4.4 Transition from laminar to turbulent flow

The transition from laminar to turbulent flow is a crucial concept in aerodynamics. This phenomenon occurs when fluid motion shifts from smooth, orderly patterns to chaotic, irregular behavior, significantly impacting drag, heat transfer, and noise generation in various applications.

Understanding transition is essential for optimizing aircraft wings, turbomachinery, and pipe flows. Factors like Reynolds number, surface roughness, and pressure gradients influence when and how transition occurs, affecting system performance and efficiency in aerospace and engineering applications.

Laminar flow characteristics

• Laminar flow is a type of fluid motion characterized by smooth, orderly flow patterns with minimal mixing between layers
• This flow regime is typically observed at low Reynolds numbers, where viscous forces dominate over inertial forces
• In laminar flow, the fluid moves in parallel layers or streamlines, with no disruption between the layers

Low Reynolds numbers

Top images from around the web for Low Reynolds numbers

• 

  Fluid Dynamics – University Physics Volume 1 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  WES - Laminar-turbulent transition characteristics of a 3-D wind turbine rotor blade based on ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Fluid Dynamics – TikZ.net View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Fluid Dynamics – University Physics Volume 1 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  WES - Laminar-turbulent transition characteristics of a 3-D wind turbine rotor blade based on ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Low Reynolds numbers

• 

  Fluid Dynamics – University Physics Volume 1 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  WES - Laminar-turbulent transition characteristics of a 3-D wind turbine rotor blade based on ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Fluid Dynamics – TikZ.net View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Fluid Dynamics – University Physics Volume 1 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  WES - Laminar-turbulent transition characteristics of a 3-D wind turbine rotor blade based on ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• The Reynolds number ($Re$) is a dimensionless parameter that represents the ratio of inertial forces to viscous forces in a fluid
• Low Reynolds numbers ($Re < 2300$ for pipe flow) indicate that viscous forces are dominant, promoting laminar flow
• At low $Re$, the fluid's viscosity is sufficient to damp out any disturbances, maintaining smooth and orderly flow patterns

Smooth, parallel streamlines

• In laminar flow, the fluid particles travel in smooth, parallel paths called streamlines
• These streamlines do not cross or intersect, indicating that there is no mixing between adjacent fluid layers
• The velocity profile in laminar flow is typically parabolic, with the highest velocity at the center and zero velocity at the walls (no-slip condition)

Minimal mixing between layers

• Laminar flow exhibits minimal mixing between fluid layers due to the absence of turbulent eddies and vortices
• The lack of mixing results in poor heat and mass transfer characteristics compared to turbulent flow
• This limited mixing also leads to lower skin friction drag in laminar flow, as there is less momentum exchange between the fluid and the surface

Turbulent flow characteristics

• Turbulent flow is a flow regime characterized by chaotic, irregular motion with enhanced mixing and momentum transfer between fluid layers
• This type of flow is commonly observed at high Reynolds numbers, where inertial forces dominate over viscous forces
• Turbulent flow is characterized by the presence of eddies, vortices, and rapid fluctuations in velocity and pressure

High Reynolds numbers

• High Reynolds numbers ($Re > 4000$ for pipe flow) indicate that inertial forces are dominant over viscous forces, promoting turbulent flow
• At high $Re$, the fluid's inertia is sufficient to overcome the damping effects of viscosity, allowing disturbances to grow and propagate
• The transition from laminar to turbulent flow occurs at a critical Reynolds number, which depends on the specific flow geometry and conditions

Chaotic, irregular motion

• Turbulent flow exhibits chaotic and irregular motion, with fluid particles following complex, unpredictable paths
• The flow is characterized by the presence of eddies and vortices of various sizes, ranging from large-scale structures to small-scale turbulent fluctuations
• The velocity and pressure fields in turbulent flow are highly unsteady and vary rapidly in both space and time

Enhanced mixing and momentum transfer

• Turbulent flow promotes enhanced mixing and momentum transfer between fluid layers due to the presence of eddies and vortices
• The increased mixing leads to improved heat and mass transfer characteristics compared to laminar flow
• The enhanced momentum transfer also results in higher skin friction drag in turbulent flow, as there is greater interaction between the fluid and the surface

Transition process

• The transition from laminar to turbulent flow is a complex process that occurs when the Reynolds number exceeds a critical value
• The transition process involves the growth and interaction of flow instabilities, leading to the breakdown of laminar flow and the onset of turbulence
• Understanding the transition process is crucial for predicting and controlling the behavior of fluid flows in various applications

Critical Reynolds number

• The critical Reynolds number ($Re_{cr}$) is the value at which the transition from laminar to turbulent flow occurs
• The critical Reynolds number depends on the specific flow geometry, surface roughness, and other factors affecting the stability of the flow
• For pipe flow, the critical Reynolds number is approximately 2300, while for flow over a flat plate, it is around 500,000

Instability growth

• The transition process begins with the growth of small disturbances or instabilities in the laminar flow
• These instabilities can be triggered by various factors, such as surface roughness, freestream turbulence, or pressure gradients
• As the instabilities grow, they interact with each other and the mean flow, leading to the formation of turbulent spots and the breakdown of laminar flow

Nonlinear interactions

• The transition process involves complex nonlinear interactions between the growing instabilities and the mean flow
• These nonlinear interactions can lead to the formation of coherent structures, such as hairpin vortices and streamwise streaks
• The nonlinear stage of transition is characterized by the rapid growth and merging of turbulent spots, eventually leading to fully developed turbulent flow

Factors affecting transition

• Several factors can influence the transition from laminar to turbulent flow, affecting the critical Reynolds number and the overall transition process
• Understanding these factors is essential for predicting and controlling the onset of turbulence in various applications
• The main factors affecting transition include surface roughness, pressure gradient, freestream turbulence, and heat transfer

Surface roughness

• Surface roughness can promote the transition from laminar to turbulent flow by introducing disturbances into the boundary layer
• Roughness elements on a surface can act as tripping devices, causing the flow to transition at lower Reynolds numbers compared to smooth surfaces
• The effect of surface roughness on transition depends on the size, shape, and distribution of the roughness elements relative to the boundary layer thickness

Pressure gradient

• The pressure gradient along the flow direction can significantly influence the transition process
• A favorable pressure gradient (decreasing pressure in the flow direction) tends to stabilize the laminar boundary layer, delaying the onset of transition
• An adverse pressure gradient (increasing pressure in the flow direction) destabilizes the boundary layer, promoting earlier transition to turbulence

Freestream turbulence

• Freestream turbulence refers to the level of turbulence in the flow outside the boundary layer
• Higher levels of freestream turbulence can promote earlier transition by introducing disturbances into the boundary layer
• The effect of freestream turbulence on transition depends on the intensity and length scales of the turbulent fluctuations relative to the boundary layer thickness

Heat transfer

• Heat transfer between the fluid and the surface can affect the transition process by altering the stability of the boundary layer
• Cooling the surface tends to stabilize the laminar boundary layer, delaying the onset of transition
• Heating the surface destabilizes the boundary layer, promoting earlier transition to turbulence
• The effect of heat transfer on transition depends on the magnitude and distribution of the temperature gradient along the surface

Boundary layer theory

• Boundary layer theory is a fundamental concept in fluid dynamics that describes the behavior of fluid flow near a solid surface
• The boundary layer is a thin region near the surface where viscous effects are significant, and the velocity varies from zero at the surface to the freestream value
• Understanding the characteristics of laminar and turbulent boundary layers is essential for predicting and controlling the behavior of fluid flows in various applications

Laminar boundary layer equations

• The laminar boundary layer is governed by the Prandtl boundary layer equations, which are a simplified form of the Navier-Stokes equations
• These equations describe the conservation of mass and momentum within the boundary layer, assuming a thin layer and negligible pressure gradient
• The laminar boundary layer equations can be solved analytically for simple geometries, such as flow over a flat plate, to obtain the velocity and shear stress profiles

Turbulent boundary layer equations

• The turbulent boundary layer is more complex than the laminar boundary layer due to the presence of chaotic, irregular motion and enhanced mixing
• The Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) equations are commonly used to describe the mean flow properties in a turbulent boundary layer
• The RANS equations introduce additional terms, such as the Reynolds stresses, which represent the effects of turbulent fluctuations on the mean flow
• Closure models, such as the k-ε or k-ω models, are used to solve the RANS equations by providing expressions for the turbulent stresses

Boundary layer thickness

• The boundary layer thickness ($δ$) is a measure of the distance from the surface where the flow velocity reaches 99% of the freestream value
• The boundary layer thickness increases with distance from the leading edge of the surface, as the viscous effects diffuse further into the flow
• In laminar flow, the boundary layer thickness grows proportionally to the square root of the distance from the leading edge ($δ ∝ x^{1/2}$)
• In turbulent flow, the boundary layer thickness grows more rapidly, proportionally to the distance to the power of 4/5 ($δ ∝ x^{4/5}$)

Transition prediction methods

• Predicting the transition from laminar to turbulent flow is crucial for designing and optimizing various engineering systems, such as aircraft wings, turbomachinery blades, and heat exchangers
• Several methods have been developed to predict the onset and location of transition, ranging from empirical correlations to advanced numerical simulations
• The choice of transition prediction method depends on the complexity of the flow, the available computational resources, and the desired level of accuracy

Empirical correlations

• Empirical correlations are simple, data-driven models that relate the transition location to the flow parameters, such as the Reynolds number and pressure gradient
• These correlations are based on experimental data and provide quick estimates of the transition location for simple geometries and flow conditions
• Examples of empirical correlations include the Michel criterion for flow over a flat plate and the Abu-Ghannam and Shaw correlation for flow with pressure gradients

Stability analysis

• Stability analysis is a more advanced approach to transition prediction that involves studying the growth of small disturbances in the laminar flow
• Linear stability theory (LST) is used to determine the stability characteristics of the flow by solving the Orr-Sommerfeld equation for the disturbance growth rates
• The eN method, based on LST, predicts transition when the amplification factor of the most unstable disturbance reaches a critical value (usually N = 9)
• Nonlinear stability analysis, such as the parabolized stability equations (PSE), can capture the nonlinear interactions between disturbances and provide more accurate transition predictions

Numerical simulations

• Numerical simulations, such as direct numerical simulation (DNS) and large eddy simulation (LES), can provide detailed information about the transition process by directly solving the Navier-Stokes equations
• DNS resolves all the relevant scales of motion, from the largest eddies to the smallest dissipative scales, providing a complete description of the transition process
• LES resolves the large-scale motions and models the effects of the smaller scales, offering a balance between accuracy and computational cost
• Numerical simulations are computationally expensive but can provide valuable insights into the complex physics of transition, especially for flows with complex geometries or multiple influencing factors

Transition control techniques

• Transition control techniques are used to delay or promote the transition from laminar to turbulent flow, depending on the specific application and desired outcome
• Delaying transition can lead to reduced drag, improved fuel efficiency, and enhanced heat transfer, while promoting transition can increase mixing and reduce flow separation
• Transition control techniques can be broadly classified into three categories: surface modifications, active flow control, and passive flow control

Surface modifications

• Surface modifications involve altering the surface geometry or properties to influence the transition process
• Riblets, which are small, streamwise grooves on the surface, can delay transition by reducing the near-wall turbulence and momentum transfer
• Superhydrophobic surfaces, which exhibit very high contact angles with water, can delay transition by reducing the surface friction and promoting slip at the wall
• Surface heating or cooling can also be used to control transition by altering the stability of the boundary layer

Active flow control

• Active flow control involves the use of external energy input to manipulate the flow and control the transition process
• Boundary layer suction, which involves removing a portion of the low-momentum fluid near the wall, can delay transition by stabilizing the boundary layer
• Boundary layer blowing, which involves injecting high-momentum fluid near the wall, can promote transition and increase mixing
• Plasma actuators, which use electrical discharges to generate a body force in the fluid, can be used to delay or promote transition by altering the near-wall flow

Passive flow control

• Passive flow control techniques manipulate the flow without the need for external energy input
• Vortex generators, which are small, vane-like devices placed on the surface, can delay transition by introducing streamwise vortices that enhance mixing and momentum transfer
• Turbulators, which are small, roughness elements placed on the surface, can promote transition and increase heat transfer in heat exchanger applications
• Passive porous surfaces, which allow for transpiration of fluid through the surface, can delay transition by reducing the near-wall turbulence and stabilizing the boundary layer

Consequences of transition

• The transition from laminar to turbulent flow has significant consequences for the behavior and performance of fluid systems
• Understanding the effects of transition on drag, heat transfer, and noise generation is crucial for designing and optimizing various engineering applications
• The consequences of transition can be both beneficial and detrimental, depending on the specific application and desired outcome

Drag increase

• Transition from laminar to turbulent flow leads to a significant increase in skin friction drag due to the enhanced momentum transfer between the fluid and the surface
• The turbulent boundary layer exhibits a higher velocity gradient near the wall, resulting in increased shear stress and drag force
• The increase in drag can have negative impacts on the performance of aircraft, ships, and other vehicles, leading to reduced fuel efficiency and increased operating costs

Heat transfer enhancement

• Transition to turbulent flow enhances heat transfer between the fluid and the surface due to the increased mixing and turbulent transport of thermal energy
• The turbulent boundary layer exhibits higher levels of heat transfer compared to the laminar boundary layer, as the chaotic motion of fluid particles promotes rapid exchange of thermal energy
• Enhanced heat transfer can be beneficial in applications such as heat exchangers, where efficient heat removal is desired, but it can also lead to increased cooling requirements in other cases

Noise generation

• Transition to turbulent flow can lead to increased noise generation due to the chaotic, unsteady motion of fluid particles and the presence of turbulent eddies
• Turbulent boundary layers exhibit higher levels of pressure fluctuations compared to laminar boundary layers, resulting in increased aerodynamic noise
• The noise generated by turbulent flow can be a significant issue in applications such as aircraft, wind turbines, and automotive vehicles, leading to passenger discomfort and environmental concerns

Transition in various applications

• The transition from laminar to turbulent flow is a critical phenomenon in various engineering applications, ranging from aerospace to energy systems
• Understanding the transition process and its effects on the flow behavior is essential for designing and optimizing these systems
• Some common applications where transition plays a crucial role include aircraft wings, turbomachinery blades, pipe flows, and atmospheric boundary layers

Aircraft wings

• Transition on aircraft wings can have significant impacts on the aerodynamic performance, fuel efficiency, and stall characteristics
• Laminar flow over wings is desirable for reducing drag and improving fuel efficiency, but maintaining laminar flow can be challenging due to various factors such as surface roughness and pressure gradients
• Laminar flow control techniques, such as suction or shaping the wing profile, can be used to delay transition and extend the laminar flow region
• Predicting and controlling transition on aircraft wings is crucial for designing high-performance, fuel-efficient aircraft

Turbomachinery blades

• Transition on turbomachinery blades, such as those found in compressors and turbines, can significantly affect the efficiency and performance of the system
• Laminar flow over turbomachinery blades is desirable for reducing losses and improving efficiency, but the high-speed, high-pressure environment can promote early transition
• Boundary layer control techniques, such as blowing or suction, can be used to delay transition and maintain laminar flow over the blades
• Predicting and controlling transition on turbomachinery blades is essential for designing efficient, high-performance turbomachinery systems

Pipe flows

• Transition in pipe flows is important for understanding the pressure drop, heat transfer, and mixing characteristics of the flow
• Laminar flow in pipes is characterized by a parabolic velocity profile and low pressure drop, while turbulent flow exhibits a flatter velocity profile and higher pressure drop
• The critical Reynolds number for transition in pipe flows is around 2300, but this value can be affected by factors such as surface roughness and entrance conditions
• Predicting and controlling transition in pipe flows is crucial for designing efficient piping systems and heat exchangers

Atmospheric boundary layer

• Transition in the atmospheric boundary layer, which is the lowest part of the atmosphere directly influenced by the Earth's surface, plays a crucial role in weather and climate patterns
• The atmospheric boundary layer can exhibit both laminar and turbulent flow, depending on the wind speed, surface roughness, and thermal stratification
• Transition in the atmospheric boundary layer affects the exchange of heat, moisture, and pollutants between the surface and the atmosphere
• Predicting and understanding transition in the atmospheric boundary layer is essential for accurate weather forecasting, air quality modeling, and wind energy applications

Experimental techniques

• Experimental techniques play a crucial role in studying the transition from laminar to turbulent flow and validating theoretical and numerical models
• Various experimental methods have been developed to measure the velocity, pressure, and temperature fields in transitional and turbulent flows
• Some common experimental techniques used in transition research include hot-wire anemometry, particle image velocimetry, and flow visualization

Hot-wire anemometry

• Hot-wire anemometry is a widely used technique for measuring the velocity and turbulence characteristics of fluid flows
• A hot-wire probe consists of a thin wire heated by an electric current, which is exposed to the fluid flow
• As the fluid passes over the wire, it cools the wire, and the change in wire resistance is related to the fluid velocity
• Hot-wire anemometry offers high temporal resolution and can measure velocity fluctuations up to several hundred kilohertz, making it suitable for studying