90 degrees and a gain that depends on the input amplitude
Coulomb friction nonlinearity
- is characterized by a constant friction force that opposes the direction of motion
- It is commonly found in mechanical systems with sliding surfaces
- The describing function for Coulomb friction nonlinearity has a phase lag and a gain that depends on the input amplitude and frequency
Describing function properties
- The describing function has several important properties that characterize the behavior of the nonlinear system
- Understanding these properties is essential for stability analysis and controller design
Amplitude dependence
- The describing function is amplitude-dependent, meaning that its value changes with the amplitude of the input sinusoid
- This captures the nonlinear behavior of the system
- The describing function is typically plotted as a function of the input amplitude, known as the describing function locus
Phase characteristics
- The describing function introduces a phase shift between the input and output signals
- The of the describing function depend on the type of nonlinearity and the input amplitude
- The phase information is crucial for assessing the stability of the system using techniques such as the Nyquist criterion
Gain characteristics
- The gain of the describing function represents the ratio of the output amplitude to the input amplitude
- The of the describing function vary with the input amplitude and the type of nonlinearity
- The gain information is used to determine the stability margins and the presence of limit cycles in the system
Stability analysis using describing functions
- Describing functions can be used to analyze the stability of nonlinear systems and predict the
- Stability analysis involves combining the describing function with linear analysis techniques
Limit cycles
- Limit cycles are self-sustained oscillations that can occur in nonlinear systems
- They are characterized by a closed trajectory in the state space and a constant amplitude and frequency
- The presence of limit cycles can be determined using the describing function and the Nyquist criterion
Existence of limit cycles
- The existence of limit cycles can be predicted by examining the intersection points between the describing function locus and the negative inverse of the linear system's transfer function
- If an intersection point exists with a phase shift of 180 degrees, it indicates the presence of a limit cycle
- The amplitude and frequency of the limit cycle can be determined from the intersection point
Stability of limit cycles
- The can be assessed by analyzing the slope of the describing function locus and the linear system's transfer function at the intersection point
- If the slopes have opposite signs, the limit cycle is stable; if the slopes have the same sign, the limit cycle is unstable
- Stable limit cycles attract nearby trajectories, while unstable limit cycles repel them
Nyquist criterion with describing functions
- The Nyquist criterion can be extended to nonlinear systems by incorporating the describing function
- The modified Nyquist criterion states that the system is stable if the Nyquist plot of the linear system's transfer function multiplied by the negative inverse of the describing function does not encircle the critical point (-1, 0)
- This criterion allows for the determination of stability margins and the prediction of limit cycles in nonlinear systems
Accuracy and limitations
- While the describing function method provides valuable insights into nonlinear system behavior, it has certain accuracy limitations and that must be considered
Approximation accuracy
- The describing function is an approximation of the nonlinear system's behavior, and its accuracy depends on the assumptions made during the derivation
- The accuracy of the approximation improves as the input amplitude increases and the higher harmonics become less significant
- The describing function method may not capture all the nuances of the nonlinear system's behavior, especially in the presence of strong nonlinearities
Validity conditions
- The describing function method is valid under certain conditions, such as the assumption of a sinusoidal input and the neglection of higher harmonics
- It is important to verify that these conditions are satisfied for the specific nonlinear system being analyzed
- Violating the validity conditions may lead to inaccurate results and incorrect conclusions about the system's behavior
Subharmonic oscillations
- are oscillations with frequencies that are integer fractions of the input frequency
- The describing function method does not capture subharmonic oscillations, as it focuses only on the fundamental frequency component
- In systems where subharmonic oscillations are significant, additional analysis techniques may be required
Asymmetrical nonlinearities
- The describing function method assumes that the nonlinearity is symmetrical, meaning that the output is an odd function of the input
- For , the describing function may not provide an accurate representation of the system's behavior
- In such cases, modifications to the describing function or alternative analysis techniques may be necessary
Design applications
- Describing functions find numerous applications in the design and analysis of
- They provide valuable insights into system behavior and guide the selection of appropriate and controller designs
Nonlinear control systems
- Nonlinear control systems are prevalent in various domains, such as robotics, aerospace, and process control
- These systems often exhibit complex behaviors and require specialized control strategies to achieve desired performance
- Describing functions enable the analysis and design of controllers for nonlinear systems by approximating their behavior with linear models
Compensation techniques
- Compensation techniques are used to modify the system's behavior and improve its performance
- Describing functions can guide the selection and design of compensation techniques for nonlinear systems
- Examples of compensation techniques include feedback linearization, gain scheduling, and nonlinear robust control
Describing function-based controllers
- are designed specifically to handle nonlinear system characteristics
- These controllers incorporate the describing function information to adapt their behavior based on the operating conditions
- Examples of describing function-based controllers include nonlinear PID controllers and adaptive controllers
Examples and case studies
- Practical examples and case studies demonstrate the application of describing functions in real-world scenarios
- They illustrate the effectiveness of the describing function method in analyzing and designing nonlinear control systems
Practical nonlinear systems
- Nonlinear systems are encountered in various engineering applications, such as automotive systems, robotics, and power electronics
- These systems often exhibit nonlinearities such as saturation, dead-zone, and hysteresis
- Describing functions provide a framework for analyzing and understanding the behavior of these practical nonlinear systems
Stability analysis examples
- Stability analysis using describing functions can be applied to a wide range of nonlinear systems
- Examples include the stability analysis of a pendulum with Coulomb friction, a servo system with saturation, and a nonlinear oscillator
- These examples demonstrate the effectiveness of describing functions in predicting limit cycles and assessing system stability
Controller design examples
- Describing functions can be used to design controllers for nonlinear systems
- Examples include the design of a nonlinear PID controller for a robot manipulator, a gain-scheduled controller for an aircraft, and a describing function-based controller for a power converter
- These examples showcase the application of describing functions in improving the performance and robustness of nonlinear control systems
Key Terms to Review (28)
Amplitude dependence: Amplitude dependence refers to the phenomenon where the behavior of a nonlinear system changes as the amplitude of the input signal varies. In control systems, this can lead to different dynamic responses depending on the input magnitude, complicating the analysis and design of controllers. Understanding amplitude dependence is crucial for predicting system performance and ensuring stability under varying input conditions.
Approximation accuracy: Approximation accuracy refers to the degree to which an approximate solution aligns with the exact solution of a given problem. In control systems, it is crucial for ensuring that simplified models or analyses closely match the behavior of the actual system, allowing engineers to make reliable predictions and decisions.
Asymmetrical nonlinearities: Asymmetrical nonlinearities refer to nonlinear behaviors in a system where the response to positive inputs differs from the response to negative inputs. This concept is crucial in control systems as it impacts the stability and performance of feedback loops, particularly in describing functions where the linear approximation may not hold true across all input ranges.
Compensation techniques: Compensation techniques refer to methods used in control systems to adjust the behavior of a system in order to achieve desired performance characteristics, particularly in the presence of disturbances or uncertainties. These techniques are essential for improving system stability, response time, and accuracy, especially when dealing with non-linearities or time delays that can complicate system dynamics.
Coulomb Friction Nonlinearity: Coulomb friction nonlinearity refers to the behavior of friction in mechanical systems where the friction force does not vary linearly with respect to motion or applied forces, but instead remains constant until a certain threshold is reached. This type of nonlinearity is essential in modeling and analyzing systems with discontinuous changes in motion, such as stick-slip phenomena, where an object may remain at rest until a specific force is exceeded, after which it moves abruptly.
Dead-zone nonlinearity: Dead-zone nonlinearity refers to a type of nonlinearity in control systems where there is a range of input values for which the output remains constant, effectively 'ignoring' small changes in the input signal. This phenomenon is important to understand because it can lead to inaccuracies in system responses and may affect the stability and performance of control systems, particularly when using describing function analysis.
Describing Function: A describing function is a mathematical tool used in control theory to analyze nonlinear systems by approximating their behavior through equivalent linear representations. It helps in simplifying the analysis of systems with nonlinear components, allowing engineers to predict system performance under various conditions without solving complex differential equations directly. This approach is especially useful when dealing with feedback loops and can provide insights into stability and system response.
Describing Function Properties: Describing function properties refer to the characteristics and behavior of nonlinear systems as they are approximated using describing functions, a method that simplifies the analysis of nonlinear control systems by converting them into an equivalent linear form. This approach facilitates understanding system stability and performance by analyzing the system response to periodic inputs, thus bridging the gap between linear and nonlinear system analysis.
Describing function-based controllers: Describing function-based controllers are a type of control strategy that utilizes describing function analysis to simplify the nonlinear behavior of a system into a linear approximation for analysis and design. This method helps in understanding how nonlinear elements influence system dynamics, allowing engineers to design effective controllers by translating nonlinear relationships into manageable equations. This approach is particularly useful when dealing with systems exhibiting nonlinearity due to components like saturation, dead zones, or backlash.
Existence of Limit Cycles: The existence of limit cycles refers to the phenomenon in dynamical systems where a periodic trajectory, called a limit cycle, persists in the system despite small perturbations. These cycles represent stable or unstable oscillations that can occur in nonlinear systems, and they are significant because they indicate the long-term behavior of a system after transients have died out.
Fourier Series Representation: Fourier series representation is a mathematical way to express a periodic function as a sum of sine and cosine functions. This technique allows for the analysis of systems by breaking down complex signals into simpler components, which is crucial in understanding non-linear systems and their behavior in the context of describing function analysis.
Fundamental component: A fundamental component refers to the basic building block or essential part of a system, often representing the dominant frequency or behavior in a given signal or response. In control systems, identifying these components is crucial for understanding how the system reacts to inputs and disturbances, as well as for designing effective control strategies.
Gain characteristics: Gain characteristics refer to the relationship between the input and output of a system, specifically how changes in gain affect the system's response. Understanding gain characteristics is crucial in control theory as it helps predict how a system will behave when subjected to various inputs, and is particularly important in the analysis and design of feedback systems.
Higher Harmonics Neglection: Higher harmonics neglection refers to the practice of disregarding higher-order harmonics in the analysis of non-linear systems, particularly when using describing functions. This simplification is often employed to focus on the dominant behavior of a system, making it easier to analyze and design control strategies without losing significant accuracy in certain contexts.
Ideal relay nonlinearity: Ideal relay nonlinearity refers to a mathematical model used in control systems to represent a relay switch that operates in an on-off manner. This concept is crucial for understanding systems with discontinuous behaviors, as it describes how the system reacts when the input signal crosses certain thresholds, effectively switching states without gradual transitions. The ideal relay introduces nonlinearity into the system, making it essential for analyzing stability and performance under various conditions.
Limit Cycles: Limit cycles are closed trajectories in phase space that represent periodic solutions of a dynamical system. They occur in systems exhibiting nonlinear behavior, where small perturbations can lead to stable oscillations, making them important in the analysis of feedback systems and stability. Understanding limit cycles is essential for analyzing the behavior of nonlinear control systems and can indicate the presence of oscillatory responses.
Nonlinear control systems: Nonlinear control systems are systems in which the output is not directly proportional to the input due to the presence of nonlinear elements or dynamics. These systems can exhibit complex behavior such as bifurcations, chaos, and limit cycles, making them more challenging to analyze and control compared to linear systems. Nonlinear control approaches often require specialized techniques like describing functions to approximate the system's behavior in order to design effective controllers.
Nonlinear systems: Nonlinear systems are dynamic systems in which the output is not directly proportional to the input, leading to complex behavior that cannot be accurately predicted using linear approximations. These systems often exhibit phenomena such as multiple equilibrium points, limit cycles, and chaotic behavior. Their analysis requires different methods and tools compared to linear systems, particularly in understanding stability, applying describing functions, and utilizing feedback linearization techniques.
Nyquist Criterion with Describing Functions: The Nyquist Criterion is a graphical method used to determine the stability of a control system by analyzing its frequency response. In the context of describing functions, it provides a means to assess the stability of nonlinear systems by evaluating how their describing functions intersect with the Nyquist plot of the linearized system. This connection helps identify potential limit cycles and enables the design of effective control strategies.
Phase characteristics: Phase characteristics refer to the properties of a system that describe how the phase angle of the output signal relates to the phase angle of the input signal, particularly in the context of non-linear systems. Understanding phase characteristics is crucial for analyzing system stability, response behavior, and overall performance, especially when using describing function analysis to evaluate non-linearities in control systems.
Quasi-linearization: Quasi-linearization is a mathematical technique used to approximate nonlinear systems by linearizing them around a nominal operating point, enabling easier analysis and control design. This method involves replacing nonlinear terms in a system's equations with linear approximations, making it possible to apply linear control theory techniques for analysis and design purposes.
Saturation nonlinearity: Saturation nonlinearity refers to a type of nonlinear behavior in control systems where the output of a system cannot exceed a certain limit or threshold, regardless of the input. This phenomenon is crucial in understanding how systems behave under extreme conditions, as it can significantly affect system performance and stability during operation.
Single-valued nonlinearities: Single-valued nonlinearities refer to nonlinear relationships in control systems where each input corresponds to exactly one output. These types of nonlinearities are crucial for analyzing the behavior of systems under various conditions, allowing for the use of describing functions to approximate and predict system responses. Understanding single-valued nonlinearities helps engineers and scientists design more robust control systems by capturing essential dynamic characteristics that linear models may overlook.
Sinusoidal input assumption: The sinusoidal input assumption is a foundational concept in control theory that presumes system inputs are sinusoidal functions, allowing for easier analysis of system behavior and stability. This assumption simplifies the process of evaluating system responses by applying techniques like Fourier analysis, which transforms complex signals into simpler sinusoidal components. Using this approach helps in determining frequency response and stability characteristics of linear time-invariant systems.
Stability analysis: Stability analysis is the process of determining whether a system's behavior will remain bounded over time in response to initial conditions or external disturbances. This concept is crucial in various fields, as it ensures that systems respond predictably and remain operational, particularly when analyzing differential equations, control systems, and feedback mechanisms.
Stability of limit cycles: The stability of limit cycles refers to the behavior of periodic solutions in dynamical systems, determining whether small perturbations will cause the system to return to the limit cycle or diverge away from it. Understanding this stability helps assess how resilient these oscillatory behaviors are to changes or disturbances in the system, such as external forces or parameter variations. Limit cycles can be stable, unstable, or semi-stable, impacting the overall system performance and response.
Subharmonic Oscillations: Subharmonic oscillations are periodic motions that occur at a frequency that is a fraction of the fundamental frequency of a system. This phenomenon often arises in nonlinear systems where oscillations can take on lower frequency components, creating additional dynamics within the system's behavior. Understanding subharmonic oscillations is crucial for analyzing stability and performance in control systems and can indicate the presence of limit cycles or bifurcations.
Validity Conditions: Validity conditions refer to the specific requirements or assumptions that must be met for a particular analysis or modeling approach to be considered accurate and reliable. In describing function analysis, these conditions ensure that the approximations made during the analysis reflect the actual behavior of nonlinear systems accurately under certain operating circumstances.