9.2 Critiques of the museum as a site of colonial power and knowledge production
4 min read•august 13, 2024
Museums have long been sites of colonial power, reinforcing Western cultural dominance and marginalizing non-Western cultures. Postcolonial and decolonial theories critique this, calling for the dismantling of colonial structures and centering of indigenous voices in museum spaces.
and challenge the idea of museums as neutral spaces. These approaches examine how museums construct knowledge, advocating for more reflexive and collaborative practices that address power imbalances and social inequalities in art institutions.
Challenging Museum Neutrality
Postcolonial and Decolonial Critiques
Top images from around the web for Postcolonial and Decolonial Critiques
Kultura i imperijalizam, Edvard V. Said | Hyperborea View original
Is this image relevant?
Orientalismo: O Oriente como invenção do Ocidente – Edward W. Said - Vida Indigital View original
Is this image relevant?
Kultura i imperijalizam, Edvard V. Said | Hyperborea View original
Is this image relevant?
Orientalismo: O Oriente como invenção do Ocidente – Edward W. Said - Vida Indigital View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 2
Top images from around the web for Postcolonial and Decolonial Critiques
Kultura i imperijalizam, Edvard V. Said | Hyperborea View original
Is this image relevant?
Orientalismo: O Oriente como invenção do Ocidente – Edward W. Said - Vida Indigital View original
Is this image relevant?
Kultura i imperijalizam, Edvard V. Said | Hyperborea View original
Is this image relevant?
Orientalismo: O Oriente como invenção do Ocidente – Edward W. Said - Vida Indigital View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 2
- critiques museums as sites of colonial power that reinforce Western cultural and marginalize non-Western cultures
- Theorists such as , , and argue that museums reflect the ideologies and interests of dominant groups rather than being neutral spaces
- For example, the display of African art in ethnographic museums has often presented these objects as primitive or exotic, reinforcing colonial stereotypes
- Decolonial theory calls for the and the dismantling of colonial structures of knowledge production
- Emphasizes the need for museums to center the voices, experiences, and epistemologies of colonized and indigenous peoples
- This may involve repatriating stolen objects, collaborating with source communities, and challenging Western frameworks of art and culture
Critical Museology and Institutional Critique
- Critical museology examines how museums construct and disseminate knowledge, shaped by power relations, institutional politics, and curatorial practices
- Challenges the notion of the museum as an objective, apolitical space
- Advocates for more reflexive, collaborative, and socially engaged approaches to museum work
- For instance, the "" exhibition by Fred Wilson at the Maryland Historical Society in 1992 juxtaposed objects to reveal the museum's complicity in perpetuating racist narratives
- Institutional critique is an artistic and curatorial practice that interrogates the power structures, ideologies, and exclusionary mechanisms of art institutions
- Artists such as and use their work to expose the biases, silences, and complicities of museums in perpetuating social and cultural inequalities
- Fraser's performances often involve adopting the persona of a museum docent or curator to critique the elitism and commercialization of the art world
Marginalized Voices in Museums
Privileging Western Art and Culture
- Museums have historically privileged Western art and culture while relegating non-Western art to the status of ethnographic artifacts or curiosities
- This hierarchical distinction between "fine art" and "primitive art" reflects the colonial ideology of cultural superiority
- Has led to the devaluation and exoticization of indigenous cultural productions
- For example, African masks were often displayed in natural history museums alongside animal specimens, denying their artistic and cultural value
- The display and interpretation of non-Western art in museums has often been shaped by colonial stereotypes and narratives
- Presents colonized peoples as primitive, savage, or inferior
- Reinforces racist and ethnocentric attitudes and denies the agency, diversity, and complexity of indigenous cultures
- "Into the Heart of Africa" exhibit at the Royal Ontario Museum in 1989 was criticized for perpetuating colonial stereotypes of African peoples as savage and uncivilized
Exclusion and Misrepresentation of Indigenous Voices
- The voices and perspectives of colonized and indigenous peoples have often been excluded from the curatorial and interpretive processes of museums
- Leads to the misrepresentation or erasure of indigenous knowledge, histories, and cultural meanings
- Denies indigenous peoples the right to self- and
- Many museums continue to lack indigenous representation on their staff and boards
- Museums have often failed to acknowledge the ongoing impact of colonialism on indigenous communities
- Including the legacy of cultural genocide, forced assimilation, and the destruction of traditional ways of life
- Lack of historical context and critical engagement with present-day realities perpetuates the myth of the museum as a neutral space
- Few exhibitions address issues such as land rights, , or the impact of extractive industries on indigenous territories
Museums and Colonial Hierarchies
Ethical Implications of Colonial Collections
- Museums have often acquired objects through colonial plunder, looting, or unethical means
- Such as the theft of sacred or ceremonial objects from indigenous communities
- Possession and display of these objects raises ethical questions about cultural ownership, , and the ongoing impact of colonial violence
- The 's retention of the Benin Bronzes, looted by British forces in 1897, remains controversial
- The continued display of objects acquired through colonial plunder or unethical means perpetuates the legacy of cultural violence
- Undermines the cultural sovereignty of indigenous peoples
- Museums must grapple with the ethical implications of their collections and develop policies that prioritize the rights of source communities
- Some museums, such as the Pitt Rivers Museum in Oxford, have begun to repatriate objects and work with indigenous communities to determine their future care
Political Implications of Museum Representations
- The representation of colonized and indigenous peoples in museums has political implications for how these communities are perceived and treated in contemporary society
- Stereotypical or dehumanizing representations can reinforce racist attitudes
- Contribute to ongoing forms of discrimination and marginalization
- The "" exhibition of Māori tattoo art at the Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa in 2008 was criticized for exoticizing and commodifying indigenous culture
- The exclusion of indigenous voices from museum narratives and decision-making processes perpetuates colonial hierarchies
- Denies indigenous peoples the right to self-determination and cultural autonomy
- Museums must work to decolonize their practices and create space for indigenous agency, knowledge, and leadership
- The National Museum of the American Indian in Washington, D.C. is one of the few museums governed by indigenous peoples and dedicated to presenting Native American cultures on their own terms
Key Terms to Review (27)
Andrea Fraser: Andrea Fraser is a contemporary American artist known for her work that critiques the museum as a site of colonial power and knowledge production. Through performances, videos, and installations, she interrogates the relationships between art, culture, and the institutions that promote them, often exposing the underlying power dynamics and cultural biases present in these spaces. Her work challenges viewers to reconsider the role of museums and galleries in shaping public perception and knowledge.
British Museum: The British Museum is a world-renowned institution located in London, established in 1753, that houses a vast collection of art and antiquities from various cultures and historical periods. It serves as a significant symbol of colonial power and knowledge production, reflecting the history of British imperialism and its impact on global heritage.
Community engagement: Community engagement is the process of building relationships and partnerships between organizations, such as museums and art institutions, and the communities they serve. It focuses on collaboration, participation, and the inclusion of diverse voices in decision-making and programming. By actively involving community members, institutions can work towards dismantling colonial narratives and creating spaces that reflect the histories, cultures, and needs of the communities they represent.
Critical museology: Critical museology is an approach to the study and practice of museums that emphasizes the examination of power relations, knowledge production, and the impact of colonial histories on museum collections and practices. This perspective seeks to challenge traditional narratives, advocating for the inclusion of marginalized voices and promoting social justice within museum contexts.
Critical race theory: Critical race theory (CRT) is an intellectual movement and framework that examines the relationship between race, law, and power. It challenges the ways in which systemic racism is embedded in legal systems and societal structures, advocating for the understanding that racism is not merely individual prejudice but a systemic issue that impacts many areas of life, including art and culture.
Cultural Appropriation: Cultural appropriation refers to the unacknowledged or inappropriate adoption of the customs, practices, or symbols of one culture by members of another culture, often without permission and typically involving a power imbalance. This concept highlights how dominant cultures exploit marginalized cultures, especially in the context of colonialism and its ongoing effects on art and cultural expression.
Cultural sovereignty: Cultural sovereignty refers to the right and ability of a group, particularly indigenous peoples, to maintain and control their cultural identity, practices, and heritage without external interference. This concept emphasizes the importance of self-determination and the preservation of cultural values in the face of colonialism and globalization, highlighting the need for respect and recognition of diverse cultural expressions.
Decolonization of museums: Decolonization of museums refers to the process of dismantling colonial narratives and practices within museum institutions to create more equitable, inclusive, and representative spaces for cultural heritage. This involves reevaluating collections, repatriating artifacts, and engaging with marginalized communities to acknowledge their voices and histories, aiming for a more just representation in the cultural sector.
Edward Said: Edward Said was a Palestinian-American scholar and literary critic, best known for his influential work on postcolonial theory, particularly through his seminal book 'Orientalism.' His ideas challenge the Western representations of the East and highlight how these portrayals have shaped cultural perceptions and power dynamics.
Epistemic violence: Epistemic violence refers to the harm inflicted on individuals and communities by the systematic erasure or distortion of their knowledge systems, cultural practices, and worldviews. This concept highlights how colonial power structures impose their own narratives while disregarding or undermining the legitimacy of other forms of knowledge, often resulting in the marginalization of indigenous voices and histories.
Ethical stewardship: Ethical stewardship refers to the responsible management and care for cultural heritage, particularly in the context of institutions that hold and display art and artifacts. It emphasizes accountability, respect for cultural communities, and the importance of collaborative decision-making in preserving and interpreting cultural materials. This concept is especially relevant in addressing historical injustices and seeking to rectify the power dynamics inherent in the museum sector.
Gayatri Spivak: Gayatri Spivak is an Indian scholar and critical theorist known for her influential work in postcolonial studies, particularly her essay 'Can the Subaltern Speak?' which interrogates the representation of marginalized voices within colonial and neocolonial frameworks. Her ideas challenge dominant narratives in art and visual culture, emphasizing the importance of listening to those often silenced by history and power structures.
Hans Haacke: Hans Haacke is a contemporary German artist known for his politically charged works that critique institutions and address issues of power, particularly in the context of museums and their roles in society. His art often challenges traditional notions of authorship and representation, emphasizing the relationship between art, politics, and social structures, especially regarding colonial histories and the implications of exhibition practices.
Hegemony: Hegemony refers to the dominance of one group over others, often maintained through cultural, ideological, or economic means rather than direct coercion. This concept is crucial for understanding how power operates in society, especially in colonial contexts where dominant cultures assert their values and beliefs over marginalized groups, shaping perceptions and representations of the 'Other', and influencing art and visual culture.
Homi Bhabha: Homi Bhabha is a prominent postcolonial theorist known for his influential concepts such as hybridity, mimicry, and the 'third space'. His work critiques the ways in which colonial power and knowledge are produced and maintained, especially within institutions like museums that often reinforce colonial narratives and authority. Bhabha's theories highlight the complexities of identity and cultural interaction in postcolonial contexts, emphasizing how colonized subjects negotiate and resist dominant cultural representations.
Indigenous-led exhibitions: Indigenous-led exhibitions are art shows and cultural presentations organized, curated, and created by Indigenous peoples, focusing on their perspectives, narratives, and artistic expressions. These exhibitions challenge traditional museum practices by prioritizing Indigenous voices and reclaiming agency over how their cultures and histories are represented, directly addressing critiques of museums as colonial institutions.
Institutional critique: Institutional critique is an artistic practice that examines and challenges the roles and functions of art institutions, such as museums and galleries, in shaping cultural narratives and power dynamics. This approach highlights how these institutions can perpetuate colonial legacies and influence knowledge production, often favoring dominant narratives while marginalizing others. By critically engaging with the structures of these institutions, artists seek to raise awareness about issues of representation, ownership, and the politics of display.
Knowledge Imperialism: Knowledge imperialism refers to the dominance of certain knowledge systems, particularly Western ways of knowing, over others, often perpetuating colonial power dynamics. This concept highlights how institutions, like museums, have historically produced and controlled knowledge about colonized cultures, reinforcing stereotypes and marginalizing indigenous perspectives.
Mining the Museum: Mining the museum refers to a critical approach that interrogates the narratives, collections, and power dynamics within museums, particularly those that originated in colonial contexts. This concept emphasizes how museums have historically curated knowledge and artifacts in ways that reflect colonial ideologies, often marginalizing indigenous voices and perspectives. By 'mining' the museum, scholars and artists aim to uncover hidden stories and challenge dominant narratives surrounding colonial power and knowledge production.
Museum as site of social justice: The museum as a site of social justice refers to the evolving role of museums in advocating for equity, inclusivity, and the representation of marginalized voices within society. This concept challenges traditional museum practices that often perpetuate colonial narratives and encourages institutions to become active participants in social change by fostering dialogue and collaboration with communities, especially those historically underrepresented.
Postcolonial theory: Postcolonial theory is an intellectual framework that examines the effects and ongoing impacts of colonialism on cultures, societies, and identities after the colonial period. It addresses issues of power dynamics, representation, and the ways in which colonial histories shape contemporary experiences, especially in art and visual culture.
Repatriation: Repatriation refers to the process of returning cultural artifacts, human remains, and other objects of significance to their country or community of origin. This term is closely linked to discussions around the restitution of items taken during colonial times, particularly in relation to the role of museums as sites of power and knowledge production that often perpetuated colonial narratives.
Representation: Representation refers to the way in which ideas, people, and cultures are depicted and portrayed in art, often reflecting societal values, ideologies, and power dynamics. It plays a critical role in shaping perceptions and understanding of different cultures, especially in contexts involving colonialism and imperialism, where the representation can either reinforce stereotypes or challenge them.
Savage beauty: Savage beauty refers to the aesthetic that captures the wild, untamed, and often brutal aspects of nature and culture. It highlights the tension between beauty and chaos, often presenting a rawness that challenges traditional notions of art and beauty. This term connects closely with discussions around power dynamics, representation, and the role of institutions in shaping cultural narratives.
Smithsonian Institution: The Smithsonian Institution is a group of museums and research centers in the United States, founded in 1846, that promotes the increase and diffusion of knowledge. It is often critiqued as a site of colonial power and knowledge production, given its historical role in collecting and exhibiting artifacts from diverse cultures, particularly those from colonized nations, raising questions about ownership, representation, and authority in the display of cultural heritage.
T.J. Demos: T.J. Demos is a prominent art historian and critic known for his work on contemporary art's relationship to colonialism, globalization, and social justice. His writings often critique how cultural institutions, particularly museums, reinforce colonial narratives and power dynamics in knowledge production and exhibition practices.
Voice: In the context of colonial power and knowledge production, 'voice' refers to the expression of perspectives, narratives, and identities that are often marginalized or silenced by dominant cultural institutions. It encompasses who gets to speak, whose stories are told, and the authority behind those narratives. Understanding voice is crucial in analyzing how museums and similar institutions have historically perpetuated colonial ideologies through selective representation and the control of knowledge.