11.3 Open innovation and crowdsourcing
8 min read•august 14, 2024
and are game-changing strategies that tap into and creativity. Companies use these approaches to solve problems, develop products, and gain a competitive edge by leveraging ideas from customers, partners, and the public.
Successful implementation requires a shift in organizational culture and processes. Benefits include faster innovation, reduced costs, and increased . However, challenges like IP management and quality control must be addressed for these strategies to truly drive competitive advantage.
Open Innovation and Crowdsourcing
Definition and Application
Top images from around the web for Definition and Application
Developing design propositions for an open innovation approach for SMEs View original
Is this image relevant?
T-TRANS: Benchmarking Open Innovation Platforms and Networks View original
Is this image relevant?
Idea Crowdsourcing for Innovation: Fundamentals and Recommendations - Management & Data Science View original
Is this image relevant?
Developing design propositions for an open innovation approach for SMEs View original
Is this image relevant?
T-TRANS: Benchmarking Open Innovation Platforms and Networks View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Definition and Application
Developing design propositions for an open innovation approach for SMEs View original
Is this image relevant?
T-TRANS: Benchmarking Open Innovation Platforms and Networks View original
Is this image relevant?
Idea Crowdsourcing for Innovation: Fundamentals and Recommendations - Management & Data Science View original
Is this image relevant?
Developing design propositions for an open innovation approach for SMEs View original
Is this image relevant?
T-TRANS: Benchmarking Open Innovation Platforms and Networks View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Open innovation is a paradigm that assumes firms should use external ideas as well as internal ideas, and internal and external paths to market, as they look to advance their technology and gain competitive advantage
- Involves leveraging knowledge and expertise from outside the organization to drive innovation and create value
- Recognizes that valuable ideas can come from both inside and outside the company (customers, partners, research institutions, and the general public)
- Crowdsourcing is the practice of obtaining needed services, ideas, or content by soliciting contributions from a large group of people, especially an online community, rather than from traditional employees or suppliers
- Harnesses the collective intelligence and creativity of a large, diverse group of individuals to solve problems, generate ideas, or perform tasks
- Platforms like and enable companies to tap into the wisdom of the crowd for various purposes (product development, market research, and problem-solving)
- Open innovation and crowdsourcing can be applied in various aspects of corporate strategy, such as new product development, problem-solving, market research, and customer engagement
- Procter & Gamble's Connect + Develop program sources 50% of its innovations from outside the company, leading to successful products like the Swiffer and Olay Regenerist
- Lego Ideas platform allows fans to submit and vote on new product ideas, resulting in popular sets like the Ghostbusters Ecto-1 and the NASA Apollo Saturn V
Implementation Requirements
- Companies can leverage open innovation and crowdsourcing platforms to access a diverse pool of knowledge, skills, and perspectives that may not be available within the organization
- Kaggle, a platform for data science competitions, enables companies to crowdsource solutions to complex problems from a global community of data scientists
- Quirky, a product development platform, allows inventors to submit ideas and collaborate with a community of experts to bring products to market
- Successful implementation of open innovation and crowdsourcing requires a shift in organizational culture, processes, and incentive structures to foster collaboration and knowledge sharing with external stakeholders
- Requires a mindset shift from "not invented here" to "proudly found elsewhere," embracing external ideas and expertise
- Necessitates the development of processes and systems to effectively manage the flow of ideas, intellectual property, and collaborations with external partners
- Involves creating incentives and rewards that encourage employees to actively participate in and contribute to open innovation initiatives (recognition, bonuses, and career advancement opportunities)
Benefits and Challenges of External Innovation
Advantages of Open Innovation and Crowdsourcing
- Benefits of open innovation and crowdsourcing include access to a wider range of ideas and expertise, faster problem-solving, reduced , and increased customer engagement and loyalty
- Tapping into external knowledge and skills can help companies overcome internal resource constraints and blind spots, leading to more diverse and innovative solutions
- Crowdsourcing can significantly accelerate the innovation process by parallelizing problem-solving efforts and leveraging the collective intelligence of a large group of people
- Collaborating with external partners can help companies share the costs and risks of R&D, while also gaining access to complementary assets and capabilities
- Engaging customers in the innovation process can lead to the development of products and services that better meet their needs and preferences, resulting in higher customer satisfaction and market acceptance
- Starbucks' MyStarbucksIdea platform allows customers to submit and vote on ideas for new products, services, and experiences, leading to successful innovations like cake pops and mobile ordering
- LEGO Mindstorms, a programmable robotics kit, was developed in collaboration with the LEGO user community, resulting in a highly successful and engaging product line
- Collaborating with partners, such as suppliers, universities, and research institutions, can provide access to complementary resources and capabilities, accelerating the innovation process and reducing risks
- Toyota collaborates with its suppliers to co-develop new technologies and components, leveraging their specialized expertise and reducing development costs and time
- Pharmaceutical companies often partner with academic research labs and biotech startups to access novel drug targets and technologies, expanding their innovation pipeline
Challenges and Risks
- Challenges of open innovation and crowdsourcing include , maintaining control over the innovation process, ensuring the quality and relevance of external contributions, and aligning incentives between the firm and external collaborators
- Firms need to establish clear intellectual property agreements and governance mechanisms to protect their proprietary knowledge and technologies when collaborating with external partners
- Balancing the need for openness and collaboration with the need for control and strategic alignment can be difficult, requiring careful management of external relationships and innovation processes
- Ensuring the quality, feasibility, and strategic fit of external ideas and contributions can be challenging, requiring robust screening and evaluation processes
- Firms need to develop appropriate legal frameworks, such as and , to protect their intellectual property rights and mitigate the risk of knowledge leakage when engaging in open innovation and crowdsourcing
- Coca-Cola, known for its secret formula, uses strict confidentiality agreements and a multi-layered security system to protect its intellectual property when collaborating with external partners
- IBM's IP licensing program carefully manages the sharing of its patented technologies with external parties, generating significant revenue while protecting its competitive advantages
Open Innovation Strategy Design
Defining Objectives and Selecting Approaches
- Defining clear objectives and key performance indicators for open innovation initiatives, aligned with the overall corporate strategy and innovation goals of the firm
- Objectives may include expanding the company's innovation pipeline, reducing R&D costs, accelerating time-to-market, or enhancing customer engagement and loyalty
- Key performance indicators can include metrics such as the number of external ideas generated, the percentage of innovations sourced from external partners, and the success rate of open innovation projects
- Identifying the most suitable open innovation and crowdsourcing approaches for the firm, based on factors such as the nature of the innovation challenge, the target audience, and the available resources and capabilities
- Approaches can range from simple idea contests and online communities to more complex platforms and strategic partnerships
- The choice of approach should be based on a careful assessment of the firm's innovation needs, capabilities, and strategic priorities, as well as the characteristics of the target audience and the external innovation ecosystem
Developing Platforms and Processes
- Developing an open innovation platform or leveraging existing platforms to facilitate the submission, evaluation, and selection of external ideas and solutions
- Platforms can be custom-built or based on existing solutions like Brightidea, Spigit, or Hype Innovation
- Key features of an effective open innovation platform include user-friendly interfaces, robust and collaboration tools, and analytics and reporting capabilities
- Establishing clear guidelines and protocols for engaging with external collaborators, including communication channels, , and intellectual property management
- Guidelines should cover topics such as confidentiality, data protection, intellectual property ownership, and revenue sharing arrangements
- Effective communication and feedback mechanisms are essential for building trust and maintaining engagement with external collaborators, ensuring that their contributions are valued and acted upon
Incentives and Capabilities
- Creating incentive structures that motivate and reward external contributors for their participation and valuable inputs, such as recognition, financial rewards, or opportunities for co-creation and partnership
- Incentives can include cash prizes, royalties, licensing fees, or equity stakes in the resulting innovations
- Non-monetary incentives, such as public recognition, exclusive access to products or services, or opportunities for professional development and networking, can also be effective in driving participation and engagement
- Building internal capabilities and processes to effectively absorb, integrate, and commercialize external knowledge and ideas, ensuring alignment with the firm's core competencies and strategic priorities
- Firms need to develop , or the ability to recognize the value of external knowledge, assimilate it, and apply it to commercial ends
- This requires investments in human capital, organizational learning, and cross-functional collaboration, as well as the development of processes and systems to manage the integration and commercialization of external innovations
Open Innovation's Impact on Competitive Advantage
Measuring Performance and Value Creation
- Assessing the contribution of open innovation and crowdsourcing initiatives to key performance metrics, such as time-to-market, innovation success rate, and customer satisfaction
- Firms should establish clear metrics and tracking mechanisms to measure the impact of open innovation on innovation outcomes and business performance
- This can include metrics such as the speed of idea generation and implementation, the number of successful product launches, and the level of customer engagement and satisfaction with co-created products and services
- Analyzing the cost-benefit ratio of open innovation and crowdsourcing investments, considering factors such as the direct and indirect costs of engaging external collaborators, the value of the generated ideas and solutions, and the potential revenue and profit impact
- Firms need to carefully assess the costs and benefits of open innovation initiatives, including the time and resources required to manage external collaborations, the opportunity costs of not pursuing other innovation strategies, and the potential risks and uncertainties involved
- The value of open innovation should be measured not only in terms of direct financial returns but also in terms of strategic benefits such as access to new markets, technologies, and talent pools
Strategic Fit and Sustainability
- Evaluating the strategic fit and complementarity of external knowledge and capabilities with the firm's existing resources and competencies, and their potential to create sustainable competitive advantages
- Open innovation initiatives should be aligned with the firm's overall strategy and competitive positioning, leveraging external assets and capabilities to enhance and complement the firm's core strengths and value proposition
- Firms should assess the potential of open innovation to create sustainable competitive advantages, such as unique product offerings, superior customer experiences, or efficient and agile innovation processes
- Monitoring the competitive landscape and benchmarking the firm's open innovation performance against industry peers and best practices
- Firms should continuously scan the external environment for emerging trends, technologies, and competitors, and assess their potential impact on the firm's open innovation strategy and competitive position
- Benchmarking against industry peers and best practices can help firms identify gaps and opportunities for improvement in their open innovation capabilities and performance
Long-term Impact and Adaptability
- Assessing the long-term impact of open innovation and crowdsourcing on the firm's , organizational learning, and adaptability to changing market conditions and technological trends
- Open innovation can have a transformative impact on a firm's innovation culture, fostering a more open, collaborative, and agile mindset and way of working
- Engaging with external partners and communities can expose firms to new ideas, perspectives, and learning opportunities, enhancing their ability to adapt and respond to changing market and technological conditions
- Continuously refining and adapting the open innovation strategy based on performance feedback, lessons learned, and emerging opportunities and challenges in the external environment
- Firms should adopt a learning and experimentation approach to open innovation, continuously testing and refining their strategies and practices based on performance feedback and lessons learned
- This requires a culture of openness, flexibility, and adaptability, as well as the ability to rapidly pivot and adjust course in response to changing circumstances and emerging opportunities and threats in the external environment
Key Terms to Review (28)
Absorptive capacity: Absorptive capacity refers to a firm's ability to recognize, assimilate, and utilize external knowledge to enhance its innovation and competitive advantage. This concept highlights how organizations leverage their existing knowledge and resources to effectively integrate new information, which is crucial for driving innovation and adapting in a rapidly changing environment.
Access to diverse ideas: Access to diverse ideas refers to the ability to obtain and consider a wide range of perspectives, insights, and innovations from various sources. This concept is crucial in fostering creativity, collaboration, and problem-solving, as it encourages individuals and organizations to draw from a rich tapestry of thoughts that can lead to novel solutions and improvements.
Co-creation: Co-creation is the collaborative process where businesses and consumers work together to create value, products, or services. This approach emphasizes the importance of customer input and engagement, leading to innovations that are more aligned with market needs. By integrating insights and feedback from users, companies can enhance their offerings and build stronger relationships with their customers.
Collaborative innovation: Collaborative innovation is the process where multiple individuals, organizations, or entities work together to generate new ideas, products, or solutions by leveraging diverse perspectives and expertise. This approach often results in a faster and more effective innovation cycle as participants share knowledge, resources, and creativity to tackle complex challenges and address market needs.
Crowd voting: Crowd voting is a collaborative decision-making process where a large group of people collectively expresses their preferences or opinions on a particular issue, product, or idea. This method leverages the wisdom of the crowd, allowing diverse perspectives to influence the outcome, which is especially valuable in open innovation and crowdsourcing initiatives. By harnessing collective input, organizations can better understand market demands and identify innovative solutions.
Crowdsourcing: Crowdsourcing is the practice of obtaining ideas, services, or content by soliciting contributions from a large group of people, typically via the internet. This approach leverages the collective intelligence and diverse skills of the crowd, allowing organizations to solve problems, generate innovative solutions, or gather data at a scale that would be difficult to achieve individually. It encourages collaboration and democratizes the innovation process.
Customer engagement: Customer engagement refers to the emotional and psychological connection between a brand and its customers, characterized by the customers' interaction, involvement, and commitment to the brand. This connection goes beyond simple transactions; it encompasses customer experiences, loyalty, and feedback, making customers feel valued and heard. Engaged customers are more likely to advocate for the brand, participate in co-creation activities, and contribute to open innovation initiatives.
Eric von Hippel: Eric von Hippel is a prominent researcher and professor known for his work on user innovation and open-source methods. He has contributed significantly to the understanding of how users can play a vital role in the innovation process, particularly in the context of developing new products and services through collaboration and sharing. His ideas highlight the importance of leveraging external sources, such as users and communities, to drive innovation in organizations.
External knowledge: External knowledge refers to information, expertise, and insights that organizations obtain from sources outside their own boundaries. This can include ideas from customers, partners, competitors, or even academic institutions. By leveraging external knowledge, companies can foster innovation and improve their problem-solving capabilities, creating a more dynamic approach to product development and market strategies.
Feedback mechanisms: Feedback mechanisms are processes that provide information about the results of an action or decision, allowing for adjustments and improvements based on that information. They play a crucial role in refining strategies, promoting innovation, and enhancing decision-making through continuous evaluation and learning. In environments characterized by open innovation and crowdsourcing, feedback mechanisms enable organizations to effectively harness external input, adapt to changing conditions, and enhance collaborative efforts.
Henry Chesbrough: Henry Chesbrough is an influential scholar known for introducing the concept of 'open innovation,' which emphasizes the importance of collaboration and sharing knowledge across organizational boundaries to drive innovation. His work highlights how companies can benefit from engaging external partners, leveraging external ideas, and utilizing crowdsourcing to enhance their innovation processes.
Idea management: Idea management is the process of capturing, evaluating, and implementing ideas generated by individuals within an organization or from external sources. This practice encourages creativity and innovation by facilitating a structured approach to harnessing ideas, ensuring that valuable insights are not lost and can be translated into actionable strategies for business growth.
Innocentive: Innocentive is an online platform that connects organizations with a global network of problem solvers to crowdsource innovative solutions for complex challenges. By leveraging the collective intelligence and creativity of diverse individuals, Innocentive enables companies to tap into new ideas and technologies, enhancing their open innovation strategies.
Innovation culture: Innovation culture refers to the values, beliefs, and practices within an organization that encourage and support creative thinking, experimentation, and the implementation of new ideas. It fosters an environment where employees feel empowered to take risks and collaborate, ultimately driving progress and maintaining competitiveness in the market. This culture is crucial for organizations to leverage first-mover advantages, as it allows them to rapidly adapt and innovate in response to market demands, while also enhancing their ability to engage in open innovation and crowdsourcing initiatives.
Innovation ecosystems: Innovation ecosystems refer to interconnected networks of organizations, individuals, and resources that collaborate to foster innovation and create value. These ecosystems can include businesses, startups, research institutions, and government entities, all working together to share knowledge, technologies, and resources. The dynamic interactions among participants in an innovation ecosystem can lead to the development of new products, services, and processes that drive economic growth and enhance competitiveness.
Intellectual Property Management: Intellectual property management refers to the systematic handling of intellectual property assets to maximize their value and minimize risks associated with their use. This includes identifying, protecting, leveraging, and monetizing innovations, trademarks, copyrights, and patents in a way that aligns with the strategic goals of an organization. Effective management ensures that intellectual property can support open innovation and crowdsourcing efforts by facilitating collaboration while safeguarding proprietary information.
Joint ventures: Joint ventures are business arrangements where two or more parties agree to collaborate and share resources, risks, and profits for a specific project or business activity. This collaborative approach enables companies to leverage each other's strengths, enter new markets, and innovate while maintaining separate legal identities.
Kickstarter: Kickstarter is a crowdfunding platform that helps creators raise funds for their projects by connecting them with potential backers who are willing to support their ideas in exchange for rewards. This platform embodies the principles of open innovation and crowdsourcing, enabling individuals or groups to gather financial resources and creative input from a diverse audience, fostering a collaborative environment for bringing new ideas to life.
Licensing contracts: Licensing contracts are legal agreements where one party grants permission to another party to use, produce, or sell a product, service, or intellectual property under specified conditions. These contracts can play a vital role in fostering innovation by allowing firms to leverage external ideas and technologies while sharing the associated risks and rewards. They are especially significant in contexts where companies engage in open innovation and crowdsourcing to enhance their product offerings or access new markets.
Non-disclosure agreements: Non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) are legally binding contracts that protect sensitive information shared between parties. They are essential in maintaining confidentiality in business relationships, especially when engaging in open innovation and crowdsourcing, where ideas and proprietary knowledge are often exchanged. NDAs ensure that any shared information is not disclosed to unauthorized third parties, thus safeguarding competitive advantages and intellectual property.
Open call for ideas: An open call for ideas is a process where organizations invite individuals, groups, or the general public to submit their innovative concepts, solutions, or projects to address specific challenges or opportunities. This approach fosters creativity and collaboration by leveraging diverse perspectives and expertise, making it a key component of open innovation and crowdsourcing strategies.
Open Innovation: Open innovation is a concept that encourages organizations to use external and internal ideas and paths to advance their technologies and products. It emphasizes collaboration with external partners, such as customers, suppliers, and research institutions, to drive innovation rather than relying solely on internal resources. This approach allows companies to tap into a broader pool of knowledge and expertise, fostering creativity and speeding up the innovation process.
Participatory Design: Participatory design is a design methodology that actively involves all stakeholders, especially end-users, in the design process to ensure the outcomes meet their needs and expectations. This approach emphasizes collaboration and co-creation, making users not just passive recipients of a product but active contributors to its development. By engaging users early and throughout the design phase, participatory design enhances innovation and ensures that solutions are more relevant and effective.
R&D Costs: R&D costs, or research and development costs, refer to the expenses incurred by a company for the activities related to the innovation, improvement, and creation of new products or services. These costs can include salaries for researchers, equipment, materials, and overhead associated with development efforts. In the context of open innovation and crowdsourcing, R&D costs can be influenced by external collaboration, where companies leverage external ideas and expertise to enhance their innovation processes.
Return on Investment: Return on Investment (ROI) is a financial metric that evaluates the efficiency or profitability of an investment by measuring the return relative to the cost of the investment. It plays a crucial role in assessing competitive advantage, guiding strategic decisions in various business contexts such as analyzing market forces, evaluating mergers or acquisitions, resource allocation, and leveraging innovation strategies.
Technology Transfer: Technology transfer refers to the process of sharing or disseminating technology, knowledge, skills, and expertise from one organization, individual, or country to another. This can include the transfer of innovations from research institutions to businesses, enabling commercialization and broader application in various sectors. It plays a crucial role in fostering collaboration between organizations and enhances competitive advantages by leveraging external knowledge and resources.
The funnel model: The funnel model is a framework that illustrates the process of converting potential ideas and solutions into actionable innovations by filtering and refining them at each stage. This model helps organizations manage the flow of ideas from a broad, initial set to a narrowed focus, ultimately leading to viable products or solutions. It emphasizes the importance of open innovation and crowdsourcing by showcasing how diverse inputs can be systematically evaluated and developed.
The lead user method: The lead user method is an innovation strategy that involves identifying and engaging with lead users—those individuals or organizations that face advanced needs in a particular market. These users are typically ahead of the trend curve and can provide valuable insights for developing new products or services. By leveraging the creativity and expertise of lead users, organizations can better understand market demands and co-create innovative solutions.