9.1 Energy consumption in additive manufacturing
10 min read•august 21, 2024
Additive manufacturing processes consume significant energy, impacting costs and environmental footprints. Understanding energy sources, efficiency, and consumption patterns is crucial for optimizing AM technologies and applications across industries.
Energy considerations in AM span electrical power requirements, heat generation systems, and renewable energy integration. Improving efficiency involves analyzing technology-specific energy use, implementing monitoring systems, and developing innovative energy-saving strategies throughout the AM workflow.
Energy sources for AM
- Additive Manufacturing (AM) processes rely on various energy sources to power the complex operations involved in 3D printing
- Understanding energy sources forms a crucial foundation for optimizing efficiency and sustainability in AM technologies
- Energy considerations impact the overall cost, environmental footprint, and feasibility of AM applications across industries
Electrical power requirements
Top images from around the web for Electrical power requirements
Frontiers | 3D Printing of Metal/Metal Oxide Incorporated Thermoplastic Nanocomposites With ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Use of Biomaterials for 3D Printing by Fused Deposition Modeling Technique: A Review View original
Is this image relevant?
Single step additive manufacturing (3D printing) of electrocatalytic anodes and cathodes for ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | 3D Printing of Metal/Metal Oxide Incorporated Thermoplastic Nanocomposites With ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Use of Biomaterials for 3D Printing by Fused Deposition Modeling Technique: A Review View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Electrical power requirements
Frontiers | 3D Printing of Metal/Metal Oxide Incorporated Thermoplastic Nanocomposites With ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Use of Biomaterials for 3D Printing by Fused Deposition Modeling Technique: A Review View original
Is this image relevant?
Single step additive manufacturing (3D printing) of electrocatalytic anodes and cathodes for ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | 3D Printing of Metal/Metal Oxide Incorporated Thermoplastic Nanocomposites With ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Use of Biomaterials for 3D Printing by Fused Deposition Modeling Technique: A Review View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- AM machines typically require high-voltage electrical connections to power laser systems, motors, and control electronics
- varies widely based on machine size, technology type, and production volume
- Large industrial AM systems may demand 3-phase power supplies with ratings exceeding 20 kW
- Smaller desktop 3D printers often operate on standard 110V or 220V single-phase power, consuming 200-500W during operation
Heat generation systems
- Many AM processes involve precise temperature control for material melting, sintering, or curing
- Resistive heating elements generate thermal energy for polymer extrusion in (FDM)
- Electron beams or high-powered lasers provide localized heating in metal powder bed fusion processes
- Infrared lamps or heated build chambers maintain consistent temperatures in Stereolithography (SLA) and other resin-based technologies
Renewable energy integration
- AM facilities increasingly adopt solar, wind, and other renewable energy sources to reduce
- On-site renewable generation can help offset high energy demands of industrial AM operations
- Energy storage systems (lithium-ion batteries) enable smoother integration of intermittent renewable sources
- Green energy certifications and power purchase agreements allow AM companies to support renewable energy development
Energy efficiency in AM processes
- in AM directly impacts production costs, environmental sustainability, and overall process viability
- Improving energy efficiency requires a deep understanding of how different AM technologies utilize energy throughout the build process
- Ongoing research and development in AM focus on enhancing energy efficiency to make the technology more competitive with traditional manufacturing methods
Material extrusion vs powder bed
- Material extrusion processes (FDM) generally consume less energy than powder bed technologies
- FDM primarily uses energy for material heating and extrusion, with minimal waste heat generation
- Powder bed fusion requires significant energy input for laser or electron beam systems and powder preheating
- (SLS) of polymers typically consumes 1-2 orders of magnitude more energy than FDM for comparable part volumes
Energy consumption by technology
- Direct Metal Laser Sintering (DMLS) ranks among the highest energy consumers in AM, often exceeding 1000 kWh per kg of material processed
- Stereolithography (SLA) demonstrates moderate energy efficiency, with consumption ranging from 20-60 kWh per kg of resin cured
- Binder Jetting technologies offer relatively low energy consumption, often below 10 kWh per kg of material processed
- Emerging technologies like (HSS) aim to reduce energy consumption through innovative heating methods
Optimizing energy use
- Layer thickness optimization balances build speed with energy consumption in layer-based AM processes
- Build orientation and part nesting strategies maximize machine utilization and energy efficiency
- Implementing machine learning algorithms for process parameter tuning can lead to significant energy savings
- Regular maintenance and calibration of AM systems ensure optimal energy performance over time
Environmental impact of energy use
- Energy consumption in AM directly contributes to the technology's overall environmental footprint
- Assessing and mitigating the environmental impact of AM energy use plays a crucial role in sustainable manufacturing practices
- Comprehensive analysis of energy-related environmental factors informs decision-making for technology selection and
Carbon footprint analysis
- (LCA) methodologies quantify CO2 emissions associated with AM energy consumption
- Direct emissions from on-site energy use account for a significant portion of AM's carbon footprint
- Indirect emissions from electricity generation vary based on local grid mix and renewable energy adoption
- Carbon footprint comparisons between AM and traditional manufacturing must consider production volumes, part complexity, and material utilization
Lifecycle energy assessment
- Cradle-to-grave energy analysis encompasses raw material extraction, processing, AM production, use phase, and end-of-life scenarios
- Embodied energy in AM feedstock materials contributes significantly to overall lifecycle energy consumption
- Energy savings during the use phase (lightweight parts, optimized geometries) can offset higher production energy in some applications
- End-of-life energy considerations include recycling potential, ease of disassembly, and material recovery efficiency
Sustainability considerations
- Energy-efficient AM processes contribute to reduced resource consumption and waste generation
- Localized production enabled by AM can decrease transportation-related energy use and emissions
- On-demand manufacturing minimizes energy waste associated with overproduction and inventory storage
- Integration of AM in circular economy models promotes energy conservation through part repair, remanufacturing, and upcycling
Energy monitoring and management
- Effective energy monitoring and management strategies are essential for optimizing AM processes and reducing operational costs
- Advanced data collection and analysis techniques provide insights into energy consumption patterns and opportunities for improvement
- Implementing robust energy management systems aligns AM operations with broader sustainability goals and regulatory requirements
Real-time energy tracking
- Smart power meters and energy monitoring systems provide granular data on machine-level energy consumption
- Real-time visualization of energy use helps operators identify inefficiencies and anomalies during production
- Integration of energy data with Manufacturing Execution Systems (MES) enables comprehensive process monitoring
- Machine learning algorithms detect patterns in energy consumption data to predict maintenance needs and optimize scheduling
Energy consumption metrics
- (SEC) measures energy use per unit of material processed or part produced
- (EUR) quantifies the proportion of input energy effectively used in the AM process
- correlate energy efficiency with machine productivity
- assess heat transfer effectiveness in powder bed and material extrusion processes
Predictive energy modeling
- Physics-based models simulate energy flow and thermal behavior in AM processes
- Machine learning approaches leverage historical data to forecast energy consumption for new part designs
- enables virtual optimization of energy use before physical production
- Sensitivity analysis identifies key process parameters influencing energy consumption for targeted improvements
Energy-saving strategies
- Implementing effective energy-saving strategies in AM processes can significantly reduce operational costs and environmental impact
- Continuous improvement in energy efficiency drives innovation in machine design, process control, and material development
- Holistic approaches to energy conservation consider the entire AM workflow, from design to post-processing
Process parameter optimization
- Layer thickness adjustments balance build speed with energy consumption in layer-based processes
- Laser power and scan speed optimization in powder bed fusion minimizes energy waste while maintaining part quality
- Extrusion temperature and flow rate tuning in FDM processes reduces unnecessary material heating
- Build chamber temperature ramping strategies minimize energy use during warm-up and cool-down phases
Machine design improvements
- Insulated build chambers reduce heat loss and improve overall thermal efficiency
- Energy-efficient laser sources (fiber lasers) enhance optical-to-thermal energy conversion in metal AM
- Regenerative braking systems in powder recoating mechanisms recover kinetic energy
- Modular machine designs allow for selective activation of subsystems, reducing standby power consumption
Thermal management techniques
- Selective heating strategies target energy input to specific regions of the build volume
- Heat recuperation systems capture and reuse waste heat from exhaust gases and cooling systems
- Phase change materials in build plate designs provide passive thermal regulation
- Advanced cooling systems optimize energy use in high-power laser and electron beam processes
Energy consumption by material type
- Different materials used in AM processes exhibit varying energy requirements for processing and post-treatment
- Understanding material-specific energy consumption patterns informs material selection and process optimization
- Ongoing research in novel materials aims to reduce energy intensity while maintaining or improving part performance
Polymers vs metals
- Thermoplastic polymers generally require less energy for processing compared to due to lower melting temperatures
- Metal AM processes consume significantly more energy due to high melting points and the need for inert atmospheres
- Polymer powder bed fusion (SLS) typically requires 50-200 kWh/kg, while metal powder bed fusion can exceed 1000 kWh/kg
- Amorphous polymers often demonstrate lower energy consumption than semi-crystalline materials due to reduced phase change energy
Composites and ceramics
- Fiber-reinforced composites in AM often require additional energy for fiber impregnation or in-situ curing
- Ceramic AM processes like binder jetting consume relatively low energy during printing but may require energy-intensive sintering
- Carbon fiber-reinforced polymers can increase energy consumption by 20-50% compared to unreinforced materials in FDM processes
- Ceramic slurry-based processes (DLP, SLA) demonstrate moderate energy efficiency, typically ranging from 30-80 kWh/kg
Novel materials impact
- Biomaterials and biodegradable polymers often require precise temperature control, impacting energy consumption
- Low-temperature sinterable metals reduce energy requirements in binder jetting and similar technologies
- Nanocomposite materials may increase energy consumption due to specialized processing needs and higher thermal conductivity
- Shape memory alloys and other smart materials often require complex thermal cycling, potentially increasing overall energy use
Post-processing energy requirements
- Post-processing steps in AM workflows can contribute significantly to the overall energy consumption of part production
- Understanding and optimizing post-processing energy use is crucial for improving the overall efficiency of AM technologies
- Advancements in post-processing techniques aim to reduce energy intensity while maintaining or enhancing part quality
Heat treatment energy needs
- Stress relief heat treatments for metal AM parts typically require temperatures of 600-800°C for several hours
- Solution annealing and aging processes for precipitation-hardening alloys may consume 50-150 kWh per treatment cycle
- Polymer crystallization and annealing treatments often operate at lower temperatures (80-200°C) but for extended durations
- Vacuum heat treatment systems generally demonstrate higher energy efficiency compared to atmospheric furnaces
Surface finishing energy use
- Abrasive finishing processes (tumbling, sandblasting) consume relatively low energy, typically 1-5 kWh per part
- Chemical surface treatments may require energy for solution heating and agitation, ranging from 0.5-2 kWh per liter of solution
- Electrochemical polishing of metal AM parts can consume 5-20 kWh per part, depending on size and complexity
- Advanced finishing techniques like plasma polishing offer potential energy savings compared to traditional methods
Part removal energy consumption
- Wire Electrical Discharge Machining (EDM) for metal part removal from build plates consumes 10-50 kWh per hour of operation
- Thermal shock methods for ceramic part removal require rapid heating and cooling cycles, consuming 5-15 kWh per batch
- Soluble support removal for polymer parts typically involves low-energy processes, often below 1 kWh per part
- Automated support removal systems may increase energy efficiency through optimized chemical circulation and temperature control
Energy benchmarking in AM
- Energy benchmarking provides a standardized approach to comparing energy efficiency across different AM technologies and applications
- Establishing industry-wide benchmarks drives continuous improvement and facilitates informed decision-making in AM adoption
- Benchmarking efforts support the development of energy-focused regulations and incentives for the AM industry
Industry standards for energy use
- ASTM International develops standards for measuring and reporting energy consumption in AM processes
- ISO/ASTM 52900 provides a standardized terminology for AM energy-related concepts and metrics
- ASTM F3323 outlines a methodology for determining the specific energy consumption of powder bed fusion processes
- Industry consortia collaborate on developing best practices for energy efficiency in AM operations
Comparative analysis methods
- Round-robin testing among different AM facilities establishes baseline energy consumption for standardized part geometries
- Design of Experiments (DOE) approaches systematically evaluate energy consumption across process parameters and material combinations
- Statistical Process Control (SPC) techniques monitor energy efficiency trends and identify significant deviations
- Benchmarking studies often employ normalized metrics like MJ/cm³ or kWh/kg to facilitate comparisons across different part sizes and materials
Energy efficiency certifications
- Energy Star certification programs expand to include industrial AM equipment, setting efficiency targets
- ISO 50001 Energy Management System certification guides AM facilities in implementing comprehensive energy policies
- Green building certifications (LEED, BREEAM) increasingly consider AM energy efficiency in manufacturing facility assessments
- Industry-specific certifications (aerospace, medical) incorporate energy efficiency criteria in AM process qualifications
Future trends in AM energy use
- Ongoing research and development in AM technologies focus on improving energy efficiency and sustainability
- Integration of advanced energy management systems and smart manufacturing concepts drives innovation in AM energy use
- Emerging technologies and novel approaches promise significant reductions in energy consumption across the AM value chain
Emerging low-energy technologies
- Room-temperature metal AM processes like Cold Spray Additive Manufacturing reduce energy-intensive melting requirements
- Photopolymerization-based technologies advance towards more energy-efficient light sources and photoinitiation systems
- Acoustic energy-assisted AM processes demonstrate potential for low-energy material consolidation
- Biomimetic approaches to AM explore energy-efficient, nature-inspired fabrication methods
Energy storage integration
- On-site energy storage systems (lithium-ion batteries, flow batteries) enable peak shaving and load balancing in AM facilities
- Thermal energy storage technologies capture and reuse process heat, improving overall energy efficiency
- Integration of AM with hydrogen fuel cell technology explores synergies in energy-efficient manufacturing and clean energy production
- Advanced power management systems optimize energy flow between storage, renewable sources, and AM equipment
Smart factory energy systems
- Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) enables comprehensive energy monitoring and optimization across AM production lines
- AI-driven predictive maintenance reduces energy waste associated with equipment failures and unplanned downtime
- Digital twin technology facilitates energy-focused simulation and optimization of entire AM facilities
- Blockchain-based energy trading platforms allow AM operations to participate in decentralized energy markets, optimizing costs and sustainability
Key Terms to Review (24)
Adele H. Shapiro: Adele H. Shapiro is a prominent researcher known for her contributions to the field of additive manufacturing, particularly regarding energy consumption and sustainability in 3D printing processes. Her work often focuses on evaluating the environmental impact of different additive manufacturing technologies and optimizing energy use to promote more sustainable practices within the industry.
ASTM Standards: ASTM standards are a set of technical standards developed by ASTM International, an organization that creates and publishes voluntary consensus standards for materials, products, systems, and services. These standards provide specifications and guidelines to ensure quality, safety, and consistency across various industries, including those related to heat treatment processes, ceramics, and energy consumption in additive manufacturing. They play a crucial role in helping manufacturers, engineers, and researchers to comply with regulatory requirements and enhance product performance.
Build chamber utilization metrics: Build chamber utilization metrics are measurements that assess how effectively the space within an additive manufacturing build chamber is being used during the printing process. These metrics help identify the ratio of actual production volume to the maximum potential volume of the chamber, which can directly influence energy consumption, material waste, and overall efficiency in additive manufacturing processes.
Carbon footprint: A carbon footprint is the total amount of greenhouse gases, particularly carbon dioxide, that are emitted directly or indirectly by an individual, organization, event, or product throughout its lifecycle. Understanding the carbon footprint is crucial for evaluating energy consumption, recycling practices, and the overall environmental impact of products from production to disposal.
Digital twin technology: Digital twin technology refers to the virtual representation of a physical object or system, created using real-time data and simulations to mirror its behavior and performance. This technology allows for continuous monitoring, analysis, and optimization, ultimately enhancing efficiency and decision-making processes in various fields, including additive manufacturing.
Energy Density: Energy density refers to the amount of energy stored in a given system or region of space per unit volume or mass. In additive manufacturing, energy density plays a crucial role as it influences the efficiency and effectiveness of the 3D printing process, particularly regarding the materials used and the desired properties of the final product.
Energy Efficiency: Energy efficiency refers to using less energy to provide the same level of service or output. It involves optimizing processes and technologies to minimize energy consumption while maintaining performance, which is essential in various fields like construction, manufacturing, and product life cycles.
Energy Recovery Systems: Energy recovery systems are technologies designed to capture and reuse energy that would otherwise be wasted during industrial processes, including additive manufacturing. These systems are crucial in improving overall energy efficiency by converting excess thermal energy or kinetic energy into usable forms, thereby reducing the total energy consumption of manufacturing processes.
Energy utilization ratio: The energy utilization ratio is a measure of the efficiency with which energy is used in a process, specifically in additive manufacturing. It compares the amount of useful work or output generated by a manufacturing system to the total energy consumed during that process. A higher ratio indicates better energy efficiency, which is crucial for optimizing production costs and minimizing environmental impacts.
Fused Deposition Modeling: Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) is a 3D printing process that uses thermoplastic materials, which are heated and extruded through a nozzle to create objects layer by layer. This technique is widely used across various industries due to its affordability, accessibility, and versatility in producing both prototypes and end-use parts.
High-Speed Sintering: High-speed sintering is an advanced additive manufacturing technique that utilizes a combination of infrared heating and laser technology to rapidly fuse powdered materials, resulting in faster production times and improved efficiency. This method is especially significant for reducing energy consumption during the sintering process compared to traditional methods, as it allows for localized heating and minimizes waste.
ISO 14001: ISO 14001 is an international standard that specifies requirements for an effective environmental management system (EMS). It helps organizations improve their environmental performance through more efficient use of resources and reduction of waste, which is crucial in various sectors including manufacturing. By implementing ISO 14001, organizations can demonstrate their commitment to sustainability, which directly ties into energy consumption, standards and certifications, and the selection of sustainable materials.
Life Cycle Assessment: Life cycle assessment (LCA) is a systematic approach used to evaluate the environmental impacts of a product or process throughout its entire life cycle, from raw material extraction to disposal. It helps identify areas where energy consumption and resource use can be minimized, leading to more sustainable practices in manufacturing and product design.
Metals: Metals are a category of materials characterized by high electrical and thermal conductivity, malleability, ductility, and a shiny appearance. They play a crucial role in manufacturing processes, including those that involve shaping, joining, and additive techniques, influencing material selection and design considerations in various applications.
National Renewable Energy Laboratory: The National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) is a research facility of the U.S. Department of Energy that focuses on advancing renewable energy and energy efficiency technologies. It plays a crucial role in supporting the development and implementation of clean energy solutions, including those relevant to additive manufacturing, by conducting research, providing resources, and collaborating with various stakeholders in the energy sector.
Power Consumption: Power consumption refers to the amount of electrical energy consumed by a device or process over a specific period. In additive manufacturing, understanding power consumption is crucial because it impacts the efficiency and sustainability of production processes, as well as the overall cost of operating 3D printing machines.
Process optimization: Process optimization refers to the systematic improvement of a manufacturing process to enhance performance, efficiency, and quality while reducing waste and costs. This concept is crucial in various manufacturing techniques, particularly in additive manufacturing, where it can lead to better material utilization and faster production times, especially in methods like binder jetting and considerations of energy consumption.
Selective Laser Sintering: Selective Laser Sintering (SLS) is an additive manufacturing process that uses a high-powered laser to fuse powdered material, layer by layer, into solid structures. This technology allows for the creation of complex geometries and is widely used in various industries for rapid prototyping and production of functional parts.
Solar energy: Solar energy is the radiant light and heat emitted by the sun, harnessed through various technologies for practical use, particularly in generating electricity or heating. This renewable energy source is essential for reducing dependence on fossil fuels and minimizing environmental impact, especially in energy-intensive processes like additive manufacturing.
Specific energy consumption: Specific energy consumption refers to the amount of energy required to produce a unit of product in additive manufacturing processes. This term is essential in assessing the efficiency and sustainability of different additive manufacturing technologies, as it allows for the comparison of energy use across various systems and materials. A lower specific energy consumption indicates a more efficient process, which is increasingly important as energy costs rise and environmental concerns grow.
Thermal efficiency calculations: Thermal efficiency calculations measure the effectiveness of a system in converting heat energy into useful work or output. In the context of additive manufacturing, these calculations are crucial for understanding how much energy is consumed during the printing process compared to the energy that actually contributes to building a part, highlighting areas for potential improvement in energy usage and sustainability.
Thermal management: Thermal management refers to the process of controlling and regulating temperature in systems, particularly to ensure optimal performance and longevity of materials. In additive manufacturing, effective thermal management is crucial as it influences energy consumption, material properties, and the quality of the printed parts. Proper thermal control can lead to energy efficiency and enhanced mechanical characteristics in the final products.
Thermoplastics: Thermoplastics are a type of polymer that becomes pliable or moldable upon heating and solidifies upon cooling. This unique property allows them to be reshaped multiple times without significant chemical change, making them highly versatile for various applications in manufacturing, especially in 3D printing and additive manufacturing processes.
Wind power: Wind power is the process of converting wind energy into mechanical energy, which can then be transformed into electricity through wind turbines. This renewable energy source plays a critical role in reducing reliance on fossil fuels and decreasing greenhouse gas emissions, making it an essential part of sustainable energy strategies.