6.3 Plato's concept of justice and the ideal state
3 min read•july 25, 2024
Plato's concept of justice and the ideal state stems from his tripartite division of the soul. He applies this structure to society, creating a class system that mirrors human nature. This approach aims to achieve harmony and balance in both individuals and the state.
In Plato's view, justice emerges when each part of society fulfills its proper function. His ideal state features philosopher-kings as rulers, as defenders, and as the economic foundation. This structure, while influential, faces criticism for its totalitarian aspects and impracticality.
Plato's Concept of Justice and the Ideal State
Plato's tripartite soul division
Top images from around the web for Plato's tripartite soul division
The Concept of Justice in Greek Philosophy (Plato and Aristotle) View original
Is this image relevant?
Chapter 6: Political Theory – Politics, Power, and Purpose: An Orientation to Political Science View original
Is this image relevant?
A Non-Philosopher’s Guide to Plato | Getty Iris View original
Is this image relevant?
The Concept of Justice in Greek Philosophy (Plato and Aristotle) View original
Is this image relevant?
Chapter 6: Political Theory – Politics, Power, and Purpose: An Orientation to Political Science View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Plato's tripartite soul division
The Concept of Justice in Greek Philosophy (Plato and Aristotle) View original
Is this image relevant?
Chapter 6: Political Theory – Politics, Power, and Purpose: An Orientation to Political Science View original
Is this image relevant?
A Non-Philosopher’s Guide to Plato | Getty Iris View original
Is this image relevant?
The Concept of Justice in Greek Philosophy (Plato and Aristotle) View original
Is this image relevant?
Chapter 6: Political Theory – Politics, Power, and Purpose: An Orientation to Political Science View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Tripartite division of the soul reflects human nature and motivations
- Reason (logistikon) governs rational thought and decision-making (frontal lobe)
- Spirit (thumos) drives emotions, honor, and courage (amygdala)
- Appetite (epithumia) encompasses basic desires and physical needs (hypothalamus)
- Corresponding classes in the ideal state mirror soul's structure for societal balance
- (rulers) embody reason, make wise decisions for the state (Supreme Court)
- Auxiliaries (warriors) represent spirit, defend and maintain order (military)
- Producers (workers) reflect appetite, fulfill economic needs (farmers, craftsmen)
- Harmony and balance among parts essential for individual and state well-being
- Principle of ensures each part focuses on its natural strengths
Justice in Plato's ideal state
- Justice defined as "doing one's own work" promotes social harmony and efficiency
- Harmony among classes achieved when each fulfills its proper function without interference
- Individual justice mirrors state justice through alignment of soul parts with societal roles
- Justice viewed as a virtue of the soul fostering inner peace and ethical behavior
- Maintains social order by preventing conflict and promoting cooperation
- Relates to other cardinal virtues:
- Wisdom guides reason (critical thinking)
- Courage empowers spirit (bravery in battle)
- Temperance moderates appetite (self-control in desires)
Structure of Plato's ideal state
- Guardians (Philosopher-Kings) lead with wisdom and knowledge of the Forms
- Extensive education in philosophy and (20+ years of study)
- Make decisions based on understanding of ultimate truth and goodness
- Auxiliaries protect the state through military and law enforcement
- Embody courage and loyalty, defending against external and internal threats
- Trained in physical and mental disciplines (martial arts, strategy)
- Producers form economic foundation through various occupations
- Practice self-control and moderation in pursuit of material goods
- Include diverse professions (farmers, artisans, merchants)
- Education system tailored to each class's role and potential
- Communal living for guardians and auxiliaries eliminates private property
- Censorship and control of arts and literature shape societal values
Criticisms of Plato's ideal state
- Totalitarian aspects limit individual freedom and self-expression
- Elimination of family structure for guardians disrupts natural social bonds
- Rigid class system restricts social mobility and personal growth
- Impracticality of implementation in real-world societies
- Neglect of personal happiness in favor of collective good
- Potential for corruption among guardians despite philosophical training
- Limited role of women contradicts modern gender equality principles
- Suppression of artistic expression stifles creativity and cultural development
Plato's justice vs contemporary justice
- Plato's justice emphasizes harmony, natural hierarchy, and collective good
- Contemporary justice focuses on individual rights, legal equality, and democratic participation
- Similarities include concern for social stability and importance of education
- Differences arise in:
- Meritocracy vs equality of opportunity (selective advancement vs equal access)
- Approach to diversity and pluralism (uniformity vs multicultural acceptance)
- Concept of human rights (collective vs individual protections)
- Plato's ideas remain relevant in debates on meritocracy and role of expertise in governance
- Modern critiques highlight need for individual freedoms and democratic accountability
Key Terms to Review (18)
Aristocracy: Aristocracy is a form of government in which power is held by the nobility or a privileged class, often justified by notions of hereditary privilege and perceived superiority in virtue or wisdom. This system connects closely to the ideas of virtue, governance, and social structure as it emphasizes rule by the few who are considered the most qualified.
Aristotle: Aristotle was a Greek philosopher and polymath whose work laid the foundations for much of Western philosophy and science. He is known for his extensive writings on various subjects, including politics, ethics, metaphysics, and natural sciences, which have significantly influenced political thought and practice throughout history.
Auxiliaries: Auxiliaries refer to a specific class of guardians in Plato's ideal state, primarily tasked with enforcing the laws and protecting the city. They serve as a bridge between the ruling class, known as the philosopher-kings, and the general populace, ensuring that justice is maintained and order is upheld in society.
Critique of Plato's Ideal State by Aristotle: The critique of Plato's ideal state by Aristotle refers to Aristotle's comprehensive evaluation and rejection of Plato's vision of a perfect society as presented in 'The Republic'. Aristotle believed that Plato's model, which emphasized the rule of philosopher-kings and the communal ownership of property, was impractical and failed to account for the complexities of human nature and political life. Instead, Aristotle proposed a more realistic approach to governance that recognized the importance of balance, moderation, and the role of the middle class.
Dialectic: Dialectic refers to a method of argumentation and dialogue that seeks to uncover the truth through the exchange of opposing ideas and viewpoints. This process emphasizes critical questioning and reasoning, facilitating the development of deeper understanding and knowledge by resolving contradictions.
Eudaimonia: Eudaimonia is a Greek term often translated as 'happiness' or 'flourishing', representing the highest human good and the ultimate goal of human life. It encompasses living in accordance with virtue and realizing one's potential, connecting deeply to concepts of justice, moral excellence, and the well-being of the individual and the community.
Guardians: In Plato's philosophy, guardians are the ruling class of the ideal state, responsible for making decisions that ensure justice and the welfare of the community. They are envisioned as philosopher-kings, possessing both wisdom and virtue, which allows them to govern justly and maintain order in society. Their role is crucial in achieving Plato's concept of justice, where harmony among the classes leads to a well-functioning state.
Justice as harmony: Justice as harmony refers to the idea that justice is achieved when all parts of society work together in a balanced and harmonious way, reflecting the proper order of relationships among individuals and classes. This concept emphasizes that justice is not merely about legalistic or punitive measures but about fostering a sense of community and cooperation where everyone fulfills their roles effectively for the greater good.
Kallipolis: Kallipolis refers to Plato's vision of an ideal city-state, which embodies his conception of justice and the harmonious organization of society. This city is structured around the principles of philosophical governance, where the philosopher-kings rule with wisdom and knowledge, ensuring that every citizen fulfills their role for the common good. Kallipolis is central to understanding Plato's ideas about justice, virtue, and the moral responsibilities of rulers and citizens alike.
Philosopher-king: The philosopher-king is a concept introduced by Plato, describing an ideal ruler who possesses both philosophical wisdom and the ability to govern justly. This figure is seen as the epitome of virtue and knowledge, combining intellect with moral integrity to create a just society.
Platonic realism: Platonic realism is a philosophical viewpoint that asserts the existence of abstract objects, or forms, that are independent of human thought and perception. It suggests that these forms represent the highest level of reality and knowledge, serving as the true essence of things in the material world. This perspective is crucial to understanding Plato's metaphysics and epistemology, where the world of forms is considered more real than the physical world we experience. Furthermore, platonic realism influences Plato's concept of justice and the ideal state, as these forms provide the foundation for understanding moral values and the structure of an ideal society.
Producers: In the context of political thought, producers refer to the class of individuals who engage in economic activities that create goods and services. They play a crucial role in maintaining the ideal state by providing the necessary resources for society, allowing for the flourishing of other classes such as guardians and auxiliaries.
Socrates: Socrates was an ancient Greek philosopher credited as one of the founders of Western philosophy, known for his contributions to ethics and epistemology. His method of inquiry and dialogue laid the groundwork for future philosophical thought, particularly regarding the nature of knowledge and virtue.
Specialization: Specialization refers to the process by which individuals or groups focus on a specific task, role, or skill set, allowing them to become experts in that area. In the context of governance and society, specialization leads to a more efficient and organized structure, where individuals contribute their unique skills for the greater good of the community, ensuring that each part of the society functions optimally within a well-defined system.
Theory of forms: The theory of forms, proposed by Plato, is the philosophical idea that non-material abstract forms or ideas represent the most accurate reality. It distinguishes between the physical world, which is impermanent and flawed, and the world of forms, which is eternal and unchanging, providing a foundation for understanding concepts like justice, beauty, and equality in relation to the ideal state.
Totalitarianism: Totalitarianism is a political system where the state seeks to control every aspect of public and private life, often through oppressive means and ideological enforcement. In this system, individual freedoms are suppressed, and dissent is not tolerated, allowing the government to maintain an absolute grip on power. This concept connects deeply with various ideas of governance, such as the ideal state and justice, as it raises questions about the balance between order and freedom in society.
Tripartite soul: The tripartite soul is a concept introduced by Plato, describing the soul as divided into three distinct parts: the rational, the spirited, and the appetitive. Each part corresponds to different aspects of human behavior and motivation, with the rational part seeking truth and wisdom, the spirited part associated with courage and honor, and the appetitive part representing desires and pleasures. This framework is crucial in understanding Plato's views on justice and how a well-ordered soul leads to a just society.
Tyranny: Tyranny is a form of government where a single ruler wields absolute power, often unjustly and oppressively, without regard for the welfare of the populace. This concept is closely linked to discussions about political power dynamics and the structure of governance in ancient Greek thought, where tyranny often emerged as a reaction against oligarchies or democracies that failed to address the needs of citizens.