11.3 Arts-based research
8 min read•august 21, 2024
integrates artistic practices into qualitative research, bridging traditional methods and creative expression in art therapy. It employs various art forms for data collection, analysis, and representation, aligning with art therapy's core principle of using art for healing and self-expression.
This approach challenges conventional notions of valid knowledge, emphasizing creativity and imagination in understanding human experiences. It combines aesthetic and scientific knowledge, recognizing the value of subjective, embodied experiences in generating new insights and enhancing art therapy practice.
Definition of arts-based research
- Integrates artistic practices and creative processes into qualitative research methodologies
- Employs various art forms as tools for data collection, analysis, and representation in academic inquiry
- Bridges the gap between traditional research methods and artistic expression in art therapy contexts
Origins in qualitative inquiry
Top images from around the web for Origins in qualitative inquiry
Frontiers | Arts-Based Research Approaches to Studying Mechanisms of Change in the Creative Arts ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Arts-Based Research Approaches to Studying Mechanisms of Change in the Creative Arts ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Arts-Based Research Approaches to Studying Mechanisms of Change in the Creative Arts ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Arts-Based Research Approaches to Studying Mechanisms of Change in the Creative Arts ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Arts-Based Research Approaches to Studying Mechanisms of Change in the Creative Arts ... View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Origins in qualitative inquiry
Frontiers | Arts-Based Research Approaches to Studying Mechanisms of Change in the Creative Arts ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Arts-Based Research Approaches to Studying Mechanisms of Change in the Creative Arts ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Arts-Based Research Approaches to Studying Mechanisms of Change in the Creative Arts ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Arts-Based Research Approaches to Studying Mechanisms of Change in the Creative Arts ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Arts-Based Research Approaches to Studying Mechanisms of Change in the Creative Arts ... View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Emerged in the 1970s as a response to limitations of positivist research paradigms
- Developed from the need to capture nuanced human experiences not easily quantified
- Influenced by postmodern and constructivist theories emphasizing multiple ways of knowing
- Gained traction in social sciences, education, and health-related fields
Relationship to art therapy
- Aligns with art therapy's core principle of using art for healing and self-expression
- Provides a framework for therapists to systematically study the impact of artistic interventions
- Enhances understanding of clients' experiences through artistic exploration and interpretation
- Supports evidence-based practice in art therapy by generating rich, contextual data
Theoretical foundations
- Draws from diverse philosophical and epistemological perspectives
- Challenges traditional notions of what constitutes valid knowledge in research
- Emphasizes the role of creativity and imagination in understanding human experiences
Aesthetic vs scientific knowledge
- Aesthetic knowledge focuses on sensory, emotional, and intuitive understanding
- Scientific knowledge prioritizes empirical evidence, logical reasoning, and replicability
- Arts-based research seeks to integrate both forms of knowledge for comprehensive insights
- Recognizes the value of subjective, embodied experiences in generating new understandings
- Challenges the dichotomy between art and science in knowledge production
Embodied cognition in research
- Posits that cognitive processes are deeply rooted in the body's interactions with the world
- Emphasizes the role of physical experiences and sensations in shaping thought and understanding
- Aligns with art therapy's focus on non-verbal expression and bodily awareness
- Informs research methods that engage participants' full sensory and kinesthetic experiences
- Supports the use of movement, touch, and spatial awareness in data collection and analysis
Methodological approaches
- Encompasses a wide range of artistic disciplines and creative practices
- Adapts traditional research designs to incorporate artistic elements
- Allows for flexibility and innovation in research processes
Visual arts methods
- Utilizes drawing, painting, sculpture, and photography as research tools
- Includes techniques like photo-elicitation, visual journaling, and collage-making
- Analyzes visual elements (color, composition, symbolism) for deeper insights
- Employs digital art and graphic design for data visualization and representation
Performance-based methods
- Incorporates theater, dance, music, and into research processes
- Uses techniques like ethnodrama, dance/movement inquiry, and music improvisation
- Explores through physical expression and movement
- Engages audiences as active participants in the research dissemination process
Literary arts methods
- Employs poetry, narrative writing, and creative non-fiction in research
- Includes approaches like poetic inquiry, autoethnography, and fictional representation
- Analyzes metaphor, rhythm, and narrative structure for deeper understanding
- Explores the power of language and storytelling in conveying research findings
Data collection techniques
- Expands traditional data collection methods to include artistic creation and interpretation
- Emphasizes the process of art-making as a valuable source of information
- Allows for non-verbal expression of complex emotions and experiences
Artistic creation as data
- Treats the art-making process itself as a form of data generation
- Documents artistic choices, materials used, and time spent on creation
- Analyzes the final artwork as well as sketches, drafts, and revisions
- Incorporates artist statements and reflections on the creative process
Participant-generated artwork
- Engages research participants in creating art related to the research topic
- Uses techniques like visual mapping, body sculpting, and mask-making
- Encourages participants to explain and interpret their own artistic creations
- Allows for collaborative art-making sessions to explore group dynamics
Researcher-created artworks
- Involves researchers producing artworks as a form of data collection and analysis
- Uses artistic creation as a means of reflexivity and exploring researcher positionality
- Includes techniques like visual memos, research-based performances, and data poems
- Explores the intersection of researcher subjectivity and objective data interpretation
Analysis and interpretation
- Combines artistic sensibilities with rigorous analytical approaches
- Emphasizes the importance of context and multiple interpretations
- Involves iterative processes of creation, reflection, and meaning-making
Aesthetic analysis frameworks
- Applies art criticism techniques to analyze visual, performative, and literary data
- Includes formal analysis (elements and principles of design), iconography, and semiotics
- Utilizes frameworks like visual rhetoric and multimodal discourse analysis
- Considers cultural and historical contexts in interpreting artistic expressions
Collaborative meaning-making
- Engages participants, researchers, and sometimes audiences in interpreting data
- Uses techniques like group critiques, dialogic performances, and collaborative writing
- Explores multiple perspectives and negotiates shared understandings
- Acknowledges the role of power dynamics in collaborative interpretation processes
Visual vs verbal data
- Compares and integrates insights from visual artworks and verbal/written responses
- Explores the complementary and contradictory aspects of visual and verbal expression
- Develops strategies for translating visual data into verbal descriptions and vice versa
- Considers the limitations and strengths of both visual and verbal modes of communication
Ethical considerations
- Addresses unique ethical challenges posed by artistic research methods
- Balances the need for creative expression with participant protection
- Considers the impact of artistic representations on individuals and communities
Artistic integrity vs research rigor
- Navigates tensions between artistic freedom and scientific validity
- Develops criteria for evaluating the quality of arts-based research
- Considers the role of artistic skill and training in research processes
- Balances aesthetic appeal with the need for clear communication of findings
Consent and confidentiality
- Addresses issues of anonymity in visual and performative data
- Develops protocols for obtaining informed consent for artistic creations
- Considers ownership and copyright of participant-generated artworks
- Explores ethical ways to represent sensitive or traumatic experiences through art
Cultural sensitivity in art
- Recognizes the cultural significance of various art forms and symbols
- Addresses potential cultural appropriation in artistic research methods
- Considers the impact of researcher's cultural background on interpretation
- Develops culturally responsive approaches to arts-based data collection and analysis
Validity and reliability
- Redefines traditional concepts of validity and reliability for arts-based contexts
- Develops new criteria for assessing the quality and trustworthiness of artistic research
- Addresses skepticism from traditional research communities
Artistic vs scientific criteria
- Compares aesthetic qualities (evocative power, resonance) with scientific standards (replicability, generalizability)
- Develops hybrid criteria that honor both artistic and scientific contributions
- Considers the role of audience response in validating arts-based research
- Explores ways to balance subjective interpretation with rigorous analysis
Trustworthiness in arts-based research
- Adapts concepts like credibility, transferability, and dependability to artistic contexts
- Uses techniques like member checking, peer debriefing, and audit trails
- Emphasizes transparency in artistic decision-making and interpretation processes
- Considers the role of researcher reflexivity in enhancing trustworthiness
Peer review processes
- Develops new models for peer review that include artistic expertise
- Explores interdisciplinary review panels combining artists and researchers
- Considers alternative formats for presenting research for peer review (exhibitions, performances)
- Addresses challenges in evaluating non-traditional research outputs
Dissemination of findings
- Explores innovative ways to share research results beyond traditional academic formats
- Emphasizes the importance of accessibility and engagement with diverse audiences
- Considers the transformative potential of artistic presentations of research
Exhibition as research output
- Utilizes gallery spaces, public installations, and virtual platforms to showcase findings
- Designs interactive exhibitions that engage viewers in the research process
- Considers curatorial choices as part of the analysis and interpretation process
- Explores the impact of spatial arrangement and viewer movement on meaning-making
Integration of art and text
- Develops formats that combine visual, performative, and written elements
- Explores the use of artist books, graphic novels, and illustrated reports
- Considers the balance between artistic expression and academic rigor in presentations
- Addresses challenges in translating artistic insights into traditional academic language
Alternative presentation formats
- Utilizes digital media, podcasts, and interactive websites for research dissemination
- Explores performative presentations like research-based theater and dance
- Considers the use of social media and online platforms to engage wider audiences
- Develops strategies for preserving and archiving non-traditional research outputs
Applications in art therapy
- Explores how arts-based research can enhance art therapy practice and theory
- Considers the unique contributions of art therapists to arts-based research methodologies
- Addresses the integration of research findings into clinical practice
Assessment and diagnosis
- Utilizes arts-based techniques for initial client assessments
- Develops visual and performative tools for diagnostic purposes
- Explores the use of artistic creation in understanding client's mental states
- Considers cultural variations in artistic expression for accurate diagnosis
Treatment planning and evaluation
- Incorporates arts-based research findings into treatment goal setting
- Uses artistic processes to track client progress and evaluate outcomes
- Develops creative approaches to measuring therapeutic change
- Explores the use of client-generated artworks in treatment documentation
Client empowerment through art
- Utilizes arts-based research to enhance client agency and self-expression
- Explores how artistic creation can facilitate personal insights and growth
- Considers the role of art-making in building resilience and coping skills
- Develops strategies for incorporating client voices in research and practice
Challenges and limitations
- Addresses common criticisms and skepticism towards arts-based research
- Explores ways to overcome practical and conceptual obstacles
- Considers the boundaries and limitations of artistic approaches in research
Subjectivity vs objectivity
- Navigates tensions between artistic expression and scientific neutrality
- Develops strategies for acknowledging and utilizing researcher subjectivity
- Explores ways to balance personal interpretation with systematic analysis
- Considers the role of multiple perspectives in enhancing research validity
Generalizability of findings
- Addresses concerns about the applicability of arts-based research to broader contexts
- Explores concepts like transferability and resonance in artistic research
- Develops strategies for identifying patterns and themes across diverse artistic data
- Considers the unique contributions of case studies and in-depth artistic explorations
Resource and skill requirements
- Addresses the need for artistic training and expertise in research teams
- Explores collaborations between artists, researchers, and practitioners
- Considers the financial and material resources required for arts-based projects
- Develops strategies for integrating arts-based methods into existing research programs
Future directions
- Explores emerging trends and potential developments in arts-based research
- Considers the impact of technological advancements on artistic research methods
- Addresses the need for continued development of theoretical and methodological frameworks
Interdisciplinary collaborations
- Explores partnerships between art therapists, artists, and researchers from diverse fields
- Considers the potential for arts-based approaches in STEM research
- Develops models for integrating artistic and scientific methodologies
- Explores the role of arts-based research in addressing complex societal challenges
Technology in arts-based research
- Utilizes virtual and augmented reality in data collection and representation
- Explores the use of artificial intelligence in analyzing artistic data
- Considers the impact of digital art forms on research methodologies
- Develops strategies for preserving and archiving digital arts-based research outputs
Policy implications and advocacy
- Explores how arts-based research can inform policy decisions in healthcare and education
- Considers the role of artistic presentations in advocating for social change
- Develops strategies for communicating research findings to policymakers and stakeholders
- Addresses the need for funding and institutional support for arts-based research initiatives
Key Terms to Review (19)
Aesthetic understanding: Aesthetic understanding refers to the ability to perceive, interpret, and appreciate the beauty and meaning within various forms of artistic expression. This concept encompasses not only the emotional and sensory responses elicited by art but also the cognitive engagement that occurs when analyzing and making sense of artistic works. It plays a crucial role in how individuals relate to and derive significance from the arts, fostering a deeper connection with both the art itself and the cultural context surrounding it.
Artistic representation: Artistic representation refers to the use of artistic methods and forms to depict, interpret, or express ideas, emotions, or experiences. It serves as a bridge between the creator's internal world and the external reality, allowing for personal narratives and cultural expressions to be shared through various artistic mediums such as visual arts, performance, music, and literature.
Arts-based research: Arts-based research is a methodology that integrates artistic practices into the research process, allowing for deeper exploration and understanding of human experiences. This approach emphasizes creativity as a way to communicate findings and engage audiences, making it particularly valuable in fields like social sciences and education where traditional methods may fall short in capturing complex emotions and narratives.
Collage making: Collage making is an artistic process that involves assembling different materials, such as paper, photographs, fabric, and other found objects, onto a surface to create a cohesive visual artwork. This technique allows for self-expression, creativity, and exploration of personal narratives, making it a powerful tool in various therapeutic settings.
Community engagement: Community engagement is the process of building relationships and fostering collaboration between individuals, organizations, and communities to address shared concerns and goals. This concept emphasizes active participation, empowerment, and the integration of diverse voices, making it essential in fields that prioritize social impact and collective well-being.
Creative inquiry: Creative inquiry refers to a process of exploration and understanding that uses artistic practices to investigate complex questions or themes. It blends creative expression with research methodologies, allowing for a deeper engagement with the subject matter, often resulting in new insights and perspectives. This approach values the act of creation as a valid means of generating knowledge, encouraging innovative thinking and problem-solving.
Cultural Sensitivity: Cultural sensitivity refers to the awareness, understanding, and respect for the diverse cultural backgrounds and practices of individuals. It involves recognizing how cultural factors influence people's experiences and responses, which is essential in fostering effective therapeutic relationships and interventions.
Embodied knowledge: Embodied knowledge refers to the understanding and skills that are acquired through physical experience and practice rather than through abstract reasoning. It emphasizes the connection between the body, mind, and environment, showcasing how our lived experiences influence what we know and how we interact with the world around us. This type of knowledge is particularly relevant in arts-based research, where the creative process itself becomes a means of inquiry and understanding.
Healthcare settings: Healthcare settings refer to various environments where health services are delivered to individuals. These can include hospitals, clinics, outpatient care facilities, long-term care facilities, and community health centers. Each type of setting offers unique services and approaches to patient care, influencing how therapeutic interventions, including art therapy, are implemented.
Michael Quinn Patton: Michael Quinn Patton is a prominent figure in the field of evaluation, known for his contributions to qualitative research and the development of utilization-focused evaluation. His work emphasizes the importance of context and stakeholder involvement in evaluation processes, making him a significant influence in arts-based research methodologies.
Narrative inquiry: Narrative inquiry is a qualitative research method that focuses on the stories and experiences of individuals, exploring how they make sense of their lives through narrative. This approach values personal accounts and the meaning individuals derive from their experiences, often leading to a deeper understanding of human behavior and thought processes. By analyzing narratives, researchers can uncover themes, emotions, and cultural contexts that shape the individuals' lived experiences.
Participant consent: Participant consent is the process of obtaining agreement from individuals to take part in a study or research project, ensuring they are fully informed about what their participation involves. This concept is crucial in maintaining ethical standards and protecting the rights and well-being of participants, especially in sensitive fields like arts-based research, where the creative process can evoke personal emotions and experiences.
Patricia Leavy: Patricia Leavy is a prominent scholar and author known for her contributions to the field of arts-based research, which integrates artistic methods into social science research. Her work emphasizes the importance of creativity and narrative in understanding complex human experiences, making her a significant figure in both qualitative research and the arts. Leavy's approach encourages researchers to explore their subjects through various artistic mediums, enhancing the depth and richness of their findings.
Performative research: Performative research is an innovative approach that combines artistic practices with traditional research methodologies to create knowledge through performance. This method emphasizes the act of doing as a way to explore, interpret, and communicate complex ideas and experiences, often involving the audience as active participants in the research process. By engaging in performance, researchers can illuminate personal narratives and social issues in a dynamic and impactful manner.
Photovoice: Photovoice is a participatory research method that empowers individuals to document and express their experiences and perspectives through photography. This approach encourages participants to capture images that reflect their lives, challenges, and environments, enabling them to communicate their stories visually and advocate for social change. By combining visual storytelling with community engagement, photovoice facilitates dialogue and raises awareness about important issues affecting marginalized groups.
Poetry as research: Poetry as research is an innovative approach that utilizes poetic forms and structures to explore and convey knowledge, insights, and experiences in a creative manner. This method allows for a deeper understanding of complex themes, emotions, and social issues, bridging the gap between art and academia through expressive language and personal narratives.
Storytelling: Storytelling is the art of using narratives to convey experiences, emotions, and cultural meanings through various forms, such as spoken words, visual art, or performance. It serves as a powerful tool for individuals and communities to express identity, share wisdom, and foster connections, often incorporating cultural symbolism and personal experiences.
Transformative learning: Transformative learning is a process through which individuals critically examine their beliefs, values, and assumptions, leading to a profound shift in perspective. This process often involves personal experiences and reflection, allowing learners to integrate new insights and create meaning from their experiences. It encourages deep engagement with art and creativity, enabling individuals to make connections between their learning and real-life situations.
Visual ethnography: Visual ethnography is a research method that combines visual media and ethnographic techniques to explore and represent cultural practices, social interactions, and lived experiences. This approach utilizes various visual tools such as photography, video, and art to document and analyze the complexities of human behavior and societal norms in their natural settings.