6.2 Diversification (related and unrelated)
4 min read•august 14, 2024
Corporate-level strategies shape a company's overall direction. Diversification, a key strategy, involves expanding into new business areas. This can be related (similar to current operations) or unrelated (distinct from existing business), each with unique benefits and challenges.
Firms pursue diversification to leverage resources, reduce risk, or tap new markets. aims for , while spreads risk. Understanding these approaches helps companies make smart growth decisions and manage their business portfolios effectively.
Related vs Unrelated Diversification
Characteristics and Objectives
Top images from around the web for Characteristics and Objectives
Matrice d'Ansoff — Wikipédia View original
Is this image relevant?
Strategy Formulation | Human Resources Management View original
Is this image relevant?
Strategic Opportunity Matrix | Principles of Marketing View original
Is this image relevant?
Matrice d'Ansoff — Wikipédia View original
Is this image relevant?
Strategy Formulation | Human Resources Management View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Characteristics and Objectives
Matrice d'Ansoff — Wikipédia View original
Is this image relevant?
Strategy Formulation | Human Resources Management View original
Is this image relevant?
Strategic Opportunity Matrix | Principles of Marketing View original
Is this image relevant?
Matrice d'Ansoff — Wikipédia View original
Is this image relevant?
Strategy Formulation | Human Resources Management View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Related diversification involves expanding into new businesses that share commonalities or synergies with a firm's existing business (similar products, markets, or technologies)
- Unrelated diversification involves entering into new businesses that are distinctly different from a firm's current operations, with no direct linkages or overlaps
- Related diversification allows firms to leverage existing resources and capabilities
- Unrelated diversification aims to spread risk across unrelated industries (conglomerates like General Electric)
Motivations and Implications
- Firms may pursue related diversification to achieve (sharing R&D, manufacturing, or marketing resources across businesses)
- Unrelated diversification is often driven by financial motives like or cross-subsidization (using profits from one business to support another)
- Related diversification enables knowledge transfer and skill sharing across businesses
- Unrelated diversification requires developing new competencies and managing diverse business portfolios
Synergies and Risks of Diversification
Potential Synergies
- Synergies in diversification can arise from sharing resources (R&D, manufacturing), transferring skills and knowledge, or leveraging brand reputation across businesses
- Operational synergies can lead to cost savings through economies of scale or scope (shared production facilities or distribution networks)
- Financial synergies can improve access to capital or reduce the cost of borrowing (diversified revenue streams and risk profile)
- Market power synergies can increase bargaining power with suppliers or customers (bundling products or services)
Risks and Challenges
- Diversification carries risks such as overestimating synergies, diverting management attention, or creating organizational complexity that hinders performance
- Unrelated diversification can be particularly risky if the firm lacks the necessary expertise or resources to compete effectively in the new industry
- Excessive diversification can lead to loss of strategic focus and dilution of core competencies
- Integrating and managing diverse businesses can strain organizational resources and capabilities
- Diversification may create internal conflicts and competition for resources among business units
Impact of Diversification on Performance
Performance Outcomes and Contingencies
- The relationship between diversification and firm performance is complex and depends on various factors (type and extent of diversification, industry characteristics, firm-specific resources)
- Related diversification is generally associated with better performance outcomes compared to unrelated diversification, as it allows firms to exploit synergies and leverage core competencies
- However, excessive diversification (either related or unrelated) can lead to diminishing returns and negative performance consequences due to increased complexity, coordination costs, and management challenges
- The performance impact of diversification also depends on the firm's ability to effectively integrate and manage the new businesses, as well as the competitive dynamics in the target industries
Empirical Evidence and Strategic Implications
- Empirical research on the diversification-performance relationship has yielded mixed results, highlighting the need for careful strategic analysis and execution
- Some studies find a positive relationship between related diversification and performance (higher profitability, innovation, and market valuation)
- Other studies suggest that unrelated diversification can lead to lower performance and shareholder value (conglomerate discount)
- Firms need to carefully assess the potential synergies, risks, and performance implications of diversification strategies based on their unique resources, capabilities, and market conditions
- Successful diversification requires effective strategic planning, due diligence, and post-merger integration to realize intended synergies and performance benefits
Core Competencies in Diversification
Defining and Leveraging Core Competencies
- Core competencies are the unique combination of skills, knowledge, and resources that provide a firm with a sustainable competitive advantage
- Identifying and leveraging core competencies is crucial for successful diversification, as it allows firms to enter new businesses where they can create value and differentiate themselves from competitors
- Related diversification should be based on extending or replicating core competencies in adjacent markets or industries (Honda's engines in automobiles and power equipment)
- Unrelated diversification may involve acquiring new competencies or applying existing ones in novel ways (Virgin Group's brand extension across diverse businesses)
Assessing Fit and Sustainability
- Firms should assess the transferability and applicability of their core competencies to potential diversification opportunities, considering factors such as market attractiveness, entry barriers, and competitive intensity
- Diversification strategies that are not grounded in core competencies can lead to a lack of focus, dilution of competitive advantage, and suboptimal
- Effective diversification requires continuous development and adaptation of core competencies to maintain relevance and competitiveness in changing business environments
- Firms need to balance the exploitation of existing competencies with the exploration of new ones to sustain long-term competitive advantage through diversification
- Regular assessment and refinement of core competencies is essential to ensure their ongoing value creation potential in diversified business portfolios
Key Terms to Review (18)
Amazon's Expansion into Cloud Computing: Amazon's expansion into cloud computing refers to the strategic move by Amazon to offer cloud-based services, primarily through its Amazon Web Services (AWS) platform, which began in the early 2000s. This diversification into a new market aligns with Amazon's overall business strategy by leveraging its existing technology infrastructure and expertise, while also creating new revenue streams and reducing dependency on its traditional retail operations.
Ansoff Matrix: The Ansoff Matrix is a strategic planning tool that helps businesses determine their product and market growth strategy. It outlines four primary growth options: market penetration, market development, product development, and diversification, each representing different levels of risk and opportunity. By understanding these options, companies can better navigate the challenges presented by the industry life cycle and make informed decisions about related or unrelated diversification.
BCG Matrix: The BCG Matrix, or Boston Consulting Group Matrix, is a strategic tool used for portfolio management that helps organizations assess their business units or product lines based on their market growth rate and relative market share. By categorizing products into four quadrants—Stars, Question Marks, Cash Cows, and Dogs—companies can make informed decisions about resource allocation, investment strategies, and divestment opportunities to maximize overall performance and profitability.
Disney's acquisition of Pixar: Disney's acquisition of Pixar was a strategic move in 2006 where The Walt Disney Company purchased Pixar Animation Studios for approximately $7.4 billion in stock. This acquisition marked a significant step in Disney's efforts to diversify its offerings in animated films and leverage Pixar's innovative technology and storytelling expertise to enhance its brand and expand its market presence.
Diversification premium: The diversification premium refers to the added value or higher valuation that a company receives when it diversifies its operations into new markets or product lines. This concept highlights the potential benefits of reducing risk and achieving higher returns by spreading investments across different areas. It is important in understanding how firms leverage related and unrelated diversification strategies to enhance their overall financial performance.
Economies of Scope: Economies of scope refer to the cost advantages that a company experiences when it produces multiple products or services together, rather than separately. This concept emphasizes that a firm can lower its average costs by diversifying its product lines and sharing resources across different operations, making it beneficial for businesses to pursue related diversification strategies.
Igor Ansoff: Igor Ansoff was a Russian-American mathematician and business manager, best known for his contributions to strategic management, particularly through the development of the Ansoff Matrix. His work emphasizes how organizations can grow and achieve competitive advantage through diversification strategies, which can be either related or unrelated to their existing operations.
Increased Market Power: Increased market power refers to a firm's ability to influence the price of its products or services in the market due to its size, share, or control over key resources. This power enables companies to set prices above competitive levels, leading to higher profits and potentially affecting consumer choice. In the context of diversification, both related and unrelated, firms can enhance their market power by expanding their product lines or entering new markets, which can create synergies and economies of scale.
Industry life cycle: The industry life cycle describes the progression of an industry through various stages from inception to decline. This concept helps in understanding how industries evolve over time, which can inform strategic decisions such as diversification, either related or unrelated, that companies may undertake to maximize their growth and profitability as industries mature or face disruption.
Integration difficulties: Integration difficulties refer to the challenges and obstacles that arise when merging or aligning diverse operations, cultures, and processes within organizations, especially during diversification strategies. These challenges can hinder the successful execution of related or unrelated diversification by creating inefficiencies, misunderstandings, and conflicts between different business units or organizational cultures.
Market Saturation: Market saturation occurs when a product or service has been maximally distributed and consumed within a market, leaving little room for growth or additional sales. This situation often leads to intensified competition among existing players as they vie for the same customer base, impacting strategic decisions related to pricing, marketing, and innovation.
Michael Porter: Michael Porter is a renowned academic known for his work on competitive strategy and economics, particularly his frameworks that analyze industries and competition. His concepts of competitive advantage, the Five Forces model, and value chain analysis have fundamentally shaped how businesses assess their strategic positioning and competitive strategies in various markets.
Related Diversification: Related diversification is a growth strategy where a company expands its operations into areas that are related to its existing business lines, often leveraging its core competencies and resources. This strategy aims to create synergies, enhance efficiency, and improve competitive positioning by tapping into similar markets or industries, thereby increasing the company's overall value.
Resource Allocation: Resource allocation is the process of distributing available resources—such as financial, human, and physical assets—among various projects or business units to optimize performance and achieve strategic goals. This process is crucial for ensuring that an organization can effectively implement its competitive strategy, make informed decisions, and manage trade-offs in a competitive landscape.
Return on Investment (ROI): Return on Investment (ROI) is a financial metric used to evaluate the profitability of an investment by comparing the gain or loss relative to its cost. This measure is crucial in assessing how effectively a company can generate profit from its investments, whether in projects, products, or strategic initiatives. High ROI indicates effective use of resources, while low ROI may signal a need for strategic reevaluation.
Risk reduction: Risk reduction refers to strategies and actions taken to minimize potential losses and uncertainties that an organization might face in its operations. This concept is particularly important in the context of diversification, as companies seek to spread their investments across various sectors or markets to decrease the likelihood of experiencing significant financial distress from a downturn in any single area.
Synergies: Synergies refer to the concept where the combined value and performance of two companies or business units is greater than the sum of their separate individual parts. This idea is crucial in diversification strategies, as companies aim to leverage their strengths and resources to enhance overall performance, reduce costs, and create new revenue opportunities.
Unrelated diversification: Unrelated diversification is a corporate strategy where a company expands its operations into areas that are not directly related to its current business lines. This approach allows firms to spread risk across different markets, often leading to potential financial gains through the exploration of new products or services that differ significantly from their core operations.