13.4 Seismic detailing and retrofit strategies
4 min read•july 30, 2024
and retrofit strategies are crucial for protecting bridges from earthquake damage. These techniques focus on improving , , and in key areas. From reinforcement details to isolation systems, engineers have many tools to enhance bridge resilience.
Critical bridge components like columns, joints, and bearings require special attention in seismic design. Retrofit strategies can strengthen existing structures through techniques like or adding damping devices. Evaluating the effectiveness of these methods is essential for optimizing bridge performance during earthquakes.
Seismic Detailing for Bridges
Principles and Goals
Top images from around the web for Principles and Goals
Frontiers | Analytical Model for Multi-Hazard Resilient Prefabricated Concrete Frame Considering ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Bridge Maintenance Scheduling in Consideration of Resilience Against Natural Disasters View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Prototype Testing of a New Passive Energy Dissipation Device for Seismic Retrofit of ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Analytical Model for Multi-Hazard Resilient Prefabricated Concrete Frame Considering ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Bridge Maintenance Scheduling in Consideration of Resilience Against Natural Disasters View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Principles and Goals
Frontiers | Analytical Model for Multi-Hazard Resilient Prefabricated Concrete Frame Considering ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Bridge Maintenance Scheduling in Consideration of Resilience Against Natural Disasters View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Prototype Testing of a New Passive Energy Dissipation Device for Seismic Retrofit of ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Analytical Model for Multi-Hazard Resilient Prefabricated Concrete Frame Considering ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Bridge Maintenance Scheduling in Consideration of Resilience Against Natural Disasters View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Seismic detailing improves bridge resilience against earthquake forces without significant damage or collapse
- Ensures ductile behavior, energy dissipation, and controlled damage in predetermined locations during seismic events
- Follows and concept for optimal performance
- Provides adequate longitudinal and in critical regions
- Incorporates (, ) to reduce transmitted forces
- Accommodates seismic displacements while maintaining structural integrity through proper detailing of , , and
- Utilizes advanced materials (, ) to enhance seismic performance when properly detailed
Techniques and Components
- Designs ductile connections between bridge components to distribute forces effectively
- Implements in critical regions to prevent buckling and increase ductility
- Details in bridge elements to control energy dissipation
- Focuses on bridge columns as primary critical components, requiring special detailing in plastic hinge regions
- Addresses in frame bridges to prevent shear failure under cyclic loading
- Pays special attention to and their connections to prevent unseating of bridge spans
- Details and to allow controlled movement while preventing excessive displacements
- Implements shear keys and restrainers at expansion joints to limit transverse and
- Ensures proper detailing of (, ) for force transfer and stability
- Addresses superstructure elements (, ) to resist in-plane and out-of-plane seismic forces
Critical Bridge Components for Seismic Design
Structural Elements
- Bridge columns serve as primary critical components requiring special detailing in plastic hinge regions
- Beam-column joints in frame bridges need careful detailing to maintain connection integrity under cyclic loading
- Abutments and superstructure connections require attention to accommodate large displacements (seat-type abutments, integral abutments)
- Bridge bearings and anchorages allow controlled movement while preventing uplift (elastomeric bearings, pot bearings)
- Shear keys and restrainers at expansion joints limit transverse and longitudinal movements (steel , )
- Foundation elements (pile caps, footings) need special detailing to ensure proper force transfer and prevent excessive settlement
- Superstructure elements (girders, deck slabs) require detailing to resist seismic forces and maintain composite action
Critical Regions and Connections
- Plastic hinge regions in columns require concentrated transverse reinforcement for confinement (closely spaced spiral reinforcement, interlocking hoops)
- Beam-column joint cores need proper to prevent brittle failure (closely spaced ties, headed reinforcement)
- require careful detailing to ensure force transfer and prevent plastic hinge formation at the base (extended longitudinal reinforcement, anchor bolts)
- need ductile detailing to accommodate rotations and prevent unseating (integral connections, hybrid connections)
- Expansion joint regions require special attention to allow movement while preventing damage (, )
- and need proper detailing to distribute lateral forces effectively (moment-resisting connections, gusset plates)
Retrofit Strategies for Seismic Resistance
Structural Strengthening Techniques
- Column jacketing enhances flexural and shear capacity using steel, concrete, or fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) materials
- utilizes external post-tensioning or FRP wrapping to improve frame bridge performance
- add cross-frames or diaphragms to improve seismic force distribution and reduce torsional effects
- enhance seismic performance (soil improvement, micropile addition)
- Restrainer cables or shock transmission units prevent unseating of bridge spans and control relative displacements
- increase flexural and shear capacity of girders and deck slabs
Seismic Isolation and Energy Dissipation
- Installation of (lead-rubber bearings, friction pendulum systems) reduces transmitted forces
- Implementation of (, ) increases energy dissipation
- Replacement of existing bearings with seismic isolation bearings improves overall bridge performance
- Addition of or shock transmission units controls relative displacements between adjacent spans
- Installation of allows controlled movement while protecting critical components
Seismic Detailing vs Retrofit Effectiveness
Analysis and Evaluation Methods
- Nonlinear static (pushover) analysis assesses improvements in lateral load-carrying capacity and ductility
- using site-specific ground motions provides insights into dynamic response of bridges
- Experimental testing validates effectiveness under realistic loading conditions (, )
- compares different retrofit strategies considering implementation costs and performance benefits
- of retrofitted bridges provides data for validating and improving techniques
Performance Considerations
- Evaluation process considers bridge importance, remaining service life, and site-specific
- Assesses impact on overall seismic performance including ductility, energy dissipation, and damage control
- Compares effectiveness of preventive measures (seismic detailing) vs corrective measures (retrofit strategies)
- Analyzes the trade-offs between minimal intervention and extensive retrofitting based on performance goals
- Considers the long-term durability and maintenance requirements of different detailing and retrofit options
- Evaluates the impact on bridge functionality and serviceability during and after seismic events
Key Terms to Review (55)
Abutments: Abutments are structural elements that support the ends of a bridge or an arch, transferring loads from the bridge to the ground. They play a crucial role in maintaining the stability and alignment of the bridge, especially in arch designs where they resist lateral forces and provide a solid foundation. The design and analysis of abutments are critical for ensuring the integrity of a bridge under various conditions, including seismic activity, scour effects, and load distribution.
Anchorages: Anchorages are structural components used to secure and stabilize bridge elements, particularly in the context of tensioned cables and post-tensioned concrete. They play a crucial role in transferring loads from the bridge deck and superstructure to the foundation, ensuring the stability of the entire system during both normal conditions and seismic events.
Beam-column joint strengthening: Beam-column joint strengthening refers to the process of reinforcing the connections between beams and columns in a structural framework to enhance their load-carrying capacity and ductility, especially during seismic events. This technique is crucial for maintaining structural integrity and performance during earthquakes, as these joints are typically weak points that can lead to failures. Effective strengthening methods can involve various materials and techniques aimed at improving energy dissipation and overall resilience of the structure.
Beam-column joints: Beam-column joints are critical connections in structural engineering that link beams and columns within a framework, ensuring the overall stability and integrity of a structure. These joints play a vital role in transferring loads between horizontal and vertical members, especially during seismic events where forces can induce significant stresses. Proper detailing and reinforcement of beam-column joints are essential to enhance their performance under dynamic loading conditions, making them a focal point in seismic design and retrofit strategies.
Bearing Assemblies: Bearing assemblies are structural components used to support and transfer loads from a bridge superstructure to its substructure, allowing for controlled movement and flexibility. They play a crucial role in ensuring the stability and safety of a bridge, especially during seismic events, where their ability to absorb and dissipate forces is vital to prevent damage and maintain structural integrity.
Bridge bearings: Bridge bearings are structural devices that support the weight of a bridge while allowing for controlled movement, such as expansion and contraction, due to temperature changes or other forces. They play a crucial role in maintaining the stability and integrity of the bridge by transferring loads from the superstructure to the substructure and accommodating movements caused by seismic activity.
Capacity design: Capacity design is a structural engineering approach that focuses on ensuring that a structure can withstand extreme loads, such as those experienced during seismic events, by allowing certain components to yield while maintaining the overall stability of the structure. This method emphasizes designing elements to resist failure in a predictable manner, thus enhancing the safety and performance of structures under seismic forces. It aims to provide ductility and energy dissipation, ensuring that any damage occurs in non-critical areas.
Column jacketing: Column jacketing is a structural retrofitting technique used to enhance the strength and ductility of existing columns by encasing them in a protective layer, often made of reinforced concrete or steel. This method is particularly relevant in seismic detailing as it helps columns withstand lateral forces during an earthquake, improving overall building resilience and safety.
Column-foundation connections: Column-foundation connections refer to the structural interfaces where columns transfer loads to the foundation in a building or bridge. These connections are critical for ensuring stability and strength, especially during seismic events where lateral forces can induce significant stresses. Proper detailing of these connections is vital for maintaining structural integrity and performance under extreme conditions.
Confinement reinforcement: Confinement reinforcement refers to the additional steel bars placed around concrete columns or walls to enhance their strength and ductility, especially under seismic loading conditions. This technique improves the behavior of concrete structures by preventing premature failure and ensuring better energy absorption during earthquakes. It is a crucial aspect of seismic detailing, as it helps to enhance the overall resilience of structures in seismically active regions.
Controlled damage: Controlled damage refers to a design philosophy that allows certain components of a structure to intentionally yield or deform during extreme events, like earthquakes, while protecting the overall integrity of the structure. This approach aims to absorb and dissipate energy, minimizing catastrophic failure and ensuring that critical structural elements remain functional after seismic events. This method is crucial for maintaining safety and usability in bridge engineering.
Cost-benefit analysis: Cost-benefit analysis is a systematic approach used to evaluate the financial feasibility of a project by comparing its costs against the expected benefits. This method helps stakeholders make informed decisions by quantifying the trade-offs involved in a project, guiding them towards the most economically viable option. In bridge engineering, this analysis is crucial for determining the economic justification for new structures or the retrofitting of existing ones, ultimately influencing resource allocation and design strategies.
Cross-frames: Cross-frames are structural elements used in bridge design to provide lateral support and enhance stability by connecting different parts of the bridge deck. They help distribute loads and resist lateral forces, such as wind or seismic activity, ensuring the overall integrity of the bridge system. By connecting girders or beams across the width of the bridge, cross-frames play a critical role in maintaining the bridge's shape and performance during various loading conditions.
Deck slabs: Deck slabs are horizontal structural elements that provide a flat surface for vehicles, pedestrians, or other loads on a bridge. They are crucial in the overall functionality of a bridge, connecting the superstructure to the substructure and distributing loads evenly across supporting members. Proper design and detailing of deck slabs are essential, especially in seismic regions where additional considerations for structural integrity during an earthquake are necessary.
Ductility: Ductility refers to the ability of a material to undergo significant plastic deformation before rupture or failure, allowing it to absorb energy and deform without breaking. This property is crucial in engineering, especially for materials used in structures, as it enhances their resilience during extreme conditions such as seismic events.
End diaphragms: End diaphragms are structural elements used in bridge engineering to provide lateral stability and distribute forces during events like seismic activity. They connect the ends of a bridge span to the superstructure and help resist lateral loads, playing a crucial role in maintaining the integrity of the overall structure, especially under dynamic loading conditions.
Energy dissipation: Energy dissipation refers to the process by which energy is absorbed, transformed, or dissipated in a system, often in the context of reducing forces and vibrations in structures. This concept is particularly crucial in engineering design to enhance resilience against dynamic loads such as those caused by seismic events or environmental forces. Effective energy dissipation mechanisms can protect structures by minimizing the impact of these forces and ensuring stability during extreme conditions.
Expansion Joints: Expansion joints are structural components designed to absorb the thermal expansion and contraction of bridge materials, allowing for safe movement while maintaining the integrity of the structure. They play a critical role in accommodating changes due to temperature variations, which can lead to stresses that could potentially damage the bridge. Properly designed expansion joints ensure smooth transitions between different sections of a bridge, especially in arch bridges, and are crucial in seismic detailing to allow movement without compromising stability.
External Prestressing Systems: External prestressing systems are techniques used to apply a compressive force to concrete elements through the use of high-strength tendons located outside the concrete member. This method enhances the structural performance of bridges, particularly in areas vulnerable to seismic activity, by counteracting tension forces that arise during such events.
Fiber-reinforced polymers: Fiber-reinforced polymers (FRPs) are composite materials made by combining a polymer matrix with fibrous materials, enhancing the strength, stiffness, and durability of the resulting structure. These materials are increasingly used in construction and bridge engineering due to their lightweight nature, resistance to corrosion, and ability to be molded into various shapes, making them suitable for diverse applications like beam bridges, innovative materials, and seismic retrofitting strategies.
Fluid Viscous Dampers: Fluid viscous dampers are devices that dissipate energy from dynamic loads through the movement of a viscous fluid, providing resistance to motion. These dampers are often used in structures to reduce vibrations and enhance stability, particularly during seismic events, making them crucial in minimizing damage during earthquakes.
Footings: Footings are structural elements that distribute the weight of a building or bridge to the ground, ensuring stability and preventing settling. They are crucial in seismic design, as they help maintain the structural integrity of a building during earthquakes by anchoring it securely to the soil. Properly designed footings can minimize the risk of structural failure by providing a solid foundation that can resist lateral forces caused by seismic activity.
Foundation elements: Foundation elements are critical components that provide structural support and stability to a building or structure, anchoring it to the ground. These elements play a vital role in transferring loads from the superstructure to the soil beneath, ensuring the integrity and longevity of the overall construction, especially during seismic events where additional forces come into play.
Foundation retrofitting techniques: Foundation retrofitting techniques involve methods used to improve the stability and strength of existing building foundations to better withstand seismic forces. These techniques are crucial in enhancing the performance of structures during earthquakes, addressing vulnerabilities, and extending the life of a building. By reinforcing foundations, engineers can significantly reduce the risk of failure and increase overall safety.
Friction pendulum systems: Friction pendulum systems are seismic isolation devices designed to reduce the impact of ground motion on structures during an earthquake. They work by allowing a structure to move independently from its foundation, using friction and pendulum mechanisms to absorb and dissipate energy. This innovative approach improves the overall resilience of buildings against seismic forces and is essential in seismic detailing and retrofit strategies.
Girder-to-cap beam connections: Girder-to-cap beam connections are the structural joints that connect girders to cap beams in a bridge framework, serving as critical elements in load transfer and overall stability. These connections are essential for maintaining the integrity of the structure during various loading conditions, including static loads and dynamic forces such as those experienced during seismic events. Proper detailing and retrofitting of these connections are vital to ensure performance during seismic activity.
Girders: Girders are large, horizontal beams that support the structure of a bridge or building, often spanning long distances between vertical supports. They play a crucial role in distributing loads and providing stability, making them essential components in the design and construction of structures. Understanding girders is particularly important when considering how they respond to seismic forces and the strategies used to enhance their performance during such events.
High-performance concrete: High-performance concrete (HPC) is a type of concrete that has been specifically engineered to provide superior strength, durability, and resistance to environmental factors compared to conventional concrete. This enhanced performance makes it particularly useful in critical applications such as bridge construction, where the demands for structural integrity and longevity are paramount.
Lead-Rubber Bearings: Lead-rubber bearings are a type of seismic isolation device used to absorb and dissipate energy during an earthquake, enhancing the structural integrity of buildings and bridges. These bearings consist of layers of rubber and lead, allowing for flexibility and damping effects that reduce the transmission of seismic forces to the structure above. This technology plays a crucial role in ensuring that structures remain safe and functional during seismic events.
Lock-up devices: Lock-up devices are mechanisms used in bridge engineering to prevent the lateral movement or dislocation of bridge components during seismic events. They play a crucial role in enhancing the overall stability and integrity of a bridge, ensuring that it can withstand dynamic forces generated by earthquakes. By effectively locking critical components in place, these devices reduce the risk of failure and enhance the safety of the structure under seismic loading conditions.
Longitudinal movements: Longitudinal movements refer to the displacements and deformations that occur along the length of a structural element, often influenced by factors like temperature changes, shrinkage, and seismic activities. These movements can lead to tension, compression, or shear forces within the structure and must be adequately addressed in design and detailing, especially in structures that are subjected to seismic events.
Metallic yield dampers: Metallic yield dampers are structural devices designed to absorb and dissipate energy during seismic events by yielding under stress. They operate by deforming plastically, which helps to reduce the forces transmitted to the primary structure during an earthquake, making them essential in improving the overall resilience and safety of buildings and bridges in seismic-prone areas.
Modular expansion joints: Modular expansion joints are structural devices used in bridges to accommodate thermal expansion and contraction, as well as other movements, ensuring the integrity and performance of the bridge. These joints consist of multiple interconnected components that allow for movement while preventing water and debris infiltration, which is crucial for maintaining the durability of bridge structures during seismic events.
Nonlinear static analysis: Nonlinear static analysis is a method used to evaluate the behavior of structures under loads that produce significant deformations, capturing the complex material and geometric responses. This analysis is essential for understanding how structures, particularly bridges, behave during seismic events, where the response can be nonlinear due to large displacements and yielding of materials. By incorporating nonlinear effects, engineers can better assess the performance of structures during extreme loading conditions and design effective retrofit strategies.
Pile caps: Pile caps are thick concrete slabs that rest on top of piles and distribute the load from the superstructure above to the underlying piles. They play a crucial role in ensuring stability and load-bearing capacity in structures built on deep foundations, particularly in areas with poor soil conditions. By providing a solid base, pile caps help manage the forces exerted during events like earthquakes, making them essential in seismic design.
Plastic hinge regions: Plastic hinge regions are areas in a structural member, such as a beam or column, where significant plastic deformation occurs during loading, particularly under seismic conditions. These regions allow for rotation and energy dissipation, which helps structures to withstand dynamic loads, minimizing damage and maintaining overall stability during events like earthquakes.
Post-earthquake damage assessment: Post-earthquake damage assessment refers to the systematic evaluation of structural integrity and safety of buildings and infrastructure following an earthquake event. This process involves inspecting, documenting, and analyzing damages to determine the extent of structural issues and the necessary interventions for repairs or retrofits. The assessment is crucial for ensuring public safety and informs decisions regarding evacuation, repair priorities, and future seismic design improvements.
Quasi-static cyclic loading: Quasi-static cyclic loading refers to a type of loading that is applied gradually and repetitively to a structure, allowing it to respond to the changes in stress and strain without the rapid effects associated with dynamic loading. This loading scenario is particularly relevant in assessing the performance of structures during seismic events, where the forces applied can mimic the effects of earthquakes while allowing for controlled testing and analysis. It helps engineers understand how materials and connections in structures will behave under repeated stress.
Restrainer cables: Restrainer cables are tensioned cables used in bridge engineering to provide lateral stability and support against external forces such as seismic activity. These cables play a critical role in preventing excessive movement and potential failure of bridge structures during seismic events, ensuring the overall safety and integrity of the bridge.
Sacrificial shear keys: Sacrificial shear keys are structural elements designed to absorb and dissipate seismic forces during an earthquake, protecting the main components of a structure from damage. These keys are intentionally weaker than the primary structural elements, allowing them to deform or fail under extreme loads, which helps preserve the integrity of the overall structure. This strategy is essential in seismic detailing and retrofit strategies to enhance a bridge's performance during seismic events.
Seismic detailing: Seismic detailing refers to the specific design and construction practices used to ensure that structures can withstand seismic forces during an earthquake. This process includes reinforcing connections, selecting appropriate materials, and detailing structural elements to absorb and dissipate energy, ultimately enhancing the resilience of bridges and buildings against seismic events.
Seismic hazards: Seismic hazards refer to the potential threats and risks posed by earthquakes and related seismic events, such as ground shaking, surface rupture, and landslides. These hazards can significantly impact structures, infrastructure, and populations, especially in seismically active regions. Understanding seismic hazards is crucial for engineers to design buildings and bridges that can withstand the forces generated during an earthquake and to develop retrofit strategies to improve the safety of existing structures.
Seismic isolation devices: Seismic isolation devices are engineering tools used in structures to minimize the transmission of seismic forces during an earthquake, allowing a building to move independently from ground motion. These devices aim to enhance the resilience and safety of structures by reducing the amount of energy that is transferred to the building, thus protecting its integrity and the occupants inside. By incorporating these devices into the design or retrofit of buildings, engineers can significantly improve seismic performance.
Seismic Isolation Systems: Seismic isolation systems are engineering techniques used to minimize the impact of seismic forces on structures during an earthquake. By decoupling a building from ground motion, these systems allow the superstructure to move independently from the foundation, reducing the forces transmitted through the building. This approach is crucial in enhancing the resilience of structures and is often applied in seismic detailing and retrofit strategies to protect life and property.
Shake table tests: Shake table tests are experimental procedures used to simulate seismic ground motion and assess the response of structures or components during earthquakes. These tests provide crucial data on how buildings and bridges behave under realistic seismic conditions, enabling engineers to improve seismic detailing and retrofit strategies for enhancing structural resilience.
Shear Keys: Shear keys are structural components used to transfer shear forces between two elements, such as a bridge deck and its supporting structure. They play a critical role in ensuring stability and integrity during dynamic loading conditions, particularly in seismic events where lateral forces can be significant. By effectively preventing relative movement between parts, shear keys enhance the overall performance and safety of structures in earthquake-prone areas.
Shear reinforcement: Shear reinforcement refers to additional structural elements, usually in the form of stirrups or links, that are incorporated into concrete beams and slabs to help resist shear forces. This reinforcement is essential for ensuring that structures can withstand lateral loads, especially during events like earthquakes, where shear stresses can lead to catastrophic failures. Proper detailing and implementation of shear reinforcement are crucial for enhancing the ductility and overall stability of structural systems.
Shock Transmission Units: Shock transmission units (STUs) are specialized devices used in bridge engineering to manage and reduce the transfer of dynamic loads, particularly during seismic events. These units help to isolate the structure from the impact of shocks, thereby minimizing damage and improving the resilience of the bridge. By absorbing and dissipating energy, STUs play a crucial role in seismic detailing and retrofit strategies aimed at enhancing the performance of bridges during earthquakes.
Strip seal joints: Strip seal joints are flexible expansion joints used in bridge construction to accommodate movement between different components, allowing for thermal expansion, contraction, and other types of movement while preventing water and debris infiltration. These joints typically consist of a rubber or elastomeric strip that is set within a metal frame, ensuring durability and flexibility under various environmental conditions. They are crucial in maintaining the structural integrity of bridges by effectively managing movements caused by temperature changes and traffic loads.
Strong column-weak beam: The strong column-weak beam concept is a design philosophy in structural engineering that ensures that during an extreme event, such as an earthquake, beams are designed to yield and fail before the columns. This approach helps prevent the collapse of the entire structure by allowing controlled failure mechanisms. By ensuring that columns remain intact, it provides a higher level of safety and stability for the overall structure during seismic activities.
Superstructure retrofits: Superstructure retrofits refer to the modifications and upgrades made to the upper structural components of a bridge to enhance its load-carrying capacity, durability, and performance, especially in response to seismic risks. These retrofits are crucial for ensuring that a bridge can withstand seismic events, thereby protecting both the structure and public safety. By improving the superstructure, engineers aim to increase resilience and extend the lifespan of existing bridges.
Supplemental damping devices: Supplemental damping devices are specialized components installed in structures to absorb and dissipate energy during dynamic events, such as earthquakes. They help enhance the overall performance of structures by reducing vibrations and displacements caused by seismic forces, contributing to improved safety and stability.
Time-history analysis: Time-history analysis is a method used to evaluate the dynamic response of structures, such as bridges, when subjected to time-varying loads like earthquakes or wind. This approach captures the behavior of structures over time, allowing engineers to assess how they will respond to different loading scenarios, which is critical in understanding potential failures and designing effective retrofitting strategies.
Transverse movements: Transverse movements refer to the lateral displacements that occur in structures during seismic events, specifically when a structure experiences horizontal forces. Understanding how these movements affect bridge performance is crucial for designing structures that can withstand earthquakes, ensuring safety and functionality. They play a significant role in seismic detailing and retrofit strategies, as engineers must account for these forces when assessing the structural integrity and stability of bridges in seismic-prone areas.
Transverse reinforcement: Transverse reinforcement refers to the additional steel bars or ties used in concrete structures, specifically to provide lateral support to the primary longitudinal reinforcement. This type of reinforcement is crucial in enhancing the overall strength and stability of concrete elements, particularly under shear forces and axial loads. It plays a significant role in ensuring that concrete structures can safely carry applied loads while resisting cracking and buckling.